Showing posts sorted by relevance for query "Sturdy Wisdom". Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query "Sturdy Wisdom". Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, September 28, 2017

Sturdy Wisdoms And Realizations

     “Ve get too soon old und too late schmart.” – Ancient maxim

     “Pride goeth before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall.” – Book of Proverbs

     Our time is slowly but steadily unearthing what I call “sturdy wisdoms:” the hard won learning of our parents, grandparents, and the generations before them. The “youth revolution” of the Sixties had many destructive effects, but the very worst of them was the contempt we showed for such wisdoms. We decided that we were the smart ones. The fusty oldsters cluck-clucking at us were fossils of a bygone era, misguided by their excessive respect for tradition. We were certain that we knew better than they, on just about every subject under the Sun.

     We reaped the whirlwind for it. We deserved what we got. Yes, there were others who knew that we were headed for a fall and, for reasons of their own, hastened us toward the abyss. That doesn’t spare us the odium for our arrogance and foolishness. However, admitting that might be the key to sparing our progeny some of what we’ve suffered.

     This morning I have three sturdy wisdoms in mind for your consideration. I contend that insisting on the contrary propositions has cost us dearly and will continue to do so until we unlearn and resolve sincerely to do better. There are others beside these three; indeed, there are many. But I’m not here to write an encyclopedia of our follies, merely to provide some color commentary.


     The first sturdy wisdom to be revived is one about which there’s still much dissent. In all probability that will continue forever. It’s been derided as simplistic, self-limiting, even dictatorial. Yet the truth of it glows more brightly with every passing day.

Sex is a serious matter.

     Long, long ago, at a Website far, far away, I wrote the following:

     Viewed through a coarsely-grained lens, sex is just a variety of agreeable physical contact between bodies. Why should it differ emotionally from other physical activities we enjoy? What makes it so special?

     The mystery deepens when we note that there are devices, available for a few dollars, that can excite the body to greater degrees of pleasure than ordinary sex, or even extraordinary sex, could ever achieve. Yet people overwhelmingly prefer the genuine article, with all its muss, fuss, occasions for embarrassment, and potential for social and emotional disaster....

     You have to open your defensive perimeter, your reflex-reaction zone, to let someone else get close enough to you to make love. A woman has to permit her man to enter her body. Each partner is in a state of total physical vulnerability while their embrace lasts. There are implications and overtones to this that no rationalization about sex being mere happy friction can erase.

     And it doesn't stop with the sexual embrace itself. No matter how often we tell ourselves otherwise, every sex act is a test of a proposition: "Will we be a unit? Will I share his home and bear his children? Will she stand by me in my battles and nurture me in my times of infirmity?"

     The unit of two is the unit best suited to human beings. One person can accept and bond to another on mutually agreed terms, with little or no ambiguity about the nature, obligations and extent of the intended relationship. Larger numbers don't work nearly as well. If you disagree, you've never been in politics.

     No amount of propaganda about sex being just one more way for people to enjoy their bodies can erase these facts. They are graven in our genes, and in our nature as a species....

     See that handsome stranger or pretty lady across the bar? What were you thinking a moment ago, about how it would be nice to try the night with him / her, and that it needn't come to more than that if it doesn't work out?

     Don't kid yourself, my friend. From the moment you first touch, forces will be unleashed in heaven and on Earth that will rock you to your core, and it won't matter a dented copper groat what your intentions were.

     Be smart. Know yourself. Know your species.

     Quite a lot of Americans who pooh-poohed that sturdy wisdom, gaily dismissing the warnings of parents and grandparents about casual sex, have reached their thirties, forties, and the years beyond alone. A large fraction of them have suffered painful divorces. Others have lost all contact with their children. Others have contracted diseases they could have avoided. Still others have become embroiled in legal complications from which escape seems indefinitely far off.

     Our predecessor generations knew all the hazards. They strove to impress us with them. And we laughed them off.


     The second sturdy wisdom is one for which I’ve been called a kook, a loon, a bizarro, out of touch with the realities of contemporary living. Indeed, this is one the effacement of which affected more than just the postwar generations. Huge industries have sprung up to exploit our foolishness, and have profited greatly from it.

Debt is slavery.

     If you are in debt, a part of the reward for your labor goes to others to service the debt. You can be legally penalized for failing to service your debts. You get nothing else for doing so. You are therefore, in part, a slave.

     Debt slavery is the chain that keeps many Americans working at jobs they’d love to slough. Financiers love it; the rest of us endure it to afford our “needs.”

     I revived an old Eternity Road essay on this subject earlier this year. It drew the same choruses of dismissal in 2017 as it had in 2006. Yet the truth of it remains beyond intelligent dispute:

     Many a reader has been saying to himself "But how could I get the things I need without incurring these debts?" for several paragraphs now. Such questions arise from a perverse sense of "need" far more often than not. Americans are hooked on material self-indulgence; easy credit is the pusher that feeds our habit. Most of what we have, we do not need. We want it, and we certainly enjoy it, but those are far different things.

     "Need" is the gateway drug. "Need" is habitually "defined down" over time: from a house, to a car, to better clothes, to a better car, to a really nice house in a "suitable" neighborhood, to designer jeans and sneakers for the kids, to the latest iPods®, to a PlayStation 3 ® and all the "hot" games for it, to a Giant Economy Size bottle of Chivas Regal to dull the pain from having to pay for all that stuff.

     Man's needs are food, clothing, shelter, and heat. All else is discretionary. The truly prudent man does not incur debt to pay for discretionary items.

     William Pitt said three centuries ago that “Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves.” Nor was he incorrect. Those who hope for your enslavement have no better way of securing your collaboration in the project than by inducing you to incur debt.


     The third sturdy wisdom is one that informs most of my op-ed writing. It seems so perfectly obvious to me, yet millions upon millions of persons dispute it at a temperature that could set the world aflame. Indeed it has done so several times already.

Do not trust government or would-be governors.

     The man who wants power over you is inherently untrustworthy. For the love of God, think about it! Once you allow him power over you, he’ll be beyond your control. You’ll be stripped of the ability to defy him. When he does other than what he “promised” he would do, you’ll be without recourse.

     One of the most extraordinary aspects of the American Constitutional design, underappreciated even by the most erudite legal scholars, is this: The United States was designed to be an anarchy. The giveaway appears in the Sixth and Seventh Amendments:

     Amendment VI: In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.

     Amendment VII: In Suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise re-examined in any Court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law.

     The right of trial by jury says, in so many words, that you cannot be punished by State decree. You can only be punished by the judgment and with the consent of your peers. But a State that cannot inflict punishment upon its subjects without their explicit consent is not a State in the original sense of the word: an organization that commands the pre-indemnified use of force, whether initiated or in response.

     The statists that rule this once free country have made a mockery of those guarantees. They’ve done it with “prosecutorial discretion,” with laundry-list charges and “plea bargaining,” with the silencing of the right of jury nullification, and perhaps worst of all with administrative laws created and imposed by unaccountable bureaucrats, entirely outside the Constitutional requirements on the law.

     We permitted it. We were told it was “necessary,” that the usual processes of legislation and judicial operation were “inefficient,” “unsuited to our complex modern era.” And we swallowed it whole. The ghost of William Pitt must have wept at the sight. Yet people ask me why I study the skies each night, hoping for a convenient planetoid.


     There are some indications that those sturdy wisdoms are being rediscovered. Those who rediscover them often do so in a spirit of “if only I had known.” The understanding that debt is a form of self-imposed slavery is receiving particular respect: millions of Americans discovered during the recent recession that the deep financial holes they’d excavated for themselves shackled them more tightly than they could endure. The other sturdy wisdoms are singing less audibly, but there are some hopeful signs.

     It’s time we admitted how little we really know, and how much there is to learn from the experiences of others...especially others who have already run the race to completion and would happily tell us about the hazards they encountered along the course.

Friday, March 16, 2018

They Know What’s Best. Just Ask Them!

     After an unconscionably long time away, laughingly blamed upon such trivia as a crushing workload, the birth of a daughter, and the imminent transformation of his neighborhood into a ghetto, Dystopic / Thales has at long last returned. As usual, it’s well worth your time:

     “It’s for the children” was a tactic employed by the media during the Syrian refugee crisis, often by showing carefully staged bodies of children, or as in one particular example, showing an injured child in an ambulance. In the latter, the child was dirty and bleeding, but journalists still found time to sit him in the otherwise clean ambulance and take a carefully-considered photo to push their political points.

