Monday, September 17, 2012

Dark Gods

[This essay originally appeared at Eternity Road on January 4, 2006. Given the chaos of the moment, and the overwhelming significance of the election almost upon us, I felt it appropriate to repost it here.]

Fran here. In pondering the huge list of things I had in mind for this piece, which started life as a modest tangent from Mark Steyn's "It's The Demography, Stupid!" tour de force, I realized that there were issues even deeper than the ones Steyn has addressed. Those issues are prior and superior to all what's-the-problem and what-then-must-we-do inquiries, as important as those other things are. They're the things I most want to talk about, today and every day.

In a way, Steyn's focus is broader than mine, for he concerns himself with the whole of the developed world. My concern is for America. In another way, Steyn's focus is narrower than mine, for he concerns himself with visible threats to our present age. My concern is with the prospects for freedom and justice down the centuries to come.


1. Us And Them.

Political conflict is collective conflict. It obliges us to think in terms of opposed camps, facing one another over a more-or-less clearly defined line of conflict. Our entire approach to politics is founded on this attitude; indeed, it's impossible to talk about political matters in a political framework without it.

But the attitude has certain unexamined assumptions built into it:

  1. Each camp is essentially unified on those matters that constitute the field of battle.
  2. Those contentious matters are important enough to regard the other camp as the enemy, whose defeat eclipses all other political considerations.
  3. Compromise, even if it were possible, would be immoral and therefore unacceptable, or sufficiently less desirable than victory to make battle obligatory.

This makes political conflict sound a lot like war. As long as the assumptions go unchallenged, they compel us to hurl ourselves at the foe, and to accept no final outcome but definitive victory or undeniable defeat. But politics is not war; the shots fired are rhetorical, not metallic; no one dies from the contest itself; and no combatant ever accepts that he has been defeated for good. What does this do to the relations among men who opt for political engagement? In particular, what does it do to relations between a member of Us and a member of Them?

The answer depends critically on the ideological differences between Us and Them:

  1. Do we differ about about ultimate aims?
  2. Do we differ about the means to be used to achieve our aims?
  3. Do we differ about moral constraints?
  4. Do we differ about priorities?

Each of these gives rise to a different kind of conflict.


2. Meet The New Boss...Same As The Old Boss.

American political malaise at this time is rooted in a pathology of priorities. The Republicans have power; the Democrats want it back. Eleven years ago, the parties exchanged those positions, in the sort of electoral reversal to which a democratic republic is prone. Such reversals had happened before, of course. But I must note, sadly, that as our nation has aged, those reversals have had a steadily diminishing effect on public policy. Yet there are few substantive reasons to prefer one to the other.

At this time, prominent Democrats condemn the Bush Administration at every opportunity...for doing more or less what those Democrats would do in the Administration's place. The public wouldn't permit anything greatly different, given the events of the past five years. The anti-terror campaign might be conducted somewhat differently, but it would be there, and probably about as serious as it is today. There'd be a perceptible difference in the philosophies of the men nominated to the federal bench. The Old Media would be far more supportive of a Democratic administration. We'd be hearing a lot more about how it's all "for the children." But federal spending would be pretty much what it is, the alphabet agencies would behave pretty much as they have, and so on. In terms of day-to-day domestic governance and international dealing, the cone of popular preference that confines Washington's actions would make no greater allowances for Democrats than it does for Republicans.

These are not words of exculpation or praise. Our public officials should be able to do what's right rather than what's politically palatable and expedient. They should be able to tell us the uncomfortable truths we always refuse to hear. They should be able to refuse us when we demand that which is not rightfully ours, or that which would bring the Republic crashing down around our ears. But they are above us only in the power they wield; as men, they are an accurate representation of us -- in particular, of the weaknesses to which we of the year of Our Lord 2006 are prone.

Steyn's essay skewers those weaknesses with irresistible power:

...in the typical election campaign in your advanced industrial democracy, the political platforms of at least one party in the United States and pretty much all parties in the rest of the west are largely about what one would call the secondary impulses of society—government health care, government day care (which Canada’s thinking of introducing), government paternity leave (which Britain’s just introduced). We’ve prioritized the secondary impulse over the primary ones: national defense, family, faith, and, most basic of all, reproductive activity—“Go forth and multiply,” because if you don’t you won’t be able to afford all those secondary-impulse issues, like cradle-to-grave welfare....

The commanding heights of the culture have behaved disgracefully for the last several decades. But, if it were just a problem with the elites, it wouldn’t be that serious: the mob could rise up and hang ’em from lampposts—a scenario that’s not unlikely in certain Continental countries. But the problem now goes way beyond the ruling establishment. The annexation by government of most of the key responsibilities of life—child-raising, taking care of your elderly parents—has profoundly changed the relationship between the citizen and the state. At some point—I would say socialized health care is a good marker—you cross a line, and it’s very hard then to persuade a citizenry enjoying that much government largesse to cross back.

So why do the parties so furiously rage together?

The answer is unpleasant, but unavoidable. Their difference is a difference over priorities. The Democrats' top priority is power for the Democrats, and the Republicans' top priority is power for the Republicans. This diagnosis applies to just about every public official from either party, at least to some degree. Even President Bush, of whom I've often spoken admiringly, has from time to time conceded the priority of GOP power, for example when he threw his support behind Arlen Specter over the more reliably conservative Pat Toomey.

Ultimately, we are the reason for all of it. We've become demanding, petulant, querulous. We want our freebies and we want them now. Our descent into political venality has persuaded the best of men, the men of unshakable convictions, immaculate morality, and stainless honor, to remain out of the field. Those who've flowed into the vacuum are, to be kind, not the best of men. But they know how to pander to us.


3. iPod Opinions.

The great Mark Twain once had a character say, "You tell me whar a man gits his corn pone, en I'll tell you what his 'pinions is." Twain had accurately gauged the priority of individual interest over the common good in the minds of men. Alexander Hamilton put it somewhat less colorfully but no less accurately when he said: "Power over a man's subsistence is power over his will." But subsistence is no longer much of an issue in American society; luxury is.

Many will take issue with the following statement:

There is no one within the borders of the United States today who involuntarily lacks food, clothing, shelter, or health care.

Nevertheless, it is true. Unless you're a mountaineer at the top of Mount McKinley, these things are conveniently within your reach. If you lack the price, there are others -- many, many others -- who will purchase them for you, out of the goodness of their hearts. You can be separated from the necessities of life only by ignorance or willful intransigence.

What's that you say? The cuisine at the soup kitchens might not be to your taste? The clothes at the thrift center might be less than stylish? The shelter might be home to persons who snore? Ah, then what you want is not sustenance but your choice of sustenance. You want it your way. My sympathies, though fervent, are limited. Free gifts are given at the discretion of the giver, not the recipient. This is as it must be.

Having said that, I recognize that the demands persist. Millions of voices clamor for "free" this or "universal" that, meaning "I want someone else to pay for it." That's at the heart of calls for "socialized" anything, as conservatives and libertarians are aware. By traditional standards of right and wrong, the willingness to join in such calls indicates a moral deficit. But in an age of moral relativism, how does one refute such calls? Particularly when the relativism is so far reaching that it proclaims resistance to the demands to be the true crime?

Reflect for a moment on how far we've come. Two centuries ago, men who could not pay their obligations were imprisoned for it; today, innumerable agencies, public and private, rush into the gap to support them and theirs in something approaching luxury. The children of welfare families sport designer sneakers, gold chains, and the latest iPods. Their freedom from care doesn't prevent their parents, and their parents' political mouthpieces, from demanding ever more: "affordable" housing titled to them, unlimited free health care, unlimited free broadband Internet access, guaranteed access to college regardless of demonstrated academic merit, and so on...all at someone else's expense.

How could we doubt that the beneficiaries of such largesse would enthusiastically support the system that had pampered them? How could we doubt that they would demand its extension to the uttermost limits of human greed? How could we doubt that they would castigate in the harshest of terms those who opposed their demands?

I'm not talking solely about the objects of public assistance, either. An awful lot of folks live rather luxuriously at public expense while nominally "employed." Mostly they languish in government sinecures, from which they can only be removed by death or an offense so egregious that a century ago they'd have been hanged for it, possibly without the luxury of a trial.

As Robert A. Heinlein put it, the Makers -- we who keep the nation running by actual productive effort -- are being swarmed under by the Takers and the Fakers. These latter groups show no sign that they're learning either gratitude or moderation. Where's the percentage in that, after all? Why change a winning strategy, when strident-if-baseless demands have worked so well so far?

Were barbarians to batter down America's gates, would they take up arms and fight for her, or would they demand that the Makers do it for them?

Take a good close look at them. Whether they're conscious of it or not, they're the enemies of civilization; indeed, the enemies of Man himself. Then take a good close look in the nearest mirror and assure yourself that you're not one of them. Promise yourself that you'll never become one of them.

They don't examine themselves as you have done. They don't dare. They would see the face of a god upon whose visage they dare not look.


4. Cthulhu's Cadre.

It's true that some of the types mentioned above operate from a cerebral vacuum -- that they lack the capacity to understand what they're doing to the nation at whose teats they nurse. But others understand full well. Theirs is a mentality and morality qualitatively indistinguishable from that of the criminal. They differ only in their unwillingness to soil their own hands with gunpowder or blood.

The criminal, unless he's consciously consumed by the desire to destroy, is moved by avarice. He wants; therefore he takes. Ayn Rand correctly diagnosed this as a short-range mentality. For he who does not produce must perforce consume. Therefore, if observed categorically, their approach to life dooms all men to ultimate starvation, and the end of Man himself.

Tragically, this is the logical conclusion of a certain kind of individualism.

Eternity Road readers know me as a champion of individualism as a philosophy of rights, by which governments are properly constrained. But there are other kinds. There's the individualism that sees only oneself as real; this is called solipsism. There's the individualism that sees others solely as means to one's own ends; this is called sociopathy. And there's the individualism that blends solipsism and sociopathy with the dark pleasures of destruction. This has no name. Perhaps it's too fearsome to be allowed one.

The most memorable fictions of the immortal Howard Phillips Lovecraft were founded on a mythos of "elder gods:" entities of immense power, that knew no moral constraints and delighted in destruction. The most vividly depicted of these was Cthulhu, whose aim was literally to consume all that lives, if possible with the connivance and cooperation of men.

Cthulhu possessed human acolytes who strove to persuade others that true freedom is most manifest in the act of murder: the deliberate consumption of another's life. By that standard, to kill was the highest of all individual actions, the deed most true to the vision of oneself as unique in existence. If Cthulhu had a gospel, it would have been exactly that of the Thuggee:

"And now, my brothers, rise and kill. Kill for the love of killing! Kill for the love of Kali! Kill, kill, KILL!"

To Cthulhu's acolytes, killing was merely the supreme act of consumption. Qualitatively, there is nothing to separate them from those among us who demand that all they desire be provided to them at others' expense.


5. The Armies Of Allah.

There's a dark god in motion in our world other than him of the maw that can never be filled.

Hearken to one of the few questionable snippets of the Steyn essay:

I’m a conservative -- I’m not entirely on board with the Islamist program when it comes to beheading sodomites and so on, but I agree Britney Spears dresses like a slut: I’m with Mullah Omar on that one.

There are two problems with this assertion:

  1. Britney Spears does not dress like a slut; sluts dress like Britney Spears.
  2. Mullah Omar would behead Britney Spears. Mark Steyn would merely scold her, and perhaps send her to her room to change.

A common reaction, even among nominally tolerant persons, to "excesses" in individual behavior is to exclaim "there ought to be a law" or "if I were king," et sequelae. Indeed, there are some manifestations of disdain for others' sensibilities that are sufficiently offensive or dangerous that laws curbing them in public places are justifiable, though that slope has always been coated with a thick layer of Vaseline. (Public intoxication nearly always eventuates in harm to someone, if only the street cleaners; public fornication frightens the Buicks.) But the vast majority of "there ought to be a law" ejaculations should be answered by "no, you ought to learn to keep your nose out of others' business." Unfortunately, in this era there are far too many of the former and far too few of the latter.

