Monday, December 9, 2013

No soup OR semi-autos for you!




A few days ago at Esquire.com, a tyrant made his pitch. He wants to re-educate Americans on the real meaning of Christmas, I mean the 2nd Amendment, and convince us to see that the e-e-e-vilest things in the world aren’t sparkly-uniformed & jackbooted killers like him, but guns…in the hands of civilians like me.
The lieutenant colonel who lectures us at Esquire doesn’t ring the death knell on the U.S. Liberty Bell for the actual Pol Pot, or Idi Amin, or Uncle-Joe Stalin, or even the leftist’s favorite “rightwing nutjob”-slash-tyrant, Adolph Hitler.
Nope. This mighty-military man answers to the leftist’s very own 21st century destroyer, President Barry Sotero. I mean Barrack Obama.

Sure the Esquire article is pure double-timing agitprop: meant to raise the spirits of the faithful gun-fearful, the hoplophobes, you know, the cheerleaders-for-confiscation. But it’s also meant to bring out the cries, shouts, and threats of the opposition, like me. See how well it’s working? And sure, if the pushback by pro-self-defense types is addressed at all they’ll be called “knee jerk” by the big-league media which is nearly all anti self-defense.
But in all this, what’s most important is the need to listen to and actually believe writers like Esquire’s guest, Lt. Colonel Robert Bateman. Particularly when they admit “at the end of the day his job is about killing.” When those wielding the Weapons-of-State, like this military man, freely call themselves killers and then go on to talk Gun Confiscation, damn straight, “I’m listening Seattle.”
And since it’s doubtful this uniformed career “killer” would go out on such an extreme anti-gun limb by himself, it’s safe to conjecture plenty of his fellow officers feel precisely the same.

So…there’s bad bad-news and good bad-news Liberty- and Security- lovers. The bad is that I guess they really are out to get you - and your guns. The good-slash-bad news is you really aren’t paranoid.

Generational Gun-confiscation. I began responding to this Esquire piece for one reason: for the last ten or eleven months (following the anti-gun tsunami that swept the nation one year ago, a.k.a. Sandy Hook) I’ve been thinking a lot about “generational gun confiscation.” I witnessed the instantaneous and monster-machinelike power of the popular media back then. It molded the narratives as dictated from the White House and pumped them over and over, ad infinitum, into the childlike sponge-minds of their consumers.
And it went something like this:
“Guns-are-bad-and-unnecessary; scary gun-nuts are worse than guns; what would best would be to get rid of them all.” Rinse; repeat.

So, grasshopper, you want to get rid of guns without another quote-unquote civil war? Simple. Patience, grasshopper.
Not quite like the patience of Job, in that while Obama & his friends in high places wait they’ll still have fine salaries, armed bodyguards, beautiful safe places to live, and terrific salve prescribing health-care plans. Because they’re special and the rulers and, well, you aren’t.
Not even like the patience of the Mohammedans, who’ve been peacefully chopping heads off and lovingly blowing up infidels who refuse to “submit” to their special book, non-stop, Oh…since the 7th century.
Nope, the patience to Get-the-Guns from pesky Americans need not reach the level of those two religious examples at all. Just the kind Lt. Col. Robert Bateman methodically explains for us in Esquire.

Bateman is right in this one point: it will only take one more generation. Though overall, his faux outrage at guns in America is wrong in so many ways, beginning with the so-called inciting incident of a Black-on-Black, likely alcohol-fueled, argument turned deadly-shooting,
By, say 2030, so few will have been taught, for example, how America had to supply its British allies in WWII with e-e-evil guns; so few will understand how Bateman butchers the 2nd Amendment in Esquire by turning it inot a purely State concept, never mentioning the original intent of the Founders which was based on real-world individuals providing their own singular and group-defense.
Bateman and Esquire both preach basically to the same crowd: urban, well-educated, guilty-white liberal Americans. This congregation of folks can’t imagine owning a gun because that fact alone would be an implied deadly-threat, just as they’d likely have a hard time raising a hand in their own defense - for fear of harming the would be criminal.

By the time the last quote-unquote illegal guns are grabbed, so few civilians will see the irony when the American jackbooted pawns of the State arrive. Will those disarmed, defanged, pacified onlookers deem American Enforcers’ armaments evil? Won’t they be intimidated or scared of what’s strapped on “the good guys’” hips and/or slung across their black-uniformed, anonymous helmeted bodies? No? Why not? Will they cheer as they did the similar show of State Force in Boston after the recent bombing, when these future storm troopers pry those quote-unquote-illegal personal weapons from the cold dead hands of those onlookers’ e-e-evil gun-nut neighbors and forefathers?

