Thursday, November 1, 2018

Non-Ambitions

     I recently made a resolution of sorts – hey, we Type As can’t allow ourselves to be bound by the calendar! — to introduce more lighthearted, utterly non-political material here at Liberty’s Torch. The dump was getting far too monochromatically serious, and for most of us, the challenges of daily life are serious enough. But of course, once one has made such a resolution, it’s important to follow through. And that has proved a little more difficult than I thought it would.

     However, just this morning, the C.S.O. and I got onto the subject of career paths: more specifically, career paths no young person would ever aspire to follow. And therein lay a rich vein indeed.

     Most of us Baby Boomers set out on our lives intending, or at least hoping, to become something with some status, some actual social heft. Our parents encouraged us to “think big:” to aspire to high station, great wealth, lots of groupies. But the supply of open positions for captains of industry, long-ball hitters, and philosopher-kings has never equaled the demand for those jobs. (Jean-Baptiste Say, call your office. Urgent! Urgent!) In consequence, most of us have had to settle for somewhat less exalted stations.

     And let it be frankly said: there are some jobs one only takes when nothing better is available. Yet those jobs must be done...and they are. That speaks to an ineradicable practicality, one in which even a soul greatly disappointed by life’s vermiculations can take pride as he cashes his paycheck.

     Still, can you imagine a young boy or girl completing the sentence “When I grow up, I want to be” with any of the following?

  • A shepherd.
  • A garbageman.
  • A prison guard.
  • A street cleaner.
  • A sewer worker.
  • A process server.
  • A bail bondsman.
  • A window washer.
  • A guy who sells beer at baseball games.
  • A guy who installs the big flapping posters that go on roadside billboards.

     Would you care to extend that list, Gentle Reader?

Quickies: “Radical”

     Much has been written about the corruption of language for political purposes. Start with George Orwell, who certainly knows the subject. Real-world examples abound, especially today. Just now, one in particular stands out:

     GQ columnist Julia Ioffe said Monday on CNN that President Trump has "radicalized" many more people than ISIS ever did. Republican commentator David Urban took offense and demanded that CNN host Jake Tapper condemn what Ioffe said.

     "I think this president, one of the things that he really launched his presidential run on is talking about Islamic radicalization. And this president has radicalized so many more people than ISIS ever did," Ioffe said during a CNN panel discussion on the synagogue massacre.

     The colloquial meaning of radical in describing a political position is roughly: “This position is unacceptably far from the norm.” (See here.) “The norm,” of course, refers to “what we’re accustomed to.” However, the word carries a connotation of violence: a radical — note the use of the word as a noun that refers to an individual – is someone who’s willing to use extreme measures to get the political results he wants.

     The legacy media have taken to describing President Trump’s positions on trade, the borders, religious and civil liberties, and so on as radical. But those positions are:

  • Advanced non-violently;
  • Traditional for America;
  • Highly popular.

     But according to Julia Ioffe, the president has supposedly “radicalized” us who support him. What can this mean?

     Which side of the contemporary political face-off has been willing to use extreme measures to get what it wants? Which side has used violence and intimidation to suppress the other’s public events, rallies, and presentations? And which side has a growing wing – including the supporters of the presidential contender who came in second in its nominating contest – that explicitly calls for the replacement of the still-somewhat-free American economy with socialism?

     When the meanings of the words we use are corrupted, communication becomes impossible. When communication is impossible, so is peaceful discourse.

     The Left has gone all in. Alea iacta est. They have crossed America’s political Rubicon in both word and deed. The final reckoning can’t be far off.

     Be ready.

For Those Who Still Think “They Don’t Really Mean It”

     Take 29 seconds out of your undoubtedly crowded schedule for this:

     Google Ads blocked Mrs. Blackburn from using that video as a campaign ad.

     It’s war, folks.

Wednesday, October 31, 2018

Snort Time

     (A new series for Liberty’s Torch? Perhaps.)

     If you’re “of a certain age,” you might remember Francis Ford Coppola’s early triumph The Godfather. This towering movie and its equally impressive sequel both won the Oscar for Best Picture, and deservedly so. Marlon Brando’s performance as Vito Corleone was among the best of his career. Al Pacino’s portrayal of Vito’s son Michael was his launching pad to stardom. Many who had thrilled to Mario Puzo’s novel of the Corleone family and its conflicts had a hard time sincerely saying “I liked the book better.”

     The Godfather offers many striking moments. But for me, the snippet I cherish most and will remember longest is this one:

     I, too, like to drink wine more than I used to...and here at the Fortress of Crankitude, there’s a special moment reserved for the day’s first glass of wine: 3:00 PM Eastern time. We call it Snort Time.

     Snort Time takes precedence over anything else that might be going on. I could be in the middle of a Nobel Prize In Literature-winning sentence. The C.S.O. could be balancing the Vatican’s own books. All that will be set aside for that first glass of “the fruit of the vine and work of human hands.” (The dogs and cats don’t get a vote, though they do get Greenies and catnip.)

     In recent years, owing to our discovery of a number of absolutely smashing New York State wineries, Snort Time is often a time of discovery as well as of bibulous pleasure. We’ve made a point of getting onto those wineries’ PR mailing lists, so that we’ll be notified as soon as some new vintage or new varietal is introduced to the consuming public. We seldom fail to “buy in”...and we seldom fail to enjoy what follows.