     However, today’s tactic is, perhaps, even more insidious. In this case, Progressives are using the gullibility and lack of experience of children to push for their political goals. One individual of some notoriety, whose name escapes me at the moment (it made the rounds on Twitter, if one of my readers has a name please drop it in the comments), mentioned that children are often wiser than their parents on social and political issues. And they are supposedly less gullible, too. And while Democrats want to raise the age required to purchase a gun, they simultaneously want to lower the voting age. Surely there’s no self-interest in that, right? After all, it’s easier to talk a child into Socialism with a basic “it’s not fair” kind of argument.

     Look, the fact is children just don’t understand. That’s why they are children, not little adults. They don’t have the life experience to make such weighty decisions yet.

     Thank God someone has finally said so.


     One of my blessings / curses is a very clear remembrance of my youth. For reasons beyond the scope of this tirade, I had to “grow up young.” Part of the experience was the shocking discovery that what I’d previously believed, in my youthful ignorance of that ultimate confounder of unfounded opinions, reality, was...not so. At odds with the observable facts. In a word, wrong.

     It was embarrassing, but far less embarrassing than if my father had permitted me to spout off in public, as so many young folks do today.

     You see, back then, when the “older and wiser heads” were still weighing the merits and demerits of descending from the trees, adults had a saying: “Children should be seen and not heard.” It was based on what I call a “sturdy wisdom:” Kids don’t know shit. How could they? We learn the greater part of what we need to know to survive and flourish by observing consequences. Childhood is a period during which one is allowed to be safely irresponsible. Children are insulated against the harsher consequences of their beliefs and actions. As we mathematical types like to say, quod erat demonstrandum.

     Children – a loosely defined term; today I’d say the irresponsible puerility that defines it isn’t guaranteed to be over and done until Junior’s 35th birthday – don’t possess sound perspective or good judgment. But they will exploit any unwarranted attribution of wisdom to preen themselves and offer you all sorts of opinions. Rarely are those opinions worth more than what they once left in their diapers.

     But kids make great foils for evoking tender emotions in the unthinking. Note that I didn’t say “the unthinking adult.” He who can’t or won’t think clearly – i.e., who won’t associate decision and action with consequences and learn from the latter – will only survive if he’s protected from the consequences of his actions by more responsible persons. He remains a child, no matter how old he is.

     The promotion of ignorant, emotion-dominated children — some taller than others — as founts of sociopolitical wisdom is one of the great follies of our era. But it’s massively useful to the Left, whose strategists and tacticians know full well how tender we are toward the kids…and how, as the kids-to-adults ratio continues to shrink, that effect will only become stronger.


     One final thought: Children are more susceptible to appeals to envy than are adults. They’re more likely to wish harm on others who have something they don’t. And they’re quite inventive about justifying demands that arise from their envy.

     Socialism is denotatively defined as a politico-economic system in which “the workers” own “the means of production.” Mind you, many a “socialist” would quarrel with that definition, but that’s the way it was defined by Karl Marx, and that’s the definition that appears in the dictionary:

     Socialism, n: a theory or system of social organization that advocates the vesting of the ownership and control of the means of production and distribution, of capital, land, etc., in the community as a whole.

     However, the propulsive impulse toward socialism is envy: the desire to see others who have more brought low. How could it be otherwise? No socialist economy has ever done anything else, and socialist advocates and agitators know it. But children, equipped with neither adequate intellectual knowledge nor real-world experience, can easily be led into it through their propensity to envy.

     It’s been said, though I forget from whom I first heard it, that if the transmission of civilized values and accumulated social capital were to be interrupted for just one generation, Mankind would revert to savagery. The Left is ardent to manipulate us through the uninstructed and inexperienced: our children. Draw the moral – and keep your kids out of their clutches.

Wednesday, March 14, 2018

Past Pleasures, Present Pressures

     I’ve found many things to comment on today. Rather than slough any of them, I’ve decided to produce another of the dreaded “assorted” posts. Proceed at your own risk.


     It occurred to me recently that over the past twenty years I’ve acquired only one new taste. When I was much younger, the world seemed filled to the brim with new and exciting things, and I was eager to sample them all. Yet today, when the explosion of pleasures and diversions has made the spectrum of my youth seem constricted and pale, I have very little interest in trying anything I haven’t yet sampled. It usually seems like too much work and expense for too small a probability of reward. But that’s not the whole story.

     Tastes do tend to set in early to middle adulthood. And “pop” culture, being a form of mass merchandising, must change constantly, for only constant variation can maintain product sales, much less increases thereof. Thus, an older person’s attitude toward current “pop” music, art, or what have you is likely to be negative. But this is normal – a designation the Left is doing its level best to anathematize.


     Some people will do anything to remain “relevant.” The limelight must be a terribly addictive thing, for very few who’ve bathed in it surrender it willingly, even when it’s time and long past time.

     For example, it’s plain from the video in yesterday’s emission that Hillary Clinton has decided to join the cult of victimism. It’s a bit odd for a woman who served as a U.S. Senator and Secretary of State to claim that her failure to gain the grand prize of her ambitions was due to anyone other than herself. Yet having been conclusively thwarted in her quest for the presidency after enduring Bill’s philandering for so many years, she had to fall back on something. Perhaps “I’ve been wronged” is the best she can do. At any rate, it’s consistent with her lack of insight and imagination. But to take such a campaign overseas defies all my attempts at explanation.


     Richard Dawkins has morphed from amateur bio-morphologist to professional atheist to crusader against a unique, bizarre notion of “bias:”

     Professional atheist Richard Dawkins continues to push the envelope against a God-deluded world, proposing that cultivating and eating human “meat” might help society overcome its “taboo” against cannibalism.

     Commenting on an article from the UK’s Independent newspaper, which touts the benefits of lab-grown “clean meat,” Dawkins tweeted earlier this month that perhaps something similar could be done with human flesh, which would assist western culture in shedding yet another irrational remnant of its Judeo-Christian roots.

     Dawkins said that eating lab-grown human meat would provide an “interesting test case for consequentialist morality versus ‘yuck reaction’ absolutism,” which keeps people from doing things just because they seem morally repugnant.

     Here we confront a reliable telltale of the ersatz intellectual. Dawkins has not considered even for a moment the possibility that those innate repugnances are founded on built-in knowledge of dangers – what he would call instincts, reinforced and refined by natural selection, in a lesser species. The man simply doesn’t think; he merely emits pronouncements from his personal prejudices. Atop that, he routinely drips scorn and derision upon others for our “irrational” reactions, taboos, and convictions...and the media continue to champion him for it. There’s a moral in there, somewhere.


     Apropos of the subject of tastes: Now and then, the C.S.O. will turn on the television for some purpose other than to watch a Yankee or Ranger game, a movie on DVD, or one of Amazon Prime Video’s offerings. Lately she and (much to my surprise) I have enjoyed TNT’s series The Alienist, about a child-murder spree in late 19th Century New York City. Among its pleasures it numbers the fine acting of Daniel Bruhl, Luke Evans, and Dakota Fanning, a striking portrait of New York City at that time, including the slums and hovels to which immigrants were relegated in those years, and numerous other fascinating details about the period. Recommended.

     Concerning Amazon Prime Video, we can heartily recommend the following:

  • Mozart in the Jungle
  • Electric Dreams
  • Bosch
  • Wolf Hall
  • Absentia
  • The Kettering Incident
  • Hunted
  • Britannia

     Some of the above are Amazon Originals; the others are acquisitions from British and Australian producers. We found all of them to be worth our time – something I rarely say about a show from the “conventional” TV channels.


     One of the blessings Amazon has brought us is a means whereby niche products can be marketed to niche purchasers. For example, the C.S.O. and I have long desired to revisit our old favorite cartoons: Crusader Rabbit and Rocky and Bullwinkle. There can’t be many persons with that particular yen, which would have made the prospect of recouping the production costs of such DVDs a remote one indeed. But Amazon’s reputation for being the place one can find anything at all means that a niche marketer has a real chance of connecting with his targeted consumer.

     Extend this mechanism to any product – and a growing number of services – then add Amazon’s discounting and justly famous customer service. The effect has broadened the spectrum of product offerings and the prospects of would-be entrepreneurs beyond what would have been thinkable even twenty years ago. I mean, can you imagine succeeding with this product in a world without Amazon?


     I’m at work on a sequel to Innocents, with the working title Experienced. It’s founded on a couple of mild speculations about near-future developments. One of these is a sturdy wisdom of which no Internet user can be ignorant: specifically, that no matter how bizarre some sexual variation seems to Smith, there’s a Jones somewhere who’s, ah, jonesing for it. But the reverse of that coin is interesting, too: If a sexual variation is rendered inaccessible, those who’ve dabbled in it will be vexed, and probably spurred to action.