In the end the last old Grandpa Charlton Heston type won’t go out in a blaze of glory after all. He’ll simply have been waiting months or years for a heart bypass or some other old-age treatment; be passing some time peacefully cleaning the last old shotgun or rifle or handgun he gone years unable to find ammo for, when…Boom! Heart attack. Or some other old-age thing, and he’ll keel over, dead.

And finally old, grey, feeble, retired how-many-ever-starred General Bateman will be wheeled out for Obama’s Special Press Conference. And peace will reign in the gun-free U.S.A.. Oh, except for those owned and carried and used against defenseless civilians by the professional Federal and State killers. And except for those stashed away for a rainy day by the street criminals most of whom, even back in 2013, were/are Black or Hispanics (yet never got vilified like the NRA and generic white gun “nuts,” 99.9% of whom never shot a soul).

So check out the article at Esquire.com, and some of the comments as well; until next time, Keep Rebelling.

  This essay first appeared on the author’s YouTube-channel.

Ineducability

Owing to having been largely incapacitated since early Thursday morning, I have the sort of day before me that makes outright slavery seem an attractive alternative, so I have one quick item for you today, after which I must be off.

Failure can awaken one to what he does not know...unless he's a politician.

Consider how bereft of response were the politicians confronted by this 15-year-old girl:

This young woman is both well informed and remorselessly logical. But will she convince her local political class of her position? Almost certainly not. Why not?

Give that some thought.


Men of good will habitually assume that other men are much like them. They, being animated and guided by what C. S. Lewis called the Law of General Benevolence, have difficulty conceiving of a body of motivation centered on malice, venality, or cruelty. They want nothing from others except what should come to them in consequence of a fulfilled agreement, and cannot imagine how anyone could be otherwise oriented.

Most Americans are men of good will. Most politicians are not:

  • The man of good will seeks prosperity in harmony with his fellows; the politician seeks power over others.
  • The man of good will understands the requirements for comprehension and honest effort in the fulfillment of his promises; the politician dismisses such notions as "for the little people."
  • The man of good will frankly discloses his aims to his trading partners, and expects them to do likewise; the politician hides his true agenda for as long as possible.

Thus, for a man of good will to deal with politicians and political bodies as if they were like him is a fatal error. The latter will view the former as a sheep to be shorn.

When the man of good will lays out an airtight logical case before a political body, as did the young woman in the video above, he expects it to prevail on the merits. When it fails to do so, often leaving no trace of its passing, he tends to look for fault in himself. He assumes there must have been some flaw in his reasoning, or some ambiguity in his evidence, such that his argument failed to convince. This, too, is a fatal error.

Politicians are not educable in the traditional sense. They are creatures of power: power seekers and power fearers. Their relations with one another are intensely suspicious and zero-sum competitive. Their relations with common citizens are indelibly imbued with contempt. With vanishingly few exceptions, nothing but power matters to them.


The defense of the right to keep and bear arms is not about educating our political class. They don't lack any element of the knowledge or logic behind that right. They know full well what it was guaranteed to provide: a bulwark against the infinite lust for power that animates them and others like them. Their hostility to it, regardless of their verbal representations, is not about your safety; it's about theirs.

They will never, ever agree that the State must respect the right to keep and bear arms. All that will prevent them from ripping it out of our hands is fear: in the best case, fear of being turned out of office; in the worst, fear of being hanged from a lamppost for the edification of others.

Milton Friedman was at his wisest when he said that freedom depends less upon electing good men than upon creating conditions within which bad men would feel irresistibly pressured to do the right thing. Friedman understood the essential evil of the State -- and that an evil institution, necessary or otherwise, would inevitably become the demesne of evil persons.

The moral should be clear.
Do not think to "educate" politicians.
Never condescend to "negotiate" with them.
Instill in them an ineradicable fear of your wrath.
As Mark Twain said, they're "our only native criminal class."

Verbum sat sapienti.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

An Assortment For The Immaculate Conception

I'm still somewhat under the weather, but I dislike to go two days without posting anything -- the crocodiles start to look threatening after even one day -- so here goes nothing. Please excuse me if there's an unusual lack of connections among the bits.


To those who've written to ask about the progress of Freedom's Fury, it's approaching completion in first draft. At this time, I'd say the first draft will be complete on New Year's Day or a few days afterward. As I can no longer afford the services of a professional editor, I'll shortly be soliciting for test readers to comment on how well it holds together, both as a novel on its own and as the capstone to the Spooner Federation trilogy. Anyone who'd care to volunteer for this thankless and wholly uncompensated labor will also receive copies of Which Art In Hope and Freedom's Scion, for cross-reference.