     Today arrived a shipment from one such winery: Chateau Lafayette Reneau, in Hector NY: a case of its award-winning 2017 Dry Riesling. Upon the arrival of Snort Time today, I opened the case, uncorked a bottle, and poured glasses for the C.S.O and myself.

     I’m not a technical expert in the assessment or description of a wine, so I’m not going to go into a long discourse about the aroma, the foretaste, the balance of tannins and sugars, or anything else the pseudosophisticates who style themselves “oenophiles” would dribble endlessly on about. (Around here we call them “wine snobs.” We won’t have them in our home.) Instead I’ll simply tell you that this is a delightful beverage: slightly tart and slightly sweet, with a unique and refreshing character. Were I anything but the superbly disciplined, even Spartan epicure all Liberty’s Torch readers know me to be, I’d find it easy to drink far too much of it. (Yes, I’m still struggling to lose the last 15 pounds. Thanks so much for asking.)

     Chateau Lafayette Reneau takes orders over the phone or Web. It ships to all of New York and several other states. Give its 2017 Dry Riesling a try. You won’t regret it.

For Anyone Who Needs A Laugh

     And really, who doesn’t?

     I hope President Trump gets to see that video before someone it embarrasses contrives to have it taken down.

     Needless to say, the various “journalists” and “analysts” featured in that clip were expressing more than a little wishful thinking. But then, that’s what they do, right? That’s the core of their job descriptions, isn’t it? I mean, if it isn’t, what else are they supposed to be doing and why aren’t they doing it?

     I’d been having a down day, but that made me feel a whole lot better.

Yet Another Thing I Hadn't Thought Of

In the last budget reconciliation, Trump tossed The Wall for the money to build up the military - which, given China's periodic moves, and the hordes heading for the Mexican-US border, probably was a shrewd deal. At least, that's what The American Spectator is arguing.

In the best of scenarios, American Forces may have to fire upon the invaders. And, given the Leftist propensity for putting women and children in front of their cowardly hides, it will be a headline-making, endlessly-regurgitated, Democratic/Progressive/Leftist Talking Point for years to come.

I hate to see military doing what our cowardly Congress wouldn't - taking a stand against unregulated immigration.

Blogging may be spotty for the next month - it's National Novel Writing Month again, and I'm set for another run at it. I have several books in progress, and I'm going to just start with one, and keep writing until the month is over. With luck, I'll finish more than one.

Interpretations

     President Trump’s recent suggestion that he might undo the birthright citizenship of “anchor babies” – babies born to mothers illegally in the United States – has evoked a flurry of opposed interpretations of the first paragraph of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution:

     All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. [Emphasis added by FWP]

     The emphasized phrase is the nub of the matter. Is a child brought illegally into this country in his mother’s womb subject to the jurisdiction of the United States? When the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified, the answer was no. Left-leaning outlets claim that the Supreme Court changed this interpretation in U.S. v. Wong Kim Ark, but that’s a tendentious reading of the decision. Ark’s parents were legal residents of the United States when Ark was born. There is no indication anywhere in the majority opinion that it was intended to apply to the children of illegal aliens.

     Conservative commentators have invoked the context in which the Fourteenth Amendment was passed: specifically, that it was aimed at establishing the citizenship of children born to the recently emancipated slaves. This was an egregious matter indeed, for after the 1808 legal changes that forbade the further importation of slaves, slave owners asserted that a child born to a slave was, quite as much as the mother, the slave owner’s rightful property. The federal government did not address the matter, and of course the slave states would not contradict the assertions of the slave owners.

     I’ve searched my reference books for further Supreme Court decisions relevant to the question. I can’t find any.


     There is considerable conflict among the nations about this matter of jurisdiction. The two principal conceptions about it clash dramatically.

     The first of these is the Law of the Soil or jus soli:

     In some countries, jus soli system or birthright citizenship is followed. According to this principle, citizenship of a person is determined by the place where a person was born. Jus soli is the most common means to acquire citizenship of a nation.

     The second conception is the Law of the Blood or jus sanguinis:

     This term when used in the context of citizenship refers to acquisition of citizenship, by the citizenship of the parents. It lays down the principle that the nationality or citizenship of a person is determined by the citizenship of the parents who is a national or citizen of a state.

     In its determinations of citizenship, American law uses both conceptions:

     Pursuant to 8 USCS § 1401, the following persons can acquire citizenship by jus soli:
  1. A person born in the U.S., and subject to its jurisdiction.
  2. A person born in the U.S. as a member of an Indian, Eskimo, Aleutian, or other aboriginal tribe.
  3. A person of unknown parentage found in the U.S. while under the age of five year. The person can remain a U.S. citizen if it is not shown before s/he attains twenty five years that the person was not born in the U.S.
  4. A person born in an outlying possession of the U.S. (i.e., including Puerto Rico, the Panama Canal Zone, Panama, the Virgin Islands and Guam.) of parents, one of whom is a citizen of the U.S. who has been physically present in the United States or one of its outlying possessions for a continuous period of one year at any time prior to the birth of such person.

     The above supposedly applies jus soli criteria. However, note that the children of federal government employees stationed in other nations, no matter how long it might have been since either parent was last in the United States, are granted birthright citizenship through the application of jus sanguinis. (It would be far more difficult to hire people into the Foreign Service were that not the case.)

     American law is moderately (but not completely) averse to the concept of dual citizenship. If American citizen parents were to birth a child in another country while there under the terms of the fourth provision of 8 USCS § 1401 enumerated above, American courts would recognize the child’s American citizenship, but (with certain exceptions) would not recognize his citizenship in that other country. This provision is seldom of importance to ordinary Americans. It tends to arise only in matters of extradition and the voluntary renunciation of American citizenship, both of which are fairly rare.