     So: We know that there are some thousands of persons worldwide who inhabit the borderland of sexual identity: bodies that outwardly appear female, but possess male genitalia. We also know that there are thousands of persons – mostly male – who seek such persons as sex partners. Should the former become unavailable, how would the latter react?

     I explored one possibility in Innocents, albeit without first postulating that “shemales” – born male, but modified through surgery, diet, and hormones into appearing female except for genitalia – had somehow vanished. But given the emergence of a technology of desire control, it’s quite possible that the emotional disorder that gives rise to “shemales” could be extinguished. (See this novel for details.) How would those who desire “shemale” lovers react? For that matter, how would persons who have already elected that state for themselves react to the notion that their aberration is steadily being eliminated from existence, leaving them a demographic isolated in time?

     I await your thoughts.

Wednesday, September 23, 2020

Smart People, Foolish Notions

     The political trenches are heavy with commentators who write smart, literate pieces but who are utterly filled with folly. Folly, as Barbara Tuchman once wrote, is knowing better but doing worse. Persons who promote follies typically refuse to heed the lessons of the past. At least, that’s the most common form of folly in politics and political advocacy.

     Here’s a sample of current relevance:

     One of the big fears that some conservatives have about Republicans doing the simple thing that they were elected to do by confirming a conservative Supreme Court justice is that Democrats would respond by packing the court. As such, they are proposing a "compromise." The idea, first put forward by Adam White in a thoughtful piece, is that President Trump nominates somebody, but Republicans agree not to vote until after the election (and to not confirm a nominee in a lame-duck session if they lose) as long as Democrats agree to not pack the court. The idea has gained adherents, including David French and Jonah Goldberg.

     I don’t know anything about Adam White. I know little more about David French, other than that he’s a foaming-at-the-mouth NeverTrumper. But I followed Goldberg’s essays for some time, and I own one of his books. I have no doubt that he’s a smart fellow, his aversion to President Trump notwithstanding. However, these three persons are united in a folly of monumental dimensions: They believe the Democrats would keep a promise when violating it would be massively favorable to their interests.

     The Democrats do not keep promises. The record is quite definite on this subject. Why, therefore, would the GOP’s Senate caucus trust the Democrats to do so in this supremely important matter – a matter the Left has been talking about for years?

     Do I hear someone in the back rows nattering about “collegiality?” Where was collegiality during the Kavanaugh confirmation hearings? Where was it during impeachment hearings and the Senate trial of President Trump? Where is it today, when prominent Democrats routinely slander President Trump as a dictator and anyone who supports him as either stupid or evil?

     Given the open, venomous viciousness of the highest-placed Democrats at this time, why would anyone believe, against the historical evidence, that “this time it will be different?”

     Folly, pure and simple.


     Now and then, I’ll encounter a smart fellow in a comment section. As often as not, such a person is riddled by folly. A recent case arose in the comments to this story about the Congressional campaign ads of Kim Klacik.

     I commented there much as I expressed here. But note the reply I received:

     I would rather my federal tax dollars go towards fixing an entirely broken city, one that is so broken that the local government can't fix it alone, so it can become successful enough to, once again, thrive on its own. Every city where a Democrat gains and keeps control is in danger of descending into squalor. So, how do we prevent such a thing from happening in Baltimore again after it has been fixed? By showing the citizens that it was a Republican who finally stepped up and fixed everything, by showing the citizens that voting red is what made a difference, and by showing the citizens that as long as they keep voting red, there is no limit to how successful their city can be. Doing all of this could create long-lasting memories of how it was actually the Republicans who cared for the black communities enough to fix things, memories that would be passed down from generation to generation. Kind of the same effect the Dems "party switch" lie had, but without the lie. I think such a thing is worth my federal tax dollars.

     Folly of the first water. Why believe that the residents of Baltimore, once bailed out of their own mess – a mess they created for themselves! – would care any better for their city afterward than they did beforehand? Simply because “it was a Republican who finally stepped up and fixed everything” -- ? Memories of good deeds done to the undeserving aren’t “passed down from generation to generation;” they aren’t even perpetuated for a year! Does no one else remember that just last year, when volunteer Scott Presler led a group to Baltimore to clean up one of its worst trash-filled alleys, after which the Baltimore Sun questioned Presler’s motives – then claimed that the rest of us owed it to Baltimore to clean it up for them?

     Collectivists never accept responsibility for anything. Whatever the “problem,” it’s always someone else’s fault, and someone else’s responsibility to correct. They certainly don’t feel an obligation to keep their promises. The Democrats are collectivists. As we mathematical types are wont to say at such times, quod erat demonstrandum. But people resolved upon promoting a foolish notion will never accept that.


     It doesn’t matter how smart you are if you’re unwilling to look at the objective facts, or unwilling to draw the moral they present. I speak with some authority on this, having fallen into various kinds of folly on several occasions, including some recent ones, out of a desire to believe something that clashed with the observable facts. Those follies have cost me time, money, emotional distress, and hunks of my willingness to trust the newcomer by default. I’m not quite to the point of turning my back on others, but I’ve come close. Certainly I no longer accept rosy-glassed claims or piteous plaints without checking the evidence.

     The descent into folly is almost always because one has forgotten – or has decided to ignore or dismiss – an important bit of knowledge about people and the laws of Nature: i.e., a sturdy wisdom. Here’s a brief, non-exhaustive list:

  1. Life is short.
  2. Debt is a form of slavery.
  3. Men and women are different.
  4. There is no such thing as casual sex.
  5. Governments never return seized rights or money.
  6. He who won’t help himself doesn’t deserve your help.
  7. He who wants power over you is inherently untrustworthy.
  8. To get a man to do something, you must get him to want to do it.

     Post that list over your computer. Refer to it often. It’s a handy way of averting the descent into folly – and take my word for it: you’re not so smart that you’re immune to folly’s lures.

Saturday, March 25, 2017

Sturdy Wisdoms: The Worst Habit

     [Just yesterday, after a jaunt on which I spent far too much money on cheese – it’s one of my more difficult-to-resist vices – I received an email from Dystopic of The Declination. He drew my attention to his most recent essay, and mentioned that he’d come to an opinion about mortgage debt that differed greatly from his original one. He wrote that the change was because of the essay below, which first appeared at Eternity Road on December 13, 2006. In appreciation of his missive and the implied compliment...and yes, in recognition of the folly of spending so much on exotic cheeses that I was moved to inquire of the cheese shop proprietor whether financing might be available...I repost it here. -- FWP]


     Your Curmudgeon is rather older than most wanderers of the World Wide Web, including most of those who hawk their opinions to a general audience. He received a different sort of upbringing from most, too. As his years lengthen, he finds himself ever more frequently revisiting the teachings of his youth and reviewing them for continuing soundness and applicability.

     Many of those lessons are still quite serviceable -- infinitely more so than the guff that's displaced them in more recent years. In part, that's due to an underlying shift in premises; half a century ago, no one would have dared to posit that right and wrong are relative, or that there can be no absolute moral standards, or that "good for you" and "bad for you" are anything but matters of opinion. Today one seldom hears anything else. If you don't believe it, either you don't have children or you haven't paid enough attention to what their "teachers" have been telling them.

     Accordingly, your Curmudgeon has decided to trot out, one by one, the sturdiest and most useful of the simple wisdoms with which his own parents and teachers equipped him. It is his opinion that their promulgation could do quite a lot to correct the faults of modern American society, and even more to quell the rising tide of dissatisfaction with life that afflicts so many of our teens and young adults.

     Of course, opinions will vary. Read on, and judge for yourself.


     High among the homiletic primaries is this one: don't allow yourself to form bad habits. From the ordinary meanings of the words, this would seem self-evidently wise. For a "bad habit" is a behavior pattern that does harm to oneself. Of course, there's a heavy murk around that word "bad," whose variable interpretation has been the ingress for a lot of irrationality, but we'll get to that some other time.

     There are any number of habits on whose badness Americans would generally agree -- and not by thin majorities, either:

  • Avoidance of exercise;
  • Routinely bad nutrition and overeating;
  • Impropriety of disclosure (i.e., the habit of revealing sensitive facts about oneself or one's family, friends, and acquaintances to persons who ought not to be told);
  • Excessive television watching;
  • Smoking;
  • Drinking to excess;
  • The use of recreational drugs.