"What's coming after that?" I hear you cry. Well, if I allow myself to be steered by fan input, it will probably be a novel based on the setting described in "The Warm Lands." (Yes, it would incorporate the original novelette. Gregor has proved to be as appealing a protagonist as any of my others. Hmm. Josh Hutcherson or Chris Hemsworth for the movie version? And who for Laella? Decisions, decisions...)


Courtesy of the esteemed Doug Ross @ Journal, have a gander at what the Left does when it's caught with its hand in the cookie jar:

That's close to an exact transcript. Do please remember that though President Bush went to Congress for authorization of every one of his uses of force, the Left assailed those actions as somehow unConstitutional, and that his mild "signing statements," intended to clarify ambiguous points in the bills he signed, were viciously attacked by this...person and others of his ilk.


Nothing is better guaranteed to incite your opponents to spittle-flecked, irrational fury than well-aimed ridicule:

Though the tactic was arguably unfair in its setting, I am reminded of the passage in Inherit The Wind in which Henry Drummond calls down massive public laughter upon Matthew Harrison Brady for his assertion that God talks to him. Brady, being a stuffed shirt, was not allowed to make the appropriate riposte: "What? Are you saying God doesn't talk to you? I can't imagine why not. Are you spiritually deaf? Conscienceless?"

It is our great good fortune that Barack Hussein Obama is exactly that sort of stuffed shirt.


Today, as Catholics will know, is the Feast of the Immaculate Conception: our celebration of the conception of Mary, the Blessed Virgin Mother of the Son of God, as without sin. That was an absolute necessity for her role as the vessel by which Jesus was to be delivered into the world, for He was to know no sin Himself, and could not have been borne by a mother tainted by it.

Any number of Protestants denigrate Catholics as worshipping Mary, as if she were as divine as her Son. This could not be further from the truth, but people will always seek a reason to look down on those whose beliefs diverge from theirs. We do not worship the Blessed Virgin. We venerate her as the Mother of Jesus, and as the model for human courage and steadfastness under trial.

Don't quite get it? Consider: Mary was barely of mature years when the angel came to her and asked for her consent to be Jesus's human mother. She knew her culture well; in particular, she knew that it regarded sex outside of wedlock as a stoning offense. Therefore, to accede to God's request, she had to accept the eventual necessity to defend herself against that charge. That required a degree of courage that no one dare denigrate. It makes her the model of womanhood for all of Mankind, and justly deserving of the honor we accord her.

From the Protoevangelium of St. James, chapters 11 through 16:

And she took the pitcher and went forth to fill it with water: and lo a voice saying: Hail, thou that art highly favoured; the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women.

And she looked about her upon the right hand and upon the left, to see whence this voice should be: and being filled with trembling she~ went to her house and set down the pitcher, and took the purple and sat down upon her seat and drew out the thread.

And behold an angel of the Lord stood before her saying: Fear not, Mary, for thou hast found grace before the Lord of all things, and thou shalt conceive of his word. And she, when she heard it, questioned in herself, saying: Shall I verily conceive of the living God, and bring forth after the manner of all women? And the angel of the Lord said: Not so, Mary, for a power of the Lord shall overshadow thee: wherefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of the Highest. And thou shalt call his name Jesus: for he shall save his people from their sins. And Mary said: Behold the handmaid of the Lord is before him: be it unto me according to thy word.

And she made the purple and the scarlet and brought them unto the priest. And the priest blessed her and said: Mary, the Lord God hath magnified thy name, and thou shalt be blessed among all generations of the earth.

And Mary rejoiced and went away unto Elizabeth her kinswoman: and she knocked at the door. And Elizabeth when she heard it cast down the scarlet and ran to the door and opened it, and when she saw Mary she blessed her and said: Whence is this to me that the mother of my Lord should come unto me? for behold that which is in me leaped and blessed thee. And Mary forgot the mysteries which Gabriel the archangel had told her, and she looked up unto the heaven and said: Who am I, Lord, that all the generations of the earth do bless me?

And she abode three months with Elizabeth, and day by day her womb grew: and Mary was afraid and departed unto her house and hid herself from the children of Israel. Now she was sixteen years old when these mysteries came to pass.

Now it was the sixth month with her, and behold Joseph came from his building, and he entered into his house and found her great with child. And he smote his face, and cast himself down upon the ground on sackcloth and wept bitterly, saying: With what countenance shall I look unto the Lord my God? and what prayer shall I make concerning this maiden? for I received her out of the temple of the Lord my God a virgin, and have not kept her safe. Who is he that hath ensnared me? Who hath done this evil in mine house and hath defiled the virgin? Is not the story of Adam repeated in me ? for as at the hour of his giving thanks the serpent came and found Eve alone and deceived her, so hath it befallen me also.