The most visible representatives of the former camp are the followers of Allah.

Allah stands at the extreme opposite end of the theo-ideological spectrum from Cthulhu. He demands utter submission and absolute obedience in all things; he offers no freedom and punishes the slightest deviation from His decrees with an eternity of torment. Worse, he demands that his followers enforce his decrees in this world as well, with the full and humorless power of a totalitarian State.

Worst, our tendency to think with our wishes instead of our heads leads many to believe that Allah's sort of world is the only alternative to Cthulhu's.

This dichotomy seldom becomes conscious in the minds of those who hew to it. The typical there-ought-to-be-a-law type simply assumes that law and (temporal) punishment are just and effective ways of promoting what he likes and curbing what he dislikes. Though the impulse has been banished from Christian churches, it was once found there. In its most extreme manifestation, it produced the Calvinist "Christian police state" of seventeenth-century Switzerland, in which religious dictates and secular law were unified. And obviously, the mindset is still virulently alive in the Islamic world.

Life under a regime of such rigidity is joyless; it's hardly worth living at all. Even Islam's public figures have admitted this. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini said on more than one occasion that "There is no room for play in Islam. Islam is deadly serious...about everything." The lesson, unfortunately, tends to be lost on those inclined to enforce their preferences upon others at gunpoint.


6. The Last Battle.

It's possible that you, Gentle Reader, have been asking yourself, "What on Earth does all this drivel have to do with Steyn's points about cultural confidence and demographic decline?" I grant that you'd have some reason. Bear with me.

Classical conceptions of the culmination of history -- these are usually called eschatologies -- involve an outright battle between the forces of good and those of evil, with the loser cast down forever and the winner taking title to all that exists. The Christian eschatology is called Armageddon. The Norse called their eschatology Ragnarok. The Germans call theirs Gotterdammerung. The Hindus call theirs the death of Brahma. In their most important particulars, they're very similar. The most important one is this: the good side is clearly good, and the bad side is clearly bad.

None of these is a good fit to a struggle for the world between Cthulhu and Allah. Whichever were to win, the rest of us would lose. The world would either be destroyed, or would be locked into the most confining totalitarianism imaginable. If these are the sides that will duke it out on the Last Day, there'll be no one a good man could root for.

The most popular ideologies in the world today are the Western ideology of moral and cultural relativism -- Cthulhu's -- and the Eastern ideology of utter submission to a totalitarian god -- Allah's. The former delights in the self-destruction of the world by the incitement of the worst impulses of Man. The latter demands Man's increase, but under conditions so confining and unpleasant that death would be preferable. At present, the former has access to more temporal tools, but the speed at which the latter is multiplying suggests that it won't be long before its numbers allow it to swarm over all barricades erected against it. But in any case, if the West should continue its descent into moral and cultural relativism, it will disarm itself precisely as Islam rises to strike it dead.


7. The Search For An Alternative.

Cthulhu and Allah are not real; they are fantasies. They're the icons of evil best suited to the purposes of this essay. They serve the same function Darth Vader serves in the Star Wars movies: they transform the antagonist from an ideology to a person, they give the hero someone specific to battle, and they give the audience someone specific to fear and hate.

Reflect on that mechanism for a moment. So much of contemporary politics is oriented toward hating some iconic figure on "the other side!" So little energy goes into addressing the explanations for political difference! Can't we see here the schematic for political misdirection? If we're busy reviling some artificial devil-figure, like Winston Smith during the Two Minutes' Hate in 1984, how much time or energy will we have left for serious thought about the supposedly serious differences between the major parties? How likely is it that we'll give sober consideration to any of the contentions of "the other side?" How easily will we be marshaled into supporting men whose only attraction of any sort is that "they're our sons-a-bitches" rather than "theirs" -- ?

How likely is it that we'll fail to see the blade of our true enemies swinging for our heads?

The ideologies I've associated with Cthulhu and Allah are neither effective defenses against any threat nor practical approaches to living well; they're guides to self-immolation. Yet their devotees press us from all sides. Where are we to find protection from either or both?

The question is non-trivial. The unthinking reaction to relativism is rigidity, which leads straight to Allah's camp. The unthinking reaction to totalitarianism is anarchy, which leads to the maw of Cthulhu. Clearly, we must find a middle way.

Fortunately, there is a middle way. It doesn't involve compulsory breeding. It doesn't involve compulsory worship. It doesn't involve collectivization of any sort, whether in the name of political correctness or State-enforced virtue. It rejects demonization of the advocates of "the other side" as counterproductive.

We followed that way for about a century and a half. It derives, as Steyn put it, from "eighteenth-century British subjects who took English ideas a little further than the mother country was willing to go."


8. The New Olympus.

Combat is never a agreeable prospect. Even ideological combat, conducted entirely with words and ideas, has an unpleasant edge. For a good man to take up arms in the conflict that rages today will require as much courage as it ever did. Our enemies, though many of their number strive to wear a friendly face, are implacable.

Europe is probably lost. Russia is probably lost. Japan may be lost. Steyn's fertility rate figures are compelling indicators of a deep disease, and one does not resuscitate a dying culture by exhorting it to breed for the sake of its nonexistent progeny. But that approach would wag the dog by its tail in any case. The low levels of fertility that characterize the developed world, including the United States, are not a primary but a resultant. Large families characterize a milieu where physical labor is the principal source of wealth -- where one needs eight or ten children to work the family farm. As capitalism and technology advance, labor ceases to be the dominant factor in economic gain. Children slowly cease to be a source of labor and a form of retirement security, and become more of a luxury good. Low birth rates mostly indicate that a people has become rich enough not to exploit its children's labor. In America's case, due to our outstanding productivity, that's easily tolerable. In other lands, hagridden by much more developed, much more rapacious welfare states, it foretells the triumph of the Takers over the Makers, and the demise of both.

We cannot save the future by appealing to the future good. We can only mobilize the present for its own priorities. The adjustment of American priorities away from secondary impulses toward matters of immediate survival and the defense of the ideals that sustain American civilization is the problem to be solved.

But how may we do this, when the atomization of society appears all but complete? Riches, whether earned or merely received, cause the typical man to turn his attentions inward. His impulse is to leave others to their own troubles, and to see even the darkness creeping toward him and his own as someone else's responsibility to dispel. He resists the notion that there are some causes to whose defense his own contribution is indispensable.

The influence historically most effective at raising a man fron his knees -- or his back -- is a vision of himself as a model of courage in a noble cause: a hero.

Heroes stand foursquare for justice. They don't linger over their comforts when the alarums sound. They don't quail before opposition, however formidable it looks. And they don't accept any outcome but victory.

Self-respecting, other-respecting individualism -- American individualism -- is a hero's creed. The American individualist takes on himself the responsibility for his own well-being. He swears to raise his hand against no other man, save only in defense of himself and his own. And he pledges himself to the defense of those ideals against all enemies, foreign or domestic. They who uphold such a regime are the highest and best representatives of our kind; others emulate them as automatically as flowers turn their faces toward the Sun.

For nearly two centuries, America was seen as Olympus come to Earth: the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave. For a century it was a nation of heroes, envied by all the other peoples of the world, upon which they automatically called in their darkest hours. That's an image of ourselves that should rouse all but the terminally comatose from their torpor.

The present generation of Americans may be only half-salvageable. Cravenness is dispelled only under unforeseen trial. Miseducation is harder to overcome than ignorance. The forces that call for surrender to the intolerable, that march under the banner of relativism and accommodation, are mighty. From their perches in academe and the media, they've done gruesome damage to the history and self-regard of our nation. But that's no reason to despair. It's certainly no reason not to raise our own banners and march.

We must put away venality and rediscover our just pride.
We must proclaim a gospel of responsible individual liberty, and hold strictly to it.
We must demand absolute fidelity to promises from our public officials.
We must purge our laws, our language, and our thoughts of much nonsense that entangles them.
We must cease to grant any respect to the demands of the Fakers and Takers; they must be recognized once more as parasites and objects of charity.
We must learn to discriminate between the unconscious and the conscious followers of Cthulhu and Allah. The former must be either enlightened or neutralized; the latter must be defeated by any means expedient. In no case may they be accommodated.

These are the weapons with which we can defeat Cthulhu, Allah, and the seemingly irresistible tides of demography, and reclaim our heroism.

There will be costs. We will sometimes be compelled to do terrible things. We will sometimes have to harden our hearts in unprecedented ways. Who could deny that a rigidly enforced quarantine of the Islamic world would exclude from our company many who deserve better? Who could deny that confronting and contradicting the apostles of relativism will occasion some nasty scenes? Who could deny that the disassembly of the welfare state and its replacement with an ethic of private, voluntary community will cause rough times for some who objectively deserve better? No ideological transition has ever been free of casualties or pain. Shall we insist that, until we find a way that keeps us safe and sated, and brings us all we desire at no cost, we will refuse to move at all?

The revolutionaries of our Founding Era knew what they believed. Their passion for it inspired them to reject British rule, though it might cost "our lives, our fortunes and our sacred honor." They set out on a course never before taken in human history. Despite several missteps, they preserved their ideals intact. They never doubted that they were worth fighting for.

A man who knows what he's fighting for, and is wholeheartedly proud of himself and it, will do what he must to preserve it. There is no other path, unless one surrenders to Cthulhu or Allah.


9. Specifics.

I've proclaimed the necessity of an ideological revolution. The essentials to any revolution, including an ideological one, are education, communications, and weaponry.

Education is obvious. Our young are being miseducated as we speak. We must snatch their minds back from those who would infuse them with the relativistic, nonjudgmental creed and introduce them to the principles of the Founding. Equally as urgent, we must induce them to acquire strength and skill, the only sound foundation for pride. A man who can catch and cook his own dinner is unlikely to bow before any other man, nor will he accede to self-immolation at the behest of any god.

Communications is equally obvious. Americans who see the necessities outlined here must be able to find one another, pool information, exchange ideas, and offer mutual support. When we are isolated, we're easy targets: easy to silence and safe to ignore. When we know we're not alone, that there are others willing and able to support us, we have the strength of ten.

Weaponry is fundamental, yet its full impact is almost always overlooked. It's been said that the Second Amendment is the sole guarantor of the First, and truly. But what's less apparent is that an armed and confident man is a model for other men. He draws admiration for much the same reason as does an articulate, educated man: he can do things others can't. Therefore, be armed, and be conspicuously armed. Shoot often. Make it a family activity. Invite your friends and neighbors to join you, and to bring their children, too. When the opportunity arises, add to the simple pleasures of sport shooting a measure of history: stories of the great men of arms, whose valor brought them honor, and their nations victory.

American birth rates are at replacement rates, true. If our numbers are not to increase, our strength and our confidence will have to suffice. But if history is any guide, they will.


10. Concluding Thoughts.

To one who cherishes freedom and hopes for the destruction of its enemies, Steyn's case that those enemies are outbreeding us appears ominous:

Since the President unveiled the so-called Bush Doctrine -- the plan to promote liberty throughout the Arab world -- innumerable “progressives” have routinely asserted that there’s no evidence Muslims want liberty and, indeed, Islam is incompatible with democracy. If that’s true, it’s a problem not for the Middle East today but for Europe the day after tomorrow. According to a poll taken in 2004, over 60 percent of British Muslims want to live under sharia -- in the United Kingdom. If a population “at odds with the modern world” is the fastest-breeding group on the planet -- if there are more Muslim nations, more fundamentalist Muslims within those nations, more and more Muslims within non-Muslim nations, and more and more Muslims represented in more and more transnational institutions -- how safe a bet is the survival of the “modern world”?

...but this is a double-edged blade. The Islamic world is characterized by deficiencies so severe that on its own it could never approach the stature of the Western world. Intellectually, it's on the edge of retardation; thanks to the constraints of Islam, it knows almost no innovation of any sort. Muslims compelled to live with one another, deprived of infusions of Western capital and ideas, always turn on one another as the Palestinians have done. This is natural among persons who abjure reason and promote a pseudo-religion of totalitarianism in its place.

Imagine the world's 1.2 billion Muslims under conditions of strict geographic quarantine, compelled to make it on their own or not make it at all. Is it possible to imagine that without the opportunity to steal our aircraft and our weapons to use against us, that they would be any kind of threat?

As for the promulgators of relativism and American self-abasement: these are even less to be feared. Were they not granted unearned support by public institutions and foundations with more money than sense, and unearned respect for ideas they cannot defend in open debate, they would shrivel to nothing. Do they denounce you as a dangerous reactionary? Laugh. Do they raise campaigns of calumny against you as an enemy of the common weal? Trust your neighbors to know you better than that. There's nothing less potent than the derision of those in whom nothing wholesome resides.

To the dark gods who seek to drag us to their altars, whether to be chained there lifelong or to be sacrificed upon them, let us oppose the God of Light, Who set us free in time and gave us our power of reason, our sense for right and wrong, and our urge to community. Let us think as He would have us think: clearly, soberly, and without fear.

Men fear thought as they fear nothing else on earth, more than ruin, more even than death. Thought is subversive and revolutionary, destructive and terrible, thought is merciless to privilege, established institutions, and comfortable habit. Thought looks into the pit of hell and is not afraid. Thought is great and swift and free, the light of the world, and the chief glory of man. -- Bertrand Russell

Sunday, September 16, 2012

Sequels Continued: The Loss Of Freedom Of Speech

The redoubtable Glenn Reynolds brings us the most devastating news since the 1917 Draft Riots:

Here’s the key bit: “Just after midnight Saturday morning, authorities descended on the Cerritos home of the man believed to be the filmmaker behind the anti-Muslim movie that has sparked protests and rioting in the Muslim world.”

When taking office, the President does not swear to create jobs. He does not swear to “grow the economy.” He does not swear to institute “fairness.” The only oath the President takes is this one:

I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.

By sending — literally — brownshirted enforcers to engage in — literally — a midnight knock at the door of a man for the non-crime of embarrassing the President of the United States and his administration, President Obama violated that oath. You can try to pretty this up (It’s just about possible probation violations! Sure.), or make excuses or draw distinctions, but that’s what’s happened. It is a betrayal of his duties as President, and a disgrace.

He won’t resign, of course. First, the President has the appreciation of free speech that one would expect from a Chicago Machine politician, which is to say, none. Second, he’s not getting any pressure. Indeed, the very press that went crazy over Ari Fleischer’s misrepresented remarks seems far less interested in the actions of an administration that I repeat, literally sent brown-shirted enforcers to launch a midnight knock on a filmmaker’s door.

Some time ago, back at Eternity Road, I wrote:

The list of well known writers on liberty includes some names that don't belong there, such as John Stuart Mill, and omits some names that should appear at its head, such as the late Dr. Clarence Carson. Dr. Carson's several books are gems, each and every one, glittering with knowledge, insight, and eloquence, but even among libertarians and conservatives, they're little known and less employed. Yet no one, not even the great Ayn Rand, has contributed more to the elucidation and articulation of Americanism.

In your Curmudgeon's opinion, Dr. Carson's strongest statements on freedom and American principles are to be found in his book The American Tradition. Concerning liberals' thesis that freedom is adequately defined by freedom of speech plus the electoral mechanism, Dr. Carson declaimed as follows:

[W]e are told that there is no need to fear the concentration of power in government so long as that power is checked by the electoral process. We are urged to believe that so long as we can express our disagreement in words, we have our full rights to disagree. Now both freedom of speech and the electoral process are important to liberty, but alone they are only the desiccated remains of liberty. However vigorously we may argue against foreign aid, our substance is still drained away in never-to-be-repaid loans. Quite often, there is not even a candidate to vote for who holds views remotely like my own. To vent one's spleen against the graduated income tax may be healthy for the psyche, but one must still yield up his freedom of choice as to how his money will be spent when he pays it to the government. The voice of electors in government is not even proportioned to the tax contribution of individuals; thus, those who contribute more lose rather than gain by the "democratic process." A majority of voters may decide that property cannot be used in such and such ways, but the liberty of the individual is diminished just as much as in that regard as if a dictator had decreed it. Those who believe in the redistribution of wealth should be free to redistribute their own, but they are undoubtedly limiting the freedom of others when they vote to redistribute theirs.

Effective disagreement means not doing what one does not want to do as well as saying what he wants to say. What is from one angle the welfare state is from another the compulsory state. Let me submit a bill of particulars. Children are forced to go to school. Americans are forced to pay taxes to support foreign aid, forced to support the Peace Corps, forced to make loans to the United Nations, forced to contribute to the building of hospitals, forced to serve in the armed forces. Employers are forced to submit to arbitration with labor leaders. Laborers are forced to accept the majority decision. Employers are forced to pay minimum wages, or go out of business. But it is not even certain that they will be permitted by the courts to go out of business. Railroads are forced to charge established rates and to continue services which may have become uneconomical. Many Americans are forced to pay Social Security. Farmers are forced to operate according to the restrictions voted by a majority of those involved. The list could be extended, but surely the point has been made.

(The above comes from an essay titled "To Agree To Disagree," which your Curmudgeon regards as the capstone of Dr. Carson's book.)

Now, a regular reader of Eternity Road will already be familiar with the long train of abuses and usurpations Dr. Carson enumerates above. And of course, liberals still stoutly maintain that the object is a more perfect Union, and not a design to reduce us under absolute Despotism. But the most trustworthy indicators of evil intent are the suppression of dissent and the invalidation of mechanisms for redress: the "desiccated remains" of which Dr. Carson wrote. And so your Curmudgeon must ask: Just how are freedom of expression and the electoral process faring in the Land of the Formerly Free?

First, freedom of expression:

  • The McCain-Feingold Bipartisan Campaign Finance Reform Act has partly abrogated the right to free expression around election time.
  • Given the new Administration and the enlarged Democrat majorities on Capitol Hill, we stand in immediate danger of the revival of the Fairness Doctrine, which is aimed at quenching conservative talk radio.
  • The use of tax law to silence conservative and libertarian opinion is growing, especially as regards voluntary associations such as churches and charitable groups.
  • Several liberal luminaries, among them both Cass Sunstein and Hillary Clinton, have argued for the censorship of the World Wide Web.
  • Lawsuits attempting to silence a commentator who has merely stated established facts or accurately quoted an adversarial opponent are rife, and are usually allowed to go forward by the courts.
  • Conservative public officials are continuously derided, assailed, and slandered, both by the Mainstream Media and by activist groups.
  • Lectures and presentations by libertarian and conservative figures are heckled, massively protested, and often terminally disrupted by liberal activists. The speakers who dare to appear at such events are at continuous risk of physical assault.

The legal impediments to free expression are bad enough. When one adds the "chilling effect" of the extra-legal mechanisms used to silence pro-freedom views, the pile reaches an alarming height.

Now for the electoral process:

  • Laws which explicitly regulate ballot access are ignored by the courts when they conduce to the disadvantage of the Democrats, but are wielded rigorously, and often on specious grounds, against Republicans and pro-freedom minor parties.
  • Democrat candidates and their media allies have been allowed extraordinary latitude at opening the sealed records of their opponents' divorces, child-custody disputes, and commercial actions.
  • The media treat all allegations of impropriety against Republicans and conservatives as front page news, but hesitate to report on much worse, and much better substantiated, allegations against Democrats and liberals.
  • Boards of Election routinely operate to the advantage of the Democrat in a contested race. Election fraud is rampant, but only allegations of fraud by Republicans are treated seriously. The investigation of even flagrant abuses by Democrats is perfunctory at best.
  • Democrat Administrations have facilitated the acquisition of voting power by un-naturalized immigrants, including illegal immigrants.
  • Lawsuits challenging the validity of a vote tally are used as an entering wedge by which to enable further vote fraud.
  • When a closely disputed election turns out, after a recount, to have been won by the Republican, if the Democrat has already been seated, no action is taken in redress.

To borrow Dr. Carson's phrasing, these lists could be extended, but surely the point has been made.

Now we must add the use of the Federal Bureau of Investigation to intimidate amateur filmmakers from emitting videos that might cause The Won some embarrassment.

What's that you say? "It wasn't the embarrassment to the president; it was the riots in Egypt, Libya, and Tunisia that the video caused?" Solly, Cholly; that doesn't float even for a microsecond. Those riots were planned well beforehand, specifically to take place on September 11. Besides which, I could point you to several YouTube videos that are far more critically incisive toward Islam and Muslims, that have been out there for quite some time. Indeed, I believe I'll embed my favorite right here:

Obama's foreign policy of kowtowing to foreign despots and apologizing to Muslims for Americans' freedom is a total disaster. The riots merely laid that fact bare. But as we all know too well by now, Obama never accepts the blame for anything negative that might issue from his decisions. To criticize him is to impugn his omniscience -- and I'm not kidding about that:

Here is what Obama told aide Patrick Gaspard in 2008: "I think that I'm a better speechwriter than my speechwriters. I know more about policies on any particular issue than my policy directors. And I'll tell you right now that I'm gonna think I'm a better political director than my political director."

There is simply no argument by which any decent American could rationalize voting for this monster of inhuman vanity, this legend in his own mind who believes himself entitled to rule by decree despite the Constitution. Those who voted for him in 2008 should be near to terminally ashamed of themselves. As for anyone who plans to vote for him come November 6, keep your distance; I tend to shoot first and worry about the paperwork later.

And we still ought to be making preparations to nuke Benghazi.

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Sequels

Well, Gentle Reader, what do you think of our State Department now?

***

I'm not one for half measures, but neither am I inclined to "overdo it." If there's a gentler way to achieve some end whose attainment seems to require mass bloodshed, I'll always be willing to listen to it.

Trouble is, if the end to be attained is the suppression of Islam-powered savagery, I don't see a gentler way. Neither does anyone else.

Recently, retired Lieutenant Colonel Ralph Peters, better known to many for his novels than for his geopolitical insights, posited that there's only one effective way to respond to events such as those currently occurring throughout the Middle East: Reprisals that kill large numbers of Muslims. A clip of his opinion aired during Fox News's popular segment The Five. Left-liberal Bob Beckel, the show's comic relief -- what's that you say? He's serious? C'mon! -- immediately denounced Peters: "He doesn't know what he's talking about."

Beckel is, of course, faecularly replete. (Family-friendly website, remember?) No one has ever come up with an approach to dealing with the Muslim Middle East that: 1) works, and 2) doesn't involve mass bloodshed. The Israelis will tell you...but left-liberals are disinclined to listen to them.

What the civilized peoples of the world would really like is a way to pacify world Islam without incurring bloodstains on their consciences. There is an approach...but it requires a hardening of the heart even so.

***

Imagine the following public statement from the president of the United States:

Inasmuch as the riots in Benghazi, Libya, which have taken the lives of four American diplomats posted there, indicate that that city has become lawless, I have decided to destroy it. I intend that it be completely leveled, the ground it occupies made uninhabitable for at least a generation. Therefore, exactly one week from today, one of our Trident submarines will launch a cruise missile armed with a mid-yield nuclear warhead, targeted on the Benghazi city center. The United States will undertake no subsequent cleanup or remediation of the site. It will be left as it is, as a warning to others inclined to attack American diplomatic personnel.

The one-week delay of our reprisal is calculated to permit the residents of Benghazi to escape before the destruction of the city. We don't seek to shed anyone's blood. However, the strike will take place on schedule, regardless of whether any occupants remain in that city. We will not be deterred by "human shields." Anyone who believes otherwise is welcome to remain in Benghazi, though it will cost him his life.