     The above is, of course, a partial list. Other bad habits less dramatic in their effects would draw general concurrence as well. But there has been a sea change in American attitudes so complete, yet so quiet, that the very worst of all habits, by which millions of persons have utterly destroyed themselves and their kin beyond all hope of renewal, is almost never addressed. Indeed, when it's mentioned, most persons either refuse to acknowledge it or turn away to conceal their embarrassment.

     The habit of which your Curmudgeon speaks is living beyond your means.

     This venerable phrase has almost been effaced from our culture. Yet our nation's habit of living beyond its means is a regular news feature, reported through innumerable channels at least once per month. What else does the federal deficit signify? What else does the American trade deficit signify? What else does it mean when the dollar drops in value against the currencies of other lands? (It's been quite a long time since a physician last clapped your Curmudgeon on the shoulder and told him that he's "sound as a dollar," and not because your Curmudgeon is quick to take umbrage at insult.)

     What's bad in the large is just as bad in the small, yet nearly all of us do it, and very few of us will admit to it.

     Likely you, Gentle Reader, are nodding, perhaps a bit reluctantly, at the unwisdom of "living beyond your means." But you haven't seen your Curmudgeon's kicker yet:

If you've borrowed money, for any reason whatsoever, that you can't immediately pay back out of your own reserves, you're living beyond your means.

     Yes, that includes home mortgages and car loans.


     A century ago, "mortgage" was a dirty word. (Car loans were, of course, unknown.) In fact, the word means "death pledge." It denoted a promise to return the mortgaged property to the legal ownership of the mortgagee -- the lender -- upon the mortgagor's -- the borrower's -- death. Indeed, it still means exactly that.

     Mortgages in the Nineteenth Century were almost exclusively the province and the bane of farmers. Private housing in non-farm areas was very seldom mortgaged. The income tax, the rise of the lending industry, and the demographic and financial conditions that prevailed after our two World Wars were the impetus by which Americans were goosed into thinking that living in homes they do not own, that could be ripped out from under them at any moment, was perfectly all right.

     It's hard to get reliable statistics on the matter, but according to a financial professional of your Curmudgeon's acquaintance, no fewer than 75% of all private homes are mortgaged. The deeds to those homes are encumbered in such a fashion that the persons who "own" them could be stripped of them at any time. It would not surprise your Curmudgeon too greatly if those provisions were invoked to put force behind a Kelo-esque eminent domain proceeding; financiers and politicians have always traveled in the same circles.

     But even apart from the hazards involved in living in mortgaged housing, it's almost always unwise to undertake a mortgage for reasons of simple financial prudence:

  • It's a long-term obligation, typically 15 years or more;
  • The lender is legally privileged over the borrower -- that is, nearly all the options rest with the lender, nearly none with the borrower;
  • The borrower's income, upon which he depends for his debt service, is almost never guaranteed;
  • A default on a mortgage is regarded as the worst of financial sins, and in the worst case can ruin an individual's financial standing for the rest of his life;
  • In the event of a default, the borrower seldom recovers any significant percentage of his notional equity in the mortgaged property.

     If a mortgage, which is secured by real property and carries tax advantages that are attached to no other form of debt, is unwise, then what need one say about chattel loans on cars and other movable property? What need one say about credit-card debt, which carries extremely high interest rates and has ruined millions of families in the past quarter century alone?


     Many a reader has been saying to himself "But how could I get the things I need without incurring these debts?" for several paragraphs now. Such questions arise from a perverse sense of "need" far more often than not. Americans are hooked on material self-indulgence; easy credit is the pusher that feeds our habit. Most of what we have, we do not need. We want it, and we certainly enjoy it, but those are far different things.

     "Need" is the gateway drug. "Need" is habitually "defined down" over time: from a house, to a car, to better clothes, to a better car, to a really nice house in a "suitable" neighborhood, to designer jeans and sneakers for the kids, to the latest iPods®, to a PlayStation 3 ® and all the "hot" games for it, to a Giant Economy Size bottle of Chivas Regal to dull the pain from having to pay for all that stuff.

     Man's needs are food, clothing, shelter, and heat. All else is discretionary. The truly prudent man does not incur debt to pay for discretionary items.

     Let it be admitted that most Americans, despite their debt anchors, manage to skirt the shoals of financial disaster. But an appalling number do not, and a significant fraction of those never quite recover from the wreck. Compound interest, which master financier Baron Philippe de Rothschild called "the eighth wonder of the world," is in fact the eighth horror of the world for those habituated to debt. Its ability to drain all the vitality from one's present and hope from one's future is unequalled by anything but cocaine and heroin.

     In what might be the supreme irony of ironies, innumerable Americans look for their salvation from their debts...to government. Not only is our government the most egregious abuser of credit in the history of the world, it has an unadmitted interest in encouraging debt to the widest possible extent. Widespread severe debt is the motivator for governmental abuse of the currency: inflation. Inflation in our fiat-currency system gifts Washington with billions of "free" dollars with which it can increase its power over the rest of us. But Americans with substantial savings will not tolerate inflation; Americans deeply mired in debt, seeing the chance to pay down their obligations with "cheap" money, will embrace it eagerly.


     If you're a young person who has yet to acquire any debts, don't! Live beneath your means; acquire savings. Only borrow when utterly forced to do so, and only as a capital investment in yourself: that is, for tools or an education. Be ruthless in assuring that every dollar you make arrives in your pocket with no debt-service strings attached.

     A young man with a white-collar salary, who restricts his consumption for just ten years and puts his unspent balance into conservative investments (i.e., steady 3% to 5% returns), can usually produce the entire purchase price of a house at the end of that period. He'll have no trouble affording the cash purchase of a used car. Does it mean that he'll live in a less opulent style than that enjoyed by his coevals? Yes. But it also means that the fangs of the debt habit and the shackles of compound interest will have no chance to snag him.

     An older man who has lived free from debt can be certain of mobility and security. He will have savings. No occupational reversal will have the power to dispossess him. Neither will misfortunes of nature render him helpless. He will have leverage in all negotiations that a man chained to debt and beholden to creditors would not possess. He will be as free as his individual efforts can possibly make him. When he passes from this world, he will be able to leave his progeny a substantial patrimony. More, he will have already shown them an invaluable example.

     A sturdy wisdom indeed.

Monday, March 2, 2026

Prices

     Everything has a price. It needn’t be printed on a label or concealed in a bar code. The price is there – and if you want it, you must pay.

     Time was, we realized that. We called it “reality.” Hey, that’s the root of “realize,” isn’t it? To confront an immutable fact and acknowledge that it’s independent of our desires and opinions? My word, what insights spring from a little thought, even at this hour!

     Smith wants a raise. What’s the price? How should he proffer it? Why, by being more valuable to his employer than he is today. Then he must demonstrate that fact to his supervisor and ask, nicely, for the appropriate compensation.

     Jones wants a promotion. What’s the price? That’s harder, since that promotion would entail exercising authority that Jones doesn’t yet have. But Jones can distinguish himself by the excellence of his organization and the management of his responsibilities. Management above his head is likely to notice – and if it doesn’t, he can always pursue the position he wants at another firm.

     Davis wants love: the love of a good, attractive, affectionate, loyal woman. What’s the price? This one comes in stages. First, he must become the sort of man a good woman would love. Then he must “put himself out there,” accepting the inconvenience and enduring the indifference of many in the hope that one will notice. When one does notice, he must accept that she’s not the fantasy creature that lurks in his dreams.

     Marie wants her husband to pay more attention to her: to stay home at night, to oblige her desire for his company, and to show her affection. What’s the price? Well, she could stop wearing stained and baggy sweat clothes all the time. She could take more care with her hair and skin. She could resist the urge to nag him. She could show him the woman he courted – the woman whose appeal he found impossible to resist.

     Those prices aren’t dollar-denominated. They’re simply what the above-named must do to get what they want. Yet they’re as real as any amount of any currency proffered for an item on a store shelf.

     Common knowledge? Folk wisdom? Perhaps. But a lot of people seem not to know it. Whatever you want, it will come at a price. Wanting isn’t enough. Demanding isn’t enough. You must discern the price – possibly negotiate it – and you must contrive to pay it.

     And of course, there’s always the possibility that the price will be beyond your means.

* * *

     It’s usual when I’m off on such a tirade that some Gentle Reader will ask why this subject at this time. It’s simple: I’ve been listening to unhappy people. They don’t have what they want and have been whining about it. I resist the urge to lecture them; I’ve learned from long and painful experience that it seldom does any good. Instead I come here and write it down.