And Joseph arose from off the sackcloth and called Mary and said unto her O thou that wast cared for by God, why hast thou done this? thou hast forgotten the Lord thy God. Why hast thou humbled thy soul, thou that wast nourished up in the Holy of Holies and didst receive food at the hand of an angel?

But she wept bitterly, saying: I am pure and I know not a man. And Joseph said unto her: Whence then is that which is in thy womb ? and she said: As the Lord my God liveth, I know not whence it is come unto me.

And Joseph was sore afraid and ceased from speaking unto her (or left her alone), and pondered what he should do with her. And Joseph said: If I hide her sin, I shall be found fighting against the law of the Lord: and if I manifest her unto the children of Israel, I fear lest that which is in her be the seed of an angel, and I shall be found delivering up innocent blood to the judgement of death. What then shall I do ? I will let her go from me privily. And the night came upon him.

And behold an angel of the Lord appeared unto him in a dream, saying: Fear not this child, for that which is in her is of the Holy Ghost, and she shall bear a son and thou shalt call his name Jesus, for he shall save his people from their sins. And Joseph arose from sleep and glorified the God of Israel which had shown this favour unto her: and he watched over her.

Now Annas the scribe came unto him and said to him: Wherefore didst thou not appear in our assembly? and Joseph said unto him: I was weary with the journey, and I rested the first day. And Annas turned him about and saw Mary great with child.

And he went hastily to the priest and said unto him: Joseph, to whom thou bearest witness [that he is righteous] hath sinned grievously. And the priest said: Wherein ? And he said: The virgin whom he received out of the temple of the Lord, he hath defiled her, and married her by stealth (lit. stolen her marriage), and hath not declared it to the children of Israel. And the priest answered and said: Hath Joseph done this? And Annas the scribe said: Send officers, and thou shalt find the virgin great with child. And the officers went and found as he had said, and they brought her together with Joseph unto the place of judgement.

And the priest said: Mary, wherefore hast thou done this, and wherefore hast thou humbled thy soul and forgotten the Lord thy God, thou that wast nurtured in the Holy of Holies and didst receive food at the hand of an angel and didst hear the hymns and didst dance before the Lord, wherefore hast thou done this?

But she wept bitterly, saying: As the Lord my God liveth I am pure before him and I know not a man.

And the priest said unto Joseph: Wherefore hast thou done this? And Joseph said: As the Lord my God liveth I am pure as concerning her. And the priest said: Bear no false witness but speak the truth: thou hast married her by stealth and hast not declared it unto the children of Israel, and hast not bowed thine head under the mighty hand that thy seed should be blessed. And Joseph held his peace.

And the priest said: Restore the virgin whom thou didst receive out of the temple of the Lord. And Joseph was full of weeping. And the priest said: I will give you to drink of the water of the conviction of the Lord, and it will make manifest your sins before your eyes.

And the priest took thereof and made Joseph drink and sent him into the hill-country. And he returned whole. He made Mary also drink and sent her into the hill-country. And she returned whole. And all the people marvelled, because sin appeared not in them.

And the priest said: If the Lord God hath not made your sin manifest, neither do I condemn you. And he let them go. And Joseph took Mary and departed unto his house rejoicing, and glorifying the God of Israel.

Not too shabby for a girl of sixteen, eh? But it gets better: Mary had received a Judaic religious education, and was familiar with Judaic Scripture -- what we of today would call the Old Testament. She knew the fate in store for her divine Son, and that it would be her responsibility to accompany Him to the end of it. Add that to her willingness to risk death by stoning. Find me another human woman willing to court such a destiny.

Praise be to Mary, the Virgin Mother of God, the highest of the saints, who intercedes for us with her Son as we request.

And may God bless and keep you all.

Saturday, December 7, 2013

Day Off

Forgive me, Gentle Reader. I’m very sick and can’t sit at the keyboard for more than a minute or two at a time. With luck, I’ll be back in form tomorrow.

Friday, December 6, 2013

Justified Violence

By way of the esteemed Charles Hill, we have this potent statement of the moral imperative for violence by private parties:

[I]t’s interesting that sanctioned violence with the goal of getting a ball across a line is considered wholesome family entertainment but defensive violence is unacceptable. Why is that? Why is it that we celebrate violence on a field but not those who exercise their duty to protect themselves and their loved ones? Instead the media laments the criminals killed victimizing others. Those who must defend their lives are made out to be crazed vigilantes with some sort of chip on their shoulder while the criminal in question was just getting their life back in order. Why is being in fear for one’s own life a questionable motive?

