Showing posts with label hatred. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hatred. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2020

An Eternal Question

     According to Wikipedia, Sherlock Holmes is the “most portrayed literary human character” of all time, having appeared in 254 separate productions for radio, stage, film, and television. It’s eloquent testimony to the power of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s detective to enthrall an audience. Indeed, Holmes was so magnetic a character that Conan Doyle’s readers compelled him to bring Holmes back from the dead, after his seemingly fatal confrontation with Professor Moriarty in The Final Problem.

     Many and variously capable have been the actors who have portrayed Holmes, but for me there can be only one: the late Jeremy Brett.

     Brett gave Holmes a manner and character truer to Conan Doyle’s fictions than anyone who has played the detective before or since. His ownership of the role was so complete that even in 1994, when he was desperately ill and would occasionally collapse during filming, he was considered indispensable to the BBC / Granada production. Notably, one of the final series’ episodes, The Mazarin Stone, was filmed almost entirely without Brett / Holmes, as he was too ill to participate. The central role was given to Charles Gray, who plays Holmes’s equally brilliant brother Mycroft.

     Brett’s portrayal of the great detective grew ever darker as the productions went on. In the very last of them, The Cardboard Box, he concludes the teleplay with a line that could have served for Holmes’s epitaph:

     “What is the meaning of it, Watson? What is the object of this circle of misery and violence and fear? It must have a purpose. Or our universe has no meaning and that is unthinkable. But what purpose?...That...is humanity's great problem to which reason, so far, has no answer.”

     Reason must find an answer, and swiftly.


     I don’t talk about it, in the main, but I get a fair amount of hate mail. All of it is emitted by...persons on the political Left. Some of it goes beyond vitriolic. I shan’t bruise your eyes by exposing it to you. Let it suffice to say that my hate correspondents have wished the greatest tragedies imaginable upon me.

     “What is the meaning of it, Watson?” Why do so many Leftists hate their political opponents and wish them to come to harm? There are no few such, if my mailbag is representative – and remember, I’m a very minor voice. Could millions of people be so characterologically deficient as to imagine that hatred is the route to the supposedly better society they claim to seek?

     I can’t call that attitude anything but deranged. If it were personalized – i.e., if Smith were consumed with hatred for Jones, but was otherwise unafflicted by the emotion – it would be deemed a mental illness, no matter what Jones might have done to “deserve it.” But the haters of the Left hate impersonally: without any knowledge of those they hate except for our political opinions.

     Christians are forbidden to hate:

     “No matter where we stand in our lives, whatever our circumstances,” Father Ray had said to her, “only three paths are open to us. We can break, we can stand idle, or we can build. The Christian course is to strive to build, to improve, to contribute whatever mortal power can add to God’s edifice. If that necessitates some demolition, the tearing down of an impassable obstacle, the Christian is commanded to do so in a spirit of understanding and forgiveness. He must not condemn. He must not hate.”

     As I’ve written before, hatred is considered a capital sin because it’s a machine that produces other sins: false witness, fraud, theft, violence, and others. Its intimate connection to envy — another capital sin – makes it uniquely deadly to social relations.

     No nation, whatever its political system, can survive a condition in which millions of people hate millions of others. Yet that is the condition in which America stands today.


     Don’t look to me for an answer to the problem. I may be a genius, but I’m not omniscient. I can diagnose the malady; I have no idea how to cure it. I can’t even think of a way to palliate it.

     Were America to fission into independent “red” and “blue” sectors, the problem would persist. Indeed, it might grow infinitely worse. Imagine a state of affairs in which a free and prosperous “red” nation directly abuts a socialism-afflicted “blue” nation. You don’t have to strain for a historical example; just about any incidence of socialism anywhere in time or space will serve. What does the socialist state invariably pursue as an “answer” to its troubles?

     No, I haven’t written all of this just to sour your morning. I’m struggling for some approach to the thing that doesn’t involve millions of deaths. And I can’t produce one.

     Holmes asked “What is the object of this circle of misery and violence and fear?” He asked for its purpose — but could mass hatred, and mass malevolence, have a purpose? “It must have a purpose,” he said, “Or our universe has no meaning and that is unthinkable. But what purpose?”

     “That...is humanity's great problem to which reason, so far, has no answer.” That Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, inarguably the possessor of a great mind, was baffled by the question relieves me somewhat. I’ll keep working on it, but I wouldn’t expect an answer before lunchtime.

Friday, May 15, 2020

The Problem Of Hatred

     Dov Fischer’s remarkable column has been on my mind for a few days now. I’ve been groping for the proper angle on it: on its truths, on its excesses, and on what use can be made of Fischer’s insights without doing undo damage to any innocent.

     If you haven’t yet read it, please do so. I’ll wait here.


     Hatred is dangerous. However, it is also energizing. The core problem of hatred -- much like the core problem of exploiting the energy content of any fuel -- is how to make use of the energies it liberates while consigning the dangerous parts to some form of safe storage. It's a personal problem, and therefore unsolved in the general setting.

     In other words, if you must hate, hate responsibly: i.e., with due attention to confining the unwanted byproducts to your own environs. Physicists know, with a degree of certainty that applies to just about nothing else, that every action has at least one undesired consequence. There is no law of our reality that can be relied upon more confidently than that.

     So let’s explore the undesired consequences and byproducts of hatred.


     Fischer’s article notes the many ways in which the Democrats (and everyone to the left of them) have betrayed America’s laws and the principles of equity on which they’re founded. Each of those betrayals is angering in and of itself. Their cumulative effect is enraging. Fischer penetrates to the core of the thing in two paragraphs:

     There is something so evil in a society that tolerates a dual standard of justice, dual standards of everything. On the one hand, we political conservatives harbor profoundly deep feelings, but we do not destroy people’s lives based on abstract politics. Yes, we oppose them and expose them, and we hope that contemporary society and history judge them for the evil they represent. But we do not destroy them in their lives. They get away with everything. Hillary Clinton spoliated 33,000 emails amid a federal probe, a federal crime that always ends up with prison time — but not for her. It is a federal crime to lie under oath to Congress. Comey, Clapper, Brennan — how have they all avoided prison time? Strzok, Page, the whole bunch of them? Adam Schiff. The outliers on the Mueller team. Not one single slime among them in the swamp has been brought to justice.

     These animals destroyed the life of Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn. They drove him into such financial ruin that he had to sell his home to pay his legal bills. They went after a good boy, Nick Sandmann, and they cruelly made him into the face of racism. His own Catholic diocese in eastern Kentucky sold him out and sold out all the boys who stood with him that fateful day in Washington, D.C., when he was harassed by a messed-up Indian with a drum. And they did everything they could to destroy Brett Kavanaugh, a good man, a family man, a man who has devoted time throughout his life to his church and to the need. They endeavored through outright perjury to destroy him. The perjurers all got away with it. Name one single perjurer against Justice Kavanaugh who ever was brought to justice by Charles Grassley or Lindsey Graham of the Senate Judicial Committee.

     From those two paragraphs alone, Ecclesiastes would almost certainly agree with Fischer that this is “a time to hate.”

