Thursday, December 19, 2013

Assorted

Yes, yes, I know it’s neither Tuesday nor Friday, but...well...!


1. More Than Coincidence?

Have a few monitory tidbits from Freedom Outpost:

#21 The U.S. government has spent an astounding 3.7 trillion dollars on welfare programs over the past five years.

#31 If you assume that the labor force participation rate in the U.S. is at the long-term average, the unemployment rate in the United States would actually be 11.5 percent instead of 7 percent.

#47 After accounting for inflation, 40 percent of all U.S. workers are making less than what a full-time minimum wage worker made back in 1968.

#48 When Barack Obama took office, the average duration of unemployment in this country was 19.8 weeks. Today, it is 37.2 weeks.

#63 Back in 1950, more than 80 percent of all men in the United States had jobs. Today, less than 65 percent of all men in the United States have jobs.

#82 Back in 1972, 46 percent of all Americans believed that “most people can be trusted”. Today, only 32 percent of all Americans believe that “most people can be trusted”.

We are being impoverished, made into clients of the State, and driven apart from one another -- simultaneously. Does it matter at all whether this is the intended outcome?


2. Civility Watch.

Apparently, the newest Obamunist hire, John Podesta, doesn’t like conservatives or Republicans and doesn’t care who knows it:

Today, Politico confirmed that governing-by-executive-fiat is exactly what Podesta has in mind. The only shocking part of the story is Podesta's justification for shredding the Constitution:
In effect, I was told, it represents the clearest sign to date of the administration’s interest in shifting the paradigm of Obama’s presidency through the forceful, unapologetic and occasionally provocative application of White House power. Podesta, whose official mandate includes enforcement of numerous executive orders on emissions and the environment, suggested as much when he spoke with me earlier this fall about Obama’s team. “They need to focus on executive action given that they are facing a second term against a cult worthy of Jonestown in charge of one of the houses of Congress,” he told me.

That's right. Obama's new counselor, the man in charge of saving his presidency, believes the Republican Party is a murderous cult and that this justifies Obama's extra-constitutional use of executive power.

Let’s have a few pictures of Podesta’s face with a crosshairs over it and see how he, his masters, and his buddies in the media react.


3. Did You Really Believe It’s Just A Myth?

The 2012 presidential election wasn’t one of the very closest in American history – Hayes v Tilden was a lot closer, as was Bush v. Gore – but one side definitely did what it could to widen its margin of victory:

Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted announced Wednesday that his office found 17 non-citizens illegally cast ballots in the 2012 presidential election -- and has referred the case for possible prosecution....

"I have a responsibility to uphold election law, and under both federal and state law you must be a citizen to vote," said Husted, a Republican who has aggressively tried to investigate voter fraud cases in his state....

As part of Ohio's efforts to clean up the voting rolls, election officials discovered that more than 257,000 dead people were still listed as active voters. Their names and status, Husted said, have since been removed.

In addition, election authorities note they have drastically reduced the number of duplicate registrations, from 340,000 in 2011 to just four this past November -- and that more than 370,000 Ohio voters who have moved have been contacted to update their voting information.

Remember that the federal Department of Justice, under that great American Eric “A Nation of Cowards” Holder, did its best to prevent the cleansing of illegitimate entries from the states’ voters’ rolls before the 2012 elections.


4. Beware The Enraged Pansy!

When Duck Dynasty’s Phil Robertson said the following:

“It seems like, to me, a woman’s vagina would be more desirable than a man’s anus. That’s just me,” Robertson told the magazine. “I’m just thinking: There’s more there! She’s got more to offer. I mean, come on, dudes! You know what I’m saying? But hey, sin: It’s not logical, my man. It’s just not logical.”

When the reporter asked Robertson what he found sinful, he said “Start with homosexual behavior and just morph out from there. Bestiality, sleeping around with this woman and that woman and that woman and those men.”

The self-proclaimed religious convert then went on to paraphrase Corinthians: “Don’t be deceived. Neither the adulterers, the idolaters, the male prostitutes, the homosexual offenders, the greedy, the drunkards, the slanderers, the swindlers—they won’t inherit the kingdom of God. Don’t deceive yourself. It’s not right.”

...many commentators noted that the Arts & Entertainment network, which is heavily supported by homosexual-activist groups, would be put under intense pressure to penalize him.

Well, looky here:

On December 18th A&E suspended Duck Dynasty patriarch Phil Robertson "indefinitely" for comments he made regarding his views on homosexuality.

The comments came during an interview appearing in the January issue of GQ magazine.

According to the Chicago Tribune, A&E released the following statement in response: "We are extremely disappointed to have read Phil Robertson's comments in GQ, which are based on his own personal beliefs and are not reflected in the series Duck Dynasty."

Duck Dynasty is the most popular show on television today. You’d think that would lend its stars a certain amount of clout. Apparently those Panjandrums of Sodomitic Perversion, the American Association of Fudge-Packers and Meat-Smokers -- i.e., the homosexual-activist groups -- are stronger. There’s a lesson in there, somewhere.


5. Stick To The Scripts You’re Handed, Sweetie.

Cate Blanchett is a gifted actress, a beautiful woman...and a complete and total air-head:

Cate Blanchett, who is paid a reported $10 million to appear in perfume advertisements, would like to discuss the sacrifices made by herself and other planet-saving celebrities:
We need to keep switching up the language around climate change. For so long we’ve talked about sacrifice and people get discredited for what they haven’t given up. [Celebrities] get criticised for taking flights, but the truth is someone like Leo [DiCaprio] takes fewer flights than he’s asked to. If we want it to stay on the radar, we need to focus on the fact there’s a lot of opportunity.

We truly do not appreciate their suffering.

Miss Blanchett is entitled to her opinions, but apparently she doesn’t have enough mental horsepower to recognize the damage her comments are doing to the very cause she champions. Well, if actors were brainy, they’d be quantum physicists, right? Right?


That’s all for today, Gentle Reader. Good night and have a pleasant tomorrow.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

What else do you want to know?

Breitbart.com: So, Obama’s mentor worked in communist fronts and activities with Valerie Jarrett’s father-in-law and grandfather?

Kengor: Precisely.

"Big Mentor: The Troika—Obama, Axelrod, Jarrett." By Breitbart News, 8/8/12.

Putting It All Together

Many are the mornings on which I awaken, grope my way toward rationality, and find myself wondering if I'll manage to find anything to write about that day. Yet few are the mornings that I don't look back on that passage of doubt with a certain rueful amusement.


The brilliant Richard Epstein has written a must-read article on judges' "editing" of the Constitution. Epstein is notable among Constitutional scholars not merely for his penetration and erudition, but also for his facility for mating his legal and Constitutional knowledge to economic forces and the consequences they create from aspects of public policy. An example from his article follows:

Section 8. Clause 1. The Congress shall have Power to lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States.

This clause is a big deal because it remedies one of the major defects of the Articles of Confederation, under which the federal government had to beg the individual states for the revenues needed to discharge its own collective function. But in overturning earlier practice, the Founders were nervous about lurching too far in the opposite direction, so they limited the general power of taxation to three specified objects: “payment of debts, provision of common Defence, and the general Welfare of the United States.”

So it is important to understand that the clause is not a catchall that sweeps in every objective under the sun. Federal taxes are meant to fund only a short list of public—i.e. nonexcludable—goods that only the central government can provide. The Congressional power to levy taxes is needed to prevent free-riding by individual states. The limited purposes help prevent politically corrosive cross-subsidies between states that could sink the Union.

Epstein has detected a judicial edit: the reduction of the phrase "general Welfare of the United States" to merely "general Welfare." What follows is an example of proper, text-respecting Constitutional interpretation:

The proper interpretation of the clause raises thorny questions about whether, for example, the United States could provide disaster relief that benefits some but not all states. President Grover Cleveland thought that the answer was an emphatic “no” in 1887 when he vetoed the Texas Seed Bill, which allocated $10,000 for Texas drought relief. Under the Constitution, he did “not believe that the power and duty of the General Government ought to be extended to the relief of individual suffering which is in no manner properly related to the public service or benefit.” Indeed, the vital element in this clause is that it prohibits any transfer payment from one group of individuals to another, as those cannot serve the “general welfare of the United States.” To see why, take the analogous case where a corporate charter allows the Board of Directors to adopt only those measures that advance the general welfare of the corporation. Without question, the so-called business judgment rule insulates corporate officers and directors when they work in good faith to advance the welfare of the corporation, and thus all its shareholders, in transactions with third parties. But it is a per se violation of that rule for the directors to tax one subclass of shareholders in order to pay dividends to a second subclass. All transfer payments among shareholders clearly violate their duty to advance the welfare of shareholders as a group.