When did we become a society that regards morally justifiable violence as something repugnant? Something from which we should shield our children? We can celebrate athletes with rap sheets a mile long just as long as they put the ball in the right place again and again. We buy the shoes they tell us to buy. Why does the media vilify a neighborhood watch volunteer while venerating the thugs in jerseys?

I think I know part of the answer. As a society, we’ve separated ourselves from personal responsibility and community. Our reality comes from TV and not from interpersonal relationships. We’ve insulated ourselves from the consequences of our actions. It’s no longer our own fault if we get fat. It’s the fast food, here take a pill. Unplanned pregnancy? Just terminate it. Fail at business? Someone else is there to bail you out. And so on. It’s gotten to the point that it causes cognitive dissonance when someone takes matters into their own hands. The police are supposed to protect us, right? Sure. And our meat comes from the grocer too.

We’ve forgotten that survival is violent. All sustenance (yes, even the veggies) comes from death, and it is morally justifiable. But we don’t want to see that. We want our violence in nice neat packages for the purposes of entertainment. Never-mind the debilitating injuries suffered for our enjoyment. Get that ball across the arbitrary line so we can eat nachos! But God forbid you shoot a lion and talk about it. Even if your actions fund the conservation efforts and feed the people in Africa.

I have a lot of sympathy for Jennifer’s position. However, there are several questions to be answered after any assertion of morally justified violence:

  • Was the target guilty of the justification-act beyond all doubt?
  • Did the justification-act rise to a level that would justify killing or maiming him?
  • Did the vigilante have adequate reason to believe that, were he not to act, nothing would be done?
  • Were there secondary consequences for which the vigilante should be held liable?

Those are just the ones that come to mind at the moment -- and you can easily see that regardless of the identities, the history, and the context, each of them is inherently arguable. That's why the law recognizes the defense called justifiable homicide, but puts the burden of proof on the defendant.

Here's an excellent example of the thickets involved: A man has committed acts of sabotage to which he freely admits. Those acts have taken the lives of several persons presumed to have been innocent of all crimes. In the U.S., we would call those "felony murders," which are punished at least as harshly as any second-degree murder. His defense is to claim that the political system against which he fights justifies any and all such acts in the effort to overthrow it.

If the story is stripped of any further details, most persons would say that the saboteur is guilty and deserves the full weight of the law. But there are further details: the saboteur was Nelson Mandela, and the context was apartheid South Africa.

Let's stipulate that Mandela did mend his ways, to the extent of forgiving his enemies and striving for unity in post-apartheid South Africa. It remains an incontestable fact that as a young man he was personally involved in acts of sabotage that cost the lives of presumptive innocents. He was outspoken about it at his trial. That demands that we ask the core question of all civil uprisings: Does the situation Mandela fought against justify the violence he perpetrated?

Many persons would argue that Mandela's post-imprisonment career proves his repentance, and that his deeds in advancement of South African unity counterbalance his crimes adequately to forgive them. Others would note that we don't normally admit the accused's "good deeds" to consideration in a murder trial until the jury has returned a verdict of guilty, and then only in consideration of a possible mitigation of sentence.

Food for thought.

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Conveniently Christian

Say, remember this episode from the 2008 Presidential campaign?

That got a lot of people exercised...though, given the unprecedented weakness of the McCain campaign, not quite exercised enough to make a difference. Democrats, the party of the irreligious Left, have been hostile to religious faith, specifically Christian faith, for decades now. Casting aspersions on "religion," which the base will always interpret to mean Christianity, is an effective way for a Democrat to "rally the troops."

But soft! What light through yonder skull doth break:

(KATV) Sen. Mark Pryor is out with a new TV ad offering a Biblical solution to the already heated 2014 Senate race in Arkansas.

Pryor's campaign said the ad will begin airing on Wednesday. In the 30 second ad, Pryor speaks directly to the camera about his faith in the Bible. The ad is a substantial purchase for the campaign and will run statewide.

"I'm not ashamed to say that I believe in God, and I believe in His word. The Bible teaches us no one has all the answers. Only God does. And neither political party is always right," Pryor says in the ad. "This is my compass. My North Star. It gives me comfort and guidance to do what's best for Arkansas."

Pryor ends the ad saying he supports the message because "This is who I am, and what I believe."

Pryor is considered one of the most vulnerable incumbents in the country, partly because of his party line support of the Affordable Care Act and as his campaign is forced to deal with low approval numbers of Pres. Obama in Arkansas....

Pryor is facing Republican Congressman Tom Cotton, who is vacating his seat in the 4th congressional district. Though Cotton's campaign will continue to press upon Obamacare, Pryor's campaign has recently changed the narrative in the state to reach the more than half a million seniors receiving Medicare. Pryor's campaign ran an ad hitting Cotton over his support to turn Medicare into a voucher system and raise the eligibility age to 70, spurring Cotton to respond....

Pryor's ad saying "neither political party is always right" plays closely with his recent stance in the Senate, voting against his party and with Republicans against the nuclear option in the Senate. Pryor was one of three Democrats who parted with his party on that issue.

Mind you, on the big issue of the day, ObamaCare, Pryor stood with his party against the American people:

Whether Pryor maintains today that his vote, which was essential to the passage of the "Affordable Care Act," was "what's best for Arkansas," is unclear and will probably remain so. But the fascinating aspect of Pryor's ad is his emphasis of his supposed faith.

Democrats, as hostile as their decades-long behavior has been toward Americans' traditional religions, will nevertheless scream about their "faith" and how it informs their politics whenever they're challenged on the subject. More, they'll counterattack the challenger: "How dare you question my faith!" John Kerry, Nancy Pelosi, and the Cuomos are recent, prominent examples of this syndrome.

It gets worse. Is there a Christian remaining in these United States who truly believes that Barack Hussein Obama is a Christian too?

Obama's supposed Christianity is molecule-deep: just enough of a veneer to allow his boosters to snarl "How dare you question his faith!" at anyone who dares to do so. He doesn't attend services. He doesn't respect Christian traditions, nor presidential traditions that touch on Christianity. He pays more attention and more lip service to Islamic law and traditions than to anything from the Judeo-Christian line of development. He certainly doesn't love his enemies, to judge by his conduct.

(For the record, I don't think Obama is a Muslim. Indeed, I don't think he holds to any recognized religious creed. Any such attachment would interfere with his worship of himself.)

The moral should be obvious. These...persons recognize how important Christianity in our high officials is and has always been to the American electorate. They don't need to be sincerely Christian; indeed, that would impede them once they reach the offices they seek. They just have to "fake it" well enough to get elected. Had Obama not been "brought into the fold" by Reverend Jeremiah "God Damn America!" Wright, he would have had no shot at the presidency. He might not have reached the Senate.

Cosmetic Christianity, it seems, is better than avowed irreligion. At least, it's that way for political purposes. Ask Mark Pryor.


The various Christian denominations differ on a number of things, most notably abortion, divorce, and sexual conduct. However, they are united around the Noachite Commandments:

Then someone came up to him and said, "Teacher, what good deed must I do to have eternal life?" And He said to him, "Why do you ask me about what is good? There is only one who is good. If you wish to enter into life, keep the commandments." He said to Him, "Which ones?" And Jesus said, "You shall not murder; You shall not commit adultery; You shall not steal; You shall not bear false witness; Honor your father and your mother; also, You shall love your neighbor as yourself." [Matthew 19:16-19]

Government's penchants for theft and false witness should make any sincere Christian extremely uneasy about contact with it, approaching absolutely unwilling to be involved with it at any level. Make no mistake: to confiscate from unwilling Peter is theft no matter whether or not any of the proceeds reach Paul. The insertion of government, the supposedly disinterested servant of the "general welfare," as the confiscator makes no difference whatsoever.

But worse in our time is government's habit of lying to its subjects. When the State pursues a new imposition on the people, the "general welfare" bit is trotted out more often than any other rationale.

But what if the new law, tax, regulation or what-have-you doesn't serve the "general welfare?" Quite often, the "service" is demonstrably negative: things get generally worse instead of better. At that point, wouldn't it be the Christian thing for our political masters to say "Oops! Sorry, we got it wrong. We'll undo it at once" -- ?

Among other things, that would make our rulers' repentance a bit easier to believe -- and repentance is the precondition for forgiveness. But this past century it's almost never happened. The one exception I can name is the repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment.

"General welfare" rationales are rooted in the scheme of political thought called utilitarianism: "the greatest good for the greatest number." As I wrote long ago at The Palace of Reason:

Utilitarianism attempts to supplant the concept of rights, which [Jeremy] Bentham and his followers deemed too abstract, with the concept of collective utility: "the greatest good for the greatest number." In this formulation, the actions of the State could and should be justified entirely on the basis of the results they achieve, or, alternately, how well they "work." Utilitarianism was prominent in the thinking of early American socialists such as Edward Bellamy, Herbert Croly, and Charles Sanders Peirce.

But collective utility presupposes many things:

  1. Defensible concepts of "good" and "better" that can be applied to collectives;
  2. Accuracy in the formulation of policy to achieve what's deemed as "good" or "better,"
  3. Continuity of policy, once formulated, until the sought for "good" or "better" has been achieved,
  4. The moral defensibility of policies formulated "in good faith" even after they've failed.

All four of these suppositions are provably unsound, usually by their own internal logic.

If "good" and "better" are applicable to a collective, then by implication individual choice by any member of the collective must be irrelevant, perhaps even invalid. Yet decisions about "good" and "better" must be made somehow, whether by majority vote or by some designated planner or planners. In the first case, collective utility comes up hard against the ephemeral nature of the collective: it has no enduring identity. Its component individuals will change over time, by death, procreation, association or disassociation, which can easily lead to changes in the majority's verdicts about "good" and "better." But if the collective's decisions can change in such a fashion, with no "upper limit" on how fast they can change, under what circumstances, or in response to what developments, then how seriously can we take the concept of collective "good"?

In the second case, where designated planners decide on "good" and "better" for the collective, the utilitarians have reintroduced individual choice. The sole difference here is that some individuals are deciding on "good" and "better" for many others, rather than each man deciding for himself.

It is obvious that many a State policy formulated to bring about some well-conceived end has failed to do so. Sometimes the failure was inherent in the policy conception; sometimes it was the result of discontinuity in administration or application. What matters is that the result upon which the policy was founded was not achieved. How, then, shall we defend, morally or practically, the imposition of collective decision-making that overrode individuals' claims to rightful autonomy, when the very good they were promised in exchange for their rights has failed to materialize? Shall we make restitution to those who were deprived of their lives, liberties, or properties in service to the unachieved goal? If so, what becomes of collective utility's conceptual superiority to individual rights? If not, why should individuals agree to submit to the usurpation of their rights, however conceived, in the first place?

It becomes clear from such simple analyses that utilitarianism in theory reduces to absolutism in practice.

What's seldom mentioned in discussions of utilitarianism is how anti-Christian it is. It explicitly rationalizes doing harm to some innocents if that harm would result in an increase in "the greatest good for the greatest number." Given that it almost always fails to produce the practical results claimed for it, shrugging aside the moral objections to it will not save it. Nor will it save those who impose it on their subjects.

Some politicians, such as Mark Pryor, ask for our forgiveness. Yet they do not repent and mend their ways. That's not Christian conduct, nor would any degree of attendance at Sunday services make a difference to it.


We will make no progress toward regaining the freedom we have lost until we resolve as a people to call things by their right names -- and to deny names and labels to those whose conduct contradicts them, no matter how vituperatively they and their boosters might respond.

It is not enough to claim to be a Christian. He who routinely violates the Commandments must not be permitted the appellation. It is not enough to claim to be a patriot. He who on several occasions has deliberately worked against his nation's interests, especially in war and international dealings, must be challenged on his "patriotism" regardless of his response.

Confucius regarded such corrections as fundamental to the health of a polity:

Zi-lu said, "The ruler of Wei has been waiting for you, in order with you to administer the government. What will you consider the first thing to be done?"

The Master replied, "What is necessary to rectify names."

"So! indeed!" said Zi-lu. "You are wide off the mark! Why must there be such rectification?"

The Master said, "How uncultivated you are, Yu! A superior man, in regard to what he does not know, shows a cautious reserve.

If names be not correct, language is not in accordance with the truth of things.

If language be not in accordance with the truth of things, affairs cannot be carried on to success.

When affairs cannot be carried on to success, proprieties and music do not flourish.

When proprieties and music do not flourish, punishments will not be properly awarded.

When punishments are not properly awarded, the people do not know how to move hand or foot.

Therefore a superior man considers it necessary that the names he uses may be spoken appropriately, and also that what he speaks may be carried out appropriately.

What the superior man requires is just that in his words there may be nothing incorrect."

[The Analects of Confucius, XIII, 3]

I'm sure Christ would have agreed.

Conversations

FWP: Sweetie, do you remember when I bought this thing? (scowls at bottom-of-the-line electric razor)
CSO: A long time ago. Several years. Why?

FWP: It might be time to...upgrade.
CSO: To what?

FWP: I don’t know. This one does cut beard hair, or it used to, anyway.
CSO: So? What does it lack?

FWP: Well, there’s no events calendar, and I can’t send email or change channels on the TV.
CSO: Won’t allow you to record programs?

FWP: Nope. And it won’t sync to my phone, either.
CSO: That’s it. You need a new one.