     But what is the central motivation of the man who hates? It is to wreak harm upon the object of his hatred. Unless that harm is:

  • Focused upon its proper target and his misdeeds,
  • Proportional to what that target has done to deserve it,
  • Bounded, so that innocent bystanders are preserved,

     …it cannot be squared with Americans’ concept of justice. It might fit within the protocols of war, with the collateral damage war always inflicts upon the uninvolved and the innocent. But going to war is a step one does not take lightly, specifically because of its lose-lose nature and the collateral damage it will cause.

     The man who hates tends to dismiss those considerations and go directly to war.


     Because hatred is so energizing, it tends to consume the entire attention of the man who hates. It displaces other considerations…sometimes including one’s duties and responsibilities. Even at its least pernicious, it will absorb energy that ought to be reserved for constructive purposes.

     But however justified one is in hating someone or something, that does not exempt him from his responsibilities. Those must always come first. Earning one’s living, caring for one’s dependents and treating them properly, keeping one’s promises, and overall abiding by the Commandments remain paramount, or one quickly descends to the same level as what one hates.

     Christ commanded us to love our enemies and pray for them in part because it helps to detoxify our hatreds. It renders hatred’s energies more susceptible to constructive uses. Yet keeping those constraints uppermost in mind is supremely difficult.


     Finally for this brief essay, hatred is both addictive and infectious. Every surrender to hatred makes future surrenders more likely. Paradoxically and perversely, active hatred makes the hater more attractive to others in certain ways. It makes him appear decisive, resolute, and dynamic. Those around him who are thus attracted are highly likely to catch the hatred-bug for themselves. While the consequences cannot be foreseen in detail, they will surely be negative…and most likely destructive.


     This is not a complete, exhaustive treatment of the problem of hatred. I merely wanted to point out some important directions for my Gentle Readers’ contemplation. But in closing, let us note the role of the world’s major religious faiths in addressing hatred, its objects, and the consequences of acting on it.

     While Christianity reveres justice, it abjures the emotion of hatred completely.
     Judaism, as far as I’m aware, strives to keep hatred within its proper bounds as I’ve delineated them above.
     Of the world’s major faiths, only Islam commands its adherents to hate – and Islam has racked up a body count no other faith can approach.

     That should be enough to think about on a Friday morning in May.

Saturday, February 15, 2020

If You Need A Pandemic To Worry About...

     ...I think there’s a verifiable one in progress. Here are the symptoms du jour:

     Mind you, the Left’s hatred of the Right has a long lineage. You could argue that it began with Marx and Engels, though it took Lenin and Beria to perform the first instantiations on record. But the most recent outbreaks display the ferocity that characterizes a genuinely dangerous disease.

     To the best of my knowledge, while the Democrats were certainly willing to defame Barry Goldwater in his campaign for the presidency, no one suggested that he or any of his supporters belonged behind bars. No one attacked him or his supporters physically. At that point the hatred was still incubating.

     While the Left fulminated when the GOP renominated Richard Nixon in 1968, it was a phenomenon largely confined to the fringe: the outright socialists and communists, and the “student activists” who sought media attention for themselves. Leftists’ antipathy to Nixon had to wait for the Watergate scandal, at which point it could burst forth in the desired fashion. Their success in compelling him to leave office whetted their taste for further campaigns.

     Ronald Reagan’s campaign for the presidency excited the Left’s derision, but at first leftists and liberals were confident that he would lose: he was too old and too conservative to win a majority. Reagan’s smashing victory really got the ball rolling. President Reagan suffered denunciations America hadn’t seen since the Lincoln Administration – and if you’re not familiar with those, they make illuminating reading.

     Policy denunciations and belittlements were the fodder of the two Bush Administrations. However, the Bushes were personally warm and likeable, especially Bush the Younger a.k.a. Dubya, which made savage personal attacks on them politically unwise. There came a time of retrenchment. The Left needed a new and more assailable devil figure.

     Then came Donald Trump. He was an answer to the Left’s prayers: the exact opposite of its social-fascist hero Barack Hussein Obama. More, he had pledged to undo Obama’s “achievements” root and branch. His “America First” stance is the antidote to the Left’s principal political weapon: identity-group politics. And the more Trump has succeeded for America and Americans, the more the Left has hated and assaulted him, his agenda...and his lieutenants and supporters.

     As Aerich noted in yesterday’s citation from The Phoenix Guards, it can be dangerous to succeed where another has failed.


     The emotions are motivators. Indeed, if we omit the drives of the body for sustenance and safety, they’re the only motivators of importance. Once we understand what has elicited a strong emotion, we have a chance of making some headway to counter its effects – if countering its effects is what we decide is appropriate.

     The Left is currently in a state of great fear. It faces an opponent who has called it out, most recently and explicitly during his recent State of the Union speech. Moreover, he is in the process of demonstrating, even in the face of strong and sustained opposition from the political and media elites, that his positions are correct: the best ones for America and Americans generally.

     Fear’s natural companion is hatred:

     [H]atred is best combined with Fear. Cowardice, alone of all the vices, is purely painful—horrible to anticipate, horrible to feel, horrible to remember; Hatred has its pleasures. It is therefore often the compensation by which a frightened man reimburses himself for the miseries of Fear. The more he fears, the more he will hate. And Hatred is also a great anodyne for shame. [C. S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters]

     It thus comes naturally to the Left to hate the man who is showing it up in such brilliant American colors. But of course, this combines naturally with a pre-existing hatred: the Left’s hatred of the sole unbending bastion against its ascension worldwide: the United States of America itself.

     The Left’s hatred has reached a pitch and tempo that demands its expression in action. We’ve seen expressions of that hatred ever more frequently as time has passed. From leftists in the political class we get demands for President Trump’s removal from office, his prosecution for imagined crimes, the confiscation of his wealth and businesses, and so forth. We also get crusades against those of his lieutenants who prove vulnerable, such as Michael Flynn and Roger Stone. We can expect more such between now and November 3.

     Lower-level supporters of President Trump and the GOP have suffered physical attacks with increasing frequency. You’ve read about them: assaults on citizens wearing MAGA hats, attacks on Republican voter-registration drives, and cases of vandalism against Republican district headquarters. There will be more. Not only are they the only things the Left can do to intimidate Trump supporters and conservatives generally out of participation in the political arena; they also help to assuage Leftists’ hatred of the man and his movement that are making them look like fools.

     It will continue. It will get worse as the year wears on. Whether it will cease after the election is doubtful. We must hope that it won’t deteriorate to open, blood-spilling warfare in the streets.


     And now, a coda:

     Coda n: a more or less independent passage, at the end of a composition, introduced to bring it to a satisfactory close.

     In this piece of yesterday, I counseled the reader not to panic: not to give in to hysteria that would cause him to sever all his ties with the world beyond his door. That is my assessment of Dr. John Campbell’s recommendations: that to subscribe to them fully would involve the severance of economic and interpersonal relations, with an effect on our society so devastating that only a threat on the order of the Black Death could make it seem appropriate.

     Fear can make us do things we would not otherwise do. Sometimes that’s appropriate. As I said yesterday, judicious fear – fear proportional to the dimensions of the threat – can be protective. But at this time, I dispute that the dimensions of the Coronavirus threat are well enough established to justify a contraction of our interactions that would effectively stop both our economy and our society.

     The Chinese are panicking. Perhaps they have a good reason. But the virus has not yet begun to spread to any great extent in North America. The most recent count of American cases I’ve seen is fourteen. Watchfulness and the avoidance of unnecessary risks are appropriate measures. More than that? I don’t think so. Choose according to your own judgment.

