Thursday, November 19, 2026

Today’s Exception To Due Process

     A lot of people are exercised about the things Immigration & Customs Enforcement agents are doing in the effort to undo decades of illegal immigration. They regularly scream about “due process,” but have largely been ignored. Whether an illegal alien is due any particular sort of process before being expelled is up for debate, but the cries are plaintive nonetheless.

     “Due process of law” is a hallowed Constitutional phrase. However, it lacks precise definition. At one time, the only sort of due process we recognized was a court hearing or trial. Today quite a few things have been passed off as “due process” that bear no resemblance to a court hearing. What “due process” applied to the “lockdowns” of 2020?

     Today at the Brownstone Institute, we have this article on the Russell Brand case:

     This month, Russell Brand was sentenced to over a decade in prison for supposedly “raping” women over 20 years ago. The trial allowed the purported victims to recreate phone exchanges from memory, featured a lengthy analysis of whether Mr. Brand grabbed a woman’s breasts in 2004, and considered whether Mr. Brand attempted to coerce a woman into a bathroom stall in 2001. The entire case was devoid of physical evidence, and the charges only came after Channel 4 and the Sunday Times (owned by NewsCorp and Rupert Murdoch) released a “documentary” in which hired actresses portrayed unverified accounts of Brand committing sexual assault.
     The reasonable doubt in the Brand trial is undeniable. The prosecution offered no forensic evidence, DNA tests, or CCTV footage. The testimony was the product of memories of over 20 years that frequently changed to suit the narrative of the post-“documentary” era. For example, one “victim” originally told friends that Brand had made unwanted advances on her at a bar, but she had escaped before anything occurred. Then, after seeing the Times documentary, she told the police that Mr. Brand dragged her into a toilet (in front of the crowded bar) and raped her.
     But in the believe-all-women exception to due process, the court chastised Mr. Brand’s counsel for cross-examining the accusers. Justice Bennathan scolded Brand, “all those women had to face being confronted and being told they had lied or twisted the truth and, or, they had agreed to your sexual demands: that was all done because of you, on your instructions.” He later denounced Mr. Brand’s “staggering arrogance” and “dreadful behavior.”

     Scandalous, no? The desire of the political Establishment of the United Kingdom to diminish Brand’s influence was so great that it perverted its own legal procedures, even descending to letting a trial judge behave as chronicled above. The overriding aim was to imprison Brand, and thus silence him. Nothing else mattered as much as that.

     Yes, it’s happened in America, or very nearly so. We’ve had the Tawana Brawley scandal, the Duke lacrosse players scandal, the Christine Blasey Ford scandal, and most recently the E. Jean Carroll scandal. And I almost forgot the Anita Hill scandal! Unforgivable!

     Those are just the highest-profile cases in which a woman’s accusation of rape or sexual misconduct was enough to ruin the lives of innocent men. Of actual evidence there was none. But the frothing at the mouth of “women’s rights” activists and their allies was sufficient to subject the accused to torture by lawfare.

     In the cases I just enumerated, sanity eventually prevailed. But damage was done anyway, including to the fortunes and reputations of two Supreme Court Justices and an American president.

     The Brownstone article categorizes such houndings as the fruits of “moral panic:”

     In Crawford v. Washington, the late Justice Antonin Scalia wrote “the only indicium of reliability sufficient to satisfy constitutional demands is the one the Constitution actually prescribes: confrontation.” Yet the permanent moral panic prohibits fulfillment of those constitutional demands in sexual assault cases.
     Instead, we get a system of kangaroo courts and media lynchings, giving rise to attorneys like Michael Avenatti, accusers like Julie Swetnick, journalists like Sabrina Erdely at Rolling Stone, and actual victims like the Duke lacrosse team.

     The Cornell Seven are the latest American victims of this “moral panic.” Russell Brand differs only in being a target of the political elite of the U.K. But above all particulars and specifics rises a more pressing question:

What justifies exceptions to Constitutional law?

     When the text is clear, the intent cannot be “interpreted” away. The Sixth Amendment is perfectly clear on this subject:

     In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.

     Those protections are inheritances from the legal tradition of England, which was itself founded on the laws and practices of the Roman Republic and later Empire.

     The “moral panic” over sexual assault has bulled its way through the Sixth Amendment, to the ruination of many innocent men. But there’s no reason why a similar panic could not afflict us over some other subject. Illegal immigration is the hottest current topic, but watch out for “national security!” Our political Establishment has many times found that to be an axe that can smash a Constitutional protection. Then there’s “public health” to be considered. But I find that I’m on the verge of frothing at the mouth myself, so I think I’ll close there.

No comments: