Monday, November 16, 2026

Average

     [A short story for you. Envy is a powerful emotion. It can easily turn into outright hatred. But what if it has other potentials? Perhaps as a doorway that something not nice could use to infect a soul unaware? – FWP]

     Father Raymond Altomare had not seen the inside of a guidance counselor’s office since graduating from his own high school. As pastor of Our Lady of the Pines Roman Catholic parish, which serves the whole of New York’s Onteora County, he was acquainted with a great many of the personnel who staff Onteora’s schools, but until that day he’d never been asked to advise one. However, he never turned down a request for a conversation from anyone, Catholic or not. So at the appointed hour he stuffed his stole into his breast pocket, adorned his features with a pleasant smile, and presented himself at Alvin Purvis’s office at Foxwood High.
     The office resembled what he remembered of his own guidance counselor’s cubbyhole: large enough not to be deemed a closet, but not much larger. The furnishings were no surprise: sheet-steel desk, sheet-steel bookcase, sheet-steel filing cabinet. The bookcase bore tomes with titles typical of the professional advice-giver. Ray remembered reading two of them. A couple of pseudo-motivational posters adorned the walls.
     Purvis was the epitome of the mid-Twenty-First Century public-school functionary. He was undistinguished in any way: middle-aged, medium height, medium build, brown eyes, thinning brown hair touched at the temples with middle-aged gray, and a slightly rumpled, open-collared dress shirt on which Ray could just make out the ghost of a condiment spill. The surface of his desk was littered with forms of many colors. He rose, shook Ray’s hand, muttered “Thank you for coming, Father,” and was back in his seat before Ray had settled into his.
     “Forgive me, please, but you don’t look familiar,” Ray said. “Are you one of my parishioners?”
     Purvis grimaced fleetingly. “No, Father, I’m not. Not religious at all, really. I hope that won’t interfere with our conversation.”
     “It won’t, but I’m quite curious as to why you asked for my assistance. Am I the confessor to a troubled student?”
     “No, actually.” Purvis appeared momentarily uncomfortable. “Ah, a lawyer I know spoke highly of you as an advisor, and I’m having a spot of trouble with a student I can’t figure out.”
     A lawyer recommending a priest? That’s a first. Probably Sylvie Yngstrom. Al Donaldson is about as Catholic as Interstate 90.
     “Well then, who is this student and how can I help you with him?”
     A spike of discomfort flitted across Purvis’s features. “His name is David Johnson. Any chance you know him?”
     “His name doesn’t ring a bell.”
     “I suppose it was too much to expect.” Purvis fiddled with the papers before him. “He’s not one of our brighter lights, but he’s not a known troublemaker either. Low B to high C average, no particular talent for any of the disciplines, not athletic as far as I can tell, and not particularly popular. Or unpopular, for that matter. He’s almost perfectly average in every measurable way. And it’s my duty to guide him from here to the end of his high school experience.”
     An average student assigned to an average counselor.
     “So far,” Ray said, “I’m unclear on what makes young Mr. Johnson a problem. Surely you’ve advised other average kids by now?”
     Purvis grimaced again. “I have,” he said. “And if David were average without exception, I doubt I’d have any problem with him at all. But there is one way in which he, ah, stands out.”
     “From the way you said that,” Ray said, “I get the impression that it’s not a good way.”
     “It’s not.” Purvis looked briefly off into the corner. “I’ve been getting complaints about what happens when he’s present at a contest.”
     Ray became uneasy “What kind of contest?”
     “Any kind at all,” Purvis muttered. “Academic, athletic, artistic, you name it.”
     “What does he do?”
     “According to the proctors, nothing much. Just sits there.”
     Ray was nonplussed. “Well, then what’s the problem?”
     “Nothing happens. Nothing at all.”
     Ray peered at him. “Meaning...?”
     “The contestants and performers can’t perform. At all. None of them.”

***

     Ray had to see for himself, so with Purvis’ assistance he acquired a ticket to Foxwood’s upcoming end-of-season football game against Laurelton High. That Onteora County had only four high schools hadn’t kept the county’s education officials from forming tiny leagues in baseball, football, and basketball. Even though the competitors were few, competition was intense and fan interest was great. At least, Purvis said, it had been.
     Purvis arrived just after Ray seated himself in the bleachers. The guidance counselor perched next to him and smiled faintly. “Evening, Father. I wasn’t sure you’d make it.”
     “After what you told me last week, I had to see it with my own eyes,” Ray said. “Not that I disbelieved you. It’s just something I could never have imagined. Do you see him anywhere in the stands?”
     Purvis swept his gaze over the bleachers. “Mmm…not yet. But it might be for the best if he were to arrive some time after the game starts.”
     Ray started to ask why, thought better of it.
     As it happened, Purvis’ wish was granted. The game started out as a fierce battle between notably skilled teams. Laurelton was first to get possession. Its offense marched smartly down field until a spectacular interception granted the ball to Foxwood at its fourteen yard line. Foxwood’s quarterback led a precise eighty-six-yard campaign down field against a vigorous Laurelton defense. It culminated with a perfectly placed pass to the back corner of the endzone, a leaping catch, and the referee’s ruling that the receiver had come down in bounds and in possession.
     “These kids are pretty good,” Ray murmured.
     Purvis nodded. “A few of them have been scouted already.”
     As Foxwood’s place kicker leaped off the bench and strode onto the field for the extra-point try, a young man of no distinguishing characteristics ambled up to the bleachers. He assumed a seat near the top, a fair distance away from any other spectators, and propped his elbows on his knees.
     “He’s here,” Purvis muttered. “Watch what happens now.”
     Ray leaned forward.
     The teams lined up for the extra-point try. The holder called the signals. The center snapped the ball. It wobbled toward the holder, who had to rise from his knee to bring it in. The blockers held the line as the holder fumbled it into place for the kick, but the kicker stumbled and kicked the ball poorly. It flew directly into a blocker, who had the presence of mind to fall on it. The referee blew the whistle and decreed that the try had failed.
     Well, snaps do go bad now and then. But that wasn’t the most impressive kick I’ve ever seen.
     Purvis noted Ray’s expression. “Our kicker is first rate when David isn’t around. Just keep watching the game, Father.”
     Ray’s gaze flicked toward the young man Purvis had cited. He was doing nothing to speak of, just watching the action on the field.
     Keep an open mind.
     Though the game that had started out looking near collegiate-varsity quality, from that moment forward it was a far less impressive spectacle. On both sides, the play was no better than mediocre. At times it verged on comical. Both offenses made mistake after mistake, both physical and mental. Yet neither defense seemed able to capitalize. It was as if the teams that started the game had been replaced by inexperienced ninth-graders of no particular skills. Spectators that had cheered loudly during Foxwood’s first drive and stood to applaud the touchdown pass became silent. By halftime, half of them had departed. The inept play and the departures continued through the second half. Foxwood prevailed, though it was clear that the team had no cause to brag about its performance.
     Ray and Purvis rose as the last of the other spectators trickled away toward the parking lot. David Johnson brought up the rear.
     “Did you, expect to see…what we saw?” Ray said.
     Purvis nodded. “It’s been that way whenever he’s present. Players with a solid reputation for ability and drive turn into buffoons when he’s in the stands.”
     “Have you seen the same thing at practices?”
     “Not personally,” Purvis said. “But I’ve been told about it by other staffers I trust.”
     I have to take it seriously.
     “What about musical performances?”
     “Same deal.” Purvis scowled. “My daughter is the school’s first-chair oboist. She has a genuine gift for the instrument. When David’s in the audience, she can hardly get a note out of it. I have no explanation. Do you?”
     “Not as we stand here,” Ray said. “But there’s still a possibility that it’s a huge coincidence. Would you be willing to help me with an experiment?”
     Purvis’ eyebrows rose. “Certainly, Father. What do you have in mind?”
     “The basketball season still has a few months to run, doesn’t it? Does David usually go to those games?”
     “Oh yes. Are you thinking of keeping him away from a game or two, then letting him attend them?”
     Ray nodded. “Exactly. But I don’t know the young man. You do. Can I count on you to provide the necessary obstruction?”
     “I’ll see what I can arrange.”