I find myself thinking of a famous historical exchange: the one between Davy Crockett and Horatio Bunce. You'll find Epstein's elucidation of the Taxing Power clause mirrored in Bunce's sentiments.


Following upon Epstein's article, we have this column from Nicholas James Pell:

December 5, 2013 was the 80th annual Repeal Day, AKA the day that Prohibition was repealed. It is the highest holiday for me and my coreligionists, the American Drunkards (Unreformed). Prohibition is widely regarded as the biggest mistake in American policy ever. It’s hard to imagine now—especially in Los Angeles, where there’s a head shop on every corner—but for 13 years, a rabid coalition of progressive puritan do-gooders successfully forced Americans to make do with bathtub gin.

Prohibition created organized crime and killed California’s nascent wine industry. Historians have largely written Prohibition’s history to serve its greatest proponents: the progressive crypto-Unitarian puritans who currently dominate public discourse. We are led to believe that rather than part and parcel of the progressive movement, Prohibition was a conservative folly, the solitary “move forward” from the past that we can all agree was a step in the wrong direction. This is a blatant falsehood: Prohibition was, through and through, part of a broader movement that sought to impose a hyper-Protestant post-millennialism on the rest of us who love wine, women, and song....

Mostly we’re left with the progressive puritan notion that the state has the right—nay, the duty—to combat evil wherever it might rear its ugly head in the world. We’re also left with a teleological concept of the American Republic wherein each subsequent generation is responsible for righting the wrongs of the last. Whether it’s raising the minimum wage or affirmative action, it is now an officially prescribed function of the federal government to make the world a better place. Sure, liberty is cool and everything, but isn’t equality a lot better, maaaan?

Still, Repeal Day offers a glimmer of hope through another historical lesson: It is, in fact, possible to turn back the clock. As 100 legislators from over 30 states gathered less than a week after Repeal Day to discuss passing the so-called Liberty Amendments—nothing that strikes so much terror into the editorial board of Daily Kos and Slate can be all bad—it’s prudent to remember that arguably the best Amendment to the Constitution was passed in just such a manner.

The repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment by the Twenty-First was indeed a joyous occasion, though the enormous damage it (and the previous two Amendments) had done to the nation was not completely reversed. (BATFE, anyone?) But even more significant than the Eighteenth's repeal was its passage in the first place: Congress admitted that to outlaw the manufacture and sale of alcoholic beverages was not, by the Constitution as it stood, within its enumerated powers. Either the legislators of that time were more honest than those of today, or they were better restrained by external forces.

Chief Justice John Marshall, in McCulloch v. Maryland, wrote thus of the matter:

This government is acknowledged by all, to be one of enumerated powers. The principle, that it can exercise only the powers granted to it, would seem too apparent, to have required to be enforced by all those arguments, which its enlightened friends, while it was depending before the people, found it necessary to urge; that principle is now universally admitted.

Unfortunately, he went on to write thus:

Let the end be legitimate, let it be within the scope of the constitution, and all means which are appropriate, which are plainly adapted to that end, which are not prohibited, but consist with the letter and spirit of the constitution, are constitutional

...citing the Necessary and Proper clause as his rationale. Subsequent legislators and jurists have proved appallingly creative in their interpretations of "legitimate," "appropriate," and "within the scope of the Constitution."


In a cri de coeur piece at Doug Ross @ Journal, financial executive Richard Larsen vents his displeasure over America's accelerating slide into tyranny at...conservatives!

When you think about it quantitatively, conservatives are mostly to blame for our current modified state of the union. How many conservatives refuse to vote if their candidate is not in the race, or are disengaged or oblivious to the destruction occurring around us, or do nothing, or say nothing, to preserve and protect our constitutional republic?

Conservatives have allowed this transformation to occur, by acquiescent reticence. I think no one has stated it more perfectly than Albert Einstein who said, “The world is a dangerous place not because of those who do evil, but because of those who look on and do nothing.”

Speaking out against this erosion of freedom is good, but it’s simply not enough, and it must be more vociferous and protracted. Too many battle among themselves for ideological purity, fight amongst themselves over the most efficacious political tactics, or just throw verbal stones at those whose destructive policies are morphing the country into something never intended, but then flame out before anything is accomplished. If they don’t bother to vote, don’t get involved in the process, and don’t try to make a difference electorally, and worse yet, are divisive to the conservative ranks, they deserve some of the blame for what is happening. Every conservative must do what he can, and most of all, to vote. If every conservative voted in every election, statists wouldn’t stand a chance.

Nonsense. Nonsense of the purest water, and a man as intelligent and accomplished as Larsen should know it. Conservatives are the persons most likely to vote in any election, biennial or quadrennial. Indeed, the Republican Party appears to bend most of its electoral effort into chivvying us to the polls no matter who it puts forward as candidates -- and we go. Energetically or dispiritedly, we go. The problem isn't conservatives; it's the candidates we're presented, most of whom are only cosmetically attractive.

Constitutional governance requires that the government remain within its Constitutional bounds. Tautology, I know. All the same, it's true -- so what are we supposed to do when Republicans, supposedly the sworn protectors of the Constitution and promoters of limited government, lie down before the Democrats' carriage, as they've done repeatedly since 1933? Vote them out and install a new set? Okay, we've tried that. Has it made a perceptible difference? Have the new legislators been any more faithful to their oaths of office than the men they displaced?

Yes, there are exceptions among the newest Congressmen and Senators. But "new" is a diminishing attribute. Few are the legislators who, after three or four terms in their seats, don't adopt the go-along-to-get-along / we-can-do-it-better-and-cheaper postures of the old boars. Their party puts the screws to them in numerous ways. The alternative to submission is often getting an actual job.

This was foreseeable from the day the Sixteenth Amendment was passed. Unfortunately, I wasn't around back then.


Government Systems, acting in accordance with the laws of growth, Tend to Expand and Encroach. In encroaching upon their own citizens, they produce Tyranny, and encroaching upon other Government Systems, they engage in Warfare. -- John Gall, Systemantics

If there's truly a "quiet rage" accumulating among "silent" Americans, it has only two routes to follow: massive gastric distress or armed revolt.

Gall's citation of the "laws of growth" depends upon a theorem that cannot be proved but that's never been contradicted by evidence: That which is not growing is dying. Governments are like living organisms in that regard. They grow from the internal dynamic that animates all living and pseudo-living systems. Cyril Northcote Parkinson, David Friedman, and others have expanded on this phenomenon. There appear to be no counterexamples in the history of nation-states: governments grow until they collapse or are brought down by war or revolution.

A government that will not restrain itself, that perpetually ignores the plain text of its chartering document, that's staffed by persons who view ordinary citizens with disdain or worse, and that cannot be corrected by peaceful means will either flower fully into totalitarianism or be brought low by the force of arms. Just now, we're seeing the unfolding of the former process; the latter one appears nowhere on the horizon.

The Constitution of the United States was an attempt to countervail the "laws of growth" by formal and procedural means. To work, it had to be respected exactly as written. Indeed, the Founders were so precise in their language that the attempt to insert a semicolon where a comma was intended brought down censure upon the perpetrator.

Who in public office today would hew to that strict a standard? The Constitution worked reasonably well for about 125 years. However, as Herbert Spencer has noted, "Paper constitutions raise smiles upon the faces of those who have observed their results." All such charters require enforcement to be meaningful over a long interval...and with the sole, glittering exception of the Eighteenth and Twenty-First Amendments, ours has gone unenforced since at least 1913.

The pieces of this puzzle are not numerous, Gentle Reader:

  • Major parties controlled by untouchable kingmakers;
  • A "two-party system" effectively protected by electoral law;
  • Loose and tendentious construction of the Constitution by the courts;
  • Congress's delegation of its lawmaking power to the "alphabet agencies;"
  • Legislators and executives beyond the reach of peaceful means of correction.

It's time we put it all together.

UPDATE: A reader informs me that the link to the "semicolon episode" story no longer works. Here's another citation, though the author of that document says that he doubts that the story is true. Whether it's true or not, there's a comma where a comma belongs -- and you may be sure that the Founders would not have had it any other way.

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Failurists

There are days it seems to me that the openly left-wing media such as NPR hire only commentators and prognosticators who have been certified incapable of understanding incentives. This remarkably myopic article is the latest evidence. Here's the bit that lit my boilers this morning:

...clans and families on Easter Island didn't fall apart. It's true, the island became desolate, emptier. The ecosystem was severely compromised. And yet, say the anthropologists, Easter Islanders didn't disappear. They adjusted. They had no lumber to build canoes to go deep-sea fishing. They had fewer birds to hunt. They didn't have coconuts. But they kept going on rat meat and small helpings of vegetables. They made do.