Moreover, this will henceforward be the standing policy of the United States. Should law and order in a city with an American embassy or consulate degrade so badly that American lives are lost or American soil is invaded, that city will be destroyed one week afterward. The world is on notice: Americans have had enough. From now on, if you dare to spill our blood, you will reap the most terrible consequences imaginable. Test us if you dare.

Needless to say, the denunciations would be worldwide. They would shake the very ground. But assuming the president were firm in his resolve, there would be no further attacks on American diplomatic institutions in other lands. You don't mess with a nation willing to respond to attack in such a fashion.

Our problem is that we've placed more weight on the opinions of our enemies -- in which category I include everyone anywhere who goes by some variation of "progressive" or "transnationalist" -- than on our rights and well-being and our duty to uphold them. Note that the Russians have never committed that error, and so have had a tiny fraction of our problems with Islamic savagery. It's time we learned from their example.

***

The Islamic world is pre-Euro-Medieval in its worldview and its ethics. Islam itself is the reason. How could it be otherwise? The creed teaches its adherents that deceit, fraud, and violence in the cause of Islam are quite all right, even mandatory in some contexts. Disbelieve if you like, but it's down in the black-and-white of the Qur'an, and heavily reinforced by the life story of the "Perfect Man," the Prophet Muhammad.

They believe in the use of force to advance Islamic domination of the world. Let them feel the force we command, in its full fury. We'll see who backs down first.

Please, spare me your objections about how Muslims in the United States behave. They're surrounded and heavily outnumbered by actual civilized men, a great many of us armed and prepared to act. Yet even here, Muslims have attempted gambits intended to intimidate us "infidels" into granting them special privileges. Some of those gambits have succeeded; consult the residents of Hamtramck and Dearborn, Michigan for confirmation.

***

The objections from conscience -- that such a policy involves collective guilt and collective punishment -- are significant and should be dealt with. Here's my response.

The government of a nation-state, deemed sovereign over its territory, has the responsibility for maintaining law and order within that territory. At the very minimum, that requires that the government act to safeguard the lives of the representatives of other nation-states, under the conventions that have protected diplomatic missions since the Congress of Vienna. Thus, a government that fails to protect other nations' diplomats, or that actively encourages assaults upon them, is an outlaw government, which may rightfully be regarded as invalid by the other nations of the world. When such assaults occur, other governments have the duty to respond in whatever fashion is required to restore order and deter further violence against their representatives.

In the most extreme case, when a government completely fails of its obligation to keep the peace, it is no longer sovereign. Other nations are justified in regarding its territory as no longer the jurisdiction of a nation-state as we understand them. That puts that territory on a plane with the "high seas." Persons who commit felonies there are automatically consigned to the category of "enemies of all Mankind," whose lives are forfeit to anyone who wants to take them. That, after all, is the law of the ungoverned: the rule of naked force and nothing else. He who dares to dwell there has bet his life on his prowess, much like a prospector in the jungle or the Arctic wilds. Civilized men, who recognize individuals' rights and the constraints of law, are free to do what they like about whatever threats emanate from such a realm.

It can be no other way when savages wreak violence upon those of us who behave as civilized, rational men.

***

Mine is a hard prescription, though if respected by those upon whom I would visit it, it would reap no lives. There would be outcries against it worldwide. The volume of condemnation from the Left and the glitterati would deafen many an ear. That simply doesn't matter.

Either we believe in our right to life, our innocence before Man and God, and our right to defend ourselves as we must, or we don't. If we do, then reprisal in quantity for the harms being done us by the savage mobs of Islam is more than our right; it's our duty. If not, we are merely pretenders to the banner of justice, and we deserve to perish.

"Take your choice -- there is no other -- and your time is running out." -- Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged

Friday, September 14, 2012

An Idea to Make Space Affordable

Forget about the 'privatization' of NASA. Check out this idea for ways to make space travel cheaper:



The shift to using private enterprise to economize space travel is of course a good idea, but so far seems to overlook the central problem with getting to space cheaply -- rocketry. Using a rocket to get into space is simply too inefficient to be economical. Something like 2% of a rocket is actual payload; the rest, fuel and associated hardware for containing and harnessing the energy in said fuel.

The trick, as it seems to me -- get the fuel 'off' the space vehicle. At least for now, until otherwise radically different technologies become available.

The thing I really like about this guy's 'sales pitch' is that he has a hard and practical goal -- get fuel and supplies into space at about 90% less cost than presently feasible. Nothing particularly 'sexy,' just a clear and useful goal that could make a profit in relatively short order.

And he has a fair amount of hard evidence and experience to back up the feasibility his idea, not just theoretical calculations. Interesting.

An Urgent Request

A long-time reader, who shall go anonymous for the moment, has written with an urgent request:

My wife is 63 and listens to MSNBC EVERY NIGHT. She's wonderful and all that, but I'd appreciate it if you would help me do something that might, or might not, help.

I'd like you to list - without comment - the things we know Obama has stretched the Constitution by. (The very fact that that sentence isn't correct shows my problem.)

For example, DOJ not prosecuting the New Black Panthers. DOJ prosecuting Arizona, Obama passing the parts of the DREAM act by executive order, etc.

My point is, my wife listens to MSNBC and sees nothing about Romney that she would vote FOR.

Would you please post a concise history - line by line - of what Obama has done wrong (Constitutionally) so that she can see why Obama is WRONG, rather than why Romney MIGHT be a poor choice?

I'd love to oblige, but I'm so badly pressed at the moment by my personal and occupational difficulties that I can barely produce a piece for Liberty's Torch every couple of days. (Massive applause to Mark Butterworth for his exemplary productivity, which has salved my conscience to an embarrassing extent.)

Please, Gentle Readers:

Post your contributions in the comments to this piece.

Indicate whether you'd like your names to be used in the compendium post I expect to present over the weekend.

You'll be helping me to provide something that will be useful to more than one reader, I assure you!

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

The Smoking Qur'an: Further Thoughts

I must say, the volume of hate mail I've received over this story has been most impressive. No doubt my correspondents hope to intimidate me into some sort of recantation, or at least away from further fictional excursions of that sort. Sorry, little boys. I hate to disappoint you, but that doesn't work on me. Besides, as the flyboys like to say, if you're taking flak, you must be over the target.

The State Department's pusillanimous response to the violence against American embassies in Libya and Egypt makes it plain that our government is no longer concerned with the protection of American lives, property, and interests. What, then, might its priorities include?

  • The good opinion of the Europeans?
  • The good opinion of Islamic regimes?
  • The mollification of Islamists and al-Qaeda affiliates?
  • Soothing our seething domestic Muslims?
  • Throwing a sop to the anti-military elements of the Democratic "base?"

Draw your own conclusions.

***

I continue to recommend the Godfather Principle as the most reliable foundation for American foreign policy:

"Had you come to me in friendship, this scum who ruined your daughter would be suffering this very day. And if by some chance an honest man like yourself made enemies, they would become my enemies as well. And then, they would fear you." [From Francis Ford Coppola's masterpiece movie The Godfather, derived from Mario Puzo's book of the same title]

The Romans had their own maxim: Oderint dum metuant. "Let them hate us, so long as they fear us." Niccolo de Macchiavelli rephrased it as "It is better to be feared than loved." Lord Palmerston, prime minister of Great Britain at the height of her Empire, said "England has no eternal enmities, no eternal friendships. She has only eternal interests." Theodore Roosevelt, otherwise not one of your Curmudgeon's favorite presidents, said "Speak softly and carry a big stick."

All of these are succinct formulations of the one and only principle that has ever applied to international relations:

Only power counts.

Why? Quite simply:

  • Nation-states exist in an anarchic relation to one another.
  • Sovereignty is conditional on the power to maintain one's borders.
  • They who seek to rule nation-states tend to respect power and only power.
  • The scent of weakness in a nation-state draws predators the way a corpse draws flies.

This is true, and imperative, even when the nation-states of one's immediate concern are themselves in a "transitional" (i.e., chaotic) condition. Perhaps especially so, for mobs know no law and are notably short on inhibitions. They are driven by the impulses of the moment, which are usually bound up with the destruction of a perceived enemy. Say what you will about the late Muammar Qadaffi; his forces never dared to encroach upon an American embassy.

The ideal condition, given that the world is lousy with Muslims and other enemies of freedom, justice, and the United States, is for our nation to be so deeply and universally feared that no one anywhere would dare to offend us.

Let no one doubt the length or sharpness of our sword.
Let no one imagine that we lack the will to use it.
Let all the world tremble at the mere thought of what we're ready, willing, and able to do.

To be maximally gentle about it, that is not the case today.

***

When persons outside Nation X, pondering whether to risk its ire for some potential gain, assess the prospects, they confront four possibilities:

  1. Nation X can be strong and look strong;
  2. Nation X can be weak but look strong;
  3. Nation X can be strong but look weak;
  4. Nation X can be weak and look weak.

It should require no argument that posture #1 is preferable to all the others, and that posture #4 is to be avoided at all costs. What's more arguable is whether posture #2 should be preferred to posture #3. If the appearance of power can be maintained despite the objective deterioration of power, it might suffice to keep enemies at bay. However, the operation of international dynamics in our time guarantees that national weakness will be visible, and therefore that it will be exploited by the opportunists of the world. The last thing any nation should want is to be on the wrong end of that dynamic.

What's less well guaranteed is that strength will be visible. A chief of state such as Barack Hussein Obama can undermine international perceptions of our nation's true power. As matters stand, the American military could defeat any plausible confederation of opponents. But a president who's constantly apologizing for America and kowtowing to foreign satraps doesn't exactly emphasize that aspect of international relations.

At this time, we have the following categories of enemy:

  • The states of the European Union;
  • Islamic states and major concentrations of Muslims worldwide;
  • The post-Communist states of Russia and China;
  • The legacy-Communist states of Cuba and North Korea;
  • The neo-Communist states of Venezuela and Bolivia.

No, we're not currently at war with any of the above. Nevertheless, they are our enemies in the most fundamental sense: all of them want to see the United States weakened. It is most definitely not in America's interest to oblige them. Neither is it good for the peace of the world that anyone think the United States is growing weak -- which is precisely what the Obama Administration's obsequiousness toward Muslim sensitivities is bringing upon us.

Our enemies must be made to fear us -- not in the sense that we're planning to invade and conquer them any day now, but in the sense that they should deem it unwise to provoke us, whether militarily, economically, fiscally, or rhetorically.

We cannot have that highly preferred state of affairs if our federal government persists in acting apologetic -- weak -- toward persons, organizations, and nations that hate us.

And so a president such as Stephen Graham Sumner, who understands freedom, justice, and the proper role of the president, would not hesitate to do as described below.

No, we don't have such a president at the moment. Whether we'll have one after January 20, 2013 remains to be seen.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Eleven Years On

September 11, 2001: Black Tuesday, the day of the greatest-ever loss of American life on American soil to the act of a foreign enemy. That was eleven years ago today.

For some, it might as well never have happened. For me, it seems to happen afresh every time I close my eyes.

***

We are at war, have been at war since 1979, and will remain at war for a long time to come. The war was never formally declared. Our enemy is not a nation-state, nor even a recognized "non-state actor." Nor can we march against our enemy as we did in the "organized" wars of our history.

The war is global in scope.
The enemy is Islam.
There is no "front," as such.
The enemy's forces are already "inside our gates."

At war since 1979? Did I really write that? Excuse me! The United States has been at war with Islam since 1801. (Doesn't anyone else remember "Millions for defense, but not one cent for tribute!" -- ?) Islam has been at war with Dar al-Harb ("The House of War," by which they mean all non-Muslim-majority lands) since well before that, of course, but the matter of the Barbary Pirates is the earliest it directly affected American concerns.