***

     Whatever ruse Purvis contrived to keep David Johnson away, it worked for a basketball game and a half. Ray was much impressed by Foxwood’s accurate shooting and solid defense against the Oakleigh team. One Foxwood forward racked up twenty-two points, including four three-pointers, in the first half alone. The Foxwood center was impassable in the paint; he repelled the Oakleigh forwards’ attempts to drive the baseline with exceptional skill and without fouling. Though Oakleigh fought hard, in the end Foxwood prevailed by a twenty point margin.
     The following game was against Chedwick High. The first half was an epic battle. Chedwick’s team had been mentioned as a candidate for the national high school championship tournament. Foxwood was nearly their equal, and fought tenaciously to keep the score as close as possible to level. For sixteen minutes the teams provided the best performance, in both skill and passion, that high school athletes could give.
     David Johnson ambled into the gym as halftime ticked toward its end. Once again he entered unobtrusively, took an isolated seat near the top of the bleachers, and propped his elbows on his knees.
     Now we’ll see.
     Alvin Purvis entered a minute or two later. He scrambled into the bleachers as the game resumed and perched himself next to Ray.
     “Couldn’t keep him away?” Ray murmured.
     “I tried my best, Father,” Purvis said. “But I couldn’t keep him talking to me any longer.”
     “Then when the third period ends,” Ray said, “I’ll buttonhole him and take him out of the gym.”
     Purvis looked at him in surprise. “You think you can?”
     Ray nodded. “You stay here and watch the game.”
     The third period was a farce. Both teams played as if neither had ever touched a basketball before. Dribblers stumbled, traveled, and lost control of the ball. Shooters missed by a yard. Centers fouled as they tried to block. As the last few seconds of the period ticked away, Ray rose, went to where David Johnson sat, and stood so as to block his view of the court. The teenager looked up at him with evident irritation.
     “What is it, Father?”
     “I need to speak to you privately.” Ray filled the words with urgency. “Come with me.”
     “But the game—”
     “Right now, David.” Ray took the teen firmly by the arm and pulled him upright against considerable resistance. Nevertheless, Ray marched him down the bleachers and out of the gym.

***

     As the gym door closed behind them, Johnson finally wrenched himself free of Ray’s grip and faced him squarely. “Well, what’s so important that I couldn’t enjoy the rest of the game in peace?”
     You enjoyed it, did you?
     Ray met the teen’s glare eye-to-eye. “You are.”
     “Huh?”
     “Tonight you’re the focus of an experiment,” Ray said. “Would you like to guess what sort?”
     The teen pretended bafflement. He essayed a shrug.
     “According to your guidance counselor—”
     “Mr. Purvis?”
     “The very same. When you’re present at any kind of competition, all the competitors lose all their skills. They perform like nobodies. Like the teams on the court tonight in the third period.”
     “So?” Johnson said. “Did you expect pro basketball from a bunch of kids?”
     “They played better before you arrived,” Ray countered. “Much better. Both sides. And the same thing happened at Foxwood’s football game with Laurelton.”
     Another shrug. “Maybe they got tired.” Johnson made to return to the gym. Ray grabbed and halted him. The teen’s eyes flared with fury.
     “What the hell—”
     “Never mind that,” Ray said. “Mr. Purvis stayed in there to watch what remains of the game. You’re staying here, with me. We’ll see what he has to say when it’s over.” The teen tried to shake himself loose, but Ray clamped down with his full and considerable strength. The teen winced.
     “My parents are going to hear about this,” Johnson growled. “They’re not Catholics. Neither am I.”
     “I know,” Ray said. “And I’ll be very interested in what they have to say, as well.”
     David Johnson became silent, but the heat from his gaze grew greater still. It expressed more than the teen might have intended.

***

     One side of the little pentagon that sat in the Johnsons’ living room radiated unease and more. David’s parents sat tightly together, hand in hand and hip to hip. They didn’t trouble to conceal their suspicion at the invasion of their home by a priest. Whatever they thought of their son’s guidance counselor, they kept it to themselves.
     “We’ve never heard the first thing about any trouble David’s been in,” Mrs. Johnson said. “Now you come here in the middle of the night as if we were criminals, demanding to know about our son? We should call the police on you.”
     “You can if you like,” Purvis said. “I won’t try to pretend that we’re here for David’s benefit, or because he’s in trouble with the school authorities. It’s just that he’s been present at some…unusual events. Unusual enough to draw the notice of other school personnel. And David is the only common factor among them.”
     Johnson glared at the guidance counselor with open hostility. “What kind of ‘unusual events?’”
     “May we leave that for a few minutes in the future, please?” Ray said. Purvis glanced at him curiously, but said nothing. “It might still come to nothing. We’d like to learn a little more about you and David, if that would be all right. What you do, your opinions about child-rearing, your religious beliefs—wait.” Ray held up a hand. “We’re not here to convert you or harangue you. We’d just like to see if we can get a little insight into what we’ve…observed.”
     “Which you won’t tell us,” Johnson growled.
     “Please bear with me a moment longer,” Ray said. “What do you do for a living, Mr. Johnson?”
     Johnson’s face twitched as if he found the question distasteful. “I’m a bookkeeper at Sentry Munitions.”
     “And yourself, Mrs. Johnson?” Ray said.
     “I…work in retail,” the woman forced out.
     Ray nodded. “Nothing to be ashamed of in either case,” he said. “Do you own your home?”
     “For three years now. Along with the bank,” Johnson muttered.
     “These days, that’s the case far more often than not,” Purvis contributed.
     Perfectly average, in fact.
     “You’ve done well to acquire a home in Foxwood,” Ray said. “There are neighborhoods in Oakleigh and Laurelton where it would have been much easier.”
     “It would have,” Johnson forced out, “but we didn’t want to live among…” His face twitched again, and he fell silent.
     “Yes, the environment is a little different in…the lower-priced townships,” Ray said before Purvis could speak. “But the property taxes there are a good deal less. Homeowners have to bear down a little to cover the ones here.”
     It was a perfectly normal observation, but the Johnsons bridled as if their character had somehow been impugned.
     “We do what we have to,” Johnson growled. “The older residents use the taxes to keep folks like us away. We decided we weren’t having it. They’re no better than us. We’re as good as anybody, and we’re going to live like it.” His eyes flicked toward his son, who’d been silent throughout the “We’ve told David that over and over. Practically since he was able to walk.”
     David didn’t speak nor twitch.
     “Have you had any…difficulties because of that?” Ray murmured.
     “Some of the women have been a little standoffish,” Mrs. Johnson said. “And David hasn’t made any friends in the area yet.”
     No surprise there.
     Ray looked at Purvis. “Well, I think we’ve learned what we came to learn,” he said. He rose from his seat. “Wouldn’t you agree, Al?”
     Purvis’ eyes widened. “Ah, yes, Father.” He rose and faced the Johnsons. “Mr. and Mrs. Johnson, thank you for your time.”
     “Hold on there,” Johnson said as he rose from his sofa. “What about these events that you were so concerned about?”
     Purvis smiled formally. “I’m sure they were just coincidences. Nothing to worry about.” He turned and with a jerk of the head urged Ray to follow him. They marched quickstep for the front door. Ray closed it immediately behind them, but not before he saw the hatred that burned in David Johnson’s eyes.

