Friday, April 13, 2018

Safe working hypothesis.

I don’t know for sure what evidence we’re dealing with with regard to the alleged Douma chemical incident but I think this[1] is probably a good starting place for an attempt to make sense of the controversy:

Russian Evidence...

  • Forensic Analysis
  • Time Lines, Charts
  • Earth & Air & H20 Samples
  • Deep Interview of Witnesses
  • Comparisons to Other Gas Attacks
  • Database Analysis of All Probabilities
  • Outside Help From Non Biased Agencies
  • Logical Deductions from Evidence Found
American Evidence... (Niki Haley & US Gov en masse)
  • We Saw It On CNN... !
  • We Consulted Colin Powell
  • We Read The Trump Tweets
  • We Examined The Witches Entrails
Notes
[1] Comment by Sir Edge on “Stocks Sink As State Department Says It Has "Proof" Syrian Government Behind Gas Attack.” By Tyler Durden, ZeroHedge, 4/13/18.

Three things to keep in mind.

In these times when the urge to wage reckless and unnecessary war courses through the veins of all right-thinking personages, the ordinary citizen has his or her hands full trying to make sense of events that are, well, senseless. I don’t have the definitive guidance and version of events to put out there but there do seem to be three principles the citizen can bear in mind now:
  1. popular sovereignty in the United States is dead and our elite class pursues objectives (defend supposed American military hegemony, humiliate Russia, destroy Iran, destroy white America) and uses methods (AntiFa, speech suppression, legal extortion, media monopoly, constitutional evisceration, vote fraud and one-dollar-one-vote corruption) decided upon by them completely without input from the electorate,
  2. that elite class is intent on removing or neutralizing the insurgent, populist President Trump who was elected by virtue of, as they see it, some kind of cosmic joke (or, same thing, the wishes of the people), and
  3. the notion that corporate media are the least bit interested in exploring the truth of any matter is ridiculous.
Other principles can no doubt be listed as well, but they amount to little more than fleshing out the above three.

As proof of the third point consider this amazing article up on South Front[1] in which there is a video showing how the former chief of the U.K. armed forces, Gen. Jonathan Shaw, is summarily cut off in the midst of an interview with Sky News in Britain when he strays off the reservation where only thoughts of “Animal Assad did it” are permitted to reside:

This is simply astonishing treatment of a man once the most senior military man in the United Kingdom.

Notes
[1] "Sky News Cuts Off Former Head of British Armed Forces While He Questiones Douma ‘Chemical Attack.’" By South Front, 4/13/18.

Thursday, April 12, 2018

Hard Cases Make Bad Foreign Policy

     It’s commonplace to hear or read pronouncements – sometimes elaborate ones that amount to proposed replacements – on an administration’s “foreign policy,” especially by opinion-mongers who disapprove of what the administration did most recently. Time was, I held such discussions to be critically important. Indeed, I held them to be so important that I read rags such as Foreign Affairs and Foreign Policy cover-to-cover, practically the instant they arrived in my mailbox. (At the time I was deep in my studies of strategic-weapons planning and defense postures. So sue me.)

     As my Gentle Readers have already divined from the previous paragraph, I no longer think so. Indeed, I think the notion that an administration can have a “foreign policy” is a bit naive. And of course, this being the loudest and most opinionated of all loudly opinionated blogs, I’m here to tell you why.

     Why now? Syria, of course. Specifically, the alleged use of chemical weapons at Douma a few days ago.


     Like it or not, the determination of how the nation should act toward other nations is the president’s duty. Congress can constrain him to some degree, mainly by its exercise of the power of the purse, but when the U.S. confronts a decision about whether or not to use military force, the nation’s sword is in the president’s hand. He and he alone will wield it.

     Let’s look at a trying scenario or two. Here’s Scenario #1: Another continent is convulsed in a devastating war. It’s gone on for years and appears likely to go on for years more. The president’s sympathies lie strongly with one side, but the nation is firmly opposed to involving itself in the troubles of other lands, and he’s fully aware of it. Indeed, his re-election campaign made a big deal out of his unwillingness to stick America’s nose into that conflict.

     The president discovers that he can contrive an excuse for sending an expeditionary force to assist his preferred side. Moreover, he knows that should he do so, the country would rally behind its men at arms, as it nearly always has. He acts accordingly – and dooms the world to a still greater conflagration only a couple of decades down the river of Time.

     Now, Scenario #2: Another continent is convulsed in a devastating war. It’s gone on for years and appears likely to go on for years more. The president’s sympathies lie strongly with one side, but the nation is firmly opposed to involving itself in the troubles of other lands, and he’s fully aware of it. Indeed, his re-election campaign made a big deal out of his unwillingness to stick America’s nose into that conflict.

     The president discovers that he can contrive an excuse for sending an expeditionary force to assist his preferred side. Moreover, he knows that should he do so, the country would rally behind its men at arms, as it nearly always has. He acts accordingly – and is hailed as the savior of Mankind for having brought an end to an unspeakable horror and having contrived an enduring peace.

     What’s that you say? The two scenarios are the same, so how could the reactions of the electorate be so greatly at variance? Well, yes. That was the point. The reaction of the electorate to Woodrow Wilson’s insertion of the U.S. into European War I differed radically from its reaction to Franklin D. Roosevelt’s insertion of the U.S. into European War II. The detail differences in setting that evoked the dramatic differences in reaction are what mattered.


     Probably the determinative factor in whether a nation’s people will approve of its executive’s decision to make war is whether the contest can be given a moral cast. In European War I (a.k.a. World War I and The Great War), President Wilson (“He kept us out of war”) had no such hook on which to hang his decision. He had been inclined to involve the U.S. practically from the outset. His rationale for doing so was contrived from the sinking of the Lusitania and the famous Zimmerman telegram. While one could certainly argue that the implied threats to American lives and interests expressed by those two events constituted a casus belli, one could just as credibly argue that they constituted reasons for the U.S. to cease its shipments of war materiel to Britain. Had Wilson followed the latter course, European War I would probably have petered out after a negotiated settlement of claims between the Triple Entente and the Triple Alliance. It’s possible that European War II (a.k.a. the European theater of World War II) would not have occurred, though given the vagaries of national sentiments that’s far from guaranteed.