     Senator Ted Cruz was briefly troubled by dual-citizenship questions during his 2016 presidential campaign. Cruz was born in Calgary, Alberta to Eleanor Wilson, an American citizen who satisfied the fourth provision of 18 USC § 1401; thus, he had birthright American citizenship. However, he also had jus soli Canadian citizenship, owing to his birth in that country. That evoked challenges to his Constitutional qualifications for the office of president, which were ultimately resolved in his favor. (Whether Cruz was qualified under jus soli to become prime minister of Canada has never been addressed.)


     It’s quite a mess, isn’t it? In all probability it won’t be settled any time soon. Should a case be presented to the Supreme Court, the Court might well decline to hear it. If the Court were to hear it, there would be arguments on both sides, owing to the clashing applications of jus soli and jus sanguinis in federal law. Moreover, as birthright citizenship has been conferred on the children of illegal aliens for several decades, a conservative’s approach to the issue would be caught between the strict wording of the Fourteenth Amendment and a desire to preserve stability by ratifying existing practices.

     Americans’ great need is to know what the law really is:

    “Miss Weatherly,” he said with a note of regret, “I’m a lawyer. I was raised by a lawyer. He taught me to think of the law as our most precious possession. One of the questions he repeatedly insisted that I ponder was ‘What is the law?’ Not ‘What would I like the law to be,’ but ‘What is it really, and how do I know that’s what it is?’
    “My profession, sadly, has made a practice of twisting the law to its own ends. There aren’t many lawyers left who really care what the law is, as long as they can get the results they want, when they want them. So they play the angles, and collaborate with judges who think they’re black-robed gods, and generally do whatever they can get away with to get what they want, without a moment’s regard for what it does to the knowability of the law.
    “I care. I want to know what the law is, what it permits, requires, and forbids. I want my clients to know. And the only way to reach that result is to insist that the words of the law have exact meanings, not arbitrary, impermanent interpretations that can be changed by some supercilious cretin who thinks he can prescribe and proscribe for the rest of us.
    “The Constitution is the supreme law, the foundation for all other law. If it doesn’t mean exactly what its text says—the public meanings of the words as ordinary people understand them—then no one can possibly know what it means. But if no one can know what the Constitution means, then no one can know whether any other law conforms to it. At that point, all that matters is the will of whoever’s in power. And that’s an exact definition of tyranny.”

     Before we leave this subject, have a highly relevant observation from Robert Curry:

     The Democrats are done with paying lip service to American ideals they do not believe in just so they can get elected. They have had it with the American people, and they have decided to replace us with people more to their liking, people who will never consider blocking their progressive agenda.

     How can the Democrats be so certain that the floodtide of illegals they’ve chosen for this task can be counted upon to empower them? Could it be because those people are not exactly dedicated to the American idea, either?

     These new people may not be able to mouth the progressive talking points against the Electoral College or argue for “the living Constitution” but, for the progressives, their hearts are in the right place and their votes will obediently follow their benefactors. That’s what counts.

     The stakes are clearly very high. High stakes means that the big guns – legal and opinion-editorial – will be firing. Nor would they cease to fire even after a definitive, 9-0 Supreme Court decision. Two utterly opposed agendas are involved, and the backers of both will go all in.

     Stay tuned.

Tuesday, October 30, 2018

There Comes A Point

     ...at which the agenda of those who despise the United States and envy it for its success becomes too obvious to deny any longer:

     UNHCR spokesman Andrej Mahecic told VOA his agency has alerted countries along the caravan's route that it is likely to include people in real danger.

     "Our position globally is that the individuals who are fleeing persecution and violence need to be given access to territory and protection including refugee status and determination procedure. And, if the people who are fleeing persecution and violence enter Mexico, they need to be provided access to the Mexican asylum system and those entering the United States need to be provided access to the American asylum system," he said.

     Mahecic said the UNHCR is very concerned about the developing humanitarian situation along the migratory route. He said there are kidnapping and security risks in the areas where the caravan may be venturing.

     So! The UN is “very concerned” about the well-being of this caravan, 80% of which consists of military-age males and all of which has been financed by George Soros and other left-wing agencies determined to destroy the borders, and therefore the sovereignty, of the United States. Then what is the UN doing for them? Is the UN providing food, clothing, shelter, resettlement support? And what about Mexico? Does the country through which the caravan has traveled, illegally but essentially without resistance, have any responsibility for it? Why should the United States lift a finger to assist those who would destroy it?

     The UN has no authority in this matter. The United States makes its own laws, including its entry and residence laws – and those laws forbid anyone from entering without a visa, or other than at an official port of entry. These are the requirements of all modern nations...but apparently the U.S., for no clear reason, is forbidden – by the UN! The UN! — to have and enforce such laws.

     President Trump: Get the UN out of the U.S.
     And for the love of God, get the U.S. out of the UN.

Conversations

     This one took place after this morning’s Mass. It is not funny:

FWP: How are you today?
Other Parishioner: Do you get this Hallowe’en stuff?

FWP: Well, it’s based on a custom from medieval Europe—
OP: No, I mean what’s with all the decorations and lights?

FWP: People like special occasions. It’s an excuse to dress up in costumes and have a party.
OP: I think it’s just more commercialism.