One niggling question: If everybody was eating enough, why did the population decline? Probably, the professors say, from sexually transmitted diseases after Europeans came visiting.

OK, maybe there was no "ecocide." But is this good news? Should we celebrate?

I wonder. What we have here are two scenarios ostensibly about Easter Island's past, but really about what might be our planet's future. The first scenario — an ecological collapse — nobody wants that. But let's think about this new alternative — where humans degrade their environment but somehow "muddle through." Is that better? In some ways, I think this "success" story is just as scary.

What if the planet's ecosystem, as J.B. MacKinnon puts it, "is reduced to a ruin, yet its people endure, worshipping their gods and coveting status objects while surviving on some futuristic equivalent of the Easter Islanders' rat meat and rock gardens?"

Humans are a very adaptable species. We've seen people grow used to slums, adjust to concentration camps, learn to live with what fate hands them. If our future is to continuously degrade our planet, lose plant after plant, animal after animal, forgetting what we once enjoyed, adjusting to lesser circumstances, never shouting, "That's It!" — always making do, I wouldn't call that "success."

People can't remember what their great-grandparents saw, ate and loved about the world. They only know what they know. To prevent an ecological crisis, we must become alarmed. That's when we'll act. The new Easter Island story suggests that humans may never hit the alarm.

[Link courtesy of Random Nuclear Strikes.]

Author Robert Krulwich has adopted wholesale a version of Easter Island's history purveyed by two Hawaiian anthropologists, Terry Hunt and Carl Lipo. If true, would it eventuate in the conditions found on Easter Island by Twentieth Century visitors from civilized lands? It seems so. Is it well supported by any form of evidence? Unclear, as no evidence is presented in the article. But the implications Krulwich wants us to draw are as plain as a fart:

  • Human beings don't possess enough memory or intelligence to grasp the consequences of their actions;
  • Success in the economic sense leads inevitably to socioeconomic deterioration and decay;
  • We need to become "alarmed," such that the Omnipotent State will rescue us from our drive for "success."

A clearer brief for ecological alarmism, after the fashion of the "global warming / climate change" fanatics, could hardly be composed. After all, we need to be "alarmed." We're too undersupplied with information, too numb to cause and effect, and too inflexible in the face of evidence to react as wisely as our betters. They simply must take us in hand, strip away what remains of our freedom to live, work, and prosper as we please...for our own good!

Splendor of the risen Christ, there are days I think that even one more article this contemptuous of Mankind will tip me over. If only our "betters" would wear some identifying sigil -- preferably something easily recognized at a couple of hundred years' distance -- I'd hit the supermarket for a fresh package of Oreo Double-Stufs,® unpack the Barrett .50, and go looking for a well placed clock tower.

But that's enough of happy fantasies. Until Christmas morning, at least.


Why are the eco-fascists so determined to stamp out human economic progress? How many of them are sincere? Are the rest merely power-seekers, or ought we to look for additional motivations for so much Chicken-Littleism?

I find it hard to credit any great number with sincere convictions, inasmuch as so few practice what they preach. "The man who eats meat cannot sneer at the butcher," as Heinlein put it. The eco-fascists tend to live just as well as the sane among us -- and in some cases, so indulgently as to defeat any imaginable attempt at rationalization.

Once sincerity is subtracted, only low motivations remain.

The power motivation is the obvious one. Eco-alarmism is an obvious play for totalitarian power over all of life. Were we to cede our remaining freedom to the cause of "protecting the planet" from our supposed eco-villainy, no imaginable development would fail to be used as a rationale for confining and restricting us. I have no doubt that there are many in the eco-fascist movement for whom that is the end in view:

What to do, when a ship carrying a hundred passengers suddenly capsizes and there is only one lifeboat? When the lifeboat is full, those who hate life will try to load it with more people and sink the lot. Those who love and respect life will take the ship’s axe and sever the extra hands that cling to the sides....

The United States symbolises the worst ideologies in the world: growth and freedom....

Any dictatorship would be better than modern democracy. There cannot be so incompetent a dictator that he would show more stupidity than a majority of the people. The best dictatorship would be one where lots of heads would roll and where government would prevent any economical growth.

We will have to learn from the history of revolutionary movements — the national socialists, the Finnish Stalinists, from the many stages of the Russian revolution, from the methods of the Red Brigades — and forget our narcissistic selves.

A fundamental, devastating error is to set up a political system based on desire. Society and life have been organized on the basis of what an individual wants, not on what is good for him or her....

Just as only one out of 100,000 has the talent to be an engineer or an acrobat, only a few are those truly capable of managing the matters of a nation or mankind as a whole. In this time and this part of the World we are headlessly hanging on democracy and the parliamentary system, even though these are the most mindless and desperate experiments of mankind. In democratic countries the destruction of nature and sum of ecological disasters has accumulated most. Our only hope lies in strong central government and uncompromising control of the individual citizen.

Take a moment to shudder over that before we turn to the motivation that will really sicken you.


A brief digression to an important ancillary topic: In a low-energy, subsistence-only economy, where an individual's life consists solely of actions performed to keep him alive, there is no "extra" time, and certainly no pool of "extra" resources, with which to attend to developing crises, including crises that can be clearly foreseen. An economy locked into a subsistence-only pattern will inevitably experience the sort of degradation that beset the Easter Islanders, precisely because its members will have no way to avert nor escape it without endangering their immediate survival.

Are the trees falling? Is the moisture departing the soil? Are rats overrunning the island and eliminating what little prospect of agriculture might remain? Nothing to be done about it just now; we're all too hungry. Besides, the search for potable water takes what little time we have left after we've harvested and consumed the morning's ration of rat tartare.

Only a high-energy economy can cope with such developments. First, it provides its members with the economic signals -- prices -- required to foretell a looming crisis. Second, it accumulates the resources needed to cope with such a development. Third and finally, it enables its members to work against it without sacrificing the needs of immediate survival. Where subsistence economies dwindle and die, high-energy trade-based economies adapt and prosper still further.

Which sort of economy was that of Easter Island?


The most important low motivation for demanding the suppression of economic growth and the resultant prosperity is envy: the desire to see another person brought low even at cost to oneself. Joseph Sobran and others have called it "hatred of the good for being good," which captures the corruption at the core of the envy-ridden soul. It is a wholly destructive emotion. In tandem with tribal hatreds, it is responsible for nearly all the misery in pre-civilized societies. Yet, as Helmut Schoeck has so brilliantly pointed out, it is the animating force behind every campaign that flies the banners of "redistribution" or "social justice:"

Envy is ineluctable, implacable and irreconcilable, is irritated by the slightest differences, is independent of the degree of inequality, appears in its worst form in social proximity among near relatives, provides the dynamic for every revolution yet cannot of itself produce any kind of coherent revolutionary program.

The hatred of the envious synergizes beautifully with the desires of power-seekers. Indeed, the emissions of American power-seekers are principally concerned with eliciting envy from targeted groups and then promising to assuage it if given power. This program is centuries old. It's not new even here in America; the history of the "Progressive" movement, all the way back to the Benthamites and the followers of Edward Bellamy, bears this out in full.

The very first thing to suspect of a man who demands that which is not his by right is that he's driven by envy. The first thing to suspect of a public figure such as the odious Robert Reich, who harps on "inequality" and demands redistribution or economic control by the State, is that he seeks to mobilize the envious to propel him to power.

In neither case should their demands be respected in even the slightest degree.


Leaving aside questions of motivation for the nonce, the plaints of the Krulwiches, the Reiches, and the rest of their ilk are attacks upon growth, prosperity, and success as we have known it. What they advocate, whether expressly or sotto voce, is failure. Those who protest that they merely want to halt or restrain growth are either deluded or deceitful, for the stasis they claim to champion is entirely unstable. Introduce any perturbation whatsoever into their scheme and it collapses with a swiftness to boggle the imagination.

The end in view is always power over others: either the totalitarian control for which power-seekers have yearned since Man first walked upright, or the power to destroy those who, being exemplars of success and well-being, cast shadows upon the envious by their very existence.

Let them be recognized and labeled as what they are: failurists, men who create nothing, yet demand that the rest of us huddle in the cold and the dark.

Grant them neither respect nor respite.