     By contrast, in European War II President Roosevelt (“Your boys are not going to be sent to any foreign wars”) had excellent arguments, moral and practical, for involving the U.S. One was the German alliance with Japan, which had already committed an overt act of war against the U.S. by striking the naval base at Pearl Harbor. The second was Germany’s declaration of war against the U.S. on December 11, 1941, which was swiftly answered with an American declaration of war on Germany. The third was the mass of horrific reports about Germany’s genocidal pogrom against European Jewry, which we now call the Holocaust. Those events were sufficient to animate the American people in favor of war. Indeed, it’s possible that any one of them would have been sufficient even without the others. And despite the rise of the Soviet Union, the imposition of the Iron Curtain, and the immense costs European War II inflicted on the U.S. – far greater than the costs we suffered from European War I – both popular sentiment and the opinions of historians remain quite strongly in favor of our having taken a hand in it.

     In neither case could we say that a predetermined “foreign policy” had anything much to do with it.


     And now to Syria and the use of chemical weapons at Douma. At this time it is unclear who deployed those weapons. It’s also unclear what interest whoever did so thought to advance by using them. The arguments are raging on all sides. Currently, President Trump appears inclined to believe that the regime of Bashar al Assad is to blame. Moreover, he seems inclined toward punishing that regime with an air strike. Here are my questions, none of which I can confidently answer from available reports:

  1. Who decided to use war gases?
  2. What did he hope to accomplish by using them?
  3. Does the use of war gases justify American action against their employer?
  4. Would American action, if taken, conduce to further American involvement in the Syrian conflict?

     ...but I contend that no matter what the answers might be, the president’s decision will have more to do with Americans’ sentiments concerning the proposed action than with his previously declared “foreign policy” of treating military action as a last resort. If the preponderance of popular opinion is that he should act against the putative miscreant, he probably will; otherwise, he probably won’t.

     The sword does rest in the president’s hand, but under current circumstances he cannot be confident that what his intelligence sources – domestic or foreign – tell him about the gas attack is true-to-fact – and he knows it. Indeed, it’s a large part of what got him elected. Therefore he must rely principally on popular opinion. It’s a more reliable gauge than any dictum that emanates from the State Department, the DIA, the CIA, or any foreign intelligence service. And it might well cause him to wield the sword in a conflict in which the U.S. has no obvious stake.

     Foreign policy decisions are like that.


     The above flows from a cynical realization:

In every nation, the diplomatic, military, and intelligence communities are in business for themselves.

     The implication is plain. It always has been. The president cannot merely assume that what the State Department, the intelligence agencies, the military, and self-interested foreign actors are telling him is the truth. He knows, from both theory and practice, that those entities have agendas of their own. Sometimes those agendas will prove harmonious with the real national interest, but sometimes they won’t. In the usual case it will be impossible for him to tell.

     The notion that a predetermined foreign policy can remain “in force” is ludicrous. Every such decision will be represented to the president by at least some of the interested parties as a good reason to depart from his prior posture. Moreover, he would be well advised to listen attentively to everyone involved – but not because what they tell him is trustworthy.

     I could go on. I could discourse at length about the internal dynamics that give rise to contentions over foreign policy decisions, especially those about the use of military force. I could tease out why it’s wise for the president to listen closely to all the arguments, to compare them with what he knows of the institutional agendas of the proposers, and to contrast their emphases with one another. But this screed is already at a reasonable stopping point.

     More anon.

A gathering or morons.

According to a Turkish think tank the map below[1] is of the areas now controlled by various factions in Syria.

Now note that the purpose of the uninvited, unconstitutional, and illegal American presence in Syria is to fight ISIS[2] who presently control the black-shaded areas on the map of Syria I’ve marked with a yellow outline.

So . . . , do you think the presumably forthcoming U.S. (and French and People’s Republic of Britain-i-stan) military strikes on Syria will take place in the area outlined in yellow or . . . do you think they will take place in the areas of government control I’ve outlined in pink?

Notes
[1] "A Map Of The Coming War: Who Is Who (And Where) In Syria." By Tyler Durden, ZeroHedge, 4/12/18.
[2] "Defeating ISIS in Syria Is Just the Beginning." By Robert Ford, The Atlantic, 2/27/18; "Tillerson urges fractious anti-ISIS coalition to stay focused." CBS/AP, 2/13/18.

Wednesday, April 11, 2018

What Happened?

     Does anyone here remember Joseph Heller’s second novel, Something Happened -- ? If you remember it, did you read it? If you read it, did you enjoy it?

     And now that we’ve winnowed the audience down to the Gideon’s Band of those who read and enjoyed that lugubrious mess, I shall ask The Question:

What is the book about?

     Limit your answers to a single sentence. Write it down. Make it perfectly clear, and grammatically correct if possible. I’ll wait here.

     Finished with that? Very good. Now shove the piece of paper bearing your answer at least an arm’s length away from you. Turn it over, so your answer cannot be read from where you’re sitting. Now return your full attention to the screen. We control the horizontal. We control the vertical...

     Sorry, that last bit just slipped out. But I’m serious about the rest. My point requires all of it. Proceed at your own risk.


     I recall reading Kurt Vonnegut’s review of Something Happened in the New York Times Book Review. It was a highly praiseful piece that elevated the book to the pantheon of Great American Novels...but it never answered the question I posed in the previous segment. Vonnegut rhapsodized for quite a number of column-inches about Heller’s tome without ever coming to grips with that question.

     Considering that the book’s title is Something Happened, you’d think the reviewer’s duties would include delineating that very thing, wouldn’t you? Especially if it’s a single “something,” a unitary event around which all the rest of the novel’s action and human drama revolve. But Vonnegut never gets around to it.

     Why not? Vonnegut had nothing but plaudits for the book. He was obviously entranced by it...at least, he seemed to want the reader to think so. Surely he could tell us what the book is about. That’s one of the two irreducible requirements of a book review: what the book is about, and what the reviewer thinks of it.

     But he never did. The reason is fairly obvious to anyone who’s suffered through the whole book: nothing happens.