FWP: Well, if businessmen see a chance to make a buck—a
OP: I just don’t get it. People treat it like Christmas!

FWP: It had a serious purpose back when—
OP: I don’t want an education!

FWP: You just want to complain?
OP: Yeah.
FWP: Have a nice day.

     I have to tell you, Gentle Reader, that shook me a little. Have you ever experienced anything like that?

The Problem of "Nudging"

For those who didn't read it when it first came out, you might want to check Amazon for Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness. It's not cheap - the Kindle edition is $13.99, and the money goes to Leftists Thaler and Sunstein. However, you can get used real books for $5 or less, and a new book is marked at $8.

However, it's a fascinating look at how Leftists think about people, their motivations, and how the Left might profit from those tendencies. Ya' see, Leftists and Progressives think the Normal people (to use Kurt Schlichter's phrase), are kinda stupid.

OK, they think they're VERY stupid. Easy led. Incapable of thinking for themselves.

So, 'cause these Slow People need the Elites to tell them What to think, How to think, What to say and do, Leftists want to step into that void, and just TELL them what they have to do.

Unfortunately, the Brighter Leftists have, over time, observed that Normals really dislike someone telling them how to live. Why, so much do Normals value their independence, they actually elected someone that the Elites told them was No good, in fact Evil, and a Big Dummy, too.

Honestly, those Stupid Normals just don't get that the Elites know better. Maybe the Elites (or, their delegated mouthpieces, those who WANT to be Elite) need to just shout LOUDER.

Hmmm. That didn't seem to work.

That's where the concept of Nudging comes in. You see, the Elite are going to SUBTLY use tricks to get the Normals to act in ways that the Elite approve of. The Elite are going to rig the selection process SUBTLY, by selecting their preferred choice. Those Dumb-Ass Normals are too Stupid to figure out what's going on, and will just click on the Submit button, thereby selecting the Default Choice.

Which, the Elites maneuvered to be the one that they wanted the Normals to choose.

It's all Real Subtle. Because those Dummy Normals are just too Stupid to see what's happening, and will go along like the Sheeple the Elites wish they were.

Little does the Left realize that the Normals have caught on. All those web forms that have "Yes, I want to receive endless spam emails forever" as the default choice have taught the sharper ones to de-select the default. And, thanks to Facebook, they were able to spread that knowledge to others, making it very hard for spammers.

And the Elite said, Damn.

And, it must be Trump's fault somehow.

Here's a take-down of the concept of Nudging.

A Quick Lexical Bitch

     Today promises to be a frazzler, and anyway, all I have at the moment is this:

  • When we speak of whether a thing is legal, we are discussing its legality.
  • When we say that a man is frugal, we are noting his frugality.
  • And when we describe a condition as normal...

     Hint, hint! It’s not “normalcy.”

     (Warren G. Harding was a better president than many suppose, but as a speaker of English...well, he was a much better president.)

     I’ll probably be back later with something more substantial.

The Changing Nature of Work and Industry

I just found the Claremont Institute Review of Books (CRB). I have no idea why I'd not read anything of theirs before, but I find myself finishing one article, then moving to another, and repeating that process over and over.

This one caught my eye, as it looks at two books about the Victorian Era, and examines just why it was such a pivotal moment in the world's economies and political systems.

From there, I went to this one, about the globalization of industry and work. The analysis of the practice doesn't merely discuss US-3rd World economic interactions, but also points out that the heavy hand of government enters into the equation, putting its own hand on the scale.
Global supply chains are big, closed systems. “The manufacturing revolution,” Baldwin writes, “only happened in developing nations that high-tech firms decided to invite into their production networks.” International corporations are constantly threatening and laying down the law to backward societies. The United States has frequently succumbed to the temptation to marshal corporate power to wreck, through boycotts and blockades, the economies of countries with which it has even minor disagreements. One of the alarming innovations of the Obama years was the way the president’s aides enlisted corporations of various kinds—from Wal-Mart to the NCAA—to discipline recalcitrant American states in the same way. Indiana was going to have gay marriage and North Carolina was going to let conflicted males use ladies’ restrooms, or the administration would rally corporate friends to destroy their economies.
 It's possible that at least some of the discontent of the Privileged Class is because their own well-being is threatened by similar changes. The value of a medical or legal education has been sharply discounted - technology has changed those professions, and they are experiencing the pinch.

The same with education - the freedom brought about by the charter school movement is accelerating, and virtual schools are fast undercutting their wages. The elementary education of the future may not need the high numbers of teachers in a local school, instead using facilitators from nearly every English-speaking nation.

Need I mention that medicine, law, and education are all professions that have been flooded by  women? The future of work does NOT look good for the highly-paid, expensively-educated female members of the Ruling Class. It would seem that many women have spent huge amounts of money to enter professions that will never be able to provide a return on the investment they have made.

Monday, October 29, 2018

It’s War To The Knife Time (UPDATED)

     We’ve already had indications of this. AntiFa committing mass assaults and vandalism and getting away with it. Organized bands of hecklers shutting down talks by conservative and libertarian spokesmen. Public harassment of Republican Congressmen and Trump Administration figures. Major Web service providers Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube censoring anyone to the right of Hillary Clinton. And of course, pustules on the body politic such as Maxine Waters and Eric Holder slyly encouraging all the above and more.