     Time was, I wrote a few pieces about “sturdy wisdoms:” bits of knowledge that have proved themselves over the centuries. The most reliable of all such wisdoms is this one:

Know what you want.
Know its price.
Make ready to pay or forgo it.

     Herewith, an old story of mine.


Prices

     It was Alex's habit to arrive early for class, especially a class where he expected to be conspicuous. Analysis II might be one such, attended mostly by Chinese who had been sent to the university because of its reputation in mathematics. He might well be the only Caucasian enrolled in it. It had been that way in Analysis I, the semester before.
     There were only two others in the classroom when he arrived. He took a seat against the windows, near the front, and busied himself arranging his notebook and writing tools. The classroom filled steadily with students and the low gabble characteristic of an as-yet-unconvened lecture class. He paid no attention.
     The last student to arrive was a young Chinese woman, the only female in the class. She was beautiful in the subtle, delicate way of her people, with flawless features, porcelain skin, a gently curved figure, and straight, shiny black hair that fell just past her shoulders. Alex looked up just as she walked in. Her eyes met his briefly; then she turned away and took one of the few seats remaining, on the far side of the room.
     As he'd expected, the class was entirely Chinese except for himself. He had nothing against the Chinese, but it grieved him that his countrymen showed so little interest in the queen of the sciences. As he surveyed the room, he noticed that the young woman was looking at him. Their eyes met again for an instant. He felt a pang pass through him that was unrelated to the study of mathematics. Most of the other students were appraising the young woman as well.
     The instructor swept in and tossed a large briefcase on the table at the front of the classroom. Alex collected himself and made ready to concentrate.

#

     Alex arrived early for the next meeting of the class as well, and settled again into a seat against the windows. He was startled when the girl walked in thirty seconds later.
     At the previous session, her clothes and grooming had been college-student normal: denim and loafers, and no makeup at all. Today she was garbed in a black silk blouse with a cowl collar, a black leather skirt that came to just above the knee, sheer stockings, and black leather high heels. More than that, she had made herself up. Her face, which had been beautiful even without cosmetics, had become a glowing song of subtle reds and yellows. It was a look a woman might take hours to perfect, and it was unheard of among the Chinese.
     Alex watched the young woman in fascination as she scanned the almost empty classroom, found him, and walked directly toward him. She took the seat at his elbow. She seated herself in silence and extracted a notebook and pen from her large purse. Alex noticed that she was also wearing fragrance, a light but musky scent that would be impossible to ignore. When the instructor arrived ten minutes later, it was all Alex could do to tear his eyes and thoughts away from her.
     An hour later, as the class dispersed, he tried to shovel his materials into his backpack and exit without looking at her again. She did not permit it.
     "Excuse me?"
     "Yes?" He hoped his internal turmoil was not evident from his face or voice.
     "What was the reading assignment again, please?" Though her English was perfect, the lilt on her words made it plain that she had not been born in America.
     He waved toward the blackboard, where the assignment was still on display, and started away, hoping to lose himself in the rush of bodies seeking nothing but the next class of the day.
     She laid a hand on his arm. The gentle touch rocked him more than any blow could have done.
     "Have I made you uncomfortable? Please tell me how." Midnight black eyes opened wide looked straight into his own, threatening to drown him.
     He felt himself becoming light-headed, losing control not only of events but of his rationality. His breath seemed caught in his chest. He was able to produce only the falsest of smiles, no poise in it at all.
     "No, it's all right, really, excuse me please, I have to go." He turned and tried to hurry away, but the strap of his pack caught on the arm of the chair. The chair went over with a crash, and the contents of the pack distributed themselves over the classroom floor. Heedless of everything but the need to escape, he scooped up his belongings, jammed them into his pack, and darted for the door, not daring to try for a more dignified exit. The other students tittered at his back.

#

     She continued to arrive just after he did and to seat herself next to him. He could have sworn she was following him. When he chose a seat at the back of the room, so did she. She also continued to dress as if she were on her way to a high-society dinner party. A number of the Chinese men tried to attract her interest. She disregarded them completely.
     She made no attempt to conceal her interest in him. He could not help sneaking glances her way. Almost always, she would be doing the same.
     Alex began to dread the class. Mathematics, his major, was becoming his least favorite subject, for he could no longer think of it without thinking of her. She began to intrude upon his thoughts at all hours and occasions. He, who had prided himself upon his ability to focus, was having trouble clearing his thoughts of a young woman whose name he did not know.
     After a month he could bear it no longer. Instead of hurrying from the class at its conclusion, as had become his habit, he steeled himself and turned toward her, and found her already looking at him. She showed no sign of surprise.
     "Why?"
     He hated himself for the tremor in his voice. He had never had any luck with girls in the past, but at least he could be proud that he had never lost his head over one. Now it was all going wrong.
     "Will you come and talk with me?"
     There was no special intensity in the words. She seemed to have been waiting for this. He clenched his teeth and nodded once.
     She rose and reached out toward him. He took her hand and allowed her to lead him from the room, acutely conscious of the many pairs of eyes that followed.

#

     The coffeehouse was almost empty that afternoon. Alex and the girl had seated themselves in a corner recess. Even had the shop been filled with patrons, they would have been hidden from most and turned away from the rest. A single waitress sat at the counter, reading a romance novel. Soft folk music issued from an unseen source.
     "Will you tell me why? Please?"
     She looked down at the table and the untouched cinnamon roll he had bought her. "It's not easy to explain."
     He waited in silence. She looked up and said, "Have you ever been to China?"
     "No, of course not."
     She smiled sadly. " 'Of course not' ? But you are an American and can go anywhere, while I am only here because the People's Republic of China thinks I am likely to repay its investment."
     He said nothing, fingers playing idly with his sticky bun.
     "Most Americans know very little of my country. Women are not respected there as they are here."
     He grinned at that. "You might hear a different opinion from some of the feminists."
     She sneered, and his grin slipped away. "Then they are fools. They do not appreciate America. One week in the People's Republic would teach them to love it."
     She looked down. "More than anything else in the world, I want to be an American girl. I want to feel the freedom they feel, and have the same sense of possibilities." She hesitated, then looked directly into his eyes. "At least, I want an American boyfriend."
     Alex sat motionless, hands folded before him on the table, as he groped for some purchase on this incredible conversation.
     "You want . . . me."
     She nodded, face serious. "Yes."
     You'd like to remain in America, wouldn't you?
     "You haven't told me your name, you know."
     "Chen Hsiao-ling."
     "Hsiao-ling, my name is Alex Betancourt." He wiped his hand clean of frosting on his jeans, then extended it across the table for her to shake. She did not shake it. She clutched at it with both of her own and pulled it to her cheek. Her expression was absurdly, dreamily blissful. After a moment's hesitation, he pulled their joined hands down to the surface of the table and waited for her to calm down.
     "Hsiao-ling, have you ever dated? Anybody?"
     She shook her head.
     His grin returned. "Neither have I, really. Why did you choose me?"
     The question seemed to puzzle her.
     "Why should I not choose you? You are bright, handsome, and a good mathematician. Are you damaged in some way that does not show?"
     He had no answer to that.

#

     At first Alex assumed that it would not last more than a week or two. He might be only nineteen, but he was a realist. He knew nothing of her, and it seemed obvious that her fancy for him was based on her fantasy of life in America, not on any attributes he possessed. Nevertheless, he took it, and her, seriously; it was his nature.
     He saw her as often as possible, and took her everywhere he could think of. The coffeehouse during the week. Museums, restaurants and movies on the weekends. When the weather warmed, they began to sojourn into New York City, sometimes to shop, sometimes simply to stroll, enjoying the pulse of so much human activity. The income provided by his part-time job was not large, but his tuition was covered by a scholarship, and he had practiced thrift all his life. He could afford to entertain her in these and other ways, and so he did.
     They talked of many things. She told him of her upbringing in China, of the bleak years of her childhood on a tea farm where there was always too much work and seldom enough to eat, of her slow discovery of her intellect and her love for mathematics. Then came the glimmer of hope: the competition to be selected to go to college in America and drink of the intellectual riches of the West, to bring them back to the parched and destitute East. It was not easy to gain permission to leave the People's Republic. One had to promise many things. But no promise would be considered sufficient if there were not at least one living relative from the immediate family to remain behind as surety for one's eventual return. Family feeling being as strong as it was among the Chinese, it was an inducement to return that few could resist.
     Hsiao-ling's surety was her mother. A widow at fifty-two, she now worked the tea farm with occasional assistance from two distant cousins and continuous obstruction from two government-provided "helpers."
     He told her of his own childhood, which seemed banal and carefree when compared to hers. Only the loss of his father when he was fifteen could match the least of her stories in poignancy. Yet she listened with complete attention. She probed for details, always relating them to her own experiences. She marveled that there were no ideological monitors in the grade schools. She reeled in shock upon being told that the State permitted schools other than its own to exist. And she could not quite believe that upon graduation, Alex was not to be assigned willy-nilly to a post of the State's choosing.
     He came to know and admire her with a speed as uncanny as the manner of their connection. Soon he had ceased to think about that at all. Their time together passed swiftly.