***

     “Well, Father?” Purvis said as he drove them back to the rectory. “Any conclusions?”
     “Yes, but…” Ray winced. “I don’t know if I should say what…I’m about to say.”
     Purvis grinned. “Guidance counselors are a bit like priests, you know. We don’t repeat what’s told us. Well, unless someone’s in danger. David isn’t in danger, is he?”
     “Not physically,” Ray said. “Not as far as I can tell, anyway. But it would be a good thing if he could be kept away from competitions until he finishes his schooling.”
     “Present trends continuing, that will be the June after next,” Purvis said. He turned into the rectory parking lot, set the parking brake and killed the engine. “He’s not a strong prospect for college. But from the way you said what you said, you have an opinion.”
     The stress on the word opinion was almost too light to notice.
     “I do,” Ray said. “But I don’t think you’re going to like it.”
     “Let me be the judge, please.”
     How do I tell this secular, perfectly average man that in one way, David Johnson isn’t average at all? How do I make it comprehensible in his frame of reference?
     “Do you know about demons?” Ray said.
     Purvis’ eyes narrowed. “I haven’t made a study of the myths. I know religious people believe in them, and that they intend us harm.”
     “Well…” Ray groped for words. “You observed the Johnsons as closely as I did tonight. What sense of them did you get?”
     Purvis relaxed fractionally. “Hm. Well, I’d say they’re as average as their son, for one thing.”
     “Materially? Talent-wise?”
     “Ah, yes.” Purvis frowned for a moment. “Were you hoping I would say more than that?”
     “I wasn’t sure one way or the other.” Ray steepled his hands. “Priests get a very specific kind of education, you know. Part of it is training in the detection of…evil.”
     Purvis glared at him as if he’d proposed to erect a stake and burn David Johnson at it. “Go on, Father.”
     “A great deal of evil is completely unobtrusive,” Ray said. “Banal, even. Evil doesn’t have to be showy, though sometimes it is. The mass killings, the great genocides, and the world wars got us thinking that we’d always recognize a monster in our midst. But that isn’t always the case. Evil can express itself in some of the quietest ways you can imagine.”
     “I am having,” Purvis said, “a very hard time making sense of what you’re saying. Are you about to tell me that David Johnson is possessed?”
     “No, sir,” Ray said. You wouldn’t believe me if I did. “But I do believe a malevolent force is using him to express itself. Through no fault of his own.”
     Purvis’s eyes remained hard. Ray fought to remain placid of demeanor.
     “I began to see it when I pulled David out of the gym,” Ray said. “He growled at me for not letting him enjoy the game. And I think he was being truthful about that. He was enjoying what he saw on the court. He found it comforting.”
     “That makes absolutely no sense, Father,” Purvis said.
     “Does what we saw make sense?” Ray murmured. “The total collapse of gifted teenage athletes immediately upon the arrival of one nondescript, non-playing boy?”
     Purvis started to reply, checked himself.
     “Did the players return to form when I managed to drag David out of the gym?” Ray continued.
     For the first time, the guidance counselor appeared to open slightly to what Ray was saying.
     “What David saw,” Ray said, “told him that he would have played as well as any of the varsity players we watched beclown themselves. That he was as good as any of them.”
     “But—”
     “The Johnsons gave it away back there.” Ray grimaced at the memory. “They’re as good as anybody. They said so! They’ve said it to themselves for so long that they believe it to the core of their being. Remember what else they said? They pounded it into David since he came out of the cradle—so relentlessly that he needs to believe it despite the evidence of his senses. And it’s twisted him enough, created enough of a chink in his soul, that an evil entity could attach itself to him, ride along with him, and learn to work through him.
     “I think David’s aware of what’s going on. He may have been resentful of others’ superior accomplishments in this or that field for a long time before this, but now that he has that…ride-along, it’s using his resentment to act on those around him. He resents seeing anyone outperform what he knows, in his heart of hearts, is the best he could do. He wants to see others as no better than he is–at anything. That he’s as good as any of them. And his ride-along is showing him exactly that.”
     Ray sat back. Purvis’ eyes had clouded with doubt.
     He has to overcome a lot of preconceptions to accept it. He may not manage. But there was a time when I wouldn’t have believed it either.
     “It’s hard to accept,” Purvis said. “But it’s consistent with what we’ve seen. Still, it doesn’t suggest a way to deal with it. For me, at least. I’m not in the evil-entity-fighting business.”
     “I know,” Ray said. “I am.”
     Purvis’ mouth twitched. “Getting David or his parents to accept your kind of therapy would be a hell of a trick.”
     Ray nodded. “I know that, too.”
     Purvis nodded and offered his hand. “Thank you, Father. I appreciate your input.”
     “You’re welcome.”
     He exited Purvis’ car, walked steadily to the rectory door, and closed it behind him as the guidance counselor drove away.

==<O>==

Copyright © 2022 Francis W. Porretto. All Rights Reserved Worldwide.

Purposes

     “A man dies without a purpose.” – from Chosen One

     I don’t sleep well. I suffer several pains that wake me up several times each night. I have no doubt that this is the case for many men in the second half of life.

     “Life is pain. Get used to it,” Geena Davis as Samantha Caine says with brutal brevity to her fictional daughter Caitlin in The Long Kiss Goodnight. It’s not a perfect description of life, especially if you’re fortunate enough to be a contemporary First Worlder. Indeed, part of the reason for all the jokes about “first world problems” is the immense success the First World has had at alleviating pains that were inescapable for men of earlier centuries.

     Yet there are pains that resist being alleviated. Some of them aren’t entirely physical.

     In case you’re wondering, I was prompted by this tweet:

     Give that gal a medal, for it is undeniably so.

* * *

     Retirement is a challenge for many men. For half a century, I had a specific mission to which I applied myself unstintingly. I had no image of what my life would be like were I to retire. But eventually, steadily increasing pain and limitations forced it on me. I’ve been fortunate, in that I’ve found other pursuits to occupy me and buttress my sense of purpose.

     Not every man is that fortunate. Many of us wither and die once our careers are over. When they “see the end coming,” their sense of purpose starts to fail them. They ask themselves, sotto voce, “What value have I to others? Why would anyone want me around?”

     Who knows what percentage of suicides stem from the loss of purpose?

     Women don’t seem to suffer that particular emotional malady. At least, I’ve never heard a woman – yes, I’ve known plenty of them, thanks – complain about it. They have their own special sorrows, and I wouldn’t want to trade ours for theirs, but this one, the sense of having lost one’s purpose, seems to pertain to men alone.

* * *

     This clip remains one of the most piercing things I’ve ever found on the Web:

     One of those demons is awareness that as time passes, our significance to others, including those we love, is fading. It’s a man thing: the older we get, the more we collapse into ourselves. Barriers go up that slowly close us off to others. It’s propelled by the weariness, pain, and increasing futility of life as a man.

     Yet it is our crown and our cross. With a few dubious exceptions that get a disproportional amount of air time and column-inches, we wouldn’t have it any other way. For it is the essence of manhood. We are our purpose.

     If there’s an analgesic to the suffering expressed in the tweets embedded above, it’s for a man to recognize and celebrate who he has been and what he has achieved. Those things cannot be taken away from him, even if further achievement is beyond him, even if other men will go on to higher heights. Now and then, if he has a wife of the right sort, his wife will remind him.

     “Well done, thou good and faithful servant.” Every man needs to hear it from time to time. If there are any women reading this, please take that to heart. The man who loves you needs to hear it from you. After all, you’re a great part of his purpose… aren’t you?

* * *

     A closing thought: If you have a few minutes and can bear the sound of my voice, watch this clip, and let me know how it strikes you. Yes, it speaks of an extreme case, but extremes, even fictional ones, can help us to see things we’ve overlooked. How might it apply to purpose-built artificial intelligences? Would they suffer “male syndrome” too? If so, what could be done for them – and would it be morally obligatory to do it?

Sunday, November 15, 2026

The New Pandemic

     This will be one of those “I would never have believed it” articles. And indeed, I wouldn’t have, except that Eugene Volokh attests to it:

     From a survey this month of Democratic voters by the Center for Strategic Politics, a self-described progressive organization.

     Now, it’s possible that there are enough Democrat voters who don’t know what “publicly owned and operated” means to bias a survey of this sort even if the great majority of Democrat voters have better sense. But recent trends in Democrat Party affiliation suggest that it just might be the view of 39% of Democrats nationwide that restaurants should be owned and operated by the State. That possibility has made me suspect that there’s a new pandemic abroad – one of a variety of which history has no record.

     I speak of an insanity pandemic.

     What could induce Democrats to embrace the insane notion that the operation of restaurants should be a function of government? Could it be The Jab? A mutation of Trump Derangement Syndrome? Or did someone put something in the water? And whatever the cause, why does it afflict only Democrat voters?

     Gentle Reader, if you know any Democrat voters, please help your old friend and preferred prose provider, the Curmudgeon Emeritus to the World Wide Web: i.e., Fran Porretto. As you get the chance, inquire of those Democrat voters you know whether they would favor the nationalization of the restaurant industry. If they look at you as if you just sprouted a second head, please show them the Volokh article, or this one. But if they say that it sounds like a good idea, something that needs to happen, pass that along to me.

     No, I don’t have any intentions for the information. I just want a better sense for how many of our fellow Americans have gone completely batshit insane. And now, if you’ll excuse me, it’s time for Mass. After that I think I’ll clean and oil all my guns again.

Friday, November 13, 2026

“Remember, Fran: Try To Be Funny!”

     Has anyone ever given you that advice? I got it long ago, from a source not exactly known for counsel of that sort: a Catholic nun. (A Dominican, at that. Ask your nearest Catholic-educated acquaintance why that makes it special.) She felt that I was excessively serious, and therefore not getting the best out of my young life. So she advised me to become entertaining to others.

     Her reasoning was simple: if you entertain others, they’ll entertain you. You’ll smile. You might even laugh and come up with something funnier. And everyone around you will relax and consider you “one of us.”

     The excessively serious have a hard time in society. Regardless of the realities, those around them see them as “bring-downs.” Invisible barriers form to exclude such persons, unless they’re unusually useful. And who among us is useful enough to countervail that?

     I took that good nun’s advice somewhat irregularly, as most six-year-olds would. But over the years, events have confirmed her wisdom. Now and then it comes back to me in its original form: a tall, habited Dominican nun girdled with a rosary and armed with a Bolo paddle.

     “Try to be funny.” How does it sound to you? Trivial or salubrious?

     Persons of high intellect should put special effort into being funny. High intellect is as much a burden as an asset. We think about things, usually too seriously and sometimes monomaniacally. He who concentrates on great problems and involute conundrums can develop a grim aspect that renders him forbidding to others. Undesirable, to say the least.

     Yet the syndrome can be as invisible to the sufferer as water to a fish. He can plumb deep mysteries of all sorts and concoct brilliant theories about them, yet never become aware of his own shortcomings. The somber face that stares back at him from the mirror might as well belong to someone else. Any of his buddies, assuming he has some, at any time could tell him to “lighten up.” Whether he’ll hear it is another question. Some never do.

* * *

     I’ve expressed my admiration for Haretina Kukuri several times here. She’s young, brilliant, possessed of enormous determination to understand the great problems of our time, and penetrating in her analyses of all such things. I believe her insights to be critically important to the future of the First World. I hope her audience continues to grow.

     So it was with a special delight that I discovered that she’s also funny. (You have to have a degree of familiarity with both hip-hop and video-gaming culture to get full value for that quip, but these days that’s fairly common.) People not only enjoy humor and those who provide it; they also derive special impact from it. For humor, even when delivered offhand or indirectly, is a powerful assistant to memory.

     The late Cyril Northcote Parkinson, himself a man of great penetration, was aware of this. He strove to be entertaining in all his emissions. For my tastes, he succeeded brilliantly. Toward the end of his “public” career, he said so explicitly:

     Any effective announcement or message conveys a sense of personality. While precise and terse, it goes beyond precision and brevity. It comes from a known character, not from a faceless management. It never includes long words and involved constructions. Short words are best, each one a hammer blow and not a handful of cotton wool. Last of all, it often includes a touch of humor. This serves more than one purpose. It makes the message human. It attracts attention. Above all, it assists memory. And the secret of humor, employed as a deliberate tool or device, is to tie in the joke with the message that remembering one means remembering both.

     [From Parkinson’s essay “Law of the Vacuum.”]

     The truly inspiring and effective leaders of history have all been funny. Say what you will about Abraham Lincoln, he was the funniest man ever to rise high in public office. It seemed to come naturally to him. Given what we know about the tragedy of his life and work, it may have been what sustained him. Have a sample:

     Once [Lincoln] was looking out the window of his law office in Springfield, Illinois, and saw a stately matron, wearing a many-plumed hat, picking her way gingerly across the muddy street. Suddenly she slipped and fell.
     “Reminds me of a duck,” said Lincoln.
     “Why is that,” asked a friend.
     “Feathers on her head and down on her behind,” said Lincoln.
     […]
     A dozen or more leading Wilmington businessmen called on Lincoln one day. They told him they represented the “weighty men of Delaware” and had come to discuss ways and means of winning the war. After the chairman of the delegation had finished his little speech, Lincoln asked, “So you are the weighty men of Delaware? All from New Castle County?” “Yes, all from the same city.” “Well,” said Lincoln mischievously, “did it ever occur to you gentlemen that there was danger of your little state tipping up during your absence?”

     [From Paul Boller’s Presidential Anecdotes.]

* * *

     I could go on in this vein, but I think the point has been made:

To be effective,
Be Funny!

     Cultivate a sense for the absurd. Observe and remember the contradictions and inconsistencies that abound among men, for these are the wellspring of humor. Don’t wear a grim face when out and about. Make others laugh, or groan. And remember this: if your taste runs to the pratfall, make yourself the object of it. People will happily laugh with you, as long as you aren’t laughing at them.

Laugh! And the world laughs with you.
Weep… and you weep alone.
For this sad old Earth
Must borrow its mirth
But has troubles enough of its own.

     May God bless and keep you all.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Demise Of Multiculturalism

     Even five years ago, I would not have predicted this.

     Voices are rising throughout the First World for an end to the promotion of cultures alien to that of the Christian Enlightenment. The engine powering this surge was ignited by the distaste ethnic Europeans have for the arrogance and aggression of Muslim immigrants. Their governments imposed Third World immigrants upon them by mouthing pieties about “low birth rates” and “the economy.” Europeans soon discovered that those millions of Muslims would have effects far more significant than an increment to the GDP.

     Much the same has happened in Australia, Japan, and America, though the effects of those immigrants have been slower to become visible, and the official defense of them leans more on “diversity.”

     Law enforcement, particularly in the United Kingdom, has deferred to Muslims and Islam. Clashes between Muslims and other Britons have almost always been “settled” in favor of the Muslims. London is now under de facto control of its Muslim residents. The same appears to be developing in Paris and New York. The three capitals of the West are becoming alien to it.

     But wait: there’s more! As I’ve written before, success breeds emulation. As Muslims have imposed themselves ever more on the rest of us, racial and ethnic minorities have noted it and have copied their aggressiveness. A reaction to the swell of violence and predation was predictable, though I did not expect it to be so large.

     The boil might be near to bursting.

* * *

     Questions abound. What is ethically justifiable in dealing with a querulous, disorderly, and often violent minority some of whose members are innocent? Can wholesale measures be rationalized when they’re guaranteed to sweep in the blameless? If so, where do the limits lie?

     The late Jack Vance dealt with the question several times. He, who apparently disavowed any particular ideology or moral theory, seemed fascinated by the subject. Here’s one of his emissions on it:

     Xanten made an airy gesture. “A. G. Philidor, you over-simplify grievously. Do you consider me obtuse? There are many kinds of history. They interact. You emphasize morality. But the ultimate basis of morality is survival. What promotes survival is good; what induces mortefaction is bad.”
     “Well spoken!” declared Philidor. “But let me propound a parable. May a nation of a million beings destroy a creature who otherwise will infect all with a fatal disease? Yes, you will say. Once more: Ten starving beasts hunt you, that they may eat. Will you kill them to save your life? Yes, you will say again, though here you destroy more than you create. Once more: a man inhabits a hut in a lonely valley. A hundred spaceships descend from the sky, and attempt to destroy him. May he destroy those ships in self-defense, even though he is one and they are a hundred thousand? Perhaps you say yes. What, then, if a whole world, a whole race of beings, pits itself against this single man? May he kill all? What if the attackers are as human as himself? What if he were the creature of the first instance, who otherwise will infect a world with disease? You see, there is no area where a simple touchstone avails.”

     [From The Last Castle.]

     You might imagine that he would dissent from an essentially collectivist program to deal with a difficult minority. But perhaps not:

     "Why did you decide to kill these four young people?"
     "Why does the sun shine? Why does the wind blow? I admit nothing. On the Lutwen Islands live a hundred thousand folk. At Stroma are a few hundred; at Araminta a few hundred more. If every Lutwenese still on Deucas were able to kill four woskers, there would be none left."
     "Quite so. Lucidly and reasonably put." Ysel Laverty smiled grimly. "We had hoped to terminate jobs like yours by attrition. You were trusted and might have remained here as long as you liked. It seems to have been a mistaken policy. Because of your act, every Yip on Deucas will be sent home, or perhaps off-world."

     [From Araminta Station]

     The cleavage question, whose answer determines the range of ethically acceptable measures, is Are we at war? At war, things unthinkable under peacetime conditions suddenly seem reasonable. War makes possible measures such as this one. Peoples allow their governments to do “what must be done” to avert outcomes such as this one.

     And all must live with the consequences.

* * *

     I could go on, but I think my Gentle Readers will have the idea by now. Are First Worlders at war with the alien cultures that have been imported to their shores? That’s the critical decision. Who will make it? As First World governments are complicit in facilitating the Third World’s invasion of the First, we cannot expect their luminaries to admit their errors voluntarily and strive to correct them.

     But national populaces have seldom compelled war upon their States. The opposite is far more frequently the case.

     Should a great number of Britons, Frenchmen, or Germans decide that they cannot and will not abide Muslims any longer, what would follow? Do they have anything close to the means required to expel that many invaders? Were they to embark upon it, would they succeed in imposing new terms upon their States? What would follow geopolitically?

     Americans could do so. We have the means and the numbers. But is it conceivable? What would follow for federal immigration policy and American political alignments?

     This isn’t just “food for thought.” Consider comparative birth rates. Consider Ilhan Omar, Abdul El-Sayed, and Zohran Mamdani. Consider Dearborn and Hamtramck. A time of decision will be upon us all too soon.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Heritages

     We speak loosely of certain things that seem sufficiently common to us all. But we also speak pretty loosely of “us all.” Does it have specific criteria for membership? Are there by-laws? Can you be thrown out of the club for violating them?

     Yes, I’m being slightly silly here, but I do have a point.

     Not long ago, I ran across a rant by an entertainment lawyer to the effect that most of us who write fiction could be sued for zillions for the copyright violations we commit in our stories. Even quoting a few lines from a pop song, he wrote, exposes the writer to legal hazard. Lawsuits have been filed over such things, yes – but how often does the plaintiff win, and on what grounds? How often are such suits dismissed by the court, and on what grounds do the dismissals rest?

     In looking into such things, the inquirer will find a particular phrase prominent: “The common cultural heritage of Mankind.” Certain artistic treasures are regarded as being part of that heritage. Therefore, quoting them or referring to them is regarded as legally protected. Their originator is regarded as having lost copyright protection, often by having had the grace to die long ago.

     But admission to “the common cultural heritage of Mankind” is a rather informal process. It’s a prestigious thing, something to which many an artist would aspire. However, there are no strict criteria, other than some legislated magic numbers that are also legislatively alterable.

     I’ve occasionally “taken liberties” with a song lyric. I did so in this novel, and have done so occasionally in my pieces here. Perhaps I was legally assailable for it, but no lawsuits have followed. Many other writers have done the same. Yet those song lyrics are supposedly copyright-protected.

     Will those lyrics and others like them ever pass into “the common cultural heritage of Mankind?” It’s not possible to know. Some will be forgotten entirely, which would render the question moot. Others, possibly including some that are current as I write this, will be celebrated for decades to come. Yet at some point their legal protections will lapse. Will they then be deemed to be part of that cultural heritage?

     It’s a loose category, and fairly recent at that. I rather doubt that Ludwig van Beethoven bothered to ask Johann Friedrich von Schiller for permission to use the latter’s “Ode to Joy” in the final movement of the former’s Ninth Symphony. I could be wrong, of course.

     At this time, American copyright protection for written material extends throughout the life of the writer plus seventy years. (However, several contemporary writers have placed some of their novels outside copyright, as is their right.) After that, the work passes into the “public domain” – which is not the same as “the common cultural heritage of Mankind.” That more august category omits much that’s deemed unworthy to be so designated, and includes many works that were never deemed legally protected.

     We’re not done here. There are “fair use” provisions in the law, which permit modest quotes in reviews and other commentary. Other nations have other laws. Figuring out which laws apply to which writers and which of their works can cause headaches. And of course, some of those other nations have no standing to sue in an American jurisdiction. Often no such suit is ever contemplated, as the possible return is less than the cost of the plane ticket.

     In general, it’s courteous and good practice to ask a writer for permission to include a bit of his stuff in yours. However, I draw the line at song lyrics that pop into my head spontaneously. I deem them to be part of my “cultural heritage.” I’ll use them any way I damned well please, as compensation for their presumption in appropriating space in my brain.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Bad Moon At High Noon

     The consequences of unwisdom always arrive, albeit not always immediately.

     Do you remember This incident in Minnesota?

     On July 15, 2017, Justine Damond (née Ruszczyk), a 40-year-old Australian-American woman, was fatally shot by Minneapolis Police Department officer Mohamed Noor after she had called 9-1-1 to report the possible assault of a woman in an alley behind her house. Occurring weeks after a high-profile manslaughter trial acquittal in the 2016 police killing of Philando Castile, also in the Minneapolis–Saint Paul metropolitan area, the shooting attracted national and international press, exacerbated existing tensions over policing, and led to widespread street protests. Minneapolis Police Chief Janeé Harteau was forced to resign her post after facing substantial public criticism for her response to the deaths of Damond and Castile.

     Mohamed Noor, a Muslim Somalian immigrant, was unwisely admitted to the Minneapolis police force. That cost an innocent life. You’d think the incident would have alerted police forces everywhere to the unwisdom of allowing Muslims to serve as police. It didn’t:

     That happened less than twelve miles from my home.

     Other, unverified reports of similar behavior by Muslim cops are available. Muslim cops in New York City have harassed a woman for walking her dog. There are numerous reports of Muslim cops in New York refusing to enforce motor vehicle laws against other Muslims.

     Getting the idea yet?

     This is a subject I’ve written about often, occasionally at great length. If we combine Islamic insistence that Muslims’ duty is to impose Islam and sharia on all other creeds with the power-tropism that characterizes applicants to police departments, stir well, and serve, what else could we reasonably expect?

     Must I say out loud that we cannot have Muslims with badges? Muslims in positions of authority? Muslims who think they’ve been awarded the power to impose the dictates of their savage, Seventh-Century creed on peaceable Americans?

     But now New York City has a Muslim mayor. Minnesota has a Muslim Attorney-General, and has elected a Muslim to the United States Senate. Dearborn, Michigan is now a Muslim-majority city whose public officials are predominantly Muslim. Texas, which has experienced unprecedented levels of Muslim ingress, faces the construction of an Islamic city.

     If such unwisdoms proliferate and are permitted to continue, further consequences will be swift to arrive. We won’t like them much.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Differences And Humility

     This morning, two tweets about the paucity of fiction written for boys have my attention. First:

     We are going to have a fundamental difference of opinion if you think the answer to boys not reading is to write about “boy stuff” and not rethink how we engage with boys in general let alone as readers. No specific interest or taste should be placed on a gender binary!!!

     Second, the response:

     This kind of retardation is why you cannot write, and thus why, in 14 years on this platform, you have only accumulated an audience of 2000.
     You don't understand what the basic task of fiction writing even is.
     It's empathizing in two directions at once.
     You have to empathize with the characters, to know what they are thinking and feeling, what they want and why, so you know what happens in the story. And you have to empathize with the audience, so you know how to tell it.
     Except you cannot empathize with half the human race, because your overt ideology prevents you from admitting its very existence.
     You cannot make the effort to understand how men and boys see the world, what men and boys want, what men and boys believe, what men and boys are interested in, or what men and boys will do, if you cannot acknowledge that “men and boys” is an distinct category of people that exist, and therefore is possible to know things about.
     Of course, you do not actually believe that boys are indistinct from girls. No one believes that.
     If you believed that, you would not be able to engage with the question “Why are boys not reading?” because the very question is an admission that there is something distinct about certain children that makes them boys and not girls.
     No, what you actually believe is “If I acknowledge the differences between boys and girls, I will be punished by my social group.”
     This belief is true.
     But so what? It's entirely your fault that you chose a social group which makes such ridiculous demands.
     MY social group doesn't demand I pretend to believe silly things.
     You don't actually have to play this game anymore, you know. You can just stop. Sure, some people you know will say mean things to you, but you and I both know they kinda do a lot of that already just because of the kind of people they are.
     You and I also both know they would throw you under a bus in microsecond if some innovation in the mandatory belief system rewarded them for doing so.
     So, in addition to not having an audience, you don't even have all that many friends, for much the same reason.
     You may wish to reconsider whether the juice is actually worth the squeeze.

     Now, that second tweet is about as unsparing as it could get. It expresses open contempt of the previous one’s position, convictions, and personal integrity. The author, Devon Eriksen, is rather outspoken about his convictions, which he often goes on about at great length. That’s his right, but I think he’s a nasty son of a bitch more likely to evoke anger, resentment, and hatred than any positive reaction… even though in fact, his statement is largely correct.

     The facts are on Eriksen’s side. Facts are about differences. All information is rooted in the perception of a difference. The difference between boys and girls is the one at issue.

     The first tweeter, Kate Campione, refuses to acknowledge that difference. It would concede the “gender binary,” which she refuses to do. She’s actually rather militant about it; note the exclamation points. That’s the consequence of her adoption of a particular contemporary nostrum. That nostrum makes it impossible for her to respect the consequent fact that boys take little interest in fiction that centers on female tastes and aspirations. So factually, Eriksen’s demolition of Campione’s tweet is accurate.

     But a little humility would have served Eriksen well. Indeed, it would serve him in more fora and on more subjects than this one. The readiness to slather contempt on others is not a winning personality trait. Most people, including most who would agree with Eriksen’s statements of fact, are drawn more to kindness and civility than to brutality and contempt.

     X / Twitter isn’t Speakers’ Square. It isn’t a Sunday morning talking heads’ broadcast, whose participants are paid to slag one another off. (Yes, this is a Sunday morning. Don’t press the matter.) It’s particularly tawdry to try to humiliate another participant on the grounds of her low follower count. What can you purchase with that?

     You can be dead right on the facts and still be destructive in manner when you assert them. There’s no need for it, ever. And that’s all I have to say on the matter, except for this:

     Chapter 6 in the Book of Wisdom personifies Wisdom as female. Have a few verses:

     Wisdom is glorious, and never fadeth away, and is easily seen by them that love her, and is found by them that seek her.
     She preventeth them that covet her, so that she first sheweth herself unto them.
     He that awaketh early to seek her, shall not labour: for he shall find her sitting at his door.
     To think, therefore, upon her, is perfect understanding: and he that watcheth for her, shall quickly be secure.
     For she goeth about seeking such as are worthy of her, and she sheweth herself to them cheerfully in the ways, and meeteth them with all providence.
     For the beginning of her is the most true desire of discipline.
     And the care of discipline is love: and love is the keeping of her laws: and the keeping of her laws is the firm foundation of incorruption:
     And incorruption bringeth near to God.

     Wisdom does not inhere in facts. It inheres in the recognition of fundamental things. Among those are the recognition of one’s own limitations and fallibility.

     May God bless and keep you all.

Friday, November 6, 2026

The Tenor Of Our Age

     A provocative tweet from Spain has raised a question that has no universally applicable answer:

A 24-year-old woman started working in our office on Monday.
By Wednesday, she had already handed in her resignation.
The reason?
She refused to install a company app on her personal phone.
Her boss told her it was mandatory for receiving messages outside the office.
She asked if they would give her a work phone.
They told her no.
“So, will you pay part of my phone bill?”
“No. Everyone here does it.”
The woman looked at the rest of the team.
No one said anything.
Then she asked one last question:
“And if you message me on a Saturday, do I have to reply?”
Her boss replied:
“We expect commitment, not for you to be watching the clock.”
She looked at him and asked him a question that left the entire office in silence…
"Does commitment also show up in the paycheck, or is it only demanded once my workday ends?"
The boss laughed.
"With that attitude, you won't get very far."
She nodded.
"Maybe. But at least I'll get home knowing I've finished working."
She closed her laptop.
She gathered her things.
And she left.

She'd been with us less than three days.
And she got half the office wondering why we'd spent years putting up with it.
The funny thing is, some colleagues called her immature.
They said that at 24, she wasn't in a position to get so demanding.
Others said they wished they'd had her courage at that age.
I was left thinking one thing.
I get that a company needs committed people.
That there are unexpected things and times when you have to put in extra effort.
But if being available outside work hours is an obligation, why is it presented as a voluntary show of commitment?
And now tell me this:
Was she irresponsible for leaving a job on the third day, or did she do the right thing by setting boundaries from the start?

     Have you ever been in that young woman’s position, Gentle Reader? I have. Startup companies are like that. The possibility of “making it big” in such a company can outweigh the employee’s desire for boundaries between work and private life. But what about in established firms, where the real prospects are merely for a salary, annual increments to it, and the possibility of promotion?

     An established firm has clout enough to demand such accommodations and insist on them, especially in a buyer’s market for labor. The young woman who refused the demand is exceptional for having had the courage and resolve to do so.

     Should she remain an exception, or should the rest of us strap on our spines and stand with her?

* * *

     There’s been a lot of talk recently about “work-life balance” and getting it right. Once again, there’s no generic formula that every working stiff can apply. Personal circumstances make all such decisions individual. Sometimes personal or familial needs constrain our options, often to the point of eliminating all but one. Employers will take advantage of such constraints.

     It’s part of what Thomas Sowell has called “the tragic vision.” All choices involve costs, including the sacrifice of the unchosen options. Life is not “fair” in any enforceable sense. Legislative attempts to make it “fair” by some standard are nearly always misguided, for such laws preemptively eliminate options that some would willingly choose. That’s particularly the case regarding employment decisions.

     All the same, contemporary employers’ readiness to impose after-hours requirements on employees does not speak well of contemporary employment practices or corporate cultures. Work isn’t everything. They who work for wages expect to have some personal freedom once they’ve downed tools for the day. Family and personal needs can be unsparing. Decent employers should take such things into account. It might help to bring the divorce and suicide rates down.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

The Bloodbath

     Good morning, Gentle Reader. Happy Guy Fawkes’ Day. Do you feel like burning someone in effigy? I do.

     Needless to say, the results of the midterms have been on everyone’s mind. How did it happen? What should we expect? How do we cope with it? And of course, the gurus of opinion-mongering all have their analyses and prescriptions.

     It seems to me that the old investors’ maxim – “Past performance is no guarantee of future returns” – has some relevance here. Past performance doesn’t guarantee anything, but it’s all the information we have. Besides, the technical analysts have their maxim too: “The trend is your friend.” So we tend to steer by the winds we know.

     While no one in the Right wanted to see the Democrats take control on Capitol Hill, midterm elections tend to disfavor the party whose man is in the White House. So there were reasons to believe that the Left would make some gains. Given the thinness of the majorities the GOP enjoyed in both Houses, the loss of those majorities was, if not guaranteed, possible at least and probable if we go by the polls.

     But matters were graver than we thought. The fecklessness of the Republican caucuses disgusted many conservatives and Republican partisans. The GOP needed more voter turnout than it got. When a substantial fraction of “your voters” stay home, you tend to lose seats in Congress. Funny about that.

     How could it have been otherwise? Voter turnout is determined by voter engagement, and the Republican-led Congress gave us little to engage with. Blame is being heaped on a few prominent figures – Trump and Thune lead the list – but deeper understanding requires a deeper look.

     The Republican pattern is a “do nothing” pattern. The GOP has squandered its majorities since the era of Coolidge. This time around was different only in this: President Trump was expected to get them into motion. But the 119th Congress was indisposed to being mobilized for the Trump agenda.

     Sad as it is to say, that was predictable. After all, the successes of the first Trump Administration were largely produced by executive orders. The Republican caucuses of those four years were as intractable as those of the 119th Congress. The reasons are largely the same in both cases.

     A substantial number of Congressional Republicans dislike Trump and his agenda. Some didn’t want to support him. Others didn’t want to be seen supporting him. Trump’s titular leadership of the Republican Party meant little to them, for they had made careers out of their offices. Presidents can’t do that.

     Add that to Republicans’ notorious aversion to media criticism and their pusillanimity before the slanders of the Left. Add also the “don’t rock the boat” mentality that’s characterized Republican political performance since FDR. Add finally GOP nervousness about being blamed for anything that might go wrong following substantial policy changes. Given all that, would it have been reasonable to expect Republican gains in Congress?

     So here we are. What’s next?

     I expect we’ll have to endure another attempt to remove Trump from the White House. Worse, several anti-Trump Republicans will sign onto it. He probably will be impeached yet again, though he’s unlikely to be removed. His hands will be tied concerning Iran and the Middle East. He may be impeded in other areas of foreign policy as well.

     The bloodbath will also fuel the rise of contenders for the presidency who stand apart from Trump’s “Make America Great Again” agenda. They’ll point to the losses of November 3, 2026 as evidence that “it wasn’t want the nation wanted.” While attention has focused on J.D. Vance and Marco Rubio, expect the camera lenses to be pulled toward other figures that gain popular traction. The MAGA movement, such as it is, is likely to fragment as those new figures emerge.

     This is not an argument against the Trump agenda. It’s merely a forecast of the dynamics the bloodbath will evoke. If there’s a lesson for conservative-inclined voters, it would be this:

     If we want changes to federal policy, we must change federal policymakers. The opportunity to do that comes during the primaries, not on Election Day.

     Perhaps we’ll find stouter hearts and sincerer tongues to represent us two years hence. If it’s to be so, it’s time to get working on it now.

     Oh yes, there’s this as well: Buy ammo. Just in case, you understand.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Incomplete Questions

Let me remind you of the pilgrim
Who asked for an audience with the Dalai Lama
He was told he must first spend five years in contemplation
After the five years
He was ushered into the Dalai Lama's presence, who said
'Well, my son, what do you wish to know?'
So the pilgrim said
'I wish to know the meaning of life, father.'
So the Dalai Lama smiled and said
'Well my son, life is like a beanstalk, isn't it?'

[ Procol Harum ]

     This morning, we have a provocative question:

     We’ve been here before, of course:

     I’ve known a fair number of reasonably intelligent people in my sixty-six years. Many of them were atheists. But they were no happier than the theists around them. In many cases they were less happy. One complained to me privately about the sense that his life was meaningless. As bright as he was – IQ around 145, by my informal estimate – he hadn’t grasped that meaning requires an interpreter.

     “The meaning of life,” as XCosmos has put it, must be completed to be of use: “The meaning of life” to whom? To God? To history? To some federally nominated Board of Life Interpreters? Or to the asker himself?

     The completions vary; thus, the possible answers vary.

* * *

     Long ago I was told about a philosophy professor who, weary of the bickering among his students, posed them an incisive question: “Why was it wrong for Cain to kill Abel?”

     The students tossed it back and forth. Many claimed that for one human to kill another is always wrong. Others took the position that it “wasn’t necessarily wrong,” that “we don’t have all the facts.” And of course there were participants between those two poles.

     The professor allowed it to go on for awhile before he hauled the class up short. He gave the only answer that the tale of Cain and Abel in Genesis will support: “Because it was.”

     When the conditions surrounding an event have been fully specified, and the moral-ethical standards are agreed upon, questions of morality and ethics are answerable. It was wrong for Cain to kill Abel because Abel was an innocent who didn’t deserve to die. Willfully killing an innocent man is murder, which is wrong. That’s an absolute upon which Western societies agree. To question it is to question the basis of Christian-Enlightenment society.