     Something Happened, hailed by critics from every corner of the literary world, is a five hundred page veh ist mir from first-person narrator Robert Slocum. Slocum, you see, is not happy. He wants us to know that. And he wants us to know that he blames everyone and everything in his life...except himself.

     Some story.


     We might call Something Happened the flagship of the Self-Indulgent Lament school of fiction. Everyone who was anyone in the world of literary criticism praised it to the skies. There have been many books like it since its publication in 1974. None of them are more readable.

     But why would critics lavish praise on something so vacuous and whiny? For Heller’s technique? For his evocation of Slocum’s unbounded ennui and angst? For “his sensibility and its hair-like filaments, his delicate, quivering sensibility” (Clive James) -- ?

     No. They praised it because:

  1. Heller was “one of them;”
  2. He’d written something without events, drama, or a moral;
  3. At long last, a “great” writer had written a book that only they could “appreciate.”

     If the critics could elevate Something Happened to the literary pantheon, while the rest of us were saying “Huh?” and “WTF?” and “I don’t get it,” they could put themselves on the same plane as a “great” writer whose previous book had enthralled millions.

     Robert A. Heinlein once wrote that:

     A "critic" is a person who creates nothing and thereby feels qualified to judge the work of creative people. There is logic in this; he is unbiased — he hates all creative people equally. [From Time Enough For Love]

     The corrosive envy the critic feels toward the genuinely creative man is expressed in many ways, but this is the most destructive of them: putting a piece of junk assembled from miscellaneous rusted auto parts next to Michelangelo’s Pieta and deeming them equally worthy of reverence and awe. Yet there is no other way in which the critic can elevate himself to a plane above us grubby groundlings. It’s his sole vehicle for rising above us who read in hope of a good story well told, that illuminates some essential element of the immutable realities of human life under the veil of time.

     Much the same can be said about publishers and publishers' editors.


     At this point my Gentle Readers are probably asking themselves “what lit Porretto’s boiler this morning?” In candor, ignition partook of several sources, only one of which deserves independent mention.

     In his tirade about “Why Contemporary Science Fiction and Fantasy is Godawful,” Jeffro makes a couple of good points and a couple that are less well aimed. But his conclusion seems to me to be inadequate:

     Normal people are exasperated when they are confronted by this sort of thing, no different from how fans of the recent superhero movies react when told that you can’t get an Iron Man comic book right now starring insanely popular Tony Stark. Oh, it comes out in fits and starts. There’s all kinds of rationalizations that people will leap to before they finally give them up. But it all comes down to this: something happened to cause the science fiction and fantasy canon to just plain evaporate. A whole bunch of somethings, maybe. And there’s just no good justification for it.

     “Something happened” -- ? Something that caused the F&SF “canon” to “just plain evaporate” -- ? All that preceding verbiage, much of it in a tone of exasperation even I, the Curmudgeon Emeritus to the World Wide Web, would be hard pressed to equal, concludes with this?

     I suppose one can compose a rant specifically for the purpose of raising a question. I suppose for that purpose the question “What happened to F&SF?” is as good as any. But given all the developments in those genres these past thirty years, including the incredible explosion of independently-published works made possible by print-on-demand and the eBook, answers should be available for discussion, at least. Indeed, answers have been proposed from several points of the compass.

     For those interested in the subject, my preferred answer is the conventional publishing world anathematized the Golden Age works filled with imagination, adventure, heroism, and drama, and embraced bloodless, pointless, anti-how real people really behave “message fiction.” Others are free to differ. My point, though, is not that my answer is unquestionably the correct one. Of course I think that; why else would I have written it? My point is that Jeffro’s question has already been answered many times. Our mission (should we choose to accept it) is to sort through the proposed answers, to compare them to the available evidence, and to propose still others not yet considered, not to emit further veh ist mir laments about how what we older aficionadi loved has vanished from the bookstore shelves.

     Leave the laments to the critics who can’t imagine why the great majority of us who thrilled to Catch-22 consider Something Happened a pile of snurgsh. Better yet, write something filled with imagination, adventure, heroism, and drama. That’ll learn ‘em.

     (What’s that? You don’t know what snurgsh is? Use your imagination. Or read Larry Niven, the grandmaster of “hard” science fiction and the acknowledged expert at turning typos into alien vocabularies.)

Glenn "Ready. Fire. Aim." Beck.

Glenn Beck was just inveighing against the Russians implying that they are the threat to world peace now. He criticizes them for vetoing a proposed U.N. Security Council resolution to investigate the supposed chemical incident in Douma on April 7 and admonishes them to disassociate themselves from a regime that uses gas on its own citizens.

Mr. Beck does many good things but on the Russia issue he's all about selling their supposedly hostile objectives and nefarious activities. Today on The Blaze TV he and sidekick Stu exhibit not the least skepticism on the subject of the "attack" and seem to be completely unaware of the astounding rush to judgment so painfully evident in the thinking of Washington elites. Neither those elites nor Beck trouble themselves with any objective data collection and analysis but rush straight to the most ludicrous, evidence-free conclusion, that of Assad's lunatic idea to use gas on civilians when he's on the cusp of total victory in the Damascus area and killing civilians serves no tactical purpose whatsoever.

That this is dishonest and reckless does not occur to Beck who assures himself that we can't not "do something" and that future "rogue regimes" need to know that their ability to use similar methods will not be tolerated.

To Beck, the U.N. is a waste of time in this situation and he obviously, like Nikki Haley, believes that the U.S. can ignore the U.N. Charter if matters in the Security Council are not resolved to our satisfaction. The opposite is in fact true. Namely, that the U.N. Charter is meant precisely to deal with security matters of critical importance where it is precisely (1) that in the Security Council situation that the great powers will be able to exercise a veto as per plan and (2) no military force may be used except in the case of self defense (which this obviously is not) or authorization from the Security Council.

Beck spared us any actual tears but chose to serve up a ton of reckless nonsense and pure Beckian sanctimony ("more in sorrow than in anger, I reluctantly must say . . . ).