#

     The assaults began shortly thereafter.
     At first he paid no mind to the jostlings and impacts, assuming they were only the usual consequence of the press of bodies one had to endure just before and after a large class. But the frequency and severity of the incidents increased, and became difficult to ignore.
     He was tripped many times. He suffered several sharp blows to his back and to the back of his head. Two of them were powerful and unexpected enough to send him sprawling to the floor. When he looked about for an explanation, none was evident. No one stood there to confront him. He would find himself standing apart, the faces of his classmates turned away from him, as if he were the least noteworthy thing in the room.
     Once it happened in the open, as he was going from one building to another. The impact was to his lower back, near his kidneys, and was sharp enough to pitch him face-first into a patch of mud. He turned without rising, and saw a tall male figure receding from him at good speed. The young man's shoulders were hunched forward, denying Alex the sight of his face. His skin was Oriental in tone, and his short, glossy black hair was hardly disturbed by the early spring breeze.
     He thought about telling Hsiao-ling, and decided against it.

#

     She was always radiant when he was with her. He could not imagine a more beautiful, more vital, or happier woman. She continued to dress and make herself up for every meeting with him as if they were headed to a White House ball. Once he asked her why.
     "It's for you."
     "It's not necessary, you know."
     She smiled. "Yes, Alex, I know. But do you like it?"
     He stared at her. "What's the superlative of 'Christ, yes' ?"
     Despite a powerful reluctance to draw attention to himself, he resolved to try to match her. Over a period of weeks, the contents of his closet changed completely. A barber cut and tamed his rough blond hair. A manicurist brought refinement to his hands. He added cologne to his morning grooming ritual. She said nothing, but there was no concealing the delight she took in his efforts to make himself over for her.
     On the night of his twentieth birthday, after they had been seeing one another for about three months, they were walking back from their restaurant to his car, when she bade him to stop and look at an image on a television in a store window. It was of the two of them, captured by a video camera trained on the sidewalk.
     The tall young man in the picture was the image of youthful male elegance. He wore his navy blue blazer, his sharply creased gray trousers and his highly polished black Oxfords as if he'd been born to them. His grooming was immaculate, and his bearing was rich with self-assurance and pride. Alex could hardly believe that it was he.
     The young woman who held his hand and rested her cheek against his shoulder was the essence of youthful female beauty. Her gaze was not upon the image in the monitor, but upon him. It spoke of a devotion that bordered on adoration.
     He turned to face her, and she slid into his arms, face uptilted. When their lips met, the current that surged through him made him press the length of her body against his own. Her arms tightened around him in response. Neither of them noticed that dozens of passers-by had stopped to watch that kiss.
     She came back with him to his room that night, and they made love for the first time. He had never before done more than hold her hand. He could not bring himself to tell her that he was a virgin. He could hardly bring himself to think about what it would be like or what he would have to do. She guided him silently, her manner more comforting than any words.
     Afterward they held one another, weeping softly from pleasure and relief. Presently he said three words, in a voice that quivered only a little. Without inflection, she said them back to him, and the world was made new.

#

     "Hello?"
     "Hi, Mom."
     "Alex! How are you, dear?"
     "Terrific." He paused. "Mom, I'm in love."
     There was a moment's silence on the line.
     "That's wonderful, dear. Where did you meet her?"
     "In class. She's a math major too."
     "How long have you been seeing one another?"
     "About four months now."
     "Well? Aren't you going to tell me about her? What's her name?"
     "Hsiao-ling." He did his best to pronounce it as she would have.
     "Charlene? A very pretty name. What does her family do?"
     "Uh, they're in . . . agriculture."
     Another pause. "Farmers, Alex?"
     "Well, yes."
     "I suppose it's respectable enough. But you said she's headed into mathematics, too?"
     "Yes, she's really smart."
     Mrs. Andrew Betancourt of Washington, D.C., nee Angela Tessier of Niagara Falls, New York, chuckled dryly. "I don't suppose you'll be willing to consider medical school now, if there'll be another mathematician in the family?"
     "Mom—!"
     She chuckled again. "I've missed you, Alex. I've even missed that tone of exasperation of yours. I only ask because your father wanted it so much. But even he wouldn't have tried too hard to talk you out of mathematics. He knew how much you loved it, and I do too."
     He sighed. "I know, Mom. It's okay."
     "But let's get to the important matters now. Is your Charlene a Catholic? And will I get to meet her soon?"

#

     As the end of the semester approached, Alex found himself unwilling to face the prospect of a separation from Hsiao-ling. Yet it seemed inevitable. He would return to Washington, and she would return to the People's Republic of China. It took him a long time to work up the courage to ask her if she could contrive a way to stay.
     "I will be back in September, Alex, just as you will."
     They were seated on his bed, having passed the afternoon in study. Textbooks and notes were spread all around them.
     "Are you sure?"
     She shrugged. "Not perfectly sure. Sometimes the government changes its mind. But it has no reason to do that to me. My grades are good, and I have shown no sign of disloyalty."
     "Oh, you haven't? What about your relationship with me?"
     She said nothing.
     "Well, how would they know about anything you've done here?"
     She pursed her lips. "One or two of the students from the People's Republic are monitors. I don't know which ones, of course. Their duties include keeping watch on the rest of us. They would report any indication that I was about to request political asylum, or had filed for permanent residence, or..."
     "Or had gotten involved with an American?"
     She sat unmoving for a moment, then nodded. "Perhaps, if they knew."
     He took her hands between his own. "Hsiao-ling, when we first met, I assumed that what you liked best about me was that I'm an American citizen. That may have been callous of me, but a lot of girls from other countries do marry American men just for the right to stay here. That never occurred to you . . . did it?"
     Her eyes had gone very wide. Mutely, she shook her head. After a moment she tried to pull her hands from his. He did not permit it. She looked down into her lap, face red with shame she did not deserve.
     He began to speak, and found that his tongue had cleaved to the bottom of his mouth. His throat had gone completely dry, and his pulse had begun to pound in his ears.
     "Hsiao-ling, will you marry me?" It came out as a croak.
     She looked up at him, astonished. "What did you say?"
     Without releasing her hands, he rose from the bed, moved to face her, and sank awkwardly to his knees. Her eyes were riveted to his.
     "Chen Hsiao-ling, will you marry me and be my wife? Come live with me and be my love for all the days and nights of our lives? Share my successes and failures? Bear my children? Grow old with me? For ever and ever, till death do us part?"
     He had never seen a human being so taken by surprise. Her eyes had opened so wide that her epicanthic folds had disappeared. Her mouth was open, but no sound issued forth. She was shaking from head to toe.
     "Hsiao-ling, will you marry me? I won't ask again."
     Her voice was the faintest of whispers.
     "Yes."
     He rose and pulled her into his arms. She continued to shake. He waited, holding her close. Presently she spoke again, her voice still whisper-faint but piercing from grief.
     "My mother."

#

     The next day was the final examination for Analysis II. Alex and Hsiao-ling arrived together and were heading for their usual seats when he received a savage blow in the small of the back.
     Rage too long repressed flared within him. He whirled and flailed a tightly balled fist. By luck he caught his assailant across the face. The young Chinese staggered back and righted himself, but the target who had been so passive until now charged and took him by the throat.
     Alex gave the thug no time to react. He shoved the young man's head into the wall of the classroom with all his strength. The crack of the impact rang through the room. The Chinese slid down the wall and lay there, slumped against its base.
     "Get up."
     The boy didn't move. Perhaps he was too dazed to make sense of the words. While the rest of the class watched, Alex reached down and grabbed his attacker's shirt front, hoisted and heaved him into a vacant seat at the front of the room.
     Alex breathed once deeply, pulled himself upright and turned to face the rest of the class.
     "Is there anyone else here who'd like to lay his hands on me?"
     Silence gripped the room. At that moment the instructor arrived. He stopped in the doorway, examination papers clutched in one hand. Alex ignored him.
     "I have been struck from behind too many times this semester for this piece of garbage to be the only one who was doing it. Who else is involved? Are you willing to face me openly, or is your government unable to afford the services of men?"
     After a moment, a student near the back of the room rose.
     "We are not in the employ of our government. We are only students."
     Alex scowled as contempt rose within him.
     "That would only make it worse. That would mean that all of this has been because you don't want your countrywoman to be involved with a white man."
     The boy sat. Alex went to where Hsiao-ling stood, well away from where the violence had occurred, and led her by the hand to stand before their classmates.
     "This lady is my fiancée. In a week she'll be my wife. If any of you have a problem with that for any reason at all, I'll be happy to give you satisfaction." He waved at his assailant, who had slumped forward in his seat. "I believe I've satisfied him."
     He waited a moment more before leading Hsiao-ling back to their seats. They sat and waited as the instructor, himself of Chinese birth, moved falteringly among them to distribute the examinations.