The war is global in scope because it is ideological in nature, just like the Cold War. Islam, the totalitarian ideology that masquerades as a religion, teaches its adherents that the domination of the world is theirs by right, and that any and every means by which the Islamic ummah might advance toward that end is to be embraced as it becomes expedient. Those means include every stratagem and every tactic imaginable, from the mildest deceits to the most ravening, horrifying acts of terrorism.

Because the United States has permitted Islam to shelter under the mantle of religious freedom, Muslims have established several beachheads on our soil. If your memory is lacking of such, try Googling "Islamberg" and "Sheikh Gilani Lane." Look into the recent history of Dearborn and Hamtramck, Michigan, and the concessions that have been made to Muslim cab drivers in Minneapolis. Review the contentions of Keith Ellison (R, MN), America's only (admitted) Muslim in Congress.

(Did someone mutter "Louis Farrakhan?" Yes, that miscreant too.)

Yet we've opened our arms to immigrants from Muslim-majority states. We've sniffed at Europe's misfortunes from having done so, as if there were no lesson to be drawn from them. We've preened ourselves on the power of freedom and prosperity to break down cultural barriers and unite the ten thousand tribes of Man into a coherent polity...even though the flood of Hispanic immigrants overrunning the Southwest, with whom we have much better cultural and ethical compatibility, has almost completely resisted assimilation. We've told ourselves that even if "the parents" are unassimilable, "the children" will grow up to be Americans.

We have been fools.

Muslims do not immigrate to the United States to become Americans. They come here to turn America into an Islamic state -- to negate the Constitution and put shari'a in its place.

No, they haven't succeeded yet. But they will if we give them time.

***

Black Tuesday, we've been told, wasn't about Islam. It was merely the mad act of nineteen deranged men, sent forth by another deranged man who happened to command a large fortune. Islam, we've been told, is "a religion of peace."

A religion of peace, you say? Yeah, right.

Islam's insane mythos is merely a cover for its totalitarian aspirations. Consider the foundation of that mythos:

  • An illiterate seventh-century caravan-driver was selected by God to be His Final Messenger to Mankind;
  • That caravan-driver was then awarded sole and complete memory of a book that expresses God's Will in all things, which it became his duty to present to Mankind;
  • However, he had to "revise" the book several times (cf. "the Satanic verses"), and many of his later additions contradict his earlier ones;
  • Among the privileges awarded to him for this duty was an exemption from any odium for adultery, which he exploited without restraint;
  • The book confers upon those who accept its dictates complete freedom to abuse "infidels" in any and every way, including:
    • Deceit and dissimulation toward "infidels;"
    • Pre-indemnified default upon one's given word, if given to "infidels;"
    • The breaking of any truce made with "infidels" when it's tactically advantageous to Islam;
    • Imposition of special taxes and other burdens upon "infidels," when and where politically possible;
    • Enslavement of "infidels" -- yes, really! -- when and where possible;
    • And of course, the use of violence against "infidels" and Dar al-Harb, when and where it appears a suitable means to advance Islam.

Come on! If this is a religion, then I'm Ahura Mazda; bow ye down, ye lowly ones, and worship me.

***

We cannot eradicate Islam from the world. There are too many Muslims; the toll would be too great. Even if it were within our powers, to commit such carnage would destroy us as a civilized, life-respecting people. But we can acknowledge that it is our enemy, that it has fueled nearly 20,000 violent, terroristic attacks in the past eleven years, and was immediately responsible for the deaths of three thousand Americans on Black Tuesday, September 11, 2001.

We can admit to ourselves that just because an ideology calls itself a religion doesn't mean that it is one. Better yet, we can incorporate into our understanding of religion as a category what C. S. Lewis called The Law of General Benevolence: that to be considered Constitutionally protected in its exercise, a creed must doctrinally forswear the use of violence, fraud, and deceit against members of other creeds, including in all scriptures it incorporates into its canon and all materials it employs in outreach.

Don't tell me about how friendly your Muslim neighbors are. Show them a Qur'an; ask them if it is the literal and immutable word of God, to be respected and obeyed in all particulars. Ask them whether Muhammad really was the Perfect Man, to be emulated in every way. Inquire about shari'a law, and whether they'd like to see it implemented in the United States. Take careful note of their answers; I assure you, they'll be anything but straightforward and unambiguous. Remember these exchanges, and compare their responses to it.

***

Time was, applicants for immigration to the United States were asked if they advocate the overthrow of the government of the U.S. by subterfuge or violence. Perhaps they still are -- but Muslims feel justified about lying to "infidels," when it's to the advantage of Islam.

Black Tuesday was only the most dramatic salvo.
Muslims, including Muslims in America, feel that it was justified by our "aggressions."
Muslims in the Middle East actually celebrated it, firing AK-47s into the air and handing out sweets to passers-by.
Ask yourself how many such neighbors you can comfortably accommodate.

Remember that we are at war.

Monday, September 10, 2012

The Smoking Qur'an

[Inasmuch as the Pentagon has announced that there will be "administrative punishments" for the six American servicemen who burned a pile of defaced Qur'ans some months ago, I decided to repost this, which originally appeared at Eternity Road.]

President Stephen Graham Sumner looked up from the incident report to find Secretary of State Ernest Tyszczenko and Secretary of Defense Isaac Guillory staring down at him expectantly.

“I wouldn’t have believed it if it had been any less blatant or less well documented,” Sumner said.

Guillory nodded. “It was witnessed by more than thirty people, most of them First Division troops.”

“Where’s the murderer now?”

“The Afghan foreign minister claims he’s in custody awaiting trial,” Tyszczenko murmured.

“Oh? Really?” Sumner rose and stood with arms akimbo. “Awaiting trial? We’ll see about that.” He stabbed at the intercom button on his desk phone. “Sally?”

“Yes, Mr. President?”

“Get General Maclaurin over here, pronto.” Sumner released the button and turned back to his guests. “There will be no trial, gentlemen.”

“Mr. President—” Tyszczenko said. Sumner silenced him with a slashing hand.

“You know better, Ernest. If the Afghans keep him, he’ll neither be tried nor punished. So I mean to have him.” An ice-glazed smile spread over his face. “And he still won’t receive a trial.”

“Sir, the diplomatic implications—”

“Enough, Ernest.” Sumner’s smile gave way to a murderous glare. “I’m sick and tired of pretending that we can conduct civilized relations with savages. There will be no diplomatic exchanges. No notes. No letters of protest. No representations before the General Assembly of the United Nations.” He closed his eyes, breathed deeply and released it slowly. “There will be justice. For the whole world to see.” The attention light on his desk phone lit, and his arctic smile returned. “Now if you gentlemen will excuse me, I have another visitor to confer with.”

* * *

Though the simultaneous strikes by American forces on targets deep in Afghanistan had world media agog, the Sumner Administration remained absolutely silent about them throughout. Thus it came as a global surprise when, three days after the first of the strikes, President Sumner himself took to the airwaves to comment on them.

The setting for the broadcast was equally surprising: a large, featureless room with glossy walls, a smooth concrete floor, and no furniture. The camera panned the room to reveal twenty-two uniformed American soldiers, each with his battle weapons, and a swarthy, bearded, tightly trussed man struggling not to fall to the floor. At the front of the room, in his habitual two piece navy blue suit, stood a stone-faced Stephen Graham Sumner.

“My fellow Americans,” Sumner said, “no doubt you’ve all seen or read news reports about the massive strikes our forces have just conducted against a set of targets in the supposedly pacified nation of Afghanistan. I ordered those strikes personally, after learning of the murder of two American soldiers by a member of the Afghan Army. The perpetrator of those murders was apparently enraged over the burning of a few copies of the Qur’an.

“Afghanistan has reaped many benefits from our actions there. It’s been freed from Taliban tyranny. It’s acquired a somewhat democratically elected government. Its armed forces have received weapons and training, paid for by you, my friends. You would think the Afghan government, if not the whole people of the nation, would be grateful for such beneficence. You would think that government would fall all over itself to honor a polite request from the United States for the custody of a man who had murdered two Americans. You would think the commission of those crimes on an American military base would hardly need to be mentioned.

“Well, my friends, if you thought any of those things, you’d be sadly mistaken. Apparently, the Afghan government, whatever public position it might take, regards the murder of a couple of infidels as a far less serious matter than the burning of a few Qur’ans. You see, we offended the Afghan people by burning their holy book. Islam isn’t to be mocked or criticized by us lowly Americans, even to the extent of burning a few copies of the Qur’an that had been used to pass messages among al-Qaeda detainees held at an American-operated detention camp. For daring to do so, our lives are forfeit to Islamic justice—and so the man who murdered two Americans was put into custody, not in expectation of justice of the sort you and I hold dear, but to protect him from us.”

Sumner smiled gently. “But he who protects a murderer from justice is an accomplice in the murders, regardless of the rationale. He who defends such protection rhetorically has made himself an advocate for evil. He who has been entrusted with executive powers over a nation, and rejects an American demand for the murderer’s living body on such grounds, has ruled himself unfit for the respect of any civilized man, much less for any amount of authority over others.

“So I sent our forces forth for redress. They undertook three missions:

“To smash the protections of the murderer and bring him here alive.

“To encircle the Afghan Army, compel its surrender, and seize or destroy every weapon in its possession, all the way down to officers’ sidearms.

“To topple the government of Afghanistan and transport its former rulers, completely without resources of any sort, to Rudolf Island in the Franz Josef Land archipelago, where they will be immured for the remainder of their lives.

“Our forces responded in their usual magnificent fashion. They were completely successful on all three counts. I have formally extended my thanks to the government of the Russian Republic for selling us a ninety-nine-year lease on Rudolf Island. I have no doubt it will prove useful in the future.

“America’s forces will soon be leaving Afghanistan. They might return—but if so, it will be in response to another atrocity, to punish that country so severely that only the memory of it will remain. I intend that if that becomes necessary, the event will stand alongside the great retributions of history. I intend that all other Islamic states draw the lesson. Indeed, I will take whatever steps are required to ensure that they do.”

Sumner gestured to the camera crew to turn its attention to the heavily shackled man.

“This is the man who murdered two Americans over a couple of charred books. He was witnessed in the act of doing so by twenty-two American soldiers of the First Infantry Division. Those twenty-two men are here as well. Gentlemen,” Sumner said as the camera cut to focus on the American troops, “do any of you have any doubt at all that the man before you is he who murdered your fellow soldiers?”

The troopers looked at one another, each one shaking his head and watching the reactions of his fellows. Finally one of them stepped forward and stood at attention. “None at all, Mr. President.”

Sumner nodded. “Then would you be kind enough to lend me your weapon, Corporal?”

The soldier looked mildly puzzled, but handed his rifle to Sumner without hesitation. Sumner took it, studied it briefly, and turned back to the camera.

“This is an M4 carbine. It fires 5.56 millimeter rounds at a muzzle velocity of about thirty-five hundred feet per second. It’s the standard weapon provided to American infantry...and it’s the sort of weapon the prisoner used to kill his victims.”

Sumner waved to someone standing off camera, and a Secret Serviceman stepped forward bearing a canned ham.

“Open it, please.”

The Secret Serviceman pulled a key loose from the underside of the can, opened the can with it, and displayed the contents to the cameras.

“Among Islam’s teachings,” Sumner said, “is that for a Muslim to experience contact with a pig’s flesh or the products thereof, if he is not immediately and most elaborately purified, dooms him to Hell. Agent McCloskey, would you care to do the honors?”

The Secret Serviceman grinned. “With pleasure, Mr. President.” He strode to the shackled prisoner, poured the fluid from the can over the frantically spasming form, then took a fistful of meat from the can and rubbed it on the man’s face, getting as much as possible into his beard.

“Step back, Agent,” Sumner said. The Secret Serviceman did so. Sumner flicked off the safety on the rifle, leveled it at the prisoner, and fired a three-round burst into his chest. The man dropped where he’d stood. The room went completely silent. Sumner handed the rifle back to the trooper and turned to face the cameras once more.