     Yes, there are lands whose denizens don’t hew to Christian-Enlightenment moral-ethical standards. We’re having a spot of trouble with nations of that sort. Worse, individuals and groups within our own nation are disdaining those standards, some for political purposes. Consider the Left’s attitude toward the murder of Charlie Kirk. Those cleavages are causing more horror and grief than any other abstract disagreement could.

* * *

     At the base of all of what Robert Burns called “Man’s inhumanity to man” one will always find divergences from moral-ethical standards. But we’re aware that there are other lands than those of the Christian Enlightenment. They cannot trouble us unless we permit it… and by and large, we don’t.

     The divergences from Christian-Enlightenment moral-ethical standards among Americans are more troubling. They force an uncomfortable question upon us: What do we mean by ‘an American?’ What are the qualifications? Contemporary realities compel us to include those standards among the qualifications. That implies something many people would rather not face.

     Just as one cannot inquire about meaning without specifying an interpreter, one cannot inquire about membership of any kind without specifying the qualifications for membership. Aristotle told us so many centuries ago. The question must be complete to be meaningful… which brings us full-circle to the nature of meaning yet again. Sorry about that.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Democracy

     [This first appeared at the old Palace of Reason, so long ago that I can no longer remember exactly when. – FWP]

     To many Americans, the names of the two majority parties are words without precise definitions. The original meaning of the word “democracy” has been displaced by a host of implications and a glow of unquestioned sanctity. For “republic,” few persons have any feeling at all.

     In the Random House World Atlas, the United States is classified as a “federal republic.” Indeed, it was the intent of the Founding Fathers to form precisely that object; and for about a hundred years, the political structure of the United States was in that style. However, with respect for the editors of the World Atlas, it is no longer any such thing.

     Several historians specializing in the Constitutional period have written of the fear of democracy several Founders expressed. A number of historians have inferred that, whatever their gifts might have been, these nation-builders regarded the common man with the contempt typical of oligarchs. It's difficult to verify or falsify such a suspicion at two centuries' remove.

     Concerning the contempt felt for the private citizen by our contemporary political class, there is much that may be observed and analyzed. Despite politicians' endless public importunings for our “participation,” it is quite clear that once we favor any one of them with enough votes to install him in office, his desire for citizen “participation” vanishes. A citizen may count himself lucky to get half a minute's attention from a sitting executive, legislator, or judge, until about three months before that executive, legislator or judge is due to stand for re-election, and even then a furious waving of the checkbook is generally required. On the approachability and attentiveness of career bureaucrats, it is unnecessary to comment.

     In the early days of the Republic, the franchise was extremely limited in scope and application. The citizens of a state who were Caucasian, male, over twenty-one years of age, and owned land in that state could vote for the men who would sit in one or both of the two chambers of that state's legislature. The enfranchised citizens of the state were also empowered to choose those who would sit for them in the House of Representatives. Members of the Senate were chosen by the legislatures, not the people, of the states they represented, as required by the Constitution. The President was chosen by a College of Electors, whose members were also chosen by the state legislatures.

     Clearly, the citizen's democratic franchise, if he had it, was much less extended then, and its effects upon the federal government were much less direct than is the case today. The state of affairs described above lasted almost unchanged until 1913, when the Seventeenth Amendment empowered enfranchised citizens to choose federal Senators. The Sixteenth (Income Tax) Amendment and the Federal Reserve Act were also passed in 1913. In 1914, the fraction of the Gross National Product consumed by government at all levels passed 10% for the first time.

     Within five years, the United States had entered a war against a group of nations with which it had no contiguous borders; the federal government had asserted the power to nationalize whole industries; conscription and price controls had been instituted; the federal government had “suspended” redemption-in-gold of federal paper currency; a massive “civil service” bureaucracy, hundreds of thousands strong, had arisen in Washington; nine billion dollars (more than $200 billion in 1988 dollars) had been loaned to the governments of Great Britain and France from the federal treasury, never to be repaid; federal expenditures had exceeded the sum of all state and county expenditures for the first time; and 125,000 Americans had died in the trenches, fields and hospitals of war-ravaged Europe.

     This is not to suggest that the direct election of Senators, or the extension of the franchise to non-Caucasians and women, brought these things about. But it is remarkable that a people living in nearly complete peace and freedom could have been stripped so thoroughly of that peace and freedom for so small a price as the extension of the power to vote.

     Not one of the statist-imperialist trends set in motion during the Wilson Administration has ever been abated. The Republic had been dismantled from within, and a democracy had been erected in its place. A republic is a nation in which the permissible activities of government are limited by a written Constitution which defines them precisely; a democracy is a nation in which the majority makes all decisions, either directly or through its representatives, and imposes them on the minority by force. The doctrine of individual sovereignty had disappeared as government at all levels asserted unlimited power to arrange the lives of Americans and dispose of their fortunes as it pleased.

     Some of the Republic's finest moments were among its last, under one of its least appreciated Presidents, Grover Cleveland. Cleveland was the last of the Democrats of the party of Thomas Jefferson and Andrew Jackson, “the party of hard money and personal liberty.” Under rising pressure from his own party, Cleveland maintained to the end that government in America had only a limited sphere; at tremendous cost to his popularity, he vetoed every emission of Congress not consistent with the moral limits on government. Among his achievements against a socialist tide whose strength is hard to appreciate today, Cleveland restrained the federal government's debt and spending, prevented the use of tax revenues for individual or corporate welfarism, blocked all attempts to legislate on personal morality, saved the gold standard, and limited the size of the civil service. The excesses of his successors would not have been possible had Cleveland not preserved the country in such fine condition.

     Old Grover knew what a republic was, and it's plain that he loved ours. He might well weep to see what has taken its place.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

For Your Own Good Dept.

     “Death is the price we pay for our life, and for all life.” – Ursula Le Guin, The Farthest Shore
     “No one here gets out alive.” – Jim Morrison

     Welcome to All Hallows’ Eve, Gentle Reader. Yes, it’s better known as Hallowe’en – don’t omit the apostrophe – and the legions of candy-grubbing spratlings in weird costumes that troop from door to door in the evening. But in point of fact, this is the opening day of a solemn Christian commemoration. This day is marked for the contemplation of mortality: yours and mine.

     We shall all die. All that lived before us knew it. All that will come after us will know it, too. Fantasies of physical immortality are just that.

     Thousands are dying as we speak. For many, the event is considered premature, because their lives were ended by accident or violence. But we don’t get to say when the clock of mortality, “that two-handed engine that stands behind the door,” will smite us for the last time.

     It behooves us to be ready.

* * *

     Whew! Glad that’s out of the way. Now where was I? Oh yes, this story:

     The manosphere and online misogyny should be treated by the government as a public health issue, in the same way as obesity or smoking, experts have said.
     Writing in the Lancet, the authors of a new report argue that a coordinated response is needed, involving governments, schools, health services and community organisations, similar to the public-health response to tobacco use and ultra-processed food.
     “Men’s problems are framed [in the manosphere] as the result of feminism rather than structural conditions, and masculine identity is commodified through products and paid content that normalise and reinforce health-harming and performance-oriented masculinities,” the authors write.
     The report defines the manosphere as “a diffuse commercial ecosystem and loose collection of online communities united by shared beliefs about masculinity, misogyny and male victimisation”.

     Heavens to Murgatroyd! Men online are saying critical things about women! I could stop right there, secure in the knowledge that my Gentle Readers are all bright enough to predict the rest. However, a bit from the cited article in The Lancet deserves special attention:

     Similar to the tobacco and ultra-processed food industries,44 content creators and hosting platforms deploy strategies that individualise responsibility.45 Men's problems are framed as the result of feminism rather than structural conditions, and masculine identity is commodified through products and paid content that normalise and reinforce health-harming and performance-oriented masculinities.46 Efforts to regulate or moderate content are frequently framed as threats to men's autonomy, restricting political space for intervention.

     So treatment of the “public health issue” of men griping about women and pursuing traditionally masculine goals is being impeded by that inconvenient matter of freedom of expression! Well, the folks in the United Kingdom have already been told that that’s over with. No doubt their political masters will defer to “experts” Sarah Hawkes and Kent Buse. After all, it’s for your own good!

     Yes, we Americans take a somewhat different view of the matter. But… but… public health! Surely we can see the importance of that! What’s an itty-bitty infringement of our free-speech rights compare to the all-important goal of protecting the health of the public? Can’t we give just a little for something so momentous? It’s for your own good!

     I could go on this way, but it’s ceased to be entertaining.

* * *

     Time was, the “public health” shibboleth was reserved for dangerous infectious diseases. Maladies that can spread rapidly among the populace without anyone knowing. There was some justification for government efforts at tracking and general education, at least. But not long ago, the Left discovered the intimidating power of the phrase. It developed that even Americans are willing to allow their rights to be abridged in the name of “public health.”