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Death by Government

The following post has been shamelessly stolen from HERE with the author's permission for three reasons:
1.It needs the widest possible exposure
2. It exposes the mindset of the pc mainstream media, and
3. This ageing blogster lacks the literary capabilities to improve upon it

Government More Likely to Kill Your Kids Than a School Shooter Is

By Thomas Hochmann
December 14th, 2013
Government More Likely to Kill Your Kids Than a School Shooter Is
In light of the sensationalist news coverage of yesterday's Arapahoe High School shooting, I thought it would be fun to look at some actual facts about school shootings. I know, I know... It's so old fashioned to resort to such inconvenient things as facts. Please forgive me for committing this grave sin against the journalistic standards of the 21st century.
First off, there are 132,656 K-12 schools in the US. From 2003 to date, there have been 76 shootings in US schools. 53 of those shootings resulted in deaths. Thus, over this 10 year period, the US has experienced an average of 5.3 fatal school shootings per year. Using these numbers, you can figure out that the odds that any given school will experience a fatal shooting during an entire calendar year are about 1 in 25,029.
Compare that figure that to the odds that you will die from:
  • An air travel accident (1 in 20,000)
  • Drowning (1 in 8,942)
  • Electrocution (1 in 5,000)
  • Falling down (1 in 246)
  • Committing suicide (1 in 121)
  • A car crash (1 in 100)
According to Wikipedia, "schools will do a lockdown drill one or two times per year." In anticipation of an event that has a 1 in 25,029 chance of actually occurring at a given school, children have a 100% certainty that they will be terrorized by the school itself at least once every year. On any given school day, there's at least a 1 in 270 chance that the school will frighten the crap out of your child with a lockdown drill.
Schools don't have mandatory drowning drills (though death by drowning is twice as likely as experiencing a fatal school attack), or mandatory "how not to fall down" classes (100 times as likely), or mandatory "don't get in a car because you might die" drills (250 times). They don't even devote this much shock-and-awe theatrics to teaching kids about cancer, which has a 1 in 7 chance of killing you (3,575 times more likely than a fatal school shooting).
As a fun aside, it's worth noting that you have a 1 in 89 chance of being killed by your own government. That's right: it's 281 times more likely that your own government will kill you or your child than your child's school will experience a fatal gun attack.
Funny how the schools don't drill kids on how to evade the police or withdraw their consent from government, both of which are far more likely sources of death and destruction than any crazed civilian gunman.



A Day Of Hope

The two great preparatory seasons of the liturgical year, Advent and Lent, are intended to stimulate reflection and resolution among the Christian faithful. Sadly, Advent is shrugged aside by many, owing to the huge secular demands the "holiday season" imposes on us. Scarcely are Thanksgiving and its indulgences behind us than the time has come to...shop? Buy and decorate a "Christmas tree?" Festoon the house with garlands of red, green, and gold? Inundate the Postal Service with a blizzard of Hallmark's finest? Arrange our schedules to accommodate as many of our relatives' and friends' seasonal celebrations as possible?

Gahh.


I finished the first draft of Freedom's Fury just yesterday afternoon. Sent it off to my beta reader with the last of my energy. It was a draining, emotionally wringing experience. I'll be awhile recovering from it. That's what completing an emotionally and spiritually evocative story does to me. But in this case, it did something else as well: something for which my gratitude knows no bounds.

Those of you who've read Which Art In Hope and Freedom's Scion know how I tried to weave gentle Christian themes into those tales of a wholly ungoverned world. It wasn't easy. The political and sociological motifs were so compelling to me that it was a rearguard struggle to meld them with the spiritual content I've tried to incorporate into everything I write. I'm not wholly satisfied with those efforts -- what writer is ever wholly satisfied with a completed story? -- though for the life of me I can't see how I might have done better with them.

Freedom's Fury, a tale of love, war, and the emergence of political conflicts and structures on Hope, a world populated by the descendants of Spoonerite anarchists, was an even greater challenge. As the conclusion to the Spooner Federation saga, it had to complete the evolution of the sociopolitical mechanisms developed in the earlier novels. That took quite a lot of hard thought and careful character motivation and orientation. Figures who might not have "had it in them" when they first appeared on Hope's stage had to be brought forward and animated with the most powerful of fuels. In one case, they fashioned a seemingly ordinary man into a king; in another, they burned the unfortunate vessel to a crisp.

But on every page, behind every act of the tragedy, stood the Cross and the shadows it casts upon men.

I'm not going to elaborate further on that just now. You'll see what I mean when you read the novel. God and my cover artist willing, it will be out in eBook format no later than mid-February.


It's massively unfortunate that Ayn Rand so polluted the meaning of the word sacrifice. Rand was, of course, a case-hardened secularist who held religion in contempt. She was unable to cope with the cleavage between the teachings of the great figures of the Christian tradition, highest among them Jesus Himself, and the exploitation of those teachings by men who cared more for worldly authority and stature than for God's love and mercy. Thus, she declined to deal with the fundamental meaning of sacrifice as expressed in its etymology: to make holy.

Christ Himself introduced a measure of uncertainty into the Jews' traditional interpretation of sacrifice:

As Jesus went on from there, he saw a man named Matthew sitting at the tax booth. “Follow me,” he said to him. And he got up and followed him. As Jesus was having a meal in Matthew’s house, many tax collectors and sinners came and ate with Jesus and his disciples. When the Pharisees saw this they said to his disciples, “Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?” When Jesus heard this he said, “Those who are healthy don’t need a physician, but those who are sick do. Go and learn what this saying means: ‘I want mercy and not sacrifice.’ For I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners.” [Matthew 9:9-13]

Indeed, the point was so important that He repeated it:

At that time Jesus went through the grain fields on a Sabbath. His disciples were hungry, and they began to pick the grain and eat. But when the Pharisees saw this they said to him, “Look, your disciples are doing what is against the law to do on the Sabbath.” He said to them, “Haven’t you read what David did when he and his companions were hungry—how he entered the house of God and they ate the sacred bread, which was against the law for him or his companions to eat, but only for the priests? Or have you not read in the law that the priests in the temple desecrate the Sabbath and yet are not guilty? I tell you that something greater than the temple is here. If you had known what this means: ‘I want mercy and not sacrifice,’ you would not have condemned the innocent. For the Son of Man is lord of the Sabbath.” [Matthew 12:1-8]

Judaic practice, of course, followed the tradition of the burnt offering: the deliberate rendering of food, animal, vegetable, or both, unfit for human consumption as a symbolic offering to God. I've written about the revolution in religious thought Jesus's words and deeds wrought upon this subject in particular. That revolution culminated with His Passion and is commemorated at every celebration of the Eucharist by mortal men.

Holiness is the supreme expression of wholeness: of congruence with God's Will as expressed in the laws He has written for this universe. Among those laws is one we rail against at every turn, despite its obvious immutability: that all things have a price. As a somewhat less exalted figure has written:

“Nothing of value is free. Even the breath of life is purchased at birth only through gasping effort and pain....The best things in life are beyond money; their price is agony and sweat and devotion... and the price demanded for the most precious of all things in life is life itself--ultimate cost for perfect value.”

They who most highly valued freedom, during the years of our Revolution, had to risk their lives for it -- and many paid the ultimate price. They who value justice are often compelled to pay the same price. Many a mother has paid that price in an attempt, successful or not, to protect her children. And throughout the two millennia behind us, many men, including most of the Apostles, have been compelled to surrender their mortal lives for the sake of remaining true to their faith.

Let him who dares condemn those men and their sacrifices.


A human life is an organic whole. Its events are connected to one another by bonds of causation and ripples of consequence that can sometimes be difficult to see. Yet the connections are always there. We would be unable to make sense of our experiences, learn the lessons they bear for us, if it were otherwise.

Each of the protagonists of Freedom's Fury confronts a point of crisis, a fork in his life where he must either sacrifice or admit that what he values isn't as important to him as he'd claimed it to be. A superficial reading of the book will leave the reader puzzled by that description. They win, don't they? They get what they seek from their enterprises, don't they? Yes, they do. But they pay a price for each such gain. Sometimes the price isn't obvious until long after it's been "rung up."

A man's continuity of values and commitment to them, including the price they demand, is what elevates him above the common run. It's the fee for his admission to the halls of greatness. The highest and most dramatic of such figures are our greatest heroes. We see their lives as expressions of their values, despite the obvious truism that any mortal, however dedicated, will have his lapses and his intervals of doubt. In identifying them with the values they championed, we contrive to see them whole. We measure ourselves against their integrity of purpose, dimly aware that in that wholehearted commitment to something greater than oneself lies the true meaning of heroism.

In that wholeness resides the holiness of life.