There is one and only one question to be asked at this point and that is "What, if anything, happened?" The world is not served by American elites and loudmouths rushing to attack a sovereign state yet again with no @#$% period of investigation or deliberation. The U.S. and Britain are in the grip of some kind of obsession to decide complex matters overnight when a delay of 180 days would make no difference in the least to proper resolution.

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

Assorted

     I haven’t done one of these in a while. Feels like it’s time.


     The always excellent Thales (previously known as Dystopic (previously known as Wonko the Sane (previously known as “the artist previously known as...))) has produced a creditable tirade that punctures feminists’ ranting about “patriarchy.” My favorite bit:

     [T]he phenomenon of catering to female delusions is far greater than merely enabling that particular movement. We are supposed to see the raised pink fists, the pussy hats, the women dressing up as giant vaginas as somehow changing the world by their mere presence. All the millions of marching Starbucks drinkers; all the hopey-changey bologna spouted by the feminists achieves nothing, but we are supposed to believe otherwise. As if a woman chanting “I am fierce” somehow makes it true. Various vaguely female trolls say “this pussy grabs back” as if Donald Trump has some kind of interest in having sex with them (itself a delusion). None of this means anything in the great political struggles of our age, but the media ardently pretends otherwise.

     A more accurate headline might be “a million cat ladies descend on Washington to complain about something they can’t do shit about.”

     Indeed. But then, claiming to be a “victim” of “oppression” and screaming absurd demands is the sociopolitical currency of the moment, and feminists are anything but innovators.

     A large part of feminists' notions about “patriarchy” is in reality the consequence of millennia of implicit bargaining between men and women: “Women, if you give us men this, we men will give you that. Sold? Sold!” That allows us to reframe the majority of feminist demands as “We want what we want and we refuse to pay for it!” This illuminates the innate unattractiveness of feminists and feminism better than many other encapsulations.

     As one of Robert A. Heinlein’s trademarked older-and-wiser characters once said, “Most women are damn fools and children.” It was true in 1951 and it remains true today; only a few minor characteristics of female tantrums have changed.


     In the wake of the Atlantic’s firing of only-just-hired Kevin Williamson upon the discovery that he is (gasp!) an actual conservative, the mighty Ace of Spades has spotlighted the major media’s exploitation of weak-water conservatives’ yearning to be heard:

     I have long been saddened by the self-hatred of the conservative movement, a movement which frequently views acceptance by their enemies as the ultimate accolade, and a Token Hiring by a leftist magazine as the crowning achievement of their careers.

     What is it among the allegedly individualist conservatives that makes them so smitten with leftist collectives? What is about allegedly can-do, future-friendly conservatives that makes them so giddy about opportunities in the already-built-by-other-hands legacy media and so disdainful of DIY garage-band success stories like the Federalist?

     A friend of mine noted that the left hates The Federalist so much precisely because they don't see any way to get them fired or compel them to play nice by threatening to no longer invite them on to CNN -- most of them have internalized that that ship has sailed, so no veiled threat from a CNN stooge that "you're burning bridges" can bring them to heel.

     And that's probably why allies of Fusion GPS are pushing their stupid "Who funds The Federalist?" hashtag campaign, suggesting -- absurdly -- that THE RUSSIANS are funding it.

     Some conservatives are sincere individualists who wouldn’t abandon their true intellectual homes even under torture. Others are as avid for large-scale audiences, adulation, and acceptance as any would-be starlet, and as willing to strip naked to get them. The former sort tend toward the classical-liberal / constitutionalist libertarian position. The latter will say and do whatever they think might get them a few more clicks. It’s important to know the one from the other.

     I’ve already written about the Williamson matter. The moral remains what it was: Conservatives and libertarians must build our own platforms, and we must remain loyal to them. There is no other way to break the Left’s stranglehold on the media.


     The Robert Mueller-ordered raid on the office of Michael Cohen, for a long time Donald Trump’s personal lawyer, has raised more than a few eyebrows. Wolf Howling has captured the scandalous core of it:

     This morning, the DOJ, based on allegations passed on by Bob Mueller, executed a warrant on Trump’s personal attorney, Michael Cohen, sweeping up a host of material covered by attorney client privilege. Indications are that the information related to Stormy Daniels, something completely unrelated to a single thing about Trump-Russian collusion. This from the same bastards who have yet – two years after the fact – to execute a warrant to verify that the single most basic fact of the collusion story, that the DNC server was hacked by the Russians. This from the same bastards that allowed Hillary to maintain her private server for months after it became known that she had run all State Dept. business through that server, all but certainly exposing thousands of confidential, secret and top secret documents and items of information in violation of our state secrets laws. During that time, Hillary and her attorney wiped that server clean. And now these bastards, seemingly having found nothing on which to charge Trump relating to Russian collusion, and having given Hillary and her team a pass on crystal clear felonies, go after Trump and/or his personal attorney on a technical violation of election law? These worthless bastards are out of control.

     They’ve been out of control for quite some time. Indeed, they were encouraged to place themselves above the law by the Obama Administration, which regarded the Department of Justice as an instrument with which to torment the enemies of the Democrats.

     Eric Holder and Loretta Lynch weren’t given the Attorney-General post in recognition of their exemplary service to the nation. They were hatchet men for Barack Hussein Obama from the first moment of their respective appointments. In recognition thereof, they put their fullest efforts toward politicizing the Justice Department and using its manifold capabilities to undermine anyone deemed an opponent to Obama’s extra-Constitutional rule.

     Throughout the Obama Administration, the DoJ turned a blind eye to the outrages of its friends and allies while mercilessly scrutinizing and when possible prosecuting its adversaries. The finishing stroke was Loretta Lynch’s collaboration with the Clinton Administration at putting Hillary Clinton above the law, despite her demonstrated felonious behavior in the handling of classified material. After that it could no longer be denied that the Department of Justice had been made into yet another political action committee for the Democrat Party, but with guns, subpoenas, and indictment powers.

     Wolf Howling writes that “The single biggest mistake [Trump] has made to date has been to allow the utterly lawless prior administration and the related deep state to skate on all of their illegal actions.” I concur – and if Mueller isn’t hauled up by the short hairs and keelhauled for this outrageous violation of Trump’s attorney-client privilege – over a matter neither illegal nor in any way connected with the “Russian collusion” investigation! — the Trump Administration will have signaled that it has no will to defend itself.