“That, my friends, is my response to the protestations of Muslims everywhere about the blasphemy committed by burning a few Qur’ans, and the justice of reaping a few American lives as payment. Muslims of the world, feel free to do as you please about it. But remember the forces at my command. I will not hesitate to use them.

“To my fellow Americans: Thank you all, and good night.”

* * *

“Mr. President?”

Sumner leaned forward and pressed the intercom button on his phone. “Yes, Sally, what is it?”

“Mr. Chisholm is here to see you.”

Sumner smiled. “Send him in, please.”

Sumner rose as the Oval Office door opened to admit Ethan Chisholm, the White House chief of staff. Chisholm was among the oldest of Sumner’s appointees: white-haired and erect, patrician in bearing, and perpetually scornful of nearly everything he saw or heard. Sumner seldom saw him smile or heard him compliment anything, including the president who had named him to his post. On that occasion, he wore a look of bafflement, the sort of expression that spoke of having turned a wholly new page in the book of time.

“Mr. President, how did you know?”

Sumner waved Chisholm into a guest chair and resumed his own seat. “Know what, Ethan?”

“That the country would approve! That operation must have cost ten billion, to say nothing of ten thousand Afghans killed.”

“And the country approves?”

Chisholm nodded and shook his head at the same time. “The entire staff was certain you’d take a bath over it. A few of us thought you might even be impeached. But the morning polls have you at ninety-three percent approval and only two percent disapproval. No president in a century has had ratings that good. How did you know?”

“The short answer is that I didn’t. The long answer is that I thought about the possible popular reaction for about a second and a half before I realized that I was going to do it anyway, come hell or high water. My job is to protect America, American citizens, and American interests, Ethan. Whatever that job seems to require, I will do it. The political consequences are for other people to worry about.” Sumner smiled. “People like you.”

Chisholm shook his head again. “You had no fear of the possibility of impeachment?”

“It didn’t even occur to me.”

“Mr. President...Steve...” Chisholm stared at his knees in obvious confusion. “Why do you have political advisors if you’re not going to seek their opinions and listen to them?”

“Oh, I listen to them.” Sumner sat back in his chair and steepled his fingers. “About things such as campaign slogans and tactics. About whom in the various caucuses on the Hill I can trust, and who I should never turn my back on. Not about policy. I resolved on my policies a long time ago.”

Chisholm gaped at him. Sumner snorted gently and rocked a bit in his chair.

“Do you know why everyone allows himself opinions about politics, Ethan? Because politics is supposed to be simple. It’s supposed to be about justice. Right and wrong. Things every schoolchild learns at his mother’s knee. Politics isn’t supposed to be the property of a bunch of specialists running simulations on high-powered computers. It’s supposed to be about the defense of the nation and peace in the streets.

“I never expected to land here, until I actually did. But when the final tallies were in, I knew what would happen immediately afterward. And did it ever! I was practically overrun by would-be advisors, each of them toting some grand scheme to create a Utopia by federal action. Have you ever read about the Coolidge Administration, Ethan?”

The chief of staff shook his head.

“I gave them the Coolidge treatment. I invited them to pitch their cases, listened in total silence, and showed them out. Every one of them hoped to become a part of my administration, awarded power and prestige. None of them did, of course.

“Politics is supposed to be the pursuit of justice. That and nothing else. From what you’ve told me, the public agrees with my understanding of justice, in this instance at least. But if it were the other way around, it wouldn’t have changed a thing. I will do as I think justice requires, regardless of anyone’s opinion before, during, or after the fact.”

Sumner’s gaze moved to the Gilbert Stuart portrait of George Washington over the Oval Office fireplace.

“I may not be here long, Ethan. Perhaps only one term. Perhaps less than that, if Congress should ever become really incensed at me. But no matter how long I hold this office, I intend to go to my rest each night with a quiet heart. I learned what that requires long ago.”

Ethan Chisholm’s eyes had filled with awe.

“What?”

Sumner smiled.

“Knowing that I did my job.”

====

Sunday, September 9, 2012

A Sunday Assortment

1. "No Religious Test"

J. P. Travis declaims on a religious imbalance that worries him:

Something is terribly wrong with our nation. Much as I like Romney and plan to vote for him, it worries me that the top level of leadership, in all three branches of government, does not reflect the religious preferences of the majority of Americans.

First of all, some facts: nearly 80% of Americans identify themselves as Christian. 25% are Roman Catholic, and somewhere between 50% and 55% are Protestants of one type or another. 1.7% are Mormon, 1.7% are Jewish, and other religions are each less than 1%.

So this is overwhelmingly a Christian nation, with a majority of us being Protestants. The numbers aren’t surprising given our history. Early immigrants were often people fleeing religious persecution by the Roman Catholic Church or the Church of England. We are mostly Protestant because that’s who we were from the beginning....

So here’s the point – here’s why I’m saying something is terribly wrong: no matter who wins the presidential election in November, we will have no Protestant Christians in leadership positions in Washington, D.C.

It's going to work out that way from time to time. "No religious test" means no religious test, so Catholics, Mormons, Jews, atheists, etc. can't be excluded from federal offices on the basis of their faiths.

25% of Americans profess Catholicism, yet Catholics were radically under-represented in federal office until about 1960. There has yet to be a Taoist, Hindu, or Buddhist in federal office. We have one open Muslim in Congress (and by my lights, that's one too many, but there's that "no religious test" business again).

I'd worry more about the characters and political convictions of our federal officeholders, and less about their religious allegiances. I'd make an exception for the Gaia worshippers, and another for the self-worshippers, but maybe that's just me.

(On a tangential matter: "Roman Catholic" is not a religion; it's a rite. The religion is Catholic Christianity. There are about twenty rites within Catholicism, but those pertain strictly to things such as the specific forms of ceremonies, clerical garb, and other peripheral matters.)

***

2. "Crazy."

John Hinderaker at Power Line asks and answers a cutting question:

Radio host Peter Schiff went to Charlotte, posed as a liberal and interviewed a number of delegates. He floated a proposal to ban all corporate profits. A number of the delegates thought this was a grand idea; the more moderate ones just wanted to cap profits. You have to see it to believe it....

And they aren’t the only crazy ones. The Secret Service is investigating this delegate’s threat to kill Mitt Romney....

These people aren’t just a little slow, or far too liberal. They are, frankly, crazy.

Well, yes, they are. But are they a dismissible fringe, the majority of Democrats, or the majority of all politically engaged Americans? I could make a good case for that third possibility, but as it would include me, I'll take the Fifth.

Libertarians have often spoken of "the right to ignore the State." It's a pretty concept, which carries an even broader implication: in a polity where the activities of government are firmly confined to protecting the lives, liberties, and properties of the law-abiding, if one wished to ignore politics itself, his position would be entirely defensible, and arguably smarter than that of the politically engaged...or at least, less susceptible to neurosis.

That might be the strongest argument anyone could make for a classical-liberal limited government.

***

3. Obama The Deceiver.

Watch the following video, and decide for yourself whether you would trust this man's word on anything:

At Independent Journal Review, Kyle Becker provides the following summation:

This is a stunning thirteen minute video that shows Obama in his own words, with commentary from mostly mainstream media sources. If this video goes viral and reaches moderate and independent voters, it would be a big blow to the Obama re-election bid.

Like I said in the title, if an undecided voter sees this, it’s over for Obama.

I can't help but agree.

4. Tactical Deployment Of Silence.

The worthy Ace of Spades notes a distinct pattern in the topics that flick liberals on their weenies:

You Can Tell If Something Hurts Liberals By Their Shrill Insistence We Not Discuss It

So, four things we're to not talk about:

1. Obama's convention speech. Who cares about speeches? It's results that matter.

2. Obama's results. Who cares about results? We should be talking about Romney's vague statements about Afghanistan.

3. Obama's declining popularity requiring him to shift his speech from a 70,000 seat arena to a 20,000 seat cafetorium. It was the weather, guys. The night was cool and clear but no one could have predicted such a strange weather pattern.

And now, 4: The jobs report.

Note that these subjects aren't just being shouted down by left-liberal mouthpieces on the talking-heads shows; they receive approximately no attention from the Legacy Media. Thus, we lay bare the Mainstream Media's guideline for what it will and will not cover: anything that might impede the re-election of The Won, The Lightworker, The Messiah, the Czar of all Czars: Barack Hussein Obama.

This year, despite my misgivings, I'll be going to the polls. Stay home out of disgust if you wish, but be aware of the stakes: voting might just be the most effective measure you can take toward your personal survival.

Saturday, September 8, 2012

The Islamic Two-Step

[The following essay first appeared at Eternity Road on November 28, 2008. Its relevance to the post immediately below it should require no explanation.]

Not many creeds that have afflicted this unhappy world approach the barefaced fraudulence and viciousness of Islam. The sole modern competitor that comes to mind is Nazism; after that, one must recur to the worship of Ba'al, Ormuzd, and the other savage gods of pre-Christian times. But Islam is here with us today, whereas those other cults have been laid in their graves. And so we must cope with it, and its millions of adherents, as best we can.

It's something of a problem. The great majority of Muslims have detoxified their faith for their own purposes; despite the explicit commands of the Qur'an that they make war on us "infidels," they're as non-violent and generally tolerant as any modern Christian. Yet they do not deny those commands, nor do they demand that they be struck from their scriptures. More, despite the incredible number of infamies Muslims have perpetrated in recent decades -- this site alone has recorded more than 12,000 lethal terror attacks by Muslims -- they cannot be moved to condemn their co-religionists for their slaughters. Rather, their prevailing response is a denial that Islam could possibly have anything to do with violence -- usually mated to a tu quoque assertion that "Christians and Jews have done violence, too."

Consider the following, quoted in this John F. Cullinan article at National Review Online:

...both our histories have been intermingled with periods of violence, and when religion has been strong in our societies various political forces have carried out violence in its name and in certain cases this violence has received legitimacy by religious authorities. Certainly we cannot claim that violence is the monopoly of only one religion....

You and we, we both believe in religious freedom, but we Muslims do not allow an aggressive proselytizing in our midst that would destroy our faith in the name of freedom any more than would Christians if they were in our situation.

Those words come from the closing address by Professor Seyyed Hossein Nasr of George Washington University to a conference on inter-religious dialogue. It's as perfect an example of the Islamic two-step as any your Curmudgeon has encountered, with the groundless assertion that when not forbidden by law, Christian evangelists force themselves on defenseless Muslims, added as a (dis)grace note.

Is it not clear that "Professor" Nasr -- yes, those are "sneer quotes" -- has no use for freedom of religion? Except in those places and cases where Islam is not yet politically ascendant and can use such latitude to advance its own aims, of course.

Are there any Muslim "professors" with doctorates in anything but "Islamic Studies?" Leave that aside: what prominent Muslim will admit that the Qur'an, the Sunnah, and the various ahadith all counsel Muslims to deceive and defraud us "infidels" until they've grown powerful enough to subjugate us by force? What prominent Muslim will admit that the savageries prevalent in Islamic states arise from Islamic doctrine? What prominent Muslim will admit that Muhammad, Islam's "perfect man" whom all Muslims are exhorted to emulate, was a warlord, a murderer, an adulterer, a pedophile, and a shameless voluptuary? What prominent Muslim will admit to these things as flaws in Islam, and demand that they be corrected for the good of all men everywhere?

Perhaps it's too much to ask of a body of believers whose worldwide average IQ is 85. All the same, until high Islamic religious authorities -- men conceded doctrinal authority near to that of a Catholic pope -- are willing to make such admissions, and condemn their Muslim brethren for thinking, speaking, or acting otherwise, there can be no trusting Muslims to behave according to the norms of civilized society. Nor can we expect, when their jihad-minded brethren demand money, help, or concealment from them, that they will dare to refuse.