I've written in the past about the "private experience" that, coupled to the desire for transcendence, will allow one to complete one's journey to faith. From time to time a Gentle Reader will write to me inquiring -- sometimes pleading, sometimes demanding -- what constitutes an experience of that sort. It's an impossible question to answer in any way but this one: When it happens to you, you'll recognize it at once.

In these latter years, I've come to believe that to open oneself to such an experience, one must live in full commitment to one's values, whatever they may be. Commitment that complete implies that when the price for upholding and advancing them is presented to the holder, he pays it willingly and without attempting to haggle. He recognizes that the price is inseparable from the value itself.

You might think that's oversimplified. Aren't there bad values, of a sort that God frowns upon? Of course. But bad values lived with full commitment tend to evoke corrective forces. Those forces charge a price that reduces the transaction to a pure loss. Afterward we are reoriented, made aware of our errors, and equipped to do better. That, too, is an aspect of the wholeness of life. With a single necessary exception, there are no saints who were not also sinners.


Today, the third Sunday of Advent, is the Sunday of Hope. We are counseled to elevate our hopes above our fears, to petition God confidently for sustenance in facing our trials, and to look forward with the optimism of persons who really, truly believe in the possibility of admission to eternal bliss in His nearness. Christmas, the commemoration of the birth of Jesus and the second highest of all the holy days, is almost upon us. The season is His and ours, for He came to free us from the chains of sin and open the gates of heaven to us.

It's not a sacrifice of shopping time, or decorating time, or time sending out greeting cards or responses to party invitations, to spend an hour reflecting on that. It's an admission that above the secular trappings of the season there are values that stand infinitely higher: values to which we can and should commit ourselves, not only for the "holiday season" but for all time to come.

May God bless and keep you all.

Saturday, December 14, 2013

Assorted

Look, I know you come here for the weighty, ponderous stuff. I know you find spiritual relief in the high-toned sentiments and the impeccable grammar. I know you look forward to wallowing in the multitude of "howevers," "therefores," and of course the "indeeds." (Which reminds me, my royalty payment to Glenn Reynolds should go out this morning.) But I have my days, Gentle Reader. I have my days. And this, I regret to say, is one of them.


1. "Ladies and gentlemen, this is a funeral...so let's have some fun with it!"

The line above comes from either Kentucky Fried Movie or Amazon Women On the Moon, I forget which. Anyway, I surely hope the ghost of Nelson Mandela has a sense of humor -- the living Mandela never displayed one -- because his recent commemoration must have been the biggest laugh riot of 2013:

"I don’t want to be emotional but this is one of the greatest moments of my life,” declared Nelson Mandela upon meeting the Spice Girls in 1997. So I like to think he would have appreciated the livelier aspects of his funeral observances. The Prince of Wales, who was also present on that occasion in Johannesburg, agreed with Mandela on the significance of their summit with the girls: “It is the second-greatest moment in my life,” he said. “The greatest was when I met them the first time.” His Royal Highness and at least two Spice Girls (reports are unclear) attended this week’s service in Soweto, and I’m sure it was at least the third-greatest moment in all of their lives. Don’t ask me where the other Spice Girls were. It is a melancholy reflection that the Spice Girls’ delegation was half the size of Canada’s, which flew in no fewer than four Canadian prime ministers, which is rather more Canadian prime ministers than one normally needs to make the party go with a swing.

But the star of the show was undoubtedly Thamsanqa Jantjie, the sign-language interpreter who stood alongside the world’s leaders and translated their eulogies for the deaf. Unfortunately, he translated them into total gibberish, reduced by the time of President Obama’s appearance to making random hand gestures, as who has not felt the urge to do during the great man’s speeches. Mr. Jantjie has now pleaded in mitigation that he was having a sudden hallucination because he is a violent schizophrenic. It has not been established whether he is, in fact, a violent schizophrenic, or, as with his claim to be a sign-language interpreter, merely purporting to be one. Asked how often he has been violent, he replied, somewhat cryptically, “A lot.”...

That would never happen in Washington, of course. But how heartening, as one watches the viral video of Obama droning on while a mere foot and a half away Mr. Jantjie rubs his belly and tickles his ear, to think that the White House’s usual money-no-object security operation went to the trouble of flying in Air Force One, plus the “decoy” Air Force One, plus support aircraft, plus the 120-vehicle motorcade or whatever it’s up to by now, plus a bazillion Secret Service agents with reflector shades and telephone wire dangling from their ears, to shepherd POTUS into the secured venue and then stand him onstage next to an $85-a-day violent schizophrenic. In the movie version—In the Sign of Fire—grizzled maverick Clint Eastwood will be the only guy to figure it out at the last minute and hurl himself at John Malkovich, as they roll into the orchestra pit with Malkovich furiously signing “Ow!” and “Eek!” But in real life I expect they’ll just double the motorcade to 240 vehicles and order up even more expensive reflector shades.

As always with Mark Steyn, the whole thing is a must-read. 'Nuff said.


2. Hey, a "turducken" is one thing...

We seasonal gluttons do have our pride, you know:

So, what would we think of a Christmas Tinner, an entire Christmas dinner in, you guessed it, a can? Would it be the most convenient mass-produced full-course meal ever, or just the latest sacrilegious insult to the the holiest of holidays? U.K. based video game retailer GAME purports to be offering the condensed meal as “the ultimate innovation” for those who “can’t tear themselves away from their new consoles and games on Christmas Day.”

A diagram on the GAME’s product site lists each of the nine courses as individual layers, starting with scrambled eggs and bacon on top, followed by mince pies and a main course of turkey, potatoes, Brussels sprouts and roasted carrots in the middle, and finishing up with a creamy layer of Christmas pudding. The product, which we suspect is more of an art piece than a serious commercial product, was designed by graphic artist Chris Godfrey, who, oddly enough, had previously created a similarly gimmicky 12-course romantic dinner as a way of lampooning the marketing tactics used by the food industry to sell processed goods. To make that version, he spent an hour preparing each gelatinized layer before adding it to the concoction so that the delineated portions remained intact. It was meant to be easily served right out of the can without the extraneous need for tidying up afterwards.

Gentle Reader, I could actually feel myself gaining weight as I read that story. "Obscene" doesn't quite do the notion justice. Yes, yes, I know a lot of very small households will lament over the wastefulness of a "traditional" Christmas feast this year, what with prices being so high and all the kids being far away / at loggerheads with one another / busy with their new sex partners and toys, but still! Is nothing sacred?

Here at the Fortress of Crankitude, we'll tie down with a simple repast of eggs and Tactical Bacon, and a jug of Gallo's finest. Or perhaps we'll do it posh: a Monte Cristo with a side of hash browns. I'm sure the Comte wouldn't mind.


3. You think things are getting dicey here?

India might soon suffer a violent revolution:

While all vegetables have become more expensive this year, the most dramatic change has been for onions. In August, Mumbai saw prices more than double, with some markets selling at 80 rupees per kilo. Elementary economics would tell you that prices are up because of a reduced supply, and indeed, this year’s production of 16.65 million tons is down 4.8 percent from 17.5 million last year, partly because less land was farmed and partly because a heavy monsoon season damaged output in the western states, the heart of India’s onion production.

The people aren’t taking the rising price lightly. When August showed no signs of relief, armed robbers looted a truck transporting 40 tons of onions on the Jaipur-Delhi highway. A few days later, reports surfaced of another robbery in Rajasthan’s Nagaur district. Desperate, India made moves to import onions from Pakistan for the first time since 2010’s onion crisis. What are neighbors for, if not to come to the rescue when you need a bowl of sugar? Or in this case, several thousand tons of onions. But as the huge demand from India spiked the price within Pakistan as well, the latter banned exports to its neighbor. A 24-ton shipment arrived from Afghanistan instead. And additional relief, albeit fleeting, came from within India itself, when Groupon launched a wildly popular weeklong special: one kilo of onions for the low, low price of nine rupees.

In the ladies’ section of the Mumbai Local one evening, an auntie hints at the political importance of the price increase, while reviving an old joke. “Onions are bringing tears to everyone’s eyes in Maharashtra,” she says, adding, “They can and have toppled governments, you know!”

Indeed. (Damn, that's another nickel I owe Reynolds.) States have fallen over far less. I recall something about the American colonies and tea.


4. You Can't Make This Stuff Up Dept.

Just how gullible do they think we are?

In an astounding feat that defies several of the known laws of nature, a 17 year old North Carolina boy managed to shoot himself in the head while his hands were cuffed behind his back. Allegedly, young Jesus Huerta died while he was alone, locked in the back of a police cruiser, after having been patted down.