Friday, July 12, 2019

Quickies: “Remember the Boyne” – ?

     Being of Irish descent, I was at one time frequently asked by acquaintances about what the Irish call “the troubles:” the unending, savagely bloody pseudo-war between such organizations as the Irish Republican Army and the Ulster Defence League. Both are regarded with loathing by decent Irishmen, who want only peace and safety for their families. That doesn’t seem to have dampened either group’s ardor for slaughter.

     My Irish progenitors left their homeland to escape the violence, which had come close to claiming their lives. I’m sure they weren’t the only children of the Emerald Isle to flee to America for that reason. What better reason to emigrate than in search of peace and safety?

     Hearken to the late Stan Rogers, Canada’s finest songwriter and singer:

I took back my hand and I showed him the door.
No dollar of mine would I part with this day
For fueling the engines of a bloody cruel war
In my forefathers’ land far away.

Who fled the first Famine wearing all that they owned,
Were called Navigators, all ragged and torn,
And built the Grand Trunk here, and found a new home
Wherever their children were born.

Their sons have no politics. None call recall
Allegiance from long generations before.
O'this or O'that name just can't mean a thing,
Or be cause enough for to war.

And meanwhile my babies are safe in their home,
Unlike their pale cousins who shiver and cry,
While kneecappers nail their poor Dads to the floor,
And teach them to hate and to die.

It's those cruel beggars who spurn the fair coin.
The peace for their kids they could take at their will.
Since the day old King Billy prevailed at the Boyne,
They've bombed and they've maimed and they've killed.

Now they cry out for money and wail at the door,
But Home Rule or Republic, 'tis all of it shame;
And a curse for us here who want nothing of war.
We're kindred in nothing but name.

All rights and all wrongs have long since blown away,
For causes are ashes where children lie slain.
Yet the damned UDL and the cruel IRA
Will tomorrow go murdering again.

But no penny of mine will I add to the fray.
"Remember the Boyne!" they will cry out in vain,
For I've given my heart to the place I was born,
And forgiven the whole House of Orange...
King Billy and the whole House of Orange.

     May God forever guard and guide these United States of America.

Friday, May 3, 2019

The Search For Someone To Hate

     The great problems are those that are insusceptible to complete and enduring solutions. One who confronts a great problem must disabuse himself of any nonsense notions about “solving it.” He cannot and will not. Rather, he must do, categorically, what others have done: he must cope.

     To cope is not to solve. To cope is to find a way around or through. Coping is what we do with nearly all the problems we face. It is, in some sense, the fundamental survival skill.

     But in this year of Our Lord 2019, it appears that coping has become despised.


     I know the title of this piece seems not to match the segment above. Bear with me. By now you should know how circuitous I am.

     The problem of hatred is one of the most severe in all of human experience. We’re inclined to “otherize,” and hatred follows rather naturally. Definition, you see, proceeds by stating first a genus — what the defined category includes, and second a differentia — what it excludes. Both parts are required. We define ourselves, as members of various categories, in exactly that fashion.

     When the exclusion comes close to our highest-priority values, the urge to hate what is excluded, to despise and condemn it and wish it ill, can be very strong. Regard one more time this passage from C. S. Lewis’s masterpiece That Hideous Strength:

     “Come in,” said Dimble in his rooms at Northumberland. “Oh, it’s you, Studdock,” he added as the door opened. “Come in.”
     “I’ve come to ask about Jane,” said Mark. “Do you know where she is ?”
     “I can’t give you her address, I’m afraid,” said Dimble.
     “Do you mean you don’t know it? “
     “I can’t give it,” said Dimble….
     “What do you mean?” he asked. “I don't understand.”
     “If you have any regard for your wife's safety you will not ask me to tell you where she has gone,” said Dimble.
     “Safety from what?”
     “Don't you know what has happened?”
     "What's happened?"
     “On the night of the riot the Institutional Police attempted to arrest her. She escaped, but not before they had tortured her.”
     “Tortured her? What do you mean? “
     “Burned her with cigars.”
     “That's what I've come about,” said Mark. “Jane- I'm afraid she is on the verge of a nervous breakdown. That didn't really happen, you know.”
     “The doctor who dressed the burns thinks otherwise.”
     “Great Scott!” said Mark. “So they really did? But, look here ...”
     Under the quiet stare of Dimble he found it difficult to speak.
     “Why have I not been told about this outrage?” he shouted.
     “By your colleagues?” asked Dimble dryly. “It is an odd question to ask me. You ought to understand the workings of the N.I.C.E. better than I do.”
     “Why didn't you tell me? Why has nothing been done about it? Have you been to the police?”
     “The Institutional Police?”
     “No, the ordinary police.”
     “Do you really not know that there are no ordinary police left in Edgestow?”
     “I suppose there are some magistrates.”
     “There is the Emergency Commissioner, Lord Feverstone. You seem to misunderstand. This is a conquered and occupied city.”
     “Then why, in Heaven's name, didn't you get on to me?”
     “You?” said Dimble.
     For one moment Mark saw himself exactly as a man like Dimble saw him. It almost took his breath away.
     “Look here,” he said. “You don't . . . it's too fantastic! You don't imagine I knew about it! You don't really believe I send policemen about to man-handle my own wife!”
     Dimble said nothing and his face did not relax.
     “I know you've always disliked me," said Mark. “But I didn't know it was quite as bad as that.” And again Dimble was silent.
     “Well,” said Studdock, “there doesn't seem to be much more to say. I insist on being told where Jane is.”
     “Do you want her to be taken to Belbury?”
     “I don't see why I should be cross-questioned in this way. Where is my wife?”
     “I have no permission to tell you. She is not in my house nor under my care. If you still have the slightest regard for her happiness you will make no attempt to get into touch with her.”
     “Am I some sort of leper or criminal that I can't even be trusted to know her address?”
     “Excuse me. You are a member of the N.I.C.E. who have already insulted, tortured, and arrested her. Since her escape she has been left alone only because your colleagues do not know where she is.”
     “And if it really was the N.I.C.E. police, do you suppose I'm not going to have a very full explanation out of them ? Damn it, what do you take me for? “
     “I can only hope that you have no power in the N.I.C.E. at all. If you have no power, then you cannot protect her. If you have, then you are identified with its policy. In neither case will I help you to discover where Jane is.”
     “This is fantastic,” said Mark. “Even if I do happen to hold a job in the N.I.C.E. for the moment, you know me.”
     “I do not know you,” said Dimble. “I have no conception of your aims or motives.”
     He seemed to Mark to be looking at him not with anger or contempt but with that degree of loathing which produces in those who feel it a kind of embarrassment. In reality Dimble was simply trying very hard not to hate, not to despise, and he had no idea of the fixed severity which this effort gave to his face.

     Imagine yourself as Mark Studdock in the above. You confront a man – Dimble – for whom you have a curious respect. Dimble is willing to speak and act according to his values. In other words, he has the courage of his convictions. You find that those values put the two of you on opposite sides of a moral boundary. Is it not supremely difficult to imagine that he doesn’t hate you? Is it not just as difficult not to hate him?

     Ponder that for a moment.


     Do you recall this episode from last year?

     Kyle Kashuv is going to prom. With a girl he doesn’t know. Who lives in another state. Kashuv is one of the few survivors of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas shooting who publicly supports the Second Amendment. He has gained a substantial Twitter following based largely on his refusal to toe the party line on gun control, or engage in the negative rhetoric of his classmates on the left. But now Twitter has gained him something else: a date.

     Last week a girl from Nebraska, who goes by Fidan on Twitter, sent Kyle a direct message asking, “How many retweets for prom?!!” Kyle responded, “5K,” adding “Also I don’t have a tux.” Fidan tweeted out this exchange with the caption, “PLEASE HELP ME OUT. A DREAM COME TRUE.” And Twitter leapt to the challenge.

     Within a day Fidan had her 5,000 retweets. To tackle Kyle’s other dilemma — the lack of a tux — Fidan set up a GoFundMe page with a goal of raising $1,700 to cover the cost of the tuxedo and Kyle’s plane travel to and from Nebraska. She met her goal within six days. But what about Kyle? Would he actually go?

     Kyle’s answer came as a result of an unfortunate plot twist in this little romance. In amongst all the well-wishers and retweeters came Planned Parenthood senior advisor Elizabeth Thorp, like some kind of anti-fairy godmother, telling Fidan: “Hard pass, sweet girl. You can do better.”

     Elizabeth Thorp, an executive of the institution that, among “non-state actors” in the First World, holds the world record for killing innocents, hates Kyle Kashuv. It’s as plain as print. Yet she hasn’t met him and probably never will. So why does she hate him? For the same reason Mark Studdock believed that Dimble hated him: Kashuv’s values, which Thorp has inferred are morally opposed to hers.

     Erick Erickson wrote at the time:

     The secular left in America has its own religion -- the state. Worship of the state and the self cannot tolerate dissent or competition, and therefore is moving aggressively to shut down, silence, and drive from the town square any competing ideas. Evil has been preaching tolerance, but now that it is dominate, it seeks to silence good. [Erick Erickson]

     I must disagree, albeit mildly. The Left does not worship The State; it worships itself. The State is merely its chosen instrument for the propagation of its faith. In any case, as I wrote at the time, theirs is a faith that tolerates no dissent, however mildly expressed.


     Christians are forbidden to hate. It’s a proscription that many misunderstand. Hatred in this context involves the active desire to see someone come to harm. That’s not the same as holding him in contempt and praying that he will fail of his aims. I’ve felt contempt for many persons prominent in the public eye. I’ve prayed nightly for them to fail of their aims. I bear no guilt for those emotions and prayers, nor would you.

     But for some, there is no firebreak. They perceive the moral boundary that divides them from another, and they hate. They wish for the hated one to come to harm. They don’t resist the desire; perhaps they cannot. Whether they would act on it, given the opportunity, we can seldom know.

     He who deems himself morally superior to others is forever in danger from this progression. It doesn’t matter whether the superiority has any basis in fact. Yet the very best persons of my acquaintance, those I would deem unquestionably morally superior to me, have all exhibited a depth of humility, a sincere willingness to call themselves sinners, that armors them against both vanity and hatred. It destroys any suggestion that they would hold themselves superior to anyone.

     It is one of our great contemporary tragedies that such persons are generally not held up to our young as models to be emulated. Perhaps the adulation showered upon entertainers and sports celebrities consumes all the available bandwidth.

     Forgive me, Gentle Readers. I’m in one of those moods again. No doubt it will pass, or I will. Have a nice day.

Sunday, January 20, 2019

End-Arounds

     Our political class needs to be watched closely. They probably get away with more than any ordinarily attentive private citizen is aware – and a lot more than any unengaged private citizen can imagine.

     Yesterday’s developments were more dramatic than I’d expected them to be. I’d anticipated that the Democrats would reject and disparage whatever President Trump might propose – they’ve been trying to impeach him since before his inauguration – but I hadn’t expected that their rejection would travel backward in time. The timestamps on Nancy Pelosi’s tweets leave no doubt of it. Yet the significance of that odd sequence of events has been lost on everyone but a single British news outlet.

     President Trump has been doing exceedingly well in office. Any objective observer, assessing the state of the nation today versus that in January of 2017, would be compelled to agree. But he’s got a target on his back even so. The reasons are several and need not be recapped here, except to note the one that stands out above the rest: the Democrats’ blind hatred for the man who’s undone the pro-socialism journey of their Anointed One. That he thwarted the continuation of that process by his chosen successor, at this point, is merely icing on the cake.

     Schumer, Pelosi, and the rest of the Democrats’ Congressional vanguard once voted a $50 billion appropriation for a physical border barrier. That’s a matter of public record. You won’t hear them admit to it today, of course. Not only does a politician hate to be caught in a contradiction that stark, it would also be a big extra round for the Trump cannon. The highest priority item on the Democrats’ agenda is to thwart President Trump. Therefore their hatred of Trump overpowers all their other motives. Q.E.D.

     This is the point that must be brought home to the electorate, including those voters who: 1) mostly don’t follow political developments, and: 2) base their votes on considerations other than who’s doing the best job for the nation.

     Imagine a lifelong Democrat voter being confronted inescapably with the realization that he’s been supporting politicians whose motives and policy proposals have nothing to do with the good of the people of the United States – i.e., persons animated by a combination of hatred and power lust. Facing that would have a dramatic effect on any honest man of good will. That makes it a test: who among the Democrats’ “base” is an honest man of good will? And what would those honest men of good will think of other habitual Democrat voters – i.e., those the test reveals as not honest men of good will?

     Never before in the history of this country has the cleavage that divides the wise and honest from the venal and duplicitous been clearer or more vital to address. That there are some Democrats who still belong among the former category is indisputable. (That there are some Republicans who belong in the latter is equally plain.) But the matter must be brought home to those whose voting-booth behavior has installed them in office and who must remove them in November of 2020. If that can’t be done, America has no future.

     I’ll probably be back later with something more. Just now it’s time for Mass.

Tuesday, December 18, 2018

Quickies: Hatred Knows No Bounds

     There’s a YouTube clip, taken early in the presidential campaign for 2016, of a panel discussion in which Ann Coulter says, fearlessly as is her wont, that of the declared Republican candidates, the one with the best chance of ultimate electoral victory was Donald Trump. The camera immediately swung to the face of Joy Reid, whose expression was a perfect blend of incredulity and contempt.

     Joy Reid has never forgiven Coulter for being absolutely right. More to the point, she’s never forgiven Donald Trump for winning, which Reid equates to “making me look like an idiot.” (Mind you, she is an idiot, but that’s beside the point.) Today, this hatred-filled bitch is absolutely resolved upon bringing Trump down no matter what it takes or whome she has to hurt – and she has allies in the Socialist Republic of New York City:

     The Manhattan DA is investigating the President’s inaugural committee spending in the hopes of finding a crime. Joy Reid and her airhead guests used this as a jumping off point for discussion. Everything they said was conjecture and they had not one fact. They do want to see Ivanka imprisoned. One guest seemed to think there will be lots of crimes unfolding — any day now.

     Elie Mystal couldn’t understand why all the gossip surrounding the President isn’t enough to get him.

     At one point, they discussed possible tax crimes, embezzlement, and wire fraud although they had no evidence or facts. It would be funny except there are a whole lot of people just like them working in positions of power.

     Joy Reid and guest, Elie Mystal, would like to hurt Trump by targeting his children. They zeroed in on Ivanka.