     The latest casualty brings a unique poignancy to the situation:

     If you’re unfamiliar with Gab.com, it’s a Twitter replacement that doesn’t censor. It excludes illegal materials – e.g., child porn, doxxing, threats of violence – but that’s all. Everyone is welcome to say whatever he pleases as long as what he posts doesn’t violate the law. Its founder and chief executive, Andrew Torba, has been stalwart in his defense of absolutely free expression. Yea verily, even for folks whose views nearly everyone would find repugnant.

     But the Left is determined that we in the Right shall not be permitted to express ourselves. So ever since this affront to Leftist domination of social media got seriously rolling, the Left has conducted a campaign to have Gab.com “deplatformed:” i.e., deprived of a Web host, payment processors, and anything else a social medium requires for survival.

     Web hosts and payment processors are apparently pusillanimous enough to be bullied into denying Gab.com their services. As of this morning, Web host provider Joyent has pulled its service out from under Gab’s site. The rationale? Pittsburgh synagogue shooting suspect Robert Bowers had posted there:

     The alleged gunman in Saturday’s mass shooting at a Pittsburgh synagogue spewed anti-Semitic posts on a social media platform where he claimed that Jews were "the enemy of white people," according to a report.

     Two hours before Robert Bowers, 46, allegedly burst into the Tree of Life Synagogue and opened fire during a Shabbat service, he posted on the chat site Gab.com about the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, the New York Times reported.

     People like Louis Farrakhan and Al Sharpton – the lowest and most vicious dregs of humanity – can say anything they like at Facebook and Twitter, including a huge amount of anti-Semitic vitriol...with no consequences. But for Gab.com to allow an anti-Semite to express himself is unacceptable? Gab.com is somehow responsible for what this maniac did in the flesh?

     I hardly need to draw my intelligent Gentle Readers a cartoon.


     The Left has figured it out: If we can keep Americans in the Right from finding and communicating with one another, we can keep them feeling isolated and helpless. They’re doing everything they can to bring that about. The elimination of relatively young, relatively small social-medium Gab.com indicates that the Left has resolved that its silence-and-isolate strategy shall be seamless.

     Does that put you in mind of anything else. Gentle Reader? Perhaps a passage from a famous novel?

     “Yes, I suppose I should explain,” said Dr. Ferris, “that we wish to get your signature early in the day in order to announce the fact on a national news broadcast. Although the gift program has gone through quite smoothly, there are still a few stubborn individualists left, who have failed to sign—small fry, really, whose patents are of no crucial value, but we cannot let them remain unbound; as a matter of principle, you understand. They are, we believe, waiting to follow your lead. You have a great popular following, Mr. Rearden, much greater than you suspected or knew how to use. Therefore, the announcement that you have signed will remove the last hopes of resistance and, by midnight, will bring in the last signatures, thus completing the program on schedule.” [Emphasis added by FWP]

     There are still people who laugh at Rand’s nightmare vision. There are still people who say, to themselves if not to others, “Oh, it will never get as bad as that!” or “Well, freedom of speech is all very well in theory, but you have to draw the line somewhere.”

     Some years ago, Jonah Goldberg, whom I once respected, wrote that everyone is in favor of censorship; we just want to censor different things. Perhaps he’s reconsidered. As I disagreed with him then just as now, I don’t have to.


     Allow me to reprise a snippet from another visionary, the late Dr. Clarence Carson:

     [W]e are told that there is no need to fear the concentration of power in government so long as that power is checked by the electoral process. We are urged to believe that so long as we can express our disagreement in words, we have our full rights to disagree. Now both freedom of speech and the electoral process are important to liberty, but alone they are only the desiccated remains of liberty. However vigorously we may argue against foreign aid, our substance is still drained away in never-to-be-repaid loans. Quite often, there is not even a candidate to vote for who holds views remotely like my own. To vent one's spleen against the graduated income tax may be healthy for the psyche, but one must still yield up his freedom of choice as to how his money will be spent when he pays it to the government. The voice of electors in government is not even proportioned to the tax contribution of individuals; thus, those who contribute more lose rather than gain by the "democratic process." A majority of voters may decide that property cannot be used in such and such ways, but the liberty of the individual is diminished just as much as in that regard as if a dictator had decreed it. Those who believe in the redistribution of wealth should be free to redistribute their own, but they are undoubtedly limiting the freedom of others when they vote to redistribute theirs.

     Effective disagreement means not doing what one does not want to do as well as saying what he wants to say. What is from one angle the welfare state is from another the compulsory state. Let me submit a bill of particulars. Children are forced to go to school. Americans are forced to pay taxes to support foreign aid, forced to support the Peace Corps, forced to make loans to the United Nations, forced to contribute to the building of hospitals, forced to serve in the armed forces. Employers are forced to submit to arbitration with labor leaders. Laborers are forced to accept the majority decision. Employers are forced to pay minimum wages, or go out of business. But it is not even certain that they will be permitted by the courts to go out of business. Railroads are forced to charge established rates and to continue services which may have become uneconomical. Many Americans are forced to pay Social Security. Farmers are forced to operate according to the restrictions voted by a majority of those involved. The list could be extended, but surely the point has been made.

     Dr. Carson was quite as incisive as Rand. Yet he might not have anticipated that once freedom of speech became dangerous to the Left, it would strive to eliminate that vestige of American liberty just as it had striven to eliminate all the previous ones. Note also how Leftists have striven to corrupt the electoral system. They can’t abide that any longer, either; after all, it rejected their anointed candidate in favor of a real estate magnate from Queens!

     There’s a moral here, and it shouldn’t take a lot of skull sweat to divine it.


     We are at the edge of the abyss. We are quite literally fighting to remain even slightly free. And we are losing.

     We can afford no more prissy reservations about tactics. If we insist on keeping to Marquess of Queensberry rules while the Left batters us with bats and stomps our fallen bodies with spiked boots, we might as well surrender now.

     I trust that no more need be said.

     UPDATE: Read this if you have any remaining doubts.

New Fiction!

     But not from me:

     Where we go one, we go all!

     When the Civic Circle tries to embroil the U.S. in a senseless war, Pete must leverage his summer intern position to infiltrate their Social Justice Leadership Forum on Jekyll Island, and disrupt their plans.The danger - and the opportunity - are far greater than he imagines. The sinister power behind the Cabal - a power that aims to reshape society, destroy our civilization, and cast humanity into bondage - tolerates no rivals. Deep within the conspiracy's stronghold Pete discovers not only the secrets by which they retain their power, but also a crucial vulnerability that could cripple the Cabal with one decisive blow.

     With his plans in jeopardy and his life at risk, Pete must forge an unlikely alliance of rivals, turn The Civic Circle against itself, expose their secrets, and end their threat once and for all.The ultimate struggle for the ultimate stakes hinges on one simple question:

     Will fortune favor the brave and the bold?

     This third, exciting volume in Hans G. Schantz’s alternate-timeline techno-thriller is available in both paperback and Kindle editions.

     Highly recommended.

Sunday, October 28, 2018

Antibodies

     If God were the sort of Being Who writes out the requirements for a creature before setting to work on it, the requirements document for Mankind would have been very long. Mind you, I don’t think He did any such thing. Producing an explicit requirements document is the sort of activity that arises from having a paying customer who’ll demand that your product pass an acceptance test before he signs the check. All the same, it’s fun to contemplate what the requirements document for the human body would include.

     One of the less obvious but more vital requirements would be the inclusion of a functioning anti-infection subsystem. The one we’re equipped with is impressive. It’s not unbeatable, of course; that’s impossible in the nature of things. But it displays an ingenious degree of flexibility and responsiveness.

     The central element in our anti-infection subsystem is the antibody: an organism the body generates in response to the detection of a hostile bacterium or virus. I’m not a biologist and can’t detail exactly how this works; I only marvel that it does. The human anti-infection system is able to invent countermeasures against invading organisms it hasn’t encountered before – and those countermeasures are usually sufficient.

     This morning my thoughts are on the mental equivalent of the antibody and how it’s produced.


     One of the inner requirements of organized thought is for terms with specific and agreed-upon meanings. Without agreement on the meanings of the words we use, effective thought and discourse are impossible. Indeed, you can dismiss – not refute; simply resist – any argument simply by refusing to accept the meanings of the terms critical to it.

     Probably the best current example of this gambit is the Left’s perennial rejection of the word socialism as applicable to any real-world case. “That isn’t / wasn’t real socialism!” is their immediate reply to anyone who cites North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela, or the Soviet Union as a case for study. But under no circumstances will the Left attach a firm definition to the word and stand by it; that would expose them to counter-arguments and counter-examples that would destroy their claims.

     A few years ago we witnessed a comparable phenomenon: the application of the word science to computer simulations of the global climate system. “The science is settled!” the warmistas would chant...when there was exactly no science in their methods, just a bunch of programs that embed assumptions about how the Earth’s climate behaves. Not one of those simulations has successfully predicted any aspect of the world’s climate. Many of them can’t even use historical data to “predict” historical climate conditions. To call this “science” is to destroy the meaning of the word.

     But then, destroying the agreed-upon meanings of words short-circuits any attempt to apply evidence and logic to the Left’s claims. Refusing to allow such destruction is a prerequisite for the development of mental antibodies to specious ideas.


     The phenomenon of large numbers of persons demanding to be protected from encountering ideas they dislike is a recent thing. It’s producing masses of Americans who have no defense against hostile ideological currents. It is the encounter with a disliked idea that stimulates the development of counter-arguments to it. Because such encounters are shunned today, quite a lot of people have no capacity for intellectual self-defense: no mental anti-infection system with which to repel an invading idea. The consequences are all around us.

     Take the ludicrous notion of “degrowth” I mentioned yesterday. Today’s universities are producing graduates incapable of refuting this extraordinarily silly notion. Their “educations” haven’t compelled them to develop the mental tools required to fashion counter-arguments:

  1. Awareness of relevant historical evidence;
  2. The ability to distinguish causal forces from incidentals;
  3. The ability to formulate tests capable of falsifying a claim.

     The sciences are better off in this regard. Scientific inquiry embraces those three things. You can’t do science without them. But very few recent graduates have been exposed even lightly to the methods of science.


     It’s not always the case that a specious proposition is obviously false. (Besides, we’ve been here before: “obvious” really means “overlooked.”) If you suspect that a claim is false, analyzing it with evidence and logic is demanded of you. Looking for what a proposition implies and testing the veracity of those implications is vital, for a true proposition cannot imply a falsity. Indeed, even if an idea seems obviously true, it’s wise to examine it closely, and to test its implications as rigorously as possible. The more often you do this, the better you’ll get at it, and the readier you’ll be to defend yourself against hucksters and con men.

     But instructors don’t compel their students to face ideas they dislike. Indeed, the kids aren’t even asked to analyze ideas they find attractive. Instead, the persons and institutions they look to for knowledge and wisdom pontificate to them, expecting that they’ll accept what they’ve been told without questioning them. Education – the drawing of an untutored mind out of the darkness of uncertainty and confusion, into the light of hard thought – has been displaced by indoctrination.