     That’s all for today, Gentle Reader. The rest of the day goes to fiction. I hope to return tomorrow.

Underpants gnomes’ take on Douma chlorine incident.

The South Park underpants gnomes are famous for their business plan on how to make money from stealing underwear:

This approach has taken root in geostrategeristical circles in assigning blame to various actors for using chemical weapons on their own citizens when to do so makes no sense whatsoever given

  • strategic realities where victory on the battlefield by conventional methods is mere days if not hours away and
  • a host of lying, posturing, scumbag foreign governments are just itching to find an excuse to attack said actors, one of which governments is led by a man with the foreign policy understanding and attention span of a gnat.

I now give you the convincing and compelling approach of Western national leaders, assorted former operatives, elected whores, commentators, “analysts,” military establishments, advisers, courtiers, intelligence establishments, and the MSM:

  1. Chemical incident in Douma, Syria on April 7, 2018 reported by headchoppers and jihadi filth.
  2. ?
  3. Bashar al-Assad has used chemical weapons against innocent Syrian women and children AGAIN and now he must PAY.

Monday, April 9, 2018

Good News in Europe

The party that Soros opposed won. Despite his aggressive campaign, and large buckets of cash, the Hungarian people beat his favored candidate.

Life is good.

Despite the technology headaches (the substitute teacher jobs app was NOT working most of the day), my car still having trouble starting (despite being put on the charger, and the alternator apparently working correctly), and loads of other stupid stuff going wrong, it is, indeed, good.

The Next Battlefield - Water

I stumbled upon a link to a site that discusses the shrinkage of Iran's water, the politics involved, and the process of a once-rich farming region turned into desert.

Water scarcity has been an interest of mine for a long time. As a science teacher, I was always coming across articles related to chemistry/biology/physics that I incorporated into my lesson plans. I generally used those articles as a way of bringing literacy activities into my classes (a strong passion for the admin types, who LOVED to see me using that approach).

Truthfully, my kids generally loved those readings - they were high interest, socially conscious, and easy enough to read, with some help on the specialized vocabulary. I used these to help them gain fluency with reading science-related content, as well as to provide supplementary work for those looking for a greater challenge.

Also made a great lesson for those days I needed a sub - no lab equipment or calculators needed.


Conquest By Insisting

     There are days it’s all just too terribly clear. Consider this recent piece from Glenn Reynolds. It’s short; please read it all. But I will quote the part that got my engine turning over:

     It’s like stupid and crazy people have too much power to set agendas nowadays.

     As our beloved Instapundit himself might say: Heh. Indeed.


     Most people are at least somewhat confrontation-averse. Confrontation is unpleasant; if there’s a less-unpleasant alternative that doesn’t cost a lot, we’re likely to take it. But recently, it would appear that that tendency has gotten out of control. It seems that to far too many Americans, confrontation is now the greatest of all evils; they’re willing to sacrifice anything and everything rather than to be forced into it.

     The attitude expressed by their practice of preemptive surrender is that “There’s nothing worth fighting over.” Nothing, capital N. Even Gahan Wilson had some trouble with that one:

     Frederik Pohl and Cyril M. Kornbluth had a bit of fun with that one in their novel Wolfbane:

     Some men think by poking problems apart; some think by laying facts side by side to compare. Tropile’s thinking was neither of these, but a species of judo. He conceded to his opponent such things as Strength, Armor, Resource. He didn’t need these things for himself; to every contest, the opponent brought enough of them to satisfy two....
     He walked to the door and shouted to Citizen Harmane: “Keeper! I must see my wife! Have her brought to me!”
     It was impossible for the Keeper to refuse. He called gently: “I will invite the Citizeness,” and toddled away....
     Tropile turned to Citizen Boyne. “Citizen,” he said persuasively, “since your death poem is ready and mine is not, will you be gracious enough to go first when they—when they come?”
     Citizen Boyne looked temperately at his cellmate and made the Quirked Smile.
     “You see?” he said. “Wolf.”
     And that was true. But what was also true was that Boyne couldn’t and didn’t refuse.

     Now watch as Tropile engineers an escape from his death-row cell, simply by making demands of his gaoler:

     Tropile said harshly: “I wish to see the new sun from the street....”
     The Keeper stammeringly said: “May I—may I let you see the new sun from the corridor?...” The keeper had never since babyhood given a flat no to anybody about anything. No Citizen had. A flat no led to anger, strong words—perhaps even hurt feelings. The only flat no conceivable was the enormous flat no of an amok....
     “That will do for a start,” Tropile snarled. “Open, man, open! Don’t make me wait!”
     the Keeper reeled and unlatched the door to the corridor.
     “Now the street!”
     “I can’t!” burst in an anguished cry from the Keeper. He buried his face in his hands and began to sob, hopelessly incapacitated....Whimperingly, the Keeper flung the keys at Tropile and tottered brokenly away.

     Imagine engineering a jailbreak merely by making demands of a gaoler unable to refuse you! That’s only the most absurd consequence of an avoid-confrontation-at-all-costs mentality.


     The irrational, the crazed, and the self-deifiers are getting away with everything short of murder — and don’t expect the “everything short of” part to remain as it is, friends — because the persons at the levers of society’s power have become too confrontation-averse to refuse them anything. It’s in the nature of things, as I’ve written on other occasions, that success breeds emulation – that others watching this process will draw the lesson and decide to “get on the gravy train” while it’s still running and there’s room to board.

     We are witnessing the open, unresisted conquest of all our institutions and customs by madmen, employing the unprecedented tactic of insisting — by a horde capable of doing nothing else. Some angry group of useless bloody loonies mounts a “protest,” and an important component of American life, perhaps an individual right, gives way and is demolished. Someone engages an ethics-challenged lawyer to threaten a lawsuit on some absurd pretext, and a major corporation immediately bends the knee to lunacy. Someone feels “offended,” or “unsafe,” or “discriminated against,” and innumerable others are immediately compelled to alter their longstanding practices and preferences and conform.