What's really astounding about this tale is that the police chief wants us to accept it verbatim:

“I know that it is hard for people not in law enforcement to understand how someone could be capable of shooting themselves while handcuffed behind the back,” [Police Chief Jose] Lopez said. “While incidents like this are not common, they unfortunately have happened in other jurisdictions in the past."

I know, I know: not funny. Well, reflect on this: the probability that a formal Internal Affairs investigation will unreservedly support the cops' story approaches 100%. It might not evoke ha-ha laughter, but it surely tells us there's "funny business" going on -- and not just in North Carolina.

[Courtesy of Angry Mike.]


5. From The Fashion Front Lines.

Denmark's prime minister, the exceedingly attractive Helle Thorning-Schmidt, might soon become as well known for her fashion choices as for her dubious judgment about "selfies:"

Here we see one of the ineradicable differences between men and women. No man not in an unbreakable hypnotic trance would ever be seen in such garb. (All right, all right, the blouse and the skirt are fetching enough.) Women, on the other hand...? Well, perhaps not all women -- I have no fear of showing that photo to the C.S.O. -- but imagine what Michelle Obama might do, considering the episode immortalized below:

And that's all for today, Gentle Reader.

Friday, December 13, 2013

Thoughts On Conservatism Part 3: The Death Of Character

In response to the previous piece, commenter Magnus wrote:

What happened to our character? How is it that the world (including Christians) has become so coarse and lacking in virtue? Did we do this to ourselves? Was it orchestrated from without? Did we weaken ourselves, thus allowing evil to pounce on our weakened state? Now that we are here, how do we reverse the trend? I'm really at a loss.

It would appear that this is one of the critical questions of our time. Indeed, it might be the only one that ultimately matters.


"There is no substitute for character, and there is no rule about where you'll find it." -- Louis Nizer, My Life In Court

Character is a word susceptible to several interpretations. All but one are perversions: deliberate attempts to divert us from the proper understanding of our duties to ourselves and our places among our peers. A word can have only one exact meaning, and here is the one that pertains to any discussion of character in a sociopolitical context:

What you will permit yourself
when you cannot be restrained or punished for it
is the measure of your character.

H. L. Mencken brushed against this truth in a jocular way when he defined conscience as "the still small voice that warns us that someone might be watching."

Any exploration of character must start from a base of moral and ethical premises. One reaches that base by asking and answering fundamental questions about the nature of Man:

  • What are our obligations to ourselves?
  • What are our obligations to others?
  • Once we have arranged to respect those, are we free to do as we please?
  • If we are free politically, might we still be constrained by other considerations?

How we approach those questions will depend in large measure on factors such as upbringing, religious belief, intellect, individual maturity, and the possession of a functioning conscience. (Sociopaths need not apply.) However, their answers must converge on three absolute principles:

  • Self-control.
  • The Brazen and Golden Rules.
  • The Noachite Commandments.

...regardless of the angle from which each of us approaches them.

Yes: must. When it is otherwise, we lack a functioning civil society. We are immersed in the Hobbesian "war of each against all," where the only ethical touchstone is can I get away with it and the sole measure of success is survival. As "no one here gets out alive," and anyway, survival in a Hobbesian state-of-nature / red-in-tooth-and-claw environment tends to be measured in ever smaller units, I, for one, find that condition unsatisfactory.

A rather humorless joke has some point here. Some years ago, the political-correctness-powered push to replace "judgmental" terms and phrases with "nonjudgmental" equivalents reached a depth of absurdity so great that a couple of wags produced a book lampooning the entire enterprise. The entry that comes to mind this morning is the replacement term for evil: "morally different." It was illustrated with a photo of Pol Pot, the butcher of Cambodia: "a morally different individual."

Give that a moment to sink in.


    "You know him, Kevin. You know his capacities. Do you think there's anything in this world that could hold him against his will?"
    Conway shook his head.
    "Nor do I. But if we're correct, then the only thing that could ever restrain him is his own self-restraint, a conscious decision not to reach out for what he wants. And he knows it."
    Schliemann picked up his mug from the little table between them, looked into it briefly, and set it down again.
    "God has made Louis a man that nothing can restrain. I don't presume to know His mind in this. I do know that He's equipped Louis not just with power, but with an understanding of his power that no amount of wishful thinking could overcome. And Louis has responded by teaching himself never to want anything beyond his necessities and the welfare of those he loves."

[From Chosen One]

Once restraint and punishment are subtracted from consideration, what remains to restrain us from acting on our desires immediately and with our full powers is our character.

This is not a condemnation of desire. Human life is fueled by desire; without it we would be mere vertebrate worms. But not all desires can be satisfied without doing harm, whether to others or to ourselves.

It is a persistent feature of the mentality that seeks power over others that it recognizes character as the foremost bastion against its aims. Not the character of the power-seeker, mind you; that of those he seeks to rule. For ultimately, no ruler can withstand the wrath of his subjects. Should they choose to turn on him, he will fall as surely as the night follows the day. Therefore, he must contrive to deflect their attention from his desires, expressed in his deeds, and onto the fulfillment of their own: he must destroy their characters.

There are several approaches to this:

  • Eliciting rampant envy;
  • Encouraging personal dissolution;
  • Fostering a present-moment mentality;
  • Replacing the sense of obligation with resentment;
  • Creating a myth of villains and oppressors who "deny us what we deserve."

A wide range of tactics can be applied to each of those strategies. As I write this, all of them are in operation in these United States, and have been for decades.

External supports to character are more easily felled than most of us realize. Look at what's been done to Americans' attachment to our churches and Christian faith: wave after tidal wave of ridicule and absurd accusations of "exclusion." First we're skewered as idiots and dupes for daring to believe in God, in an afterlife, and in an absolute standard of right and wrong. Then we're told that by excluding persons who reject those beliefs, we're somehow oppressing them. Marry Adam to Steve in your cathedral or face the severest of all charges: intolerance!

Our attachment to the lessons learned at our mothers' knee falls even more easily. Those old folks just don't "get it." Things are different today. We have the Pill, motels, penicillin! Hapless John and naive Mary don't have to lose out from our use of their bodies. After all, they'll get a tickle, too. Love? Just a misspelling of "sex." Commitment? Who believes in that any more? Abortion? What's the big deal about that? It's just a blob of tissue.

Of course, what starts with a faceless "blob of tissue" doesn't stop there. It doesn't even stop with Kermit Gosnell:

BELGIUM: SENATE APPROVES MEASURE ALLOWING DOCTORS TO EUTHANIZE CHILDREN

by Steven Ertelt | LifeNews.com

The Belgian Senate voted today 50-17 to extend euthanasia to children with disabilities, in a move pro-life advocates worldwide had been fearing would come and expand an already much-abused euthanasia law even further.

The vote today in the full Senate comes after a Senate committee voted 13-4 to allow minors to seek euthanasia under certain conditions and the measure also would extend the right to request euthanasia to adults with dementia. There is still a chance to stop the bill in the House of Representatives, though pro-life campaigners fear it will become law....

“Currently the Belgian euthanasia law limits euthanasia to people who are at least 18 years old. This unprecedented bill would extend euthanasia to children with disabilities,” says Alex Schadenberg of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition....

Dr Paul Saba of Physicians for Social Justice, is very concerned about the situation in Belgium.

“They are already euthanising people who are depressed or tired of life because they have taken the interpretations of saying physical and/or psychological suffering – you don’t have to have both, if you have one, why is that not enough? If you are suffering, it’s a personal experience and it would be discriminatory for someone to judge what a person is suffering,” he says. “What this teaches us is that despite the government’s assurances that they will set very strict criteria, that won’t work.”...

Some Belgian experts are supporting the extension of euthanasia to children with disabilities because they say that it is being done already. The same medical experts suggest that the extension of euthanasia will result in an increase of 10 to 100 euthanasia deaths each year.

The Belgian euthanasia law appears out-of-control. The Belgian Euthanasia Control and Evaluation Commission appear to be in a conflict of interest. The Commission supported the euthanasia deaths of: Nathan Verhelst (44) who was born as Nancy, Ann G who had Anorexia Nervosa and was sexually exploited by her psychiatrist, Mark & Eddy Verbessem, and at least one depressed woman. These are only the cases that we know about....

In the 20th Century: from Margaret Sanger to Adolf Hitler the goal was to rid the world of the disabled and Untermenschen.

How many of us can withstand such assaults on our characters, enduring them decade after decade as they swallow ever more of our society -- of our neighbors and friends -- and are glamorized and trumpeted as "the wave of the future" by beautiful bellwethers whose carefully sculpted, strategically unclothed bodies shine down upon us from 5000-inch screens? How many of us can protect our children from succumbing to them?


