“A man dies without a purpose.” – from Chosen One
I don’t sleep well. I suffer several pains that wake me up several times each night. I have no doubt that this is the case for many men in the second half of life.
“Life is pain. Get used to it,” Geena Davis as Samantha Caine says with brutal brevity to her fictional daughter Caitlin in The Long Kiss Goodnight. It’s not a perfect description of life, especially if you’re fortunate enough to be a contemporary First Worlder. Indeed, part of the reason for all the jokes about “first world problems” is the immense success the First World has had at alleviating pains that were inescapable for men of earlier centuries.
Yet there are pains that resist being alleviated. Some of them aren’t entirely physical.
In case you’re wondering, I was prompted by this tweet:
He looked at me and said, "I'm not distant. I'm defeated." He said his body hurts every morning. Work is getting harder. He's terrified he can't retire like we planned. Terrified he's failing me. He said he stayed quiet because he thought telling me would make me lose respect for him. So he suffered alone in the garage while I cried in the shower thinking he didn't love me. That's the truth nobody wants to hear. We tell women to communicate. We tell men to man up.
— Vïvïĕ♡ (@_MissVivie) November 15, 2026
Give that gal a medal, for it is undeniably so.
Retirement is a challenge for many men. For half a century, I had a specific mission to which I applied myself unstintingly. I had no image of what my life would be like were I to retire. But eventually, steadily increasing pain and limitations forced it on me. I’ve been fortunate, in that I’ve found other pursuits to occupy me and buttress my sense of purpose.
Not every man is that fortunate. Many of us wither and die once our careers are over. When they “see the end coming,” their sense of purpose starts to fail them. They ask themselves, sotto voce, “What value have I to others? Why would anyone want me around?”
Who knows what percentage of suicides stem from the loss of purpose?
Women don’t seem to suffer that particular emotional malady. At least, I’ve never heard a woman – yes, I’ve known plenty of them, thanks – complain about it. They have their own special sorrows, and I wouldn’t want to trade ours for theirs, but this one, the sense of having lost one’s purpose, seems to pertain to men alone.
This clip remains one of the most piercing things I’ve ever found on the Web:
One of those demons is awareness that as time passes, our significance to others, including those we love, is fading. It’s a man thing: the older we get, the more we collapse into ourselves. Barriers go up that slowly close us off to others. It’s propelled by the weariness, pain, and increasing futility of life as a man.
Yet it is our crown and our cross. With a few dubious exceptions that get a disproportional amount of air time and column-inches, we wouldn’t have it any other way. For it is the essence of manhood. We are our purpose.
If there’s an analgesic to the suffering expressed in the tweets embedded above, it’s for a man to recognize and celebrate who he has been and what he has achieved. Those things cannot be taken away from him, even if further achievement is beyond him, even if other men will go on to higher heights. Now and then, if he has a wife of the right sort, his wife will remind him.
“Well done, thou good and faithful servant.” Every man needs to hear it from time to time. If there are any women reading this, please take that to heart. The man who loves you needs to hear it from you. After all, you’re a great part of his purpose… aren’t you?
A closing thought: If you have a few minutes and can bear the sound of my voice, watch this clip, and let me know how it strikes you. Yes, it speaks of an extreme case, but extremes, even fictional ones, can help us to see things we’ve overlooked. How might it apply to purpose-built artificial intelligences? Would they suffer “male syndrome” too? If so, what could be done for them – and would it be morally obligatory to do it?