In his recent book Stealth Jihad, the great Robert Spencer exhorts us to close our borders to further immigration from Islamic states and Muslim-majority lands. Your Curmudgeon has been calling for that for a while now. It's Spencer, however, who gets all the death threats, while your Curmudgeon's "evil black rifle" sits idle in his closet. What a pity.

Quickies: Iran, Israel, and America

There are reports this morning that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the so-called president of Iran, might announce a "softening of position on nuclear talks" when he appears at the United Nations later this week. On the Left, the reaction is celebratory: "The sanctions worked! No need for a strike!" On the Right, the usual wary watchfulness prevails, as it should when the subject is anything freighted with so much significance.

And then there's Israel:

Israel's defense minister says his country continues to have differences with the U.S. over Iran's disputed nuclear program....

Barak spoke Thursday hours after meeting the U.S. Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. James A. Winnefeld. Earlier this week, Israeli officials said the sides were working closely in hopes of getting their positions in sync.

Israel believes time is running out to stop Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. The U.S. opposes any Israeli military action right now.

The only public official in Israel with nearly as much clout as the prime minister is the defense minister.

My take is that Iran is about to play another round of its version of "the Islamic Two-Step:" it will use suggestions of willingness to talk, and perhaps formally scheduled and structured talks about its nuclear program, to gain time in which to complete its acquisition of nuclear weapons. Islamic mouthpiece groups use variations of this tactic to gain legal and social concessions from Western nations, by implying that such concessions are the only way to placate the seething "Muslim street" and forestall further acts of Islamic violence.

It's all lies and diversions. Muslims are encouraged by Islam to lie to "infidels" when it's to the advantage of Islam. Israel, whose very survival depends on never trusting a promise from an Islamic state, is fully aware of this; America is not.

Stay tuned.

Friday, September 7, 2012

The Bottom Line

EDMUND WALKER:
You wouldn't believe the dorkus she was with when I met her. The guy came to us with a business proposition. We're always looking for opportunities. If the conditions are right. We're willing to take an occasional risk, if the downside isn't too steep. But this guy hadn't done his homework, he didn't know the bottom line. That's how I knew he was full of shit. You've got to know the bottom line. That's all that really counts....He didn't have the goods, this guy. He was like a lot of guys you run into -- they want to get rich, they want to do it quick, they want to be there with one score. But they're not willing to do what's necessary. Do you know what I mean?

NED RACINE:

I'm not sure. You mean, lay the groundwork? Earn it?

WALKER:

No. I mean do what's necessary. Whatever's necessary.

RACINE:

Yeah. I know that kind of guy. I can't stand that. It makes me sick.

WALKER:

Me too.

RACINE:

I'm not like that.

[From Lawrence Kasdan's screenplay Body Heat.]

You don't have to be in love with mobbed-up Florida mogul Ed Walker or sleazy shyster Ned Racine (who eventually murders Walker) to appreciate the immense insight in the above passage.

What's that? You have a goal, you say? Well, what will it take to get there? Say what? You're not willing to go that far? Then your "goal" isn't really your goal, is it?

Not much further on in the play, we see that not only isn't Ned Racine "like that," but Walker's adulterous wife Maddie isn't, either -- and Maddie is much cleverer than her lover Racine, who's merely a tool in her plans.

Now and then, we see a glimmer of understanding of this principle in practical politics -- even in fringe politics:

Wayne Allyn Root, 2008 Libertarian Party's Vice Presidential nominee and political commentator, resigned this morning from the Libertarian National Committee (LNC) to, according to his resignation letter, "elect good people and change the direction of this country outside of a third party."...

When I asked if he was now backing Mitt Romney, Root responded, "I am," adding, "I don’t deny that Romney and Ryan aren't libertarians, but Romney is a pro-business capitalist and Obama is a Marxist-socialist."

"The economy has been trashed. This is about my kids' future, it's about my businesses," said Root. "There is no hope for America if Obama is re-elected."

Bravo, Mr. Root. Good sense is sufficiently rare that it should be applauded vigorously when it presents itself to public view.

***

I am a libertarian. That my personal preferences and practices are conservative-Catholic has no bearing on my political stances. Indeed, I lean anarcho-capitalist, at least when I'm thinking clearly. At one time I was the chair of the New York State chapter of the Libertarian Party, and before that the Suffolk County chapter chair. That set of associations came to an end in 1990, when it became all too terribly clear that:

  • The party was being taken over by persons I wouldn't allow into my home;
  • Above and apart from the prior observation, the party had cemented itself into a stance that was effectively anti-libertarian. That is: its public statements and operations were bringing about a net loss of popular interest in individual freedom.

Once I realized that, I could not remain a party allegiant.

Root appears to have traveled a somewhat different path. He appreciates, as I do, the importance of buying time for America. That's his driver for abandoning the LP. It's an entirely defensible stance. As chess players like to say, your strategy won't matter much if your tactics are about to get you murdered.

In the epilogue to his early Hugo Award-winner Double Star, Robert A. Heinlein delineates the overriding consideration that binds all political movements, good, bad, and indifferent:

People don’t really want change, any change at all — and xenophobia is very deep-rooted. But we progress, as we must — if we are to go out to the stars.

Or, as Arthur Herzog put it in The B.S. Factor, "Change, in any case, is hard, and difficulty makes people impatient."

In practical politics, principles matter only to the extent permitted by a nation's innate reluctance to embrace change.

***

Libertarian politics is, as the LP has touted for many years, "a politics of principles." Those principles are rooted in a conception of individual rights. Though I maintain that they're employed beyond their proper demesne in formulating certain policy positions, I have no quarrel with individual rights themselves. Indeed, I've never encountered an argument against them that would hold water for a full minute.

But "a politics of principles" is equally "a politics of oughts." One must accept its "oughts" -- its moral and ethical postulates -- to be perfectly happy with their implications. He who doesn't immediately and viscerally "buy into" those postulates simply cannot be sold on their implications for policy without arguing over the policies themselves. That's where the fun really begins.

As C. S. Lewis has told us:

From propositions about fact alone no practical conclusion can ever be drawn. This will preserve society cannot lead to do this except by the mediation of society ought to be preserved. This will cost you your life cannot lead directly to do not do this: it can lead to it only through a felt desire or an acknowledged duty of self-preservation. The Innovator is trying to get a conclusion in the imperative mood out of premisses in the indicative mood: and though he continues trying to all eternity he cannot succeed, for the thing is impossible. We must therefore either extend the word Reason to include what our ancestors called Practical Reason and confess that judgements such as society ought to be preserved (though they can support themselves by no reason of the sort that Gaius and Titius demand) are not mere sentiments but are rationality itself; or else we must give up at once, and for ever, the attempt to find a core of 'rational' value behind all the sentiments we have debunked.

(Apropos of which, if you haven't read Lewis's mighty essay The Abolition of Man, do so at once. Its arguments, and the ability to grasp and defend them, are prerequisites for the comprehension of the material published at Liberty's Torch. Yes, I'm serious. Do it now. There'll be a test on this.)

To get "all the way" to the (defensible) libertarian policy prescriptions, one must embrace the "oughts" inherent in the individual rights asserted by libertarians. That's quite a jump from our current political condition:

  • The right to one's life implies a right not to be killed except in self-defense or as retribution for premeditated murder;
  • The right to one's liberty implies a right not to be coerced into any course of action, nor out of a course of action that does not infringe on others' rights;
  • The right to one's justly acquired property implies a right not to be expropriated against one's consent, except to make restitution for an offense against someone else's rights.

Whoosh! There goes the entire corpus of federal law, the laws of the fifty states, and the ordinances of three thousand counties and nearly ninety thousand towns, villages, hamlets, and school boards. (We also sacrifice a few minor bits of the Common Law we inherited from our English brethren.) Full acceptance of the libertarian "oughts" requires that we tear up the legal accumulations of three centuries of Anglo-American practice.

I know a few people who'd shrug and say, "Well, that's the way it's got to be." A few. A very few. Most of us can't accept a change that radical, at least not in one leap. That we might just get rapped in the teeth by such a change -- not through libertarian political triumphs but through widespread social collapse -- doesn't alter the practical-political situation one iota.

People don’t want change, any change at all. Whenever they accept change, they do so grudgingly, and with much grumbling over the required adjustments to their ways of life.

***

I've argued before against partisanry, and I'll continue to do so. Allegiance to an organization, even one whose principles one accepts wholeheartedly, invariably gets in the way of other goals. Thus, I'm not a Republican partisan and will not become one, despite the rather tempting array of incentives and enticements that have been offered me. But I will tend to vote for a Republican over a Democrat, as long as the candidate is a decent man whose emphasis is on morally acceptable changes of a tolerable magnitude that militate toward greater individual liberty. In other words, for the foreseeable future, what's good enough for Wayne Allyn Root will be good enough for me as well.

If gentle, incremental changes are all that's practically possible, let's work toward those. Their bottom line, in Ed Walker's phrasing, is within ethical and practical reach. Radical changes, no matter how theoretically desirable, involve a "bottom line" that's likely to include mass suffering, even bloodshed.

You've got to know the bottom line.

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Celebrities, Failures, And Nonentities

Julian Castro?
Antonio Villaraigosa?
Kal Penn?
Eva Longoria?
Sandra Fluke?
Jon Huntsman?

This is a major party's national-convention lineup?

Oh, excuse me, please: I forgot:
Michelle Obama?
Joseph Biden?
Barack Hussein Obama?

The Republican National Convention was top-heavy with achievers. The planners were especially wise to feature Chris Christie and Scott Walker, two of America's most successful governors, among a lineup of generally heavy hitters. Yes, yes, there was an entertainer on the final night...a good one, a highly revered actor with a long and glittering resume, who's also the director most Hollywood high-liners are most eager to work with. Choose any one of the speakers from the 2012 RNC and tot his accomplishments up against those of all the above DNC speakers taken together. Who comes out on top?

I suppose it's not quite fair of me to have included the Obamas in the list. Look at them! Michelle is a former lawyer who'll never again practice law; Barack is a former "community organizer" and lapsed constitutional-law instructor who couldn't qualify for even an assistant professorship and has never made a dollar in the private sector. It would take quite a long list of genuine achievements to counterbalance their personal records of failure, especially if we include Barack's failures as president.

(No, for a Democrat to win an election is not an accomplishment of note. Not in Chicago, anyway.)

At any rate, what we're witnessing in the DNC is what's traditionally called a coronation. The whole show is centered on elevating Barack Hussein Obama to the plane of the immortals. Right up there next to Albert J. Parkhouse, inventor of the wire coat hanger.

Oops! Excuse me, please. We're not supposed to mention coat hangers and Democrats in the same paragraph, are we? It constitutes racism of some sort, no doubt.

Obama won the presidency in 2008 in large measure because the Republicans fielded a weak candidate, who went on to run a bad campaign. I've occasionally wondered whether the GOP was anxious not to occupy the Oval Office these past four years, so that the odium for the FannieMae / FreddieMac-precipitated collapse in housing and finance would be seen to rest on someone else's shoulders. It seems more plausible the longer I ponder it -- and even more plausible that the Democrats are "playing to lose" this year, so they can have the next four or eight years to purge their own ranks and attempt to bring their party nearer to the mainstream of American life and thought.

Really, how could anyone look at the ridiculous extravaganza the Democrats are staging in Charlotte and not at least contemplate the possibility?

The Republicans are no prize, granted. Of the bunch that pursued the nomination, Mitt Romney was the candidate I liked least. The GOP's Congressional "leadership" is a joke...or would be, if it were as funny as it is pathetic. But at least the RNC demonstrated some sense of what matters to Americans engaged with the political process. The Democrats are too mesmerized by the glory of The Won to take notice of the carnage his "leadership" has brought about. Full speed ahead with the coronation! His Majesty's new clothes have to turn up eventually.

I sometimes wish I could contrive to sleep until November 7. Unfortunately, this campaign is far too important. Drinking heavily is also out, as I have five novels to complete and a new guitar to master.