No discussion of this subject would be complete without mentioning the death cults. I delineated their program long ago:

  • Abortion without restrictions.
  • Assisted suicide.
  • Involuntary euthanasia of those deemed untreatable or having "no quality of life."
  • Compulsory surrender of the organs of the deceased for transplantation.
  • Creation of embryos for research and therapeutic purposes.
  • Government-enforced "triage" to conserve medical and financial resources.
  • Compulsory acceptance of specified therapies.
  • Procreation licenses.
  • Government eugenics programs:
    • At first, as subsidies to couples with favored genetic characteristics;
    • Later, as compulsory donations of gametes for use in government-supervised breeding programs.
  • Conscription for military purposes.
  • Conscription for non-military purposes.

The overarching theme of all these measures, about half of which are already in place in various Western countries, is that human life has no intrinsic value and bears no intrinsic rights. By corollary, the individual's life does not belong to him, but to the State. The deliberate creation of human embryos in government-funded research centers, despite the revulsion it evokes from more than half the population of this country, is directly in line with this campaign. It's apparently the number-one goal of the pro-death forces at this time, despite lack of any indication of scientific or medical utility.

I maintain that the above is accurate in all particulars. But what matters most to this morning's topic is how it bears upon character:

What's the point to developing a sound character if the sole point of the exercise of life is death?

Should death be raised to an unchallengeable status, Cthulhu will rise and will reign unopposed. Whatever version of Newspeak should prevail in those final years of depravity and destruction will omit the word character from its lexicon. Assuming, that is, that in our unchained lust we bother to speak to one another at all.


How do we retrieve character from the abyss to which it's been consigned? Glory be to God, Gentle Reader: ask me one I can answer! I can see no course but to isolate oneself and one's family -- one's community, if that's possible -- from the surrounding world entirely. Venture out only when absolutely necessary; interact only with others of compatible convictions and practices. But try for just a moment to imagine how you'd go about that. In this day and age, is it even possible?

I don't know. I don't know of anyone who does know. For those of us of advanced years, whose children are already grown and whose energies have faded, it might not be possible even if there is a way. We're already passing into history...and being derided as fuddy-duddies, clueless old farts whose convictions have no relevance to this 24/7 / 500-channels / get-it-while-it's-hot / happenin' world, as we depart.

Know this, at the very least: They who encourage you to set aside considerations of character in favor of a laissez les bon temps roulez mentality are the enemy. They have an agenda that includes your subjugation -- and it would greatly ease their labors for you to do the hardest part for them.

Keep the faith.

Thursday, December 12, 2013

Thoughts On Conservatism Part 2: Strawmen

As an outspoken libertarian-conservative, I take a lot of flack from all sorts of disagreeable persons -- i.e., from persons who get upset when I attack their positions on rational or empirical grounds. There's a lot of that going around, these days. Opinions, after all, are like assholes: everybody's gotta have one. However, few persons in our contemporary political discourse are all that good at distinguishing facts from opinions, and logic from preferences. Blame whoever you like for it; it's the least attractive feature of today's political interplay.

Among the most risible of all pseudo-ripostes to my contentions is that I'm "advocating for Utopia." A recent objector -- anonymous, of course -- seized on the following passage from the previous piece:

Choose among your values what you think most important to conserve, by all means. Then, having made your choice, ask yourself sincerely: Would any social system, any polity, any corpus of law or system of jurisprudence succeed in conserving those things without the three items immediately above? But with those three things fully in effect among the people, would any great engine of coercion be required to gain or keep what you seek?

...and said:

So, the question is "Is Utopia possible?" or, "What's you're plan to achieve perfect harmony among men?" And if the answer to the first is "No!", or the answer to the second is "I have no plan because that's not possible,"; then we should throw up our hands in frustration, conclude that government is an Unnecessary evil, and all human society is evil "collectivism".

Ignore the poor grammar, spelling, and punctuation. (Yes, "Anonymous," there is a Grammar and Spelling Checker. No, not at the North Pole. His name is Fran Porretto, and he bloviates at Liberty's Torch. Comment at his site and you submit yourself to his mercies.) Measure what my correspondent wrote against what I wrote and ask yourself: Does that constitute a valid dismissal of questions plainly and sincerely asked, or is it merely the largest strawman the fellow could cobble up out of his limited bile and mental horsepower?

Take a moment over that.


The late Andrew Breitbart was known, among other things, for his assertion that "Culture is upstream from politics." While the observation is important, it is not fundamental. There's something upstream from culture that's far more basic: the nature and proclivities of Man.

Culture is an expression of the norms prevalent in a society at a particular time. Though it sometimes seems to have an infinite number of facets, they can be partitioned into only three categories:

  • What is considered decent public behavior;
  • What is accepted in the arts;
  • What is accepted in the pursuit of material gain.

Note: I have omitted private behavior. Private behavior can clash dramatically with the public norms of a society; witness Victorian England. Despite our supposed permissiveness about what's publicly acceptable today, this is true in the contemporary United States as well: the domestic lives of many Americans conceal things that would be frowned upon or worse were they to become generally known.

Culture, however, is a transmission system. It relays norms and concepts, both express and implied, to a society's young. When that transmission system contradicts the norms and concepts their parents and designated educators attempt to inculcate in them, a power struggle is in progress. Whichever system has the firmer basis and the greater persistence will prevail. the results are visible only in the behavior of our progeny.

Let's review "the nature and proclivities of Man:"

  • Each man is animated by independent volition and individual desires;
  • He sees himself as the center of all things; things about which he does not know, or which he regards with indifference, cannot motivate him.
  • Though he is capable of limiting his own behavior, he must be provided with a reason to do so:
    1. A conditioned aversion to the behavior;
    2. Fear of the probable consequences of the behavior;
    3. Repugnance toward the behavior itself, on abstract grounds (e.g., a moral code).

When I composed my take on "The Algorithm:"

  1. Select a technique that you think will get you what you think you want.
  2. Will this technique require you to lose body parts, go to jail, or burn in Hell?
    • If so, return to step 1.
    • If not, proceed to step 3.
  3. Do a little of it.
  4. Are you at your goal, approaching it, or receding from it?
    • If at your goal, stop.
    • If approaching, return to step 3.
    • If receding, return to step 1.

..I had exactly those properties of human nature in mind.

If a culture at odds with the norms being relayed by parents and other trusted sources of counsel prevails over those norms, our reasons to limit our behavior come under attack. We lose any aversive conditioning to what the culture slathers us with. Our fear of unpleasant consequences is weakened. Any moral code we might otherwise have acquired is undermined, perhaps to collapse into rubble.

From that point forward, the limits on what we can and will do will consist solely of what we can get away with. There is no countermeasure except to win the previous struggle: to equip our young people with bastions of character that are proof against the seductions of libertinism (not libertarianism, damn it!) purveyed by the culture that seeks to twist them.


Considering how sharp the great majority of my Gentle Readers are, the above probably seems to most of you to be too obvious to require restating. However, consider once more what "Anonymous" wrote to me:

So, the question is "Is Utopia possible?" or, "What's you're plan to achieve perfect harmony among men?" And if the answer to the first is "No!", or the answer to the second is "I have no plan because that's not possible,"; then we should throw up our hands in frustration, conclude that government is an Unnecessary evil, and all human society is evil "collectivism".

This...person has implicitly evaded the core of my question. But perhaps I should have used smaller words and put it in really big type:

Which Works Better:
Coercion?
Or Character?

Six millennia of recorded history testify that coercion -- the use of the police powers of the State to enforce some standard of virtue -- is almost pointless. There are several reasons for this, but they're better saved for a separate tirade. Contrariwise, when characters are built on solid foundations and buttressed by recognition and approval, they stand firm against any and all temptation. The seeming desirability of an omniscient and omnipotent State to keep us all on the straight and narrow vanishes like a bad dream.

Does that completely obviate the need for government? Only in the minds of those who believe that private methods will suffice to deal with such matters as national defense, border control, criminal jurisprudence, and the soundness of the commons. They have a case to make, and it should not be waved aside. But for those of us who prefer the "night-watchman" State of classical liberal / Constitutional design, the answer is no. (Provided, of course, that we can manage to keep our own State within those bounds.)


In casual conversation, the proper response to a strawman such as "You're advocating Utopia!" is to laugh it aside, possibly following that up with "Is that all you've got?" However, current political interchange appears to admit such strawmen on an equal footing with reasoned argument, so one must be prepared.