     Please read it all. (There’s also a video, if you can stomach it.) Imagine what the reaction from Reid and her fellow-travelers would be were the Clintons to be targeted through Chelsea. Imagine if Barack Hussein Obama were to be targeted through Michelle, or their daughters. The outraged shrieking would be audible on Mars.

     But the Left doesn’t feel that strictures about not targeting family are binding upon it. They’d target Trump through his family dog if they thought they could get him for shitting on the sidewalk.

     It’s not enough to defeat them electorally. They must be expunged, root and branch: from government, from the media, from the world of entertainment. And when they’ve been deprived of all those pulpits, we should kick them off the planet. You know, for lagniappe!

Saturday, October 27, 2018

A New Rationale Every Day

     “Give up your freedom!” the Left shrieks. “Let the State make all your decisions for you!” It’s lunacy, of course. Lunacy with an ever-changing rationale, to be sure. But the prescription is always the same: eliminate capitalism in favor of larger and more powerful government. Here’s an article that lays it out plainly:

     Enter Dr. Jason Hickel of the London School of Economics, a man on a crusade to end "the tyranny of GDP."

     In an interview for BBC's Newsnight show on Thursday, Hickel called for "degrowth." Ignoring energy innovation in fracking, nuclear power, renewables, and battery-based power systems, Hickel claimed that Earth is running out of resources. Rich nations are apparently to blame because we "use three times our fair share of bio-capacity."

     Hickel then claims that degrowth is not the same as "austerity" (reduced government spending). Instead, he says, "the goal is to increase human well-being and happiness while reducing our economic footprint."

     That’s only 106 words. (About “0.1 pictures.”) But what a picture it paints! It helps, of course, if the reader can see the implications of a program of “degrowth.”

     Let’s start with this one: How does it come about? For individuals, following their natural desires to be better (not worse) off, will naturally strive to produce more (not less). So the only route toward “degrowth” is coercion: the heavy hand of an Omnipotent State.

     The rationale is the currently fashionable one about “running out of resources.” It’s never been plainer that this is false. The prices of natural resources of every sort have been falling. We’re better at natural resource exploitation, conservation, and recapture than ever before in history. Scarcity is measured better by price than by any other metric.

     Hickel’s nonsense about increasing “human well-being and happiness” is merely camouflage. There’s no causal connection between making people poorer and increasing their well-being. The reverse is quite plainly true: making people poorer results in a decline in their well-being. If you don’t believe me, ask the Venezuelans.

     What else did this obvious government-worshipper have to say about his program?

  • "Cut excess consumption by curbing advertising and taxing carbon."
  • "Introducing a basic income and a shorter working week would allow us to get rid of unnecessary jobs."
  • "Industrialized countries will have no choice but to downscale their economic activity by 4-6 percent per year. And poor countries are going to have to follow suit after 2025, downscaling by about 3 percent per year."

     The question such ultra-statists never face is quite simple: “What if you’re wrong? What then?” Whether that’s because they’ve made it a precondition that no such question be asked of them or because their interviewers are pusillanimous poltroons, it’s never raised. Coercive utopians have never been able to face it. They can’t be wrong; it’s an article of faith.

     But this is nothing new.


     Consider this snippet from For A New Liberty, by the late Dr. Murray Rothbard:

     Left-liberal intellectuals are often a wondrous group to behold. In the last three or four decades [Dr. Rothbard published this in 1973], not a very long time in human history, they have, like whirling dervishes, let loose a series of angry complaints against free market capitalism. The curious thing is that each of these complaints has been contradictory to one or more of their predecessors. But contradictory complaints by liberal intellectuals do not seem to faze them or serve to abate their petulance—even though it is often the very same intellectuals who are reversing themselves so rapidly. And these reversals seem to make no dent whatever in their self-righteousness or in the self-confidence of their position.

     Dr. Rothbard goes on to catalogue seven successive Leftist demands for greatly increased government power over the American economy: each with its own specious rationale, wholly disconnected from the rationale that preceded it:

  1. Secular stagnation in the late 1930s and 1940s;
  2. Insufficient economic growth in the early 1950s;
  3. Excessive affluence in 1958 (cf. Galbraith’s The Affluent Society);
  4. Increasing poverty in the early 1960s; (cf. Harrington’s The Other America);
  5. The “automation crisis” in the mid 1960s;
  6. Pollution in the later 1960s;
  7. Exhaustion of resources in the 1970s and beyond.

     The malady changes, but the remedy remains the same: Capitalism and private property must be abolished. Quoth Joseph Schumpeter:

     Capitalism stands its trial before judges who have the sentence of death in their pockets. They are going to pass it, whatever the defense they may hear; the only success victorious defense can possibly produce is a change in the indictment.

     Considering that capitalism – the system of free people producing and trading in a free market – is the only economic scheme that’s done anything to improve human well-being and happiness, we must ask: Why is the Left so implacably hostile to it?


     This is not a new subject for me. I’ve ranted about it on occasions beyond counting. What brings it to mind afresh is not some recent change in the Left’s arguments against capitalism. The arguments enumerated above seem to have exhausted their ingenuity. Rather, it’s about the Left’s recent descent to violence.

     When a miscreant is determined to have his way, but he’s become convinced that he can’t get it by peaceful means – i.e., reason, evidence, victories at the ballot box – he’ll recur to seedier methods. He’ll usually start with deceit. If deceit proves insufficient, he’ll try fraud next. But if he can neither lie nor cheat his way to his goal, he’ll consider violence.

     Violence as a political tactic works when it’s not vigorously opposed. I’m not talking about what we might call “normal violence,” the sort the police and justice system exist to deter. I’m talking about large mobs of violent thugs, sufficiently numerous to overwhelm normal police forces.

     The Left’s embrace of AntiFa makes it plain that the critical battle for the soul of these United States is at hand. They’ve failed to persuade a majority of Americans that their nostrums are right for us. They’ve cheated their way to several Congressional and Senatorial seats, but haven’t managed to achieve a majority that way either. Other fraudulent tactics have proved no more useful to them. Violence is their sole remaining weapon.

     A political movement that chooses violence has “crossed the Rubicon.” If it doesn’t win, it will be exterminated. The Left’s strategists know this. Therefore, knowing that to lose is to lose everything, they will go “all in.”

     A rational man must ask why. What makes the risk seem worthwhile to them? Considering that the majority of Americans are happy with capitalism and don’t want to see it replaced by a socialist system, the Left’s masters must know that the odds are against them. Why not accept being the “loyal opposition” for a generation or two, and live to press its case some other day?

     The only plausible explanation is hatred. But it’s not quite plausible enough.


     Hatred attains its greatest intensity when it’s conceptualized in personal terms. That is, the hater must conceive of his target as a conscious entity that is doing him harm, or seeking to do so. It’s far easier to inflame oneself with hatred of Smith than with hatred of an abstraction such as capitalism. So how did we get here? How did we reach a point at which large masses of people – mostly young people – are willing to risk unlimited harm to themselves for the chance to suppress the views and associations of peaceable strangers?

     Perhaps if we knew the answer, we might find an antidote. But answers are lacking at the moment. All we have is video clips of thugs smashing windows, setting fires, and attacking peaceable conservatives and Republicans. We infer their hatred without being able to explain it – and owing to the many flip-flops their pseudo-intellectuals have committed, none of their rationales will hold water.