     Yes, they’re mad. Completely bonkers. Off the wall. Froot Loop City. But are we the putatively sane any less mad for having accommodated them?

     Think about it.

Best article title for April.

Douma Is Arabic for 'Reichstag Fire'
Douma being the site of the alleged chemical weapon attack by the Syrian government on its civilian population.

Notes
[1] Publius Tacitus, Russia Insider, 4/9/18.

Tunnels under E. Ghouta in Syria.

Vanessa Beeley elsewhere indicates the tunnels were built with the labor of jihadi captives and heavy equipment provided by the French.

Beeley's interview is presented along with one Syrian woman's horrific report of children being kidnapped and having their organs removed. That's raw intelligence and unlikely to be picked up and explored by any Western MSM.

Believable, without further investigation, however, is Beeley's statement that these tunnels were built with slave labor. Clearly the walls of the tunnels are made by heavy equipment and not by hand so the only question is who provided the equipment and the funding? Exactly who played what role is not clear but I have not doubt that it will eventually be shown what foreign powers have been responsible for the killing and destruction in Syria.

Poor Syria has been subjected to a large-scale attack by foreign jihadi infantry and the existence of these tunnels is proof that the jihadis have substantial outside backing.

Haley's Comment.

Nikki Haley has erupted in another fiery Russophobic rant, warning that Russia will “never be America’s friend.” Moscow can try to behave “like a regular country,” but the US will “slap them when we need to,” Haley said.[1]
This is a woman who should be talking about recipes on the Food Channel not playing “Powerful Woman” at the U.N.

Notes
[1] "‘Russia Will Never Be Our Friend, We’ll Slap Them When Needed’ – Waffle House Waitress on the Loose." Russia Insider, 4/6/18 (formatting removed).

Sunday, April 8, 2018

A New IDEA

Rep. Steve King has introduced a bill that would modify IRS regulations to reduce the incentives to hire illegals. It would disallow the ability to use employee expensing for the purposes of reducing tax liability, if the employee were an illegal alien.

I'm not a lawyer, but it looks like it could work - at least for the major corporations.


Faith, Doubt, And What Lies Apart From Them: A Sunday Rumination

     Now Thomas, one of the twelve, who is called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came. The other disciples therefore said to him: We have seen the Lord. But he said to them: Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the place of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.
     And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them. Jesus cometh, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said: Peace be to you. Then he saith to Thomas: Put in thy finger hither, and see my hands; and bring hither thy hand, and put it into my side; and be not faithless, but believing.
     Thomas answered, and said to him: My Lord, and my God.
     Jesus saith to him: Because thou hast seen me, Thomas, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and have believed.      [The Gospel According to John, 20:24-30, Douay-Rheims translation]

     Today is “officially” called Divine Mercy Sunday, but I tend to think of it as “Doubting Thomas’s Sunday.” The story of “Doubting Thomas,” given above, is the heart of the traditional Gospel reading for the day. It makes Thomas, one of the Apostles to whom Jesus gave the Great Commission, sound unusually skeptical. Hardheaded. A man who wants evidence for the propositions he’s expected to accept.

     But one little snippet from the above ought to be appreciated in its full significance:

     The other disciples therefore said to him: We have seen the Lord.

     The other Apostles were in the same boat as Thomas. They had already seen what Thomas demanded to see. He wasn’t doubting Jesus; he was doubting the testimony of the other Apostles. He withheld the investment of his faith until he was presented with the evidence that they had already confronted.

     What could be more reasonable? Remember your C.S.I. maxims: “People lie; evidence doesn’t.” Thomas was no more skeptical than any Jew of classical Judea naturally would have been. Jesus rose from the dead? And you saw Him? The hell you say! When’s He coming to dinner?

     And indeed, Jesus did return to the locked room, once again miraculously entering it without opening the door, and gave Thomas the evidence the others had already received. But for the risen Christ, the Son of God to do that was easily within His powers. He’d already done it once before, hadn’t He? So He did it again, that Thomas might be united in faith with his fellows, and might have faith in his fellows as well.


     We stand two thousand years down the river of time from the events of the Gospels. We have not seen the risen Christ in His glorified body; yet we believe. We have not placed a finger in the nail holes, nor thrust a hand into His side; yet we believe. The great majority of us have witnessed no miracles: i.e., no apparent violations of the laws of Nature in obedience to One who stands above them; yet we believe.

     Why we believe is personal. And of course, why others disbelieve is equally personal. I’ve made that point before. There’s nothing to be done about it. Like Thomas, the skeptic insists on being shown the evidence before he will invest his credulity.

     The evidence is strong that Jesus of Nazareth lived when and where the Gospels said He lived. The evidence is strong that He did all that the Gospels said He did. The evidence is strong that He suffered, died, and rose again to demonstrate to His followers the truth of His New Covenant and His authority to proclaim it. The evidence is strong...but it doesn’t constitute proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

     The legal phrase is “persuasive but not conclusive.” The evidence for something miraculous that no living eye has seen can never be conclusive. It’s in the nature of the mind, and of the universe in which we reside, that there will always be an alternative explanation for any given event, including events one has personally witnessed. The skeptic will always be able to defend his position.

     That doesn’t erase the evidence.

     For me, the convincing factor was this:

     Of course no non-Christian source would fully confirm the Gospels. Anyone who wrote objectively of the miracles, Passion, and Resurrection of Christ, reporting them as observed, well-testified facts, would have to be a Christian. He couldn't do so otherwise. So the lack of non-Christian confirmations means nothing.
     It could all be true. It can't be disproved. All it requires is that I allow that there might be a God -- a Being above and apart from temporal reality, to which temporal reality is subject. There could be. That can't be disproved either.
     Men went to horrible deaths rather than renounce it. Many men.

     But of course, the skeptic is free to dismiss that, as well. All he has to do is disbelieve two millennia of recorded history about the martyrdoms of Christian saints, especially the martyrdoms of the Apostles. As Christians have no better evidence to offer for their faith than that, we must agree to disagree.