     And so a great many persons – especially young Americans – are being infected with stupid ideas whose stupidities they can neither detect nor refute.


     This is a superficial treatment of a complex subject: the cultivation of the ability to analyze and judge an abstract proposition. Yet the bones of the thing are there: exactitude in the use of words, and the willingness to confront adverse ideas, tease out their implications, and develop arguments against them.

     How can we reassert these antibodies of the prepared mind in the educational institutions of today?

Nobel Laureate in Physics; "Global Warming is Pseudoscience"

Professor Ivar Giaever, 1973 Nobel Prizewinner for Physics on December 17, 2015:

“Global temperature “amazingly stable.” -- Professor Giaever.

Pearls of expression.

When Al Gore was born only 7000 Polar Bears existed. Today only 30,000 remain...
Comment by heavybones on “Nobel Laureate in Physics; 'Global Warming is Pseudoscience.'”

Makes sense to me.

Jimmy Dore is always worth watching. Guest Chris Hedges in this episode has a terrific story about when he decided to become a war correspondent. It’s right at the beginning:

Much nonsense afterwards about “neo-liberalism” and fascism from Hedges who’s afflicted with the usual liberal snark about the American experiment in self-government (“the market”) and likes to suck up to the dregs of American politics (e.g., Jeremiah Wright). But good on elite control.

(Edited.)

Saturday, October 27, 2018

A New Rationale Every Day

     “Give up your freedom!” the Left shrieks. “Let the State make all your decisions for you!” It’s lunacy, of course. Lunacy with an ever-changing rationale, to be sure. But the prescription is always the same: eliminate capitalism in favor of larger and more powerful government. Here’s an article that lays it out plainly:

     Enter Dr. Jason Hickel of the London School of Economics, a man on a crusade to end "the tyranny of GDP."

     In an interview for BBC's Newsnight show on Thursday, Hickel called for "degrowth." Ignoring energy innovation in fracking, nuclear power, renewables, and battery-based power systems, Hickel claimed that Earth is running out of resources. Rich nations are apparently to blame because we "use three times our fair share of bio-capacity."

     Hickel then claims that degrowth is not the same as "austerity" (reduced government spending). Instead, he says, "the goal is to increase human well-being and happiness while reducing our economic footprint."

     That’s only 106 words. (About “0.1 pictures.”) But what a picture it paints! It helps, of course, if the reader can see the implications of a program of “degrowth.”

     Let’s start with this one: How does it come about? For individuals, following their natural desires to be better (not worse) off, will naturally strive to produce more (not less). So the only route toward “degrowth” is coercion: the heavy hand of an Omnipotent State.

     The rationale is the currently fashionable one about “running out of resources.” It’s never been plainer that this is false. The prices of natural resources of every sort have been falling. We’re better at natural resource exploitation, conservation, and recapture than ever before in history. Scarcity is measured better by price than by any other metric.

     Hickel’s nonsense about increasing “human well-being and happiness” is merely camouflage. There’s no causal connection between making people poorer and increasing their well-being. The reverse is quite plainly true: making people poorer results in a decline in their well-being. If you don’t believe me, ask the Venezuelans.

     What else did this obvious government-worshipper have to say about his program?

  • "Cut excess consumption by curbing advertising and taxing carbon."
  • "Introducing a basic income and a shorter working week would allow us to get rid of unnecessary jobs."
  • "Industrialized countries will have no choice but to downscale their economic activity by 4-6 percent per year. And poor countries are going to have to follow suit after 2025, downscaling by about 3 percent per year."

     The question such ultra-statists never face is quite simple: “What if you’re wrong? What then?” Whether that’s because they’ve made it a precondition that no such question be asked of them or because their interviewers are pusillanimous poltroons, it’s never raised. Coercive utopians have never been able to face it. They can’t be wrong; it’s an article of faith.

     But this is nothing new.


     Consider this snippet from For A New Liberty, by the late Dr. Murray Rothbard:

     Left-liberal intellectuals are often a wondrous group to behold. In the last three or four decades [Dr. Rothbard published this in 1973], not a very long time in human history, they have, like whirling dervishes, let loose a series of angry complaints against free market capitalism. The curious thing is that each of these complaints has been contradictory to one or more of their predecessors. But contradictory complaints by liberal intellectuals do not seem to faze them or serve to abate their petulance—even though it is often the very same intellectuals who are reversing themselves so rapidly. And these reversals seem to make no dent whatever in their self-righteousness or in the self-confidence of their position.

     Dr. Rothbard goes on to catalogue seven successive Leftist demands for greatly increased government power over the American economy: each with its own specious rationale, wholly disconnected from the rationale that preceded it:

  1. Secular stagnation in the late 1930s and 1940s;
  2. Insufficient economic growth in the early 1950s;
  3. Excessive affluence in 1958 (cf. Galbraith’s The Affluent Society);
  4. Increasing poverty in the early 1960s; (cf. Harrington’s The Other America);
  5. The “automation crisis” in the mid 1960s;
  6. Pollution in the later 1960s;
  7. Exhaustion of resources in the 1970s and beyond.

     The malady changes, but the remedy remains the same: Capitalism and private property must be abolished. Quoth Joseph Schumpeter:

     Capitalism stands its trial before judges who have the sentence of death in their pockets. They are going to pass it, whatever the defense they may hear; the only success victorious defense can possibly produce is a change in the indictment.