     It might be a consequence of the numbers involved. When millions of people are engaged in discourse over a political or economic subject, some will be more passionate than others. Perhaps the numbers are large enough to provide for a few thousand conscienceless, utterly violent souls willing to do harm to others in the name of their passion.

     But their absolute, unreasoning antipathy to capitalism still requires an explanation, and I don’t have one.

     Thoughts?

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

Quickies: A Hate Crime

     This happened in my vicinity, at a church where I sometimes attend Mass:

     PORT JEFFERSON STATION, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) — A statue of the Virgin Mary was beheaded in Port Jefferson Station over the weekend, according to Suffolk County Police.

     The statue was vandalized at the Church of Saint [Gerard] Majella in Port Jefferson Station sometime between Friday and Sunday.

     Investigators are treating the matter as a hate crime.

     It’s easy to feel one’s blood boiling over an incident like this. It’s far harder to work out what might be done to prevent anything like it. The haters of Christianity are always on offense. It’s impossible to predict where they’ll strike next. Will they deface a church? Ruin other statues or sacred images? Assault churchgoers, whether going to or coming from? Assault priests and rectories? Who can say?

     I hope it was a couple of drunken teenagers, as one commenter to the linked article suggested. All the other possibilities are worse. There’s no way to defend against any of them.

     Long Island’s Catholics are numerous. We tend to be strongly bonded to our parishes and protective of our churches. We’re heavy participants in local charity, both as donors and volunteer workers. But we can’t stand guard over what’s sacred to us twenty-four hours per day. That’s the haters’ biggest advantage.

     Perhaps prayer will help. It usually does.

Sunday, November 5, 2017

The Ascendancy Of Hatred

     Imagine along with me, if you please.

     As the Year of Our Lord 2020 draws toward its end, the United States of America is enjoying a rebirth of freedom and prosperity virtually no one foresaw five years earlier. The vista is almost impossible to believe...yet there it lies before us.

     Hundreds of oppressive laws and many thousands of anti-Constitutional regulations have been lifted from Americans’ shoulders. Private citizens have regained their right to keep and bear arms, in full. Federal taxes have been sharply reduced. Kelo v. New London has been overturned, by a remarkable unanimous opinion of the Justices. Nonjudicial punishments are a thing of the past. All five branches of our military have been revitalized. Perhaps best of all, the Ninth and Tenth Amendments have been restored to their full and proper effect, returning internal autonomy to the states while binding them to their own constitutions under penalty of federal wrath.

     With the reduction in government power has come an economic explosion. Growth rates have returned to Nineteenth Century levels. Involuntary unemployment is virtually nil. The nation’s urban cores, many of which were once spoken of as blighted beyond recovery, have shared fully in the economic renaissance. The welfare rolls are a shrunken remnant of their former bloat. And American made products are once again the envy of the world.

     None if it has come without effort...and some painful re-evaluations. The fortification of the borders caused more than a little suffering. The institution of extreme vetting for all immigration applicants excited a great deal of controversy, especially when it became clear that ideological and religious affiliations would once again become criteria for exclusion. The repeal of the Environmental Protection Act, the dissolution of the Environmental Protection Administration, and the return of all environmental and conservationist authority to the states put nearly two hundred thousand federal employees out of work. Yet the public came to accept that it was all necessary.

     Our nation is once again free, rich, and secure. The architect of this remarkable turnaround, who was once reviled by half the electorate yet now seems destined to reap the first fifty-state sweep since George Washington on Election Day next week, is no other than the 45th President of the United States, Donald J. Trump.

     Yet there remain pockets of intense dissatisfaction: angry voices that can be heard from all our media. They’ve called for everything from street protests against the Administration to a violent revolution. Who are they and what do they want?


     The concluding question in the little fantasy above is the one uppermost in my thoughts this morning. Make no mistake: it is a fantasy. Unless President Trump should get total cooperation from Congress and the Supreme Court from this point forward, it could not come to pass. A president’s powers are not those of a dictator, the claims of Barack Hussein Obama notwithstanding.

     But my fantasy can serve as the basis for a Gedankenexperiment. Imagine that what I wrote above were to come to pass in reality. Who would occupy the “pockets of intense dissatisfaction?” Why would they be angry about such developments? What would be the substance of their denigrations...if there were any substance to them at all?

     Contemplate those questions while I get more coffee.


     This morning, the following snippet from this interview with Camille Paglia provides much insight into our current political turmoil:

     Had Hillary won, everyone would have expected disappointed Trump voters to show a modicum of respect for the electoral results as well as for the historic ceremony of the inauguration, during which former combatants momentarily unite to pay homage to the peaceful transition of power in our democracy. But that was not the reaction of a vast cadre of Democrats shocked by Trump's win. In an abject failure of leadership that may be one of the most disgraceful episodes in the history of the modern Democratic party, Chuck Schumer, who had risen to become the Senate Democratic leader after the retirement of Harry Reid, asserted absolutely no moral authority as the party spun out of control in a nationwide orgy of rage and spite. Nor were there statesmanlike words of caution and restraint from two seasoned politicians whom I have admired for decades and believe should have run for president long ago—Senator Dianne Feinstein and Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi. How do Democrats imagine they can ever expand their electoral support if they go on and on in this self-destructive way, impugning half the nation as vile racists and homophobes?

     Candidate Trump played by the rules: he pursued an Electoral College victory, as is prescribed by the Constitution. The Democrats were shocked! shocked! that Trump had focused on winning the election rather than on securing a majority of the popular vote. Yet it was pretense from the very first. Had Clinton secured a victory in that fashion – and an Electoral College majority is the only way to win the presidency – they would have been strident in proclaiming Clinton’s political genius and insisting that the popular vote is of no ultimate importance.

     The Democrats were endlessly forgiving of actions and measures Barack Hussein Obama took as president that were at best Constitutionally dubious. They characterized any criticism of Obama or his methods as “racism.” They applauded as Obama disparaged the GOP and its major spokesmen in the most contemptuous fashion. They blamed the economic consequences of Obamunist policies on “Republican sabotage.” They spoke of permanent Democratic hegemony in Washington, and acted as if it had already been set in stone. They dismissed all warnings from the Right as sour-grapes backbiting.

     President Trump has exercised the legitimate, Constitutional powers of the presidency to fulfill several campaign promises. The economy and public confidence are already responding favorably. Yet he’s excited the most violent condemnation imaginable from prominent Democrats. Several have accused him of having stolen the election with assistance from the Russian government. There have been several calls for his impeachment, entirely without grounds. Accusations of every conceivable low motive have been hurled at him. Yet he’s done only what he said he would do while campaigning, albeit not all of it.

     Yes, President Trump faces significant opposition from Republicans as well: the so-called “NeverTrumpers.” That opposition largely accounts for the sluggishness with which his agenda has advanced, despite GOP control of both houses of Congress. And while some of those opponents are animated by the same envy and resentment that have fueled the Left’s year-long tantrum, some are unhappy with Trump for ideological or stylistic reasons. A sufficient degree of success might win the latter group over.


     Trump fights back. It’s one of the most significant contrasts he makes with prior Republican presidents. He who disparages Trump can expect a return of fire, usually solidly based in fact. As Don Surber has noted, a wise man, after reviewing the record to this point, would refrain from crossing rhetorical swords with Trump. Yet the fusillades continue.

     The reason can only be found in the very worst kind of envy: the hatred-filled rage of him who mutters “That should be me up there.” The lust for power characteristic of politicians, combined with the conviction that power is owed to oneself by right, can elicit such a reaction from any of them. One who has had his presidential aspirations defeated is especially prone to it.

     The political Left is all about power. It has no ideals; it exists solely to dominate...to oppress. There is no joy for them other than “a boot stamping on a human face.” The Leftist politician’s alliances and collaborations are tactical only; today’s ally can swiftly become tomorrow’s blood enemy, should he become a menace to one’s ambitions.

     Yes, there’s some envy and frustrated power-lust on the Right. But it’s not Republicans or conservatives straining to turn our city streets into zones of permanent chaos. It’s not Republicans or conservatives doing their damnedest to silence our spokesmen with vilification, vandalism, and violence. It’s certainly not Republicans screaming for Trump’s impeachment and trial, as if he’d wielded the presidency in the fashion of his predecessor.

     The political dynamic of the decade is deeply colored by hatred: the hatred of those who believe themselves entitled to rule the rest of us, for the movement that elevated their bitterest foe to the White House. That hatred will not be quenched by Trumpian success. Indeed, it would be inflamed by such a demonstration of its emptiness. That’s what we have to look forward to, should the president’s agenda bring the national resurgence for which we hope.

Sunday, April 30, 2017

A Future Of Violence: A Kinda-Sorta Rumination

     These past two days I’ve received a number of emails to the same general effect: “Why all the silliness and inanity, Fran?” Rather than answer them individually, I’ve decided to post on the subject here.

     It strikes me as a fit subject for Walpurgisnacht.


     A saying many Catholics will immediately recognize runs thus: “Every saint has a past; every sinner has a future.” It’s a byword of sorts among both clerics and lay communicants. We’re all flawed, all fallible, all susceptible to temptation. Most of us fall short of our ethical commitments at some point. It’s whether we recognize and recover from our missteps that matters most.

     Some don’t. Some reject any standard that would circumscribe their self-indulgences. Some willfully refuse to evaluate their own conduct. Some of those, having been shown the error of their ways by others, refuse to repent and reform. Instead, they “double down.”

     At some point, “doubling down” transforms what might otherwise have been a venial matter into a mortal one: one that imperils others quite as much as oneself.

     What sort of future does such a person face? Is it likely to be one of tranquility and satisfaction with his lot? What sort of persons would willingly gather around him? Would those who gather at his grave – if any – be likely to deem his life “a life well lived?”

     Don’t all answer at once, now.


     When Jesus said:

     Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye? Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye. [Matthew 7:1-5]

     ...He was referring to the judgment of others as persons. Deeds may be judged; indeed, we could hardly function, individually or socially, were we unwilling to do so. But judgements of others as persons are not ours to make. They’re reserved to Him.

     The implications of that stricture are far-reaching. They who offend us remain capable of repentance and reform, which is why those they’ve offended are expected to forgive them. Penalties there may be, but unending condemnation – theological condemnation – is forbidden to us. It’s the culmination of the sin of hatred, a capital sin about which we’ve been warned throughout the ages.

     Hatred converts most readily to violence.


     If you haven’t seen Viggo Mortensen’s marvelous star vehicle A History Of Violence, I urge you most imperatively to do so. Along with its immense cinematic impact, it provides two illustrations of the importance of forgiveness: one positive, one negative.

     The negative one arises in the climactic scene. Eddie Cusack, a highly-placed Philadelphia gangster played by the great William Hurt, is unwilling to forgive his younger brother Joey, played by Mortensen, for a deed that impeded Eddie’s rise through the ranks of organized crime. He’s willing to kill Joey for having obstructed his path, though events develop contrarily.

     The positive one is displayed in the final scene, when Joey’s wife, played by Maria Bello, regards him over their dinner table. He’s been good to her their whole lives together; early in the movie she calls him “the best man I’ve ever known,” and means it sincerely. Nor is her evaluation unique; everyone who knows him only as “Tom Stall” would concur. Whether she actually forgives him for the deception the events of the movie have revealed to their family is left unresolved...but this viewer, at least, got the sense that she would find a way to do so, as difficult as it might be.

     Forgiveness and hatred are supremely powerful choices. What follows from them can mend or shatter: individuals, families, and nations. We don’t always make the right choice between them.


     The United States of America in this year of Our Lord 2017 is seething with hatred. That hatred has already animated violence. More, it’s elicited a reciprocal hatred – and a reciprocal violence. If I haven’t conveyed to you, Gentle Reader, a sense for where those influences will lead us,. I’ve failed at my principal life mission and should probably renounce it forever.

     Jesus forgave the men who crucified Him:

     And when they were come to the place, which is called Calvary, there they crucified him, and the malefactors, one on the right hand, and the other on the left. Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots. [Luke 23:33-34]

     If He could forgive His own torturers and executioners, how much more imperative is it that we resolve to forgive those who have offended us?

     I’m not suggesting that anyone should refrain from defending himself, his loved ones, or his rights. I’m not suggesting that anyone should reply meekly to a blow from another. Turning the other cheek is for times of general civility, when such an event arises from misunderstanding that temporarily eclipses the otherwise predominant spirit of good will among men. Perhaps the thing about Jesus’s preachments that most astounded the Jews of Judea was His refusal to lead them in rebellion against the Roman occupiers. Yet those who bothered to ponder the matter learned a great lesson: that the maintenance of a general peace is more important than the identity of whoever currently maintains it.

     We Americans, who have known unbroken domestic peace since 1865, face a future of violence – a future in which all political questions are ultimately decided by the mailed fist – unless we can learn that lesson promptly and wholeheartedly.

     May God bless and keep you all.

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

Phyllis Schlafly, R.I.P.

     By now, the Gentle Readers of Liberty’s Torch have learned of the passing of the great Phyllis Schlafly, one of the most prominent conservative activists of the past half century. You’ve probably also learned of the outpouring of post-mortem hatred toward her from the Left. (UPDATE: See also this compendium.)

     The Left hated Schlafly for several reasons, but above all because she was magnificently effective. Many commentators have credited her personally with thwarting the Equal Rights Amendment. Her activism in other venues, especially in the cause of life and against the demands of gender-war feminists, never failed to spur the interest of conservatives and the dismay of Leftists nationwide. Here’s what Ann Coulter had to say about her:

     There is no more pristine example of the left’s “in-crowd” snobbery than their treatment of conservative author and activist Phyllis Schlafly....Her very name prompts derisive hoots from Hollywood starlets who couldn’t approach her IQ if they were having brains instead of silicone injected. To listen to the cool people, you could be forgiven for thinking that Schlafly is one step above a cretin. In fact, Schlafly is one of the most accomplished and influential people in America. [From Slander: Liberal Lies About the American Right.]

     Schlafly’s personal achievements include a Juris Doctor earned in her fifties, a popular radio show, a syndicated column, the founding of the influential Eagle Forum, and ten published books, most of which are on military policy. Her very first book, A Choice, Not An Echo, sold 3,000,000 copies, assured the 1964 nomination of Barry Goldwater, and ultimately led to the presidency of Ronald Reagan. Her military analysis was a major factor in the Reagan Administration’s High Frontier initiative. Her activism never ceased, despite her advancing age.