#

     She finished the examination before him and hurried from the classroom, leaving him to finish alone. Everyone else in the room turned to look at him. He ignored them.
     When he had finished, he went to her room. She admitted him in silence. She had begun to pack her belongings. Apart from her clothes, there wasn't much to pack.
     "Have I done something to offend you?"
     "No." She would not meet his eyes.
     "Are you frightened of something? Maybe of me?"
     "No."
     He moved forward and took her by the shoulders. "Hsiao-ling, I've grown accustomed to longer sentences. I should tell you that in this country, it's customary for husbands and wives to talk to one another. At least, I expect it."
     She looked up at him then. "You still mean to do that."
     "Of course I do!"
     "But the price is so high!"
     He started to expostulate, then stopped and forced calm upon himself.
     "Yes, it is. The prices of valuable things usually are. Even today, there's enough racism left in America to make trouble for us. A lot of people who think of themselves as tolerant sorts get all bent out of shape at the sight of an interracial couple. There probably won't be any more violence, but we'll have to deal with snide comments and gestures of contempt for as long as we live. We might have professional difficulties. There are neighborhoods in which we wouldn't be accepted and could never live. You're worth it to me."
     He heard his voice rise with his emotions, and forced himself to calm down once again.
     "It's worse among your people than mine. Much worse, or so I've been told. Am I worth it to you?"
     In response she wrapped her arms around him and buried her face in his chest. Neither spoke for a long time.
     Presently he said, "You haven't heard about your wedding gift."
     She pulled back and looked up at him. "What?"
     "I've got a little something picked out for you. Hope you like it. I'm afraid it's going to be very hard to wrap."
     She sputtered. "I thought wedding presents came from the rest of the family."
     "Yes, and that's sort of where this one is coming from, too. Did I ever tell you that my father worked for the State Department his whole life?"
     She gaped. He smiled.
     "There are still quite a few people in State who knew Dad and liked him a lot. I've been in touch with a few of them. They've told me that an exit visa for your mother won't pose much of a problem, once we're married. And she'll automatically have permanent resident status here, too. So that part of the price you won't have to pay at all."
     He had thought her beautiful before, but it was as nothing to the light of joy that transfigured her features then.
     "Of course, there is another price we'll have to pay."
     She cocked her head, wary once more. "Another price?"
     He swallowed hard and forced a smile.
     "Hsiao-ling, have I ever told you about my mother?"

==<O>==

Copyright © 1995 Francis W. Porretto. All Rights Reserved Worldwide.

Saturday, May 11, 2019

Metrics

     Allow me to begin this tirade begin on a personal note: I’m overweight and have been for years. Not grotesquely, mind you; just about fifteen pounds. However, they’re inconvenient pounds, located in an inconvenient place that makes bending difficult. So I’m trying to lose them. As part of the effort, each morning upon rising I mount the bathroom scale and watch as it measures my current weight.

     In recent weeks that number has been trending downward, albeit slowly. That’s all right; a slow loss arising from a lifestyle change is more likely to result in an enduring improvement. So when I see a number lower than the one I saw the day before, I’m pleased. When the number is the same as the day before or higher, I frown.

     Does that behavior seem logical to you, Gentle Reader, now that you know of my aims? It should. But does it seem a complete measure of whether I’m progressing or regressing? If it does, you’re not thinking the problem all the way through.

     Why measure a particular thing? Indeed, why measure anything?

     A measure is normally tied to a goal. Imagine that there’s some goal you want to reach. If you can express that goal in measurable terms, subsequent measurements will tell you whether you’re getting nearer to that goal or farther from it.

     Any goal can be characterized in two ways:

  1. Intermediate;
  2. End-state.

     An intermediate goal is one we seek in advancing toward some other goal. An end-state goal is one we seek for its own sake. In the business world, intermediate goals are often called milestones, probably because we tend to trip over them for focusing on the end-state goal. The end-state goal will normally have direct relevance to the production of revenue: e.g., the release of a product for sale.

     The above might seem like “of course” material. In a sense, that what it is: the subconscious stratum of considerations everyone’s conscious decision-making is founded on. But now and then it should be hauled out of the shadows and examined in the light. Doing so can keep us from doing some silly, counterproductive, and outrightly destructive things.


     Many years ago, I formulated a schematic for all human action. I called it The Algorithm:

  1. Select a technique that you think will get you what you think you want.
  2. Will this technique cause you to lose body parts, go to jail, or burn in Hell?
    • If so, return to step 1.
    • If not, proceed to step 3.
  3. Do a little of it.
  4. Are you at your goal, approaching it, or receding from it?
    • If at your goal, stop.
    • If receding, return to step 1.
    • If approaching, return to step 3.

     That is how we do everything. There are no exceptions. But have a close look at step 4. It asks a question without propounding a method for answering it. What method should apply?

     In short, there must be a metric that will allow us to answer the question. The metrics best suited to some goals are more easily found than those that apply to others. Indeed, there are some goals for which the quest for the right metric is ongoing. But until the correct metric is chosen, whether we are progressing toward our goal or receding from it will be indeterminable.

     The critical word in the paragraph above is correct, as in “the correct metric.” Monitoring an irrelevancy won’t help. Indeed, by distracting us from what really matters it will likely conduce to failure.

     The central question in all of public policy has always been:

Given the goal we pursue,
What is the correct metric?

     In our time, that question is almost never answered correctly.


     Libertarian theorist and activist Kevin Cullinane once proposed a definition of progress:

     “Progress is the improved satisfaction of human desires, morally, with less effort.”

     Like “The Algorithm” of the previous segment, Cullinane’s statement implies a question: What is the proper metric for determining whether human desires are being satisfied in an improved degree? The answer is elusive for one giant reason: “our leaders” don’t want us to think about it.

     I know when my desires are being better satisfied than they were yesterday. I’d bet the mortgage money that you could say the same. But consider, as a trivial case (in the mathematical sense), the problem of marriage. How can Smith determine whether Mrs. Smith’s desires are being better satisfied today than yesterday?

     Any married man can tell you that the problem is stiff, as the married man will surely be before the answer comes to him.

     As the question is ramified by further collectivization – i.e.:

From individuals;
   to couples;
     to families;
       to neighborhoods;
         to towns;
           to counties;
             to states;
               to the nation;

     …all metrics become murky and indistinct, and all answers to the question in Step 4 of “The Algorithm” become indeterminate.

     That’s what “our leaders” don’t want us to think about. It’s also my major reason for writing, whether fiction or op-eds to appear here at Liberty’s Torch.


     On January 2, 2019, Tucker Carlson vented a subtly impassioned Jeremiad against the indifference of the “ruling class.” I didn’t see that segment of Tucker Carlson Tonight; I’m almost always in bed before 9:00 PM. Anyway, I seldom watch television other than a Yankees baseball game or a Rangers hockey game. My attention was drawn to it by a pair of opinion pieces:

  1. This one of a couple of weeks ago;
  2. This one of just this morning.

     Carlson’s soliloquy and the two articles it inspired put me in mind of the old poem about the blind men and the elephant:

It was six men of Indostan
To learning much inclined,
Who went to see the Elephant
(Though all of them were blind),
That each by observation
Might satisfy his mind.

The First approached the Elephant,
And happening to fall
Against his broad and sturdy side,
At once began to bawl:
"God bless me!—but the Elephant
Is very like a wall!"

The Second, feeling of the tusk,
Cried: "Ho!—what have we here
So very round and smooth and sharp?
To me 't is mighty clear
This wonder of an Elephant
Is very like a spear!"

The Third approached the animal,
And happening to take
The squirming trunk within his hands,
Thus boldly up and spake: "I see," quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a snake!"