The "Utopia" strawman is important because it's self-contained. Everyone knows what is meant by such an objection. More, the common response is to deny the allegation, which is a losing move. A better rejoinder would go approximately like this:

Sorry, pal. You're the one who believes in Utopia: a society made perfect by infinitely magnifying the powers of the State. I'm concerned with what works and what doesn't -- and my reading of history indicates that what works is character building and careful attention to where, how, and with whom our kids spend their time. I'm not interested in any totalitarian fantasies about making people good with the blows of a nightstick.

And with that, I yield the floor.

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Thoughts On Conservatism In Contemporary Discourse

Once in a great while, I lock horns with another writer over some topic of mutual interest, and we find that, far from being able to agree to disagree and watch the game played out, we can find no common ground whatsoever, not even the ability to respect one another's views. Neither of us is even willing to allow the other to use the terms of his choice to mean what he prefers them to mean. That sort of "it was him or me" disagreement is the most disagreeable sort there is or can ever be.

That happened recently -- forgive me, Gentle Reader; once again, I've lost the BLEEP!ing link -- but in this case, it's had a spinoff benefit, at least: It's got me thinking about the thorny path conservatism as a concept has traveled over the century behind us, and where we might expect it to go in the decades to come.


At TownHall today, Jonah Goldberg declaims upon "the triumph of the vulgarians." For me, here's the capping stroke:
Vulgarity has become cultural shorthand for everything from seriousness to rebelliousness to "keeping it real." But it's closer to the opposite....

In other words, the standards of the common culture are lower than they are in nearly every other walk of life. Which means they're not really standards at all. If anything, the new taboo is decency.

I commented as follows:

Two observations: First, the ubiquity of profanity has robbed it of all impact, such that it counts for less than a "y'know," a "like," or an "um." Therefore, the user should be looking for ways to "increase his word power," possibly by replacing his F and S bombs with "My word!" or "Upon mine honor!" (My own favorite "epithets," pace C. S. Lewis, are "Splendor of Christ!" and "Glory be to God!" The non-religious among us may choose their own paths.)

Second, one truly holds to a standard if and only if he holds to it when he's alone and unobserved. All else is an attempt to avoid public opprobrium and castigation, such as it might occasion. The truly advanced man recognizes that though the good opinion of others is worth something, the highest character accolades are available only from oneself: from the recognition that one does the right and proper thing even when straying would cost nothing and afford some measure of pleasure or relief. This extraordinarily important insight has largely been lost to our time.

The shorthand for that "extraordinarily important insight" is, of course, "self-control."


Among the many questions about what conservatism "really is," this one comes close to summarizing all the rest:

What should conservatives be trying to conserve?

For the "conservative mindset" is first and foremost an attachment to things that are or have been: things that might well be under attack, if not already vanquished and driven into the shadows. But the specific choice of those things remains a matter under dispute.

If you prize freedom supremely, you'll want to conserve freedom.
If you value military power above all else, you'll strive to protect that.
Many conservatives place absolute adherence to the law at the pinnacle.
Or you might have some conception of public order at the top of your heap.
Or perhaps there's a standard of virtue, however defined, that you'd like enforced.

I could go on, but I believe the point has been made.

If you call yourself a conservative, you have already made a choice of the above sort, though not necessarily from the above list. You have some list of values that matters to you more than your others, and you want to see them protected, or restored, or advanced. If you call yourself a political conservative, you want to see those values protected, restored, or advanced by public policy: the decrees and enforcement actions of the State.

There are as many entirely valid instantiations of conservatism -- personal and political -- as there are things that men value.


The Reverend John Williams, an Australian vicar, once gave a talk for the Foundation for Economic Education in which he noted that socialism in Britain had roots in both Tory conservatism and the classical or "Manchester" liberalism of the nineteenth century. The Tories, Reverend Williams said, wanted a very powerful State, both for the protection of the propertied classes and for the enforcement of the public moral code of post-Cromwell England. The Manchesterites were paleolibertarians: they sought individual freedom, economic mobility, and an end to State favoritism toward the gentry class. The clash between them seemed absolute...until the earliest socialists came along.

The proto-socialists appealed to the Manchesterites as being in sympathy with their goals. However, they told the liberals, the way to get it is via the powerful State favored by the Tories. They claimed that their "middle way" would co-opt the mechanisms of coercion and turn them to the goals of the classical liberals -- and many an English liberal bought the pig in the poke, ultimately to his and Britain's sorrow.

Today's analogue to that English proto-socialism is what we call "big-government conservatism."


I'm not going to hammer this flat, as if you, Gentle Reader, were incapable of connecting the dots for yourself. I intend a starting point, such that you might use it for an intellectual journey of your own. But I deem the following words from Founding Father John Adams, which he addressed to the officers of the First Brigade of the Third Division of the Militia of Massachusetts, to be of critical import to any such journey:

While our country remains untainted with the principles and manners which are now producing desolation in so many parts of the world; while she continues sincere, and incapable of insidious and impious policy, we shall have the strongest reason to rejoice in the local destination assigned us by Providence. But should the people of America once become capable of that deep simulation towards one another, and towards foreign nations, which assumes the language of justice and moderation, while it is practising iniquity and extravagance, and displays in the most captivating manner the charming pictures of candour, frankness, and sincerity, while it is rioting in rapine and insolence, this country will be the most miserable habitation in the world. Because we have no government, armed with power, capable of contending with human passions, unbridled by morality and religion. Avarice, ambition, revenge and licentiousness would break the strongest cords of our Constitution, as a whale goes through a net. Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other. Oaths in this country are as yet universally considered as sacred obligations. That which you have taken, and so solemnly repeated on that venerable ground, is an ample pledge of your sincerity and devotion to your country and its government.

Self-control.
The Brazen and Golden Rules.
And the Noachite Commandments.

Choose among your values what you think most important to conserve, by all means. Then, having made your choice, ask yourself sincerely: Would any social system, any polity, any corpus of law or system of jurisprudence succeed in conserving those things without the three items immediately above? But with those three things fully in effect among the people, would any great engine of coercion be required to gain or keep what you seek?

Give it some thought.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Reforming American Politics Counter-Intuitively

[The following reprint from May 29, 2009 at Eternity Road was evoked by the enormous popularity of the Ineducability piece. I didn’t mean it seriously at the time. Perhaps the time has come to take it so. -- FWP]


The esteemed Charles Hill has picked up a comment of your Curmudgeon's from this post of a few days ago, and in so doing has sparked a delightful discussion about political term limits and related subjects.

Your Curmudgeon's favorite contribution so far is this one, from commenter Kirk:

Personally, I prefer a variation on the Groucho Marx line about refusing to join any club that would have him as a member; I sometimes think that the mere expression of desire for an elective office should be disqualifying.

Which caused your Curmudgeon to rev his mental engines. Not for the first time, of course -- the subject of political ambition and what usually accompanies it is never far from his thoughts -- but this time, something new bubbled to the surface.

If our public offices are to be filled by men who don’t want to be there, then we must conscript them. The Thirteenth Amendment would appear to forbid that. But the Amendment contains an escape clause:

“Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”

…so we could draft convicted felons to serve as our public officials! That would seem to slay two vultures with one stone:

  1. No elections, no campaigns, and no pandering;
  2. No more worries about governmental corruption: we’d know with perfect certainty that everyone in office is dishonest.

It would even be possible to improve on the technique by establishing, as a matter of law, that only certain categories and ages of felons are eligible for political conscription. Your Curmudgeon would suggest:

  1. One-time impulse killers for President;
  2. Armed burglars for Congress and the Senate;
  3. Bunco artists for the federal courts;

...with a lower age limit of 60 in all cases. More, these categories would be reserved to federal use. The states, counties and municipalities would have to make do with other kinds of slimeballs:

For the state governments:

  1. Extortionists for state governor;
  2. Forgers for the state legislatures;
  3. Stalkers for the state courts.

For county governments:

  1. Legbreakers for county executive;
  2. Pickpockets for the county legislatures;
  3. Three-card-monte hustlers for the county courts.

And last but certainly least, for municipalities:

  1. Slanderers and libelers for mayor or town supervisor;
  2. Numbers runners for city or town council;
  3. Spousal abusers for town and family courts.

There are approximately 500,000 elective offices in these United States, and about two million persons incarcerated for the crimes enumerated above, so there are at least as many candidates for the positions as would be required to fill them. At long last, we could solve the problem of political corruption, the problem of criminal recidivism, and the problem of finding useful employment for the ex-con! It’s a cancer cure. A veritable cancer cure!