     To return to Coulter’s thoughts on Schlafly’s life and accomplishments:

     None of this is widely known because Schlafly doesn’t brag about it. There is certainly not the remotest possibility that the mainstream media will ever breathe a word of her extraordinary accomplishments. Schlafly had derailed the left’s precious sexual revolution. Consequently she is demeaned and censored by the champions of women’s advancement. There is a raw “1984” blackout quality to the media’s ideological refusal to acknowledge Schlafly while posting endless tributes to worthless feminist nothings....

     Schlafly’s feminist counterpart and molecular opposite is Gloria Steinem. While Schlafly is a serious intellectual, Steinem is a deeply ridiculous figure who succeeded as a journalist only by becoming the news rather than reporting it.

     The contrast could not be starker...but one guess which of these women the mainstream media adore and slather with praise.

     So it comes as little or no surprise that the death of Phyllis Schlafly should be treated bloodlessly by the media, while the Left heaps contempt upon her grave. De mortuis nil nisi bonum, we in the Right have said when some Leftist luminary has passed on. This bit of classical wisdom is apparently alien to the Left.

     Mrs. Schlafly, thank you for your tireless efforts in defense of freedom and the United States. May you rest forever in God’s arms. We who remain behind will miss you terribly.

Saturday, August 27, 2016

Saxons

It was not part of their blood,
It came to them very late,
With long arrears to make good,
When the Saxon began to hate.

They were not easily moved,
They were icy — willing to wait
Till every count should be proved,
Ere the Saxon began to hate.

Their voices were even and low.
Their eyes were level and straight.
There was neither sign nor show
When the Saxon began to hate.

It was not preached to the crowd.
It was not taught by the state.
No man spoke it aloud
When the Saxon began to hate.

It was not suddenly bred.
It will not swiftly abate.
Through the chilled years ahead,
When Time shall count from the date
That the Saxon began to hate.

-- Rudyard Kipling --

     It would seem at this time that campaigns of condemnation amounting to outright hatred have become “ho hum,” “just one of those things,” and “nothing to write home about.” This is especially the case when the target of such a campaign can be associated with some behavior, attitude, or concept that the public has been exhorted to hate. And there are more such campaigns, whether organized or not, than ever before in American history.

     Remarkable, eh? It calls an old Tom Lehrer song to mind:

     Of course, there are more “behaviors, attitudes, and concepts to hate” being urged upon us today than ever before, too. I’m on the negative end of many of them, so I’m more than merely aware of the vilification being heaped upon them (and me).

     Make no mistake about it: If you hold to certain beliefs, many of which are well supported by evidence, there’s a significant body of people who: 1) hate you for it, and: 2) encourage others to hate you as well. Moreover, their hatred is fundamentally insincere. They don’t hate you out of the true, visceral perception of a profound moral wrong willingly embraced. They “hate” you and exhort others to do so because they hope to get something that way, usually through the political system.

     Welcome to the age of strategic hatred.


     John Hinderaker of PowerLine has a few words for us about the fomenting of hatred:

     I don’t think we have said much about Hillary Clinton’s speech in which she denounced Donald Trump as a racist of the “alt-right,” thereby confusing, no doubt, most of her audience. Much could be said about Hillary’s smears–a Republican racist running for president? Not again!–but I want to comment on just one aspect of it: her claim that “the billionaire businessman’s campaign [is] one that will ‘make America hate again.'”

     My question is: where has Hillary been for the last eight years? Has she failed to notice that she was part of an administration that went a long way toward making America hate again? Her boss, Barack Obama, deliberately fomented racial conflict for the purpose of political gain.

     Indeed. Yet Barack Hussein Obama wasn’t the originator of strategic hatred; he saw that it had been used effectively by the Left and by various left-leaning special interests, and adopted it for his own. He put it to use to excite racial hatred – specifically hatred among blacks toward whites – perhaps hoping that it would solidify his grip on power and cow the Republican opposition into acquiescing to his policies.

     But in social systems as in mechanical systems, action will always be met by reaction. The rise of racial animosity among blacks toward whites has evoked an equal but opposite feeling among whites toward blacks. As American whites are six to seven times as numerous as American blacks, this is not a lever that favors black aspirations, regardless of their nature.

     If we look at the illegal-immigration problem through this lens, the same sort of picture appears. Hispanic populations in California and the Southwest have become ever more militant and demanding. The majority of that demographic is in this country illegally. The more aggressively quarrelsome it becomes, the greater the reaction against it among American whites.

     Focus your attention on any identifiable group – feminists, homosexuals, Muslims, Bernie Sanders-style social fascists, or left-liberals generally – and the picture is essentially the same: those that have promoted the hatred of persons outside their group have elicited reactive hatred in equal measure. They should fear the probable consequences. However, most are either too arrogant or too stupid to do so.


     We come now to the nascent coalescence of those reactive hatreds: what’s been called the Alt-Right. Theodore “Vox Day” Beale has prepared a sort of bullet-point definition of this agglomeration. After his sixteen individual theses, he says:

     The Alt Right is a Western ideology that believes in science, history, reality, and the right of a genetic nation to exist and govern itself in its own interests.

     I have no doubt that whether or not he believes that summary to be an accurate characterization of the Alt-Right, Beale sincerely wants it to be so. Unfortunately, at this time that’s not the case. Many persons – possibly the majority – who’ve adopted the Alt-Right label are moved by a reactive animosity toward a single group they perceive to have targeted them or their priorities. Mind you, those folks might be absolutely correct about having been so targeted. That doesn’t mean that they subscribe to the broader list of convictions Beale has enumerated.

     Because the Alt-Right is at this time mostly a notion being entertained by writers and commentators, it’s easily put to use by propagandists for purposes of their own. Under this video on the subject there’s a brief statement that many who might otherwise find “Alt-Right” a suitable label for their convictions would reject:

     Equality is bullshit. Hierarchy is essential. The races are different. The sexes are different. Morality matters and degeneracy is real. All cultures are not equal and we are not obligated to think they are. Man is a fallen creature and there is more to life than hollow materialism. Finally, the white race matters, and civilisation is precious. This is the Alt-Right.

     Mind you, I agree with that statement. However, tone matters, and the tone thereof is belligerent, off-putting to many. Worse, the video nods to a kind of neo-anti-Semitism:

     Unjust, untrue, and deplorable – yet it was probably inevitable. The Jews have been scapegoated for centuries, both in Europe and here in America. Yet no people anywhere more passionately desires to be left in peace. Their “influence” arises from being above-average achievers, especially in scholarship and commerce...things a decent person can only admire.

     But when “the Saxon” begins to hate, he tends to lose a portion of his power to discriminate fairly. Old resentments, including some that were and are utterly unjust, will be lumped in with the newer ones.


     The next few months will surely see further discussion and polemics about this subject. It will be critical to remain critical: i.e., to insist upon the critical distinctions among facts, desires, opinions, values, and assumptions. Whether the term “Alt-Right” requires a firm, widely accepted definition will be part of the discourse. The “conventional Right,” which many regard as too Establishmentarian for the needs of the times, will participate – and not in a fashion that favors its competitors.

     For my part, I’m certain only of this: the old labels conservative, liberal, libertarian, socialist, authoritarian, et cetera will not be sufficient to express the passions that have flared in this era of pervasive and often strategic hatred, much less to contain them. Our discourse has already moved beyond them. It will move further still...and our actions will move with it.