     Considering that capitalism – the system of free people producing and trading in a free market – is the only economic scheme that’s done anything to improve human well-being and happiness, we must ask: Why is the Left so implacably hostile to it?


     This is not a new subject for me. I’ve ranted about it on occasions beyond counting. What brings it to mind afresh is not some recent change in the Left’s arguments against capitalism. The arguments enumerated above seem to have exhausted their ingenuity. Rather, it’s about the Left’s recent descent to violence.

     When a miscreant is determined to have his way, but he’s become convinced that he can’t get it by peaceful means – i.e., reason, evidence, victories at the ballot box – he’ll recur to seedier methods. He’ll usually start with deceit. If deceit proves insufficient, he’ll try fraud next. But if he can neither lie nor cheat his way to his goal, he’ll consider violence.

     Violence as a political tactic works when it’s not vigorously opposed. I’m not talking about what we might call “normal violence,” the sort the police and justice system exist to deter. I’m talking about large mobs of violent thugs, sufficiently numerous to overwhelm normal police forces.

     The Left’s embrace of AntiFa makes it plain that the critical battle for the soul of these United States is at hand. They’ve failed to persuade a majority of Americans that their nostrums are right for us. They’ve cheated their way to several Congressional and Senatorial seats, but haven’t managed to achieve a majority that way either. Other fraudulent tactics have proved no more useful to them. Violence is their sole remaining weapon.

     A political movement that chooses violence has “crossed the Rubicon.” If it doesn’t win, it will be exterminated. The Left’s strategists know this. Therefore, knowing that to lose is to lose everything, they will go “all in.”

     A rational man must ask why. What makes the risk seem worthwhile to them? Considering that the majority of Americans are happy with capitalism and don’t want to see it replaced by a socialist system, the Left’s masters must know that the odds are against them. Why not accept being the “loyal opposition” for a generation or two, and live to press its case some other day?

     The only plausible explanation is hatred. But it’s not quite plausible enough.


     Hatred attains its greatest intensity when it’s conceptualized in personal terms. That is, the hater must conceive of his target as a conscious entity that is doing him harm, or seeking to do so. It’s far easier to inflame oneself with hatred of Smith than with hatred of an abstraction such as capitalism. So how did we get here? How did we reach a point at which large masses of people – mostly young people – are willing to risk unlimited harm to themselves for the chance to suppress the views and associations of peaceable strangers?

     Perhaps if we knew the answer, we might find an antidote. But answers are lacking at the moment. All we have is video clips of thugs smashing windows, setting fires, and attacking peaceable conservatives and Republicans. We infer their hatred without being able to explain it – and owing to the many flip-flops their pseudo-intellectuals have committed, none of their rationales will hold water.

     It might be a consequence of the numbers involved. When millions of people are engaged in discourse over a political or economic subject, some will be more passionate than others. Perhaps the numbers are large enough to provide for a few thousand conscienceless, utterly violent souls willing to do harm to others in the name of their passion.

     But their absolute, unreasoning antipathy to capitalism still requires an explanation, and I don’t have one.

     Thoughts?

Friday, October 26, 2018

Quickies: 1500 Years Old And It Still Provokes Outrage

     Get a load of this:

     In response to pressure from clients who were demanding a CoC before they would do business with him, Richard Hipp, the founder of the widely used SQLite database engine, adopted the Rule of St. Benedict as the guiding principles for his community. The move angered many in the tech community — but was applauded by others who are fed up with the distractions CoCs have caused in recent years. The rules encourage users to love God and their neighbors and to forsake overeating, laziness, and grumbling, among other things.

     Pretty wild, eh? But the reactions of the social-justice warriors / non-playable characters whose pole star is promotion of “the marginalized” and “the oppressed” are very revealing:

     Many in the tech community, accustomed to CoCs focused on sexual diversity, an obsession with gender, and safe spaces, were startled by Hipp's move to adopt the overtly religious Code of Benedict.
     Critics said that his CoC lacked a means of enforcement and insisted that a CoC must make people feel safe and welcomed.
     That was news to Hipp. "Who decided this?" he asked. "Did I miss a memo?"....
     "From what I've been able to piece together from tweets, the purpose of a CoC is to make marginalized people feel welcomed and safe. And there must be some means of enforcement written into the CoC so that if hostile forces infiltrate the community, 'safeness' can be restored by censoring or expelling the miscreants," he explained. Those two rules are apparently "sufficient to disqualify the Rule of St. Benedict as a valid CoC."....
     "Your code of conduct is a terrible joke," wrote one angry user. "Wow, you really didn't understand sh*it, did you? What you're doing there is just disgusting."
     "I will stop using SQLite wherever I can," another user declared. "Please apologize publicly, replace bogus CoC by some actual CoC that addresses issues marginalised groups actually have, and if required (and I strongly suppose it is required!) seek professional help to avoid this kind of behaviour in the future."

     The Rule of St. Benedict of Nursia is over 1500 years old. It focuses on personal virtue and the proper treatment of others. Yes, it’s a Christian document – Catholic, really – but its prescriptions are as applicable to the secular world as to any monastery. But how dare this business owner employ a Christian document as the basis for his commercial enterprise! Why, you’d almost think he’s a Christian himself! And you know how “woke” Leftists feel about those folks!

     This got me laughing so hard my wife rushed over to see if I was all right. Next: A tech entrepreneur that needs a code of conduct adopts The Catechism of the Catholic Church, and heads explode nationwide.