The Fourth reached out his eager hand,
And felt about the knee.
"What most this wondrous beast is like
Is mighty plain," quoth he;
"'T is clear enough the Elephant
Is very like a tree!"

The Fifth, who chanced to touch the ear,
Said: "E'en the blindest man
Can tell what this resembles most;
Deny the fact who can,
This marvel of an Elephant
Is very like a fan!"

The Sixth no sooner had begun
About the beast to grope,
Than, seizing on the swinging tail
That fell within his scope,
"I see," quoth he, "the Elephant
Is very like a rope!"

And so these men of Indostan
Disputed loud and long,
Each in his own opinion
Exceeding stiff and strong,
Though each was partly in the right,
And all were in the wrong!

So, oft in theologic wars
The disputants, I ween,
Rail on in utter ignorance
Of what each other mean,
And prate about an Elephant
Not one of them has seen!

[John Godfrey Saxe]

     Saxe might have been amused at the passionate disputes of theologians, but the point is relevant to public policy as well. Numbers of many sorts are available to the policy-maker. Many a “policy wonk” will trumpet such numbers loudly, implying that they measure something “the government” should regard as important. But do they really? Indeed, do they measure anything of importance?


     It’s become clear that no purely economic metric – take the Dow-Jones Industrial Average as an example – really measures the health of our nation. Indeed, it might mislead us regardless of the purpose to which we put it. The DJIA is a composite based on thirty stocks. There are far more equities than that being traded. But even if they were all factored into the DJIA, what could it possibly tell us?

     Tucker Carlson’s focus is on families. It’s arguably a better focus, but one to which no imaginable metric could be applied. Rate of family formation? Interesting information, but what kinds of families are being formed? Reproduction rates? Again, very interesting, especially to demographers, but there are some pretty squalid, miserably unhappy nations with high reproduction rates. These numbers are of the sort some wag once compared to a bikini on a beautiful girl: “What it reveals is interesting, but what it conceals is vital.”

     A public policy supremely concerned with families would be no more likely than a purely econometric one to bring about a “happy, prosperous, stable nation.” There are no metrics that would reliably lead us to the goal we seek…because collective goals are always illusory:

     There is no half-baked ecclesiastic, bawling in his galvanized-iron temple on a suburban lot, who doesn’t know precisely how it ought to be dealt with. There is no fantoddish old suffragette, sworn to get her revenge on man, who hasn’t a sovereign remedy for it. There is not a shyster of a district attorney, ambitious for higher office, who doesn’t offer to dispose of it in a few weeks, given only enough help from the city editors. And yet, by the same token, there is not a man who has honestly studied it and pondered it, bringing sound information to the business, and understanding of its inner difficulties and a clean and analytical mind, who doesn’t believe and hasn’t stated publicly that it is intrinsically and eternally insoluble. For example, Havelock Ellis. His remedy is simply a denial of all remedies. He admits that the disease is bad, but he shows that the medicine is infinitely worse, and so he proposes going back to the plain disease, and advocates bearing it with philosophy, as we bear colds in the head, marriage, the noises of the city, bad cooking and the certainty of death. Man is inherently vile—but he is never so vile as when he is trying to disguise and deny his vileness. No prostitute was ever so costly to a community as a prowling and obscene vice crusader, or as the dubious legislator or prosecuting officer who jumps at such swine pipe. [H. L. Mencken]

     That’s what “our leaders” don’t want us to think about. Were we to embrace the truth in it, they would no longer be “our leaders.” Indeed, we would have no “leaders.”


     When we institute political conditions that embed specific incentives and constraints – and every political system does this – behavior emerges that exploits those incentives and constraints. This is, if you like, Political Ecology 101: the metaphysical law that no legislature can repeal or modify. Ayn Rand understood it well:

     [Dagny] knew that no train schedules could be maintained any longer, no promises kept, no contracts observed, that regular trains were cancelled at a moment’s notice and transformed into emergency specials sent by unexplained orders to unexpected destinations—and that the orders came from Cuffy Meigs, sole judge of emergencies and of the public welfare. She knew that factories were closing, some with their machinery stilled for lack of supplies that had not been received, others with their warehouses full of goods that could not be delivered. She knew that the old industries—the giants who had built their power by a purposeful course projected over a span of time—were left to exist at the whim of the moment, a moment they could not foresee or control. She knew that the best among them, those of the longest range and most complex function, had long since gone—and those still struggling to produce, struggling savagely to preserve the code of an age when production had been possible, were now inserting into their contracts a line shameful to a descendant of Nat Taggart: “Transportation permitting.”

     And yet there were men—and she knew it—who were able to obtain transportation whenever they wished, as by a mystic secret, as by the grace of some power which one was not to question or explain. They were the men whose dealings with Cuffy Meigs were regarded by people as that unknowable of mystic creeds which smites the observer for the sin of looking, so people kept their eyes closed, dreading, not ignorance, but knowledge. She knew that deals were made whereby those men sold a commodity known as “transportation pull”—a term which all understood, but none would dare define. She knew that these were the men of the emergency specials, the men who could cancel her scheduled trains and send them to any random spot of the continent which they chose to strike with their voodoo stamp, the stamp superseding contract, property, justice, reason and lives, the stamp stating that “the public welfare” required the immediate salvation of that spot. These were the men who sent trains to the relief of the Smather Brothers and their grapefruit in Arizona—to the relief of a factory in Florida engaged in the production of pin-ball machines—to the relief of a horse farm in Kentucky—to the relief of Orren Boyle’s Associated Steel.

     These were the men who made deals with desperate industrialists to provide transportation for the goods stalled in their warehouses—or, failing to obtain the percentage demanded, made deals to purchase the goods, when the factory closed, at the bankruptcy sale, at ten cents on the dollar, and to speed the goods away in freight cars suddenly available, away to markets where dealers of the same kind were ready for the kill. There were the men who hovered over factories, waiting for the last breath of a furnace, to pounce upon the equipment—and over desolate sidings, to pounce upon the freight cars of undelivered goods—these were a new biological species, the hit-and-run businessmen, who did not stay in any line of business longer than the span of one deal, who had no payrolls to meet, no overhead to carry, no real estate to own, no equipment to build, whose only asset and sole investment consisted of an item known as “friendship.” These were the men whom official speeches described as “the progressive businessmen of our dynamic age,” but whom people called “the pull peddlers”—the species included many breeds, those of “transportation pull,” and of “steel pull” and “oil pull” and “wage-raise pull” and “suspended sentence pull”—men who were dynamic, who kept darting all over the country while no one else could move, men who were active and mindless, active, not like animals, but like that which breeds, feeds and moves upon the stillness of a corpse.

     Rand said it so well in the above snippet that I can add nothing to it except this, from “humorist” P. J. O’Rourke:

     “When buying and selling are controlled by legislation, the first things to be bought and sold are legislators.”


     If what I write here is useful to anyone, it’s because I strive to see widely and to reason inclusively. Yes, I have a value of supreme political importance: individual freedom, as if you needed to be reminded. Yes, I have my own desires and a priority scale for them. But I would not imagine that many other persons would have values, desires, and priorities exactly identical to mine.

     No one has values, desires, and priorities exactly identical to yours. He who seeks to persuade you of the opposite is your enemy. Indeed, he might be a monster.

     Believe it or not, there are persons whose highest aim is the eradication of the overwhelmingly greater part of Mankind. Many of them are considered “respectable,” even purveyors of “wisdom.” They pass the streets in safety by not saying explicitly what they seek.

     Believe it or not, there are persons whose highest aim is the enslavement of the overwhelmingly greater part of Mankind. Many of them are considered “respectable,” even “statesmen” of importance. They pass the streets in safety by not saying explicitly what they seek.

     Believe it or not, there are persons whose highest aim is the impoverishment of the overwhelmingly greater part of Mankind. Many of them are considered “respectable,” even important “humanitarians.” They pass the streets in safety by not saying explicitly what they seek.

     All of these persons can be found in the corridors of power, or straining for admission to them. They greatly outnumber those of a genuinely benevolent nature. Yet all of them claim to have your well-being as their supreme value. And all of them are villains at best, monsters at worst.

     The simplest, the clearest, and the most direct route to assessing them, to knowing them for what they are rather than what they pretend to be, is to get them to state their metrics. If their metrics are collective in nature – and nearly all metrics offered in a political context are collective in nature – they are the enemy, to be feared and fought.

     “Do not say “Trust me; rely on my word.” Only politicians say that.” – C. Northcote Parkinson

     Trust no one. Think for yourself, always.