Ah, well. This, too, shall pass away, right? Right?

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Assorted

Long weekends aren't good for the commentary business...whether you get paid for your ravings or not.

***

1. One For The Good Guys.

If you dislike a study's conclusions, you're supposed to examine its methodology and its mathematics. You're not supposed to accuse the chief investigator of fraud right off the bat:

The University of Texas-Austin is backing a sociology professor who came under withering attack for a study that found children of same-sex parents are more likely to be depressed or on welfare than kids raised by heterosexual couples.

The school launched an inquiry into Professor Mark Regnerus' peer-reviewed work last month after a New York-based blogger attacked him for a controversial paper which compared the adult lives of people raised by parents in same-sex relationships to those raised by parents in traditional marriages. The study found several differences, including some that were potentially negative. But an inquiry by the school found Regnerus used sufficiently scholarly methods, university officials announced this week.

Would it surprise you to learn that that "New York-based blogger" is homosexual -- and that he's attacked Regnerus's integrity on the basis of the professor's Catholic faith?

After it was published, blogger Scott Rose accused Regnerus of scientific misconduct in two letters to the school, first charging Regnerus with deviating from "ethical standards" for research and later accusing him of "possible falsification" of research. Rose, who is gay, claimed the study was compromised because it was funded by the conservative Witherspoon Institute and that Regnerus was unable to be impartial because he is Catholic.

There has never been any evidence proffered to the effect that Regnerus deviated from appropriate scholastic and statistical standards. But a homosexual activist who dislikes your conclusions won't be much concerned with that...even when the subject is the long-term damage done to innocent children by being raised in homosexual households.

Sure, let 'em be Boy Scout troop leaders. What could possibly go wrong?

***

2. National Empty Chair...Week?

Clearly, there are dangers inherent in booking a venue you might not be able to fill:

College students from across North Carolina will arrive in Charlotte by the busload. Same with members of predominantly black churches in neighboring South Carolina.

Their goal: help fill a 74,000-seat outdoor stadium to capacity when President Obama accepts the Democratic nomination Thursday night.

Anything short of a full house on the final night of the Democratic Party's national convention will be instant fodder for Republicans eager to use empty seats as symbols of waning voter enthusiasm for Obama.

Democrats have been fretting for months over whether the president can draw a capacity crowd at Bank of America Stadium. Polls show voter enthusiasm is down, as are Obama's crowds for his battleground state campaign rallies.

Sheesh! Rock groups know better than to book a stadium that will be half empty when they take the stage. However, there's a critical difference at work here. Rock groups are private enterprises organized and operated to make a profit, whereas the Democratic National Convention is a publicly funded undertaking organized and operated to crown a Prophet.

Seriously, if it weren't for the vestiges of Obama's cult of personality, he might not be able to fill a high school auditorium. But his massive narcissism won't permit him to admit that his star has waned too far to essay another Greek-column-filled extravaganza. That would come too close to admitting to a mistake.

Clint Eastwood's clever bit at the Republican National Convention last week will be remembered far more kindly than Barack Hussein Obama's decadal adventure in self-aggrandizement.

***

3. Never Too Late For Another Learning Experience.

A week and a bit ago, I mentioned a foray into self-indulgence that's had a few secondary consequences. One of them has been expensive but most rewarding.

I own a Guild F40 Black Beauty made in 1960. It's a beautiful guitar in several senses, with tone that challenges the very best examples of the art being made today. However, I haven't been able to play it for several years, owing to advancing arthritis in my hands.

Well, with the arrival of the Les Paul, I took the advice of a colleague and went to a "set-up man" in my neighborhood for some advice. He assured me that he could soften the action on the Les Paul to the point where I could play it in comfort -- assuming extra-light-gauge strings and some time to get my steel-string calluses back. He quoted a price for the service that surprised me pleasantly.

Inasmuch as his shop also buys and sells guitars, I asked him what he thought he could get for my Guild. After I'd described it to him, he demanded to see it at once. I went home to fetch it and set it before him scant minutes later. He picked it up, played a few bars, smiled at me, and shook his head.

"You don't want to part with this," he said. "Guitars with this sort of tone just aren't made anymore. Besides, you'll never get what it's really worth. Leave it with me. I'll soften it up for you, and you'll be back to playing it in no time."

He handed me back the Les Paul the very next day, and he was absolutely correct: this axe plays like warm butter, and it sounds like...well, if you've never heard a Les Paul's tone, get thee down to a music shop and play one for yourself.

I'll get my Black Beauty back either today or tomorow. I can't wait.

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Blessings And Cursings

Some subjects elicit bad behavior more reliably than others:

SUZANNE writes:
My husband and I are happy to be expecting our fourth child in seven years of marriage. Unfortunately, I rather dread telling most of my family members. We are Protestant, and the idea of "openness to life" has not been embraced for at least three generations, as far as I call tell. I wonder if you or any of your readers have clever answers to the questions I am sure to receive such as, "Oh no! What are you going to do?," "You're not having anymore after this, are you?!" and the ever popular, "You DO know how that happens, right?"

I would appreciate the suggestions.

Laura writes:

Congratulations.

Please don't respond to rudeness with a clever line.

Anyone who suggests, even jokingly, to a pregnant woman that her having another child is weird or excessive is not just rude and stupid, but cruel. Such comments are often motivated by envy, but you don't need to feel sympathy toward someone who is envious.

I suggest you say, "A simple congratulations is all that is needed."

Indeed. But I must differ slightly: I disagree that the usual motive is envy. We are so deeply sunk in a morass of present-moment / self-uber-alles / instant-gratification attitudes that to have children at all is frequently the target of derision and feigned incomprehension.

I recall, from some months ago, a story about a young woman who, supposedly because she regards the desire for children as "selfish" in the face of "the damage Humanity does to the planet," had herself permanently sterilized before conceiving even once. Let's stipulate, entirely for the sake of argument, that that woman was perfectly sincere about her motives. How would her behavior have been different, were she one of the "proudly childfree" dedicated to a life of self-absorbed self-indulgence?

Time was, there was an organization that styled itself the National Organization for Non-Parents. Its mission, if memory serves, was to combat "pronatalism," to uphold the rights of the "childfree," and to counter the derision the "childfree" supposedly receive from more fertile couples. I knew a couple of members thereof. They were quite defensive about their "childfree" state. I forbore to ask what had set them on that course, or why they might think anyone would begrudge it to them.

Let us grant the "childfree" their perfect right to eschew parenthood. It's a tiring state; no one who has had the experience would ever dispute that. No one should quarrel with the decision to avert it, and anyone who does is as much a boor as the sorts Suzanne mentioned in the quote above. So why, then, should we tolerate the derision the "childfree," and similar anti-natal forces, heap upon those who regard children as a delight and a blessing?

The question answers itself, doesn't it?

***

Anti-natal attitudes and forces converge from several overt postures:

  1. Radical environmentalism;
  2. Unrefined Malthusianism;
  3. Extreme urbanism;
  4. Bizarre notions about "social responsibility;"
  5. Sheer self-absorption.

Objectively, the result is what matters most: lots and lots of couples having few or no kids, while they look askance at those who enjoy children and seek to have as many as they can properly care for. But of the five postures mentioned above, the first four cloak themselves in moral garb, and thus provide cover of a sort for the fifth one, which I suspect is more applicable than all the others taken together.

It's been said by many a commentator that we most despise in others what we know to be unworthy about ourselves. He who wishes to give vent to his censorious impulses, however, must take care to avoid the "motes and beams" trap; otherwise, his castigations will be seen as an expression of envy or worse, and will fail to support his presumption of moral superiority.

Back when families of sizes greater than the contemporary average were commonplace, the castigation ran all too frequently in the opposite direction. It was wrong then, and it's wrong now -- and not because the castigators were often moved by envy of the "childfree."

***

If there's a subject more properly reserved to private decision-making than whether to bear (additional) children, I can't think of it at the moment. If we may assume that the parents accept full responsibility for their children's well-being and conduct, how on Earth could it become anyone else's business? Even the closest of family members have no place in such a matter...yet instances of intrusive meddling, well beyond simple post hoc commentary, by relatives in one another's natal decisions are legion.

No subject comes to mind that better illustrates how completely we have abandoned our traditional respect for privacy.

Yes, there are political dimensions to this subject. It's long been a popular slogan on the Left that "the personal is the political," hasn't it? But sad to say, it's not just leftists who permit themselves to thrust their noses into the genitive decisions of others; quite a number of more sensible persons allow themselves the same privilege, and with no better justification.

Ironically, as Julian Simon, Mark Steyn, and others would observe, those who fail to procreate are "part of the problem" of the American welfare state. The steady decline of our fertility is at the core of what makes our largest social entitlements unsustainable. The "solution," if you'll allow me to cast it as such, is to have scads and scads of kids, whose labors twenty years hence will pay for our Social Security and Medicare. But this is a remedy our most ardent supporters of welfarism are determined to avoid. Your conjectures as to their private reasons are, of course, your own affair.

Saturday, September 1, 2012

"Democracy" as practiced by GOP UPDATED

Some brave soul with a cell phone camera captured this disgusting Teleprompter scripting of  a "vote" choreographed by the Republican party establishment at its recent Romneyfest convention in Tampa and posted it on YouTube.

UPDATE!
The Teleprompter scripting caper is not even the "tip of the iceberg". For a more inclusive exposition of political thuggery read this.
Do you understand yet?

"To Save the Planet" NOT!!

There is old cliche which goes something like this: "No fool like an old fool." Perhaps those words should be modified to: "No hypocritical fool like an environmentalist fool."

The following is an advertisement on Ebay for a:
1965 MercedesBenz 230 SL Electric vehicle, finished in white exterior with a dark blue interior, both tops, 4 speed transmission, the motor is a ADC 9.1 inch,FB1-4001, the car has 19 6 volt PBV flooded sealed battery system , the voltage is 114 and this car can be charged with any 110 outlet and has a 60 mile range, this set up is very reliable , the batteries are very long lasting and top speed on the car is 60 MPH, runs and drives great and was designed by the creator of the EV cars GM produced in the early 90's.
The vehicle is pictured below.

The curb weight of the original 230 SL was 2750 lbs. After the modifications, this electric car now weighs approximately 2 tons (3965+ lbs).

This writer, though not an engineer or mathematician can justly claim a degree of knowledge regarding both the vehicle and its power source due to owning an unmodified 230 SL of the same vintage (see below) and having spent 10 years living off-grid utilizing these batteries to power the family residence.

Each of these golf cart batteries sell for +- $185.00 and weigh 85 lbs. The car contains 19 such items and they consist of mostly lead and sulfuric acid. Both of these substances are highly toxic and require energy intensive mining/manufacturing processes. In such an application the batteries with normal care and use will need to be replaced  in 7 years or less.

You, gentle reader, will doubtless note that this classic car displays New York license # ZERO-CO2 and is offered for sale in Malibu, California. These locations are separated by a distance of 3000 miles. In the highly unlikely event that it was driven that distance, the journey would have required +-50 days. This figure is arrived at by computing thusly: range of 1 charge of the batteries =60 mi. @ speed max 60 mph., recharge time for the battery pac =16 hrs+-.

Let us discount that recharging the batteries requires a 120v electrical outlet drawing 30 Amperes for 16 hours fed by an "evil" coal or gas fired power plant spewing noxious pollution into the atmosphere. This hypothetical road trip would of necessity need to be undertaken by no more than two people in a vehicle whose luggage compartment is now fully occupied by batteries. Those batteries have an energy efficiency recovery rate of < 20% .

I will leave you, gentle reader to draw your own conclusions as to the net environmental impact of this exercise in intellectual gymnastics. Meanwhile, the auction on ebay of this  kinetic sculpture vehicle will have ended by the time you have completed reading this screed.

cross posted at: Fighting in the Shade™