     Even Robert A. Heinlein, one of the most freedom-loving of well-known writers, was willing to permit such abridgement:

     ‘Lies! I'm not going to say another word without my lawyer.’
     At which point I made yet another mistake. ‘But, Priscilla, I am a lawyer; you know that. What they're asking is quite reasonable, a matter of public health.’

     The power of that phrase is quite astounding. I hope the ghost of Ayn Rand – it’s a good day for ghosts, isn’t it? – will forgive me for slightly altering something she wrote:

     “Mr. Rearden, the law which you are denouncing is based on the highest principle—the principle of the public health.”
     “Who is the public? What does it hold as its health?”

     Apparently, “public health” demands that we not own firearms, or drink wine, or eat what we like if “experts” disapprove of it. Mind you, there’s always a degree of dissent among the ranks of the “experts,” but some have the patronage of the Omnipotent State. Their recommendations get official respect. One guess as to why.

* * *
You don't really need to find out
What's going on
You don't really want to know
Just how far it's gone

(Don Henley)

     Everyone knows how far it’s gone. Lockdowns and forced vaccinations made it quite plain. Christian Scientists, Amish, and Mennonites who resist are painted as something akin to public enemies. It’s even been alleged that surgeons who operate on children for typical childhood needs are facilitating the vaccination of those children before the operation, without informing their parents or securing their consent. All in the name of “public health.”

     But we must raise the question governments most hate to face: “What if you’re wrong? Will you restore our rights, refund our money, and apologize for your intrusion on our lives?”

     There’s no chance we’ll get an honest answer. But upsetting the State is always worth doing.

Friday, October 30, 2026

Options Trading

     Every so often I’ll see a statement from a woman that makes me wonder if she has any ability to pay attention, much less a sense for the consequences of her actions:

     Oh, is that it? You were “weighing your options?” Pray tell, what options were you weighing? Whether the man who asked you out would provide better entertainment than some other, unnamed man? Or perhaps whether a “girls’ night out” would be preferable to an evening in his company? Did you give even an instant’s consideration to what that said to him?

     There are only two acceptable answers to an invitation to a date:

  • “Yes, I’d like that.”
  • “No, I’m sorry, but I already have plans.”

     Everything else is “options trading.” Not only is that one of the easiest ways to go broke; it’s also the route to a reputation no woman should want to acquire: that of a gold-digger.

     Think about it, for heaven’s sake! “I’ll think about it” says explicitly that he who issued the invitation may not be good enough to be worth your precious time! What kind of message is that? What would you have thought had your positions been reversed?

     (Nota bene: Gentlemen, never, ever pose an invitation to a lady as “would you like to go out sometime?” That’s bad. Always give a specific date, and the first item on the evening’s agenda – usually, dinner. Not to do so leaves the lady wondering just what she’s being asked to do. She would be entirely within her rights to decline with prejudice. Also, remember that three successive declines constitute a permanent negative response.)

     I’ve fulminated about this sort of idiocy before, of course. Not that it matters. Female thoughtlessness and callousness are everywhere. Yet they complain to one another – “Where have all the good men gone?” – without a moment’s reflection on how they have helped to produce the current situation.

     You want to know why so many men are “hit and run” types, ladies? Why they’ll grab what they can, sometimes a single night’s pleasure, and disappear? Their disdain for you is a response to your unabashed calculations about their “value.” Your constant “can I do better than him?” musings. As you reduce them to their net worth, they reduce you to your mucous membranes.

     “As ye sow, so shall ye reap.” It’s one of the oldest proverbs. It applies to agriculture and social dealing with equal force. A young woman once learned such basic wisdoms at her mother’s knee. But a great many of their mothers either have fallen down on the job, or haven’t learned it themselves. More’s the pity.

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Acculturation

     Adaptability is a double-edged sword. One who moves from a culture in which he’s comfortable to another which differs from it is expected to adapt. But his adaptation can take more than one form.

     Imagine one who moves from a dirty, violent, lawless place – a place where life is “nasty, poor, brutish, and short” – to a place of peace, cleanliness, and mutual trust. There’s no guarantee that he’ll adapt to his new environment by conforming to its norms. He may see those around him, so wealthy, clean, and peaceable in aspect – as pigeons for the plucking. Having been steeped in the ethics of his previous environments – i.e., whatever you can get away with is quite all right – he might just try to pluck them.

     Americans have been seeing a lot of that. Many of us have reacted against it, which is rational and sane. Many others have done the opposite: they’ve claimed that we, the clean, peaceable, trusting ones, have an obligation to adapt to the newcomers. They may even believe that it’s our ethical obligation to do so.

     It “should be obvious” that whichever doctrine prevails will determine the future of that society. What’s not so obvious are the sub-processes by which that future is attained.

* * *

     Mourn the passing of a great nation:

     Rhodesia was a great nation. It was built entirely by colonists from Great Britain. Yes, it was imposed willy-nilly upon the blacks in that region. It was great nevertheless, a bastion of peace, order, and prosperity where the law of the jungle had reigned. The same was true of South Africa before the Whites surrendered political control to the blacks of that region.

     In neither land is there anything resembling public order or trust today. In neither land are Whites’ lives safe. The law of the jungle has returned.

     That’s what happens when a society ceases to enforce high-civilization norms and surrenders to those who disdain them. Actually, “disdain” isn’t the right word. They who destroyed Rhodesia and South Africa didn’t think about the norms the British and Boers brought to those places. They simply lived according to the norms of the jungle, where “whatever you can get away with is quite all right.” In the absence of enforcement, they were too many and too savage for the White minorities to cope with.

* * *

     A famous incident from a few years back had a remarkable sequel. The two Sikhs who stopped a blatant shoplifter by force were subsequently investigated for assault. Now ask yourself this:

What rational man, imbued with the norms of a high-trust society, would have blamed the Sikhs for doing what they did?

     Those two Sikhs may not have been thinking about the abstract threat to the high-trust society in which they lived. They may not have been thinking that “if we permit this, the store will close and we’ll lose our livelihoods.” They may have reacted purely from fury. Whatever the case, in the three-person microcosm depicted by the video, they imposed the norms they preferred upon the miscreant who had tried to impose his norms on them. They enforced the norms of high-trust society without embarrassment, and for a spell, the law of the jungle was warded off.

     But we must not pass on without pondering the other facet to the incident. Those Sikhs, who acted in defense of the store and the norms that made it possible, were suddenly subject to legal hazard. Had the district attorney decided to prosecute them, they would have suffered greatly even if ultimately acquitted. They were fortunate that it proved not to be necessary to defend themselves against the weight of the “justice system.”

     Acculturation can penetrate any institution. Get enough softheaded types into the system and they can remake it quite opposite to its original purpose. That’s happened in a number of places in these United States. I live uncomfortably near to one.

* * *

     In even the highest and most civilized societies, there will be a criminally-inclined subgroup. Members of that group will look for opportunities to exploit the prevalence of general trust. I wrote about such a person here:

     “And thank You, dear Lord, for keeping Onteora County well stocked with idiots,” Dominic intoned, head bowed over his folded hands. Tony looked up at him in surprise. “Thank You for making them trust those ridiculous Kruger-Smith snap locks, and for never suggesting to them that they shouldn’t keep all their valuables in the master bedroom. Your humble servant really appreciates these labor-saving conveniences.”….
     Some thieves seek riches. Others seek challenges to their skills. Dominic sought only sustenance.
     Onteora suited him. Its poor had little to defend, and were philosophical about losing it. Its better-offs were few enough not to stimulate much competition for him, and found more succor in their homeowner’s insurance than in the halfhearted efforts of the county police. He knew better than to attack the well secured, privately guarded homes of the county’s few rich. As long as he stayed fit and sharp, he could survive here.

     As long as they’re few, and kept in acceptable check by the “forces of order,” that high-trust society will survive with its norms intact. But when the forces of order become acculturated to failure, the few will attract emulators. Those who were previously unwilling to risk violating the norms will become bolder: “They get away with it, so we can too.” Evidence will accumulate that the norms of general trust are fading. Violators will multiply still faster.

     It’s a positive-feedback cycle.

* * *

     I could go on about this, but I think the point will stand. Either we enforce the norms – emphasis on force — or we’ll lose them. To that end, a particular attitude toward such things is to be eliminated: the notion that “the law belongs to the State.” It does not. The State is merely our agent. If that agent has ceased to fulfill its responsibilities, private citizens who understand the foundation of all law, the principles of right and wrong, must step in.

     Those two Sikhs got it right.
     Refuse to tolerate the intolerable.
     Reject acculturation to the law of the jungle.