     However, the evidence is not conclusive, but it is strong. Therefore the skeptic owes us the assumption that we are personally sincere about having accepted what it implies. To mock and deride believers, or to accuse us of hypocrisy, simply because we have accepted what the skeptics have not is, as our British cousins would say, not quite cricket. That having been said, there are a lot of skeptics doing exactly that.

     Jesus forgave Thomas for doubting the testimony of the other Apostles. Jesus can forgive contemporary skeptics, too. A skeptic who lives a good life and harms no innocent will enjoy the same reward as any believer who conforms to the Commandments. Yes, “No man comes to the Father except through Me,” but then, we do not know where He is...or where He is not.

     May God bless and keep you all!

Saturday, April 7, 2018

“A Scoop Of What?”

     A couple of years ago, James Delingpole wrote an exceptional piece that expressed the tactical importance of standing on principle:

     In the Spectator recently, my old friend Toby Young described a dilemma which all those of us right-wing persuasion must face up to in the end: should you soften your position in order to find some common ground with people whose stupid political ideology you loathe and despise? Or should you stay true to your principles and risk being marginalised as, at best, unreasonable and, at worst, as a fruitcake, a crank, a dangerous extremist?

     Young was talking in particular about his battles with the hard-left educationalists who were trying to sabotage free schools like the one he helped set up in West London. Some parents urged him to take a more emollient line with his attackers. And for a moment Young was tempted:

     “Shouldn’t I offer to meet with the school’s opponents, such as the shop steward of the Ealing branch of the NUT [National Union of Teachers], and see if there were any concessions we could make that might secure their support?”

     If you’re cursed with a memory like mine, and if the title of this piece has piqued it, you might remember that article. If not, please read (or reread) it. It was unusually pungent and clear-sighted, especially for Delingpole. I’ll wait here until you’ve finished.

     What, so soon? My, my. Well, I’m sure any Gentle Reader of Liberty’s Torch would get the idea swiftly, so I’m not all that surprised. I’ve been in the habit of expressing the core idea this way:

If you pour a cup of wine into a barrel of sewage, it remains a barrel of sewage.
If you pour a cup of sewage into a barrel of wine, it becomes a barrel of sewage.

     Filth can contaminate purity. Purity cannot contaminate filth.

     Take a moment to consider that before we proceed.


     It’s in the nature of things that people seek to do better tomorrow than today. They look for opportunities to “move up.” This is especially the case when “moving up” involves in increase in one’s income and prestige, or an improvement in the conditions that conduce to high income and high prestige. For a writer, the critical consideration is audience: “Who is reading me, how numerous are they, and how much influence do they have on others who might be persuaded to read me as well?”

     So when writer X, currently laboring for peanuts at periodical publication Y, receives a solicitation from richer and more prestigious periodical publication Z, he’s likely to be strongly tempted. Few writers for periodicals make a lot of money. Thus, they tend to be easily seduced by such an offer. This is especially the case among op-ed writers for “think” magazines. Apparently something like that happened to Kevin Williamson, formerly of National Review Online and now formerly of The Atlantic.

     In case you don’t already know, the gig didn’t last. Williamson’s past “caught up with him,” in particular his rather strident views about abortion and the legal penalties he’d like to see visited upon unhappy mothers-to-be who have recourse to it. A number of his (former) colleagues at NRO and other conservative “think” periodicals are agog over his summary firing by The Atlantic.

     As is so often the case, Ace has the best take on it. The whole thing is worth your time, but here’s my favorite bit:

     Sacred Principles are, definitionally, Sacred.

     Inviolable.

     But now comes another company, The Atlantic, and it fires one of their Cocktail Circuit buddies, and suddenly not only is it okay to furiously wail about a corporate decision to squelch someone's free speech, but it is in fact now a Sacred Principle that we do so.

     Huh? How did that happen?

     How did pressuring and criticizing a corporation for its cavalier attitude towards the spirit of free speech (and yes, idiots, i know the First Amendment only applies to government action, which is why I'm referring to free speech generally) go from "thuggish" to "absolutely necessary"?

     Was it just that a buddy of the Corporate Cons got hit by leftist pressure tactics and corporate cowardice this time?

     Is that it all it takes to render a Sacred Principle non-operational? One of your Twitter Palz gets dinged?

     Or did you just get alarmed that rather than a company firing some Deplorable -- someone you don't know and wouldn't shake hands with if you could avoid doing so -- now you and your class was potentially at risk from corporations acting as catspaws for the left?

     Is that all it takes to rubbish your Sacred Principles?

     Are they really Sacred, then?

     That’s the meat of the matter, as far as the protests from the Right go. But I wouldn’t have decided to address this tempest in a teapot were it not for a much larger question, one that bears upon the Right’s approach to the institutions from which its ideological adversaries launch their salvoes.

     Purity cannot contaminate filth.


     There are several well-known media outlets that employ a great many left-liberal / “progressive” / social-fascist op-ed writers and one lonely kinda-sorta “conservative.” Perhaps the best known is the New York Times, which has followed that pattern since 1946, when Henry Hazlitt retired as its economics columnist. It is noteworthy that those token “conservatives” trend further to the left than any op-ed writer for a predominantly conservative outlet. Among their other signal characteristics, they frequently deride (usually gently) their more conservative colleagues and those colleagues’ views.

     It’s possible that leaning leftward and twitting their rightward colleagues are conditions of employment. At any rate, it wouldn’t surprise me. Why would a hard-left staff like that of the Times tolerate an unabashed, strongly principled conservative or libertarian among its ranks? He might corrupt the others! At best, he’d “lower the tone” in the op-ed boiler room.

     So when a leftist rag like The Atlantic solicits the interest of a Kevin Williamson, it’s more than likely that it will place limits on what he may say and how he may say it as a condition of employment. And indeed, Williamson’s first efforts for that publication were quite a distance from what his NRO audience would expect from him. Not that that was enough to save his gig when his previously emitted opinions about the criminality of abortion were discovered.

     Seriously, could anyone familiar with The Atlantic’s op-ed positions, tone, and readership have reasonably expected anything else? Could Williamson have expected anything else? Attempts by the Right to counter-infiltrate Leftist institutions always work out the same way: the infiltrator is hauled up and hanged with a maximum of fanfare. Kevin Williamson was no exception, nor should he have expected to be one.

     Leftist institutions such as The Atlantic are the ideological supreme commands of the enemy. They respect only power. They formulate and emit the General Orders to which the second and third-tier activists of the Left subsequently conform. When they seduce a conservative into their ranks, it’s with the intention of corrupting him, not debating or learning from him. We’ve known that for a long time. Since before the Journolist scandal, at any rate.

     Purity cannot contaminate filth.


     Not long ago, I wrote that thoroughly Left-corrupted institutions such as the government-run schools must be destroyed. They cannot be “saved;” their inherent dynamics are too powerful to reverse. I was serious then and I still am today. The Williamson / Atlantic foofaurauw provides a nice example.

     But this is equally a lesson for conservatives who, charmed by a solicitation from such an institution, hope to counter-infiltrate it and “turn it around.” You’re cruisin’ for a bruisin’, friends. You’ll come away scarred, embittered, and much the worse for wear. Those who run such a snake pit are far more likely to corrupt you.

     Purity cannot contaminate filth.

Cognitive dissonance.

Gen. McMaster’s speech to the Atlantic Council on April 6, 2018 had this stark point on respect for sovereignty in the international order:
As President Trump said earlier today, the United States has never ceased to recognize the independence of the Baltic republics. In 1940, when the Soviet Union invaded your nations, U.S. Acting Secretary of State Sumner Welles issued the famous Welles Declaration. In that declaration, Welles confidently wrote that the American people opposed any form of intervention on the part of one state, however powerful, in the domestic concerns of any other sovereign state, however weak. In the absence of respect for sovereignty, Welles continued, the basis of modern civilization itself cannot be preserved.[1]
How the general thinks this might apply to our war against Syria is an interesting question. That he doesn’t think it does is clear, so we have cognitive dissonance. Holy sovereignty in the Baltics and “if we feel like it” in Syria. And it really is "if we feel like it" in Syria.

Gen. McMaster’s speech is just strange and the problems with it extend beyond cognitive dissonance. To speak of “Russia’s increased aggression around the world” as he does is disturbing in view of this bit of perspective provided by Andrew Bacevich.

The rest of McMaster’s speech is a caricature of serious thinking about international relations. What isn’t tendentious and distorted is fake hysteria about activities that are anything but the sole province of (((“The Kremlin”))).[2] To be quite frank, the existence of “sustained [Russian] campaigns to undermine our confidence in ourselves” is not going to make me lose any sleep at night. One hour of listening to some of the leftist liars, dissemblers, and subversives that Tucker Carlson interviews tells me who the real people “undermining our confidence in ourselves” are. Yet McMaster thinks Russians are the major threat on that score. Really! But for the Russians we’d have all kinds of confidence in ourselves.

This was thinking operating at the highest levels of our national security establishment. That McMaster is now history is an unalloyed blessing. John Bolton is said to be an uber-hawk but I think he’s a man who first and foremost resorts to facts, history, and logic. When he has appeared on Fox he invariably sounded rational and informed. I think we just made a step up. Just how big a step can be learned from reading the whole McMaster speech. With luck, Bolton is not coming with an agenda for war with Iran and endless war in Syria. Given that we live in an America that is an unconstitutional joke, those, and worse, are distinct possibilities, John Bolton or no.

Notes
[1] "In Parting Speech, McMaster Warns 'We Have Failed To Impose Sufficient Costs On Russia.'" By Tyler Durden, ZeroHedge, 4/4/18 (emphasis added).
[2] Sound effect only.

Friday, April 6, 2018

Tippy-Toeing Around Progressive Women's FEELS

Another scalp for their collection.

Some comments on the firing.

I think it's a shame that The Atlantic didn't stand up to the chorus of bullying against Williamson. I don't always agree with him, but he sure is a fine writer.

The thing Williamson apparently didn't get is - The World of the Left doesn't want interesting, provocative dissent. They want Groupthink - a nodding echo chamber self-congratulating that they are on the "right side of history".

The Minefield That Is Affirmative Action

It's hard to imagine that the Progressive Forces that permeate the Elite Institutions can get out of the trap that they put themselves into.

They found that Minority students were not being accepted at their Lily White (well, except for all those Asians) schools. In a panic that they might seem to be what they were, they decided to implement a complicated 'holistic' admissions process that discounted the pricey sorting mechanisms that they made students pay for (ACT and SAT), and instead add more hoops to jump through:
  • Personal struggle essay - an easy-to-fake, easy-to-purchase written tear-jerker about their struggle, which might be how they Confronted the Power (social activists of the Progressive variety), Came to Realize their White Privilege (often, on expensive trips to 3rd World countries with multiple photo ops with the newfound not-White 'friends'), or Overcame the Oppressive Male Supremacy (i.e., started eating without vomiting). If Black, this is a Walk in the Park (without the mugging) that gives the admission people an excuse to admit you, despite low test scores and inflated grades from an grade factory.
Another minefield is the IQ-Race research. In my experience, IQ is pretty well distributed across races & ethnic groups. Percentages may vary, but - you can't predict the IQ based on racial/ethnic grouping. But, at this time, to even imply that there is variation in IQ that is related to heredity is guaranteed to cause the person doing so to suffer career suicide.

That's ridiculous, and contradicts the often observed and noncontroversial connection between parental IQ and that of their offspring. Can dullards spring from smart people? Sure. But, looking at probabilities, the smart betting is on a close relationship between IQ of parent and IQ of child.

Now, men - and women - have been known to mate in ways that trip up this relationship. If one parent is really smart, but the other is average (or below), it's just as likely that the child will display the mediocre intellectual capacity as the outstanding potential. Hence, the common situation of a prominent businessman who marries the proverbial 'dumb blonde'. That offspring may well be a disappointment, in terms of native smarts.

This connection is often demonstrated, and does not cause a problem if commented on.

Except in the case of race. If a researcher notes the differences between populations by race, the Progressive Dogs are unleashed. As in this case, where students and their allies attacked a speaker - and a faculty member - over a book written years ago - The Bell Curve.