[STANDARD DISCLAIMER: Yes, Gentle Reader, the above exchange actually took place this morning. No foolin’.]

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

Just Before The Fall

Adam and Eve, according to Genesis, enjoyed an idyllic, labor-free existence in the Garden of Eden. (Let's leave aside for the moment that the first six books of Genesis are necessarily allegorical, as before Abraham there were no Jews, no recordkeeping, and no "chain of evidence.") As the story runs, their sin in eating the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge was what condemned them and all their descendants to live "by the sweat of your face:"

But to Adam he said, “Because you obeyed your wife, and ate from the tree about which I commanded you, ‘You must not eat from it,’ cursed is the ground thanks to you; in painful toil you will eat of it all the days of your life. It will produce thorns and thistles for you, but you will eat the grain of the field. By the sweat of your face you will eat food until you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken; for you are dust, and to dust you will return.” [Genesis 3:17-19]

By implication, a life of labor was to be one of God's principal punishments for having defied His one explicit prohibition. Granted that the need to labor has often seemed a punishment to many -- hey, I'm looking forward to retirement myself -- the focus of the story is badly off, which is evidence for my conviction that much of the Old Testament has nothing to do with the true will of God.

Man, by his very nature, is what philosopher Loren Lomasky has called a project pursuer. To wit:

  • He perceives the passage of time;
  • He conceives of goals to be achieved and methods by which to achieve them;
  • Over time he implements those methods and adjusts them until he has either reached his goal or abandoned it.

If we omit physical torture, the very worst punishment one can inflict upon a project pursuer is enforced idleness. That's one of the principal reasons prisons are as they are, and prisoners generally regard the opportunity to work as a valuable privilege.

This seems so clear to me that I can't fathom how anyone could feel differently. Yet some persons clearly do. How many of those, should they achieve their dream of a labor-free existence, retain their opinion of its desirability for much longer, I cannot say.


Among the successes of the Giuliani and Bloomberg Administrations over New York City is the great reduction in the number of city dwellers on welfare. According to Heather Mac Donald:

Sixty-nine percent fewer residents are on cash benefits today than when Rudy Giuliani took office in 1994, and 24 percent fewer than when Mike Bloomberg took over in 2002, thanks to a deliberate attack on New York’s post-1960s dependency culture. As a result, more New Yorkers are employed today than at any time in the city’s history.

There has seldom been a more dramatic result from any attempt at welfare reform. Did it have a few rough edges? Yes, indubitably; such efforts always do. All the same, it produced an overall improvement in human well-being and earned self-respect -- the real thing, not the counterfeit the welfarists want to confer on you simply for being alive -- that surpasses any previous effort in American history, including the much-vaunted welfare reforms of the Nineties.

But here comes Bill de Blasio, the mayor-elect of New York. Again from the Mac Donald article:

[D]e Blasio has called Mayor Bloomberg’s belief that everyone should work for a living an “ideological hang-up.” He fought Bloomberg’s efforts to preserve the city’s requirement that able-bodied, childless adults at least look for work in exchange for food stamps. That requirement blocks a “path out of poverty,” he said in 2009 — in other words, working or looking for work keeps one in poverty, per de Blasio, while collecting benefits without working is a “path out of poverty.” He has promised to restore “education and training” as a core activity of welfare recipients and will ask the state to again allow four-year college students to collect welfare without any reciprocal obligations....

[D]e Blasio has vowed to “stop efforts to divert individuals from accessing cash assistance.” He wants to use ObamaCare outreach workers to put more New Yorkers on all government welfare programs and thinks that the city’s already high number of food-stamp recipients — nearly 1.9 million or 21 percent of the population — is at least a quarter-million too low....

De Blasio appears to believe that welfare applicants would never dream of ripping off taxpayers. He grandstanded against Bloomberg’s insistence that food-stamp applicants be finger-imaged, claiming it was “stigmatizing.” Somehow an identical finger-imaging requirement hasn’t stopped hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers from working for the city.

This can only be read one way: De Blasio is openly in favor of encouraging idleness and parasitism among able-bodied New Yorkers.

Does it come as a surprise that De Blasio is an ardent admirer of Barack Hussein Obama? Obama, after all, has placed more obstacles in front of productive work, while simultaneously weakening all the disincentives to going on welfare, than any other politician in American history. You'd almost get the idea that these two dislike work and hold people who value it in contempt.

What's their shibboleth again? The one they trumpet as their claim to moral superiority? "Compassion," isn't it? Oh yes, of course.


Labor itself, while sometimes arduous, is not a punishment but the fulfillment of Man's nature as a project pursuer -- if performed in pursuit of a freely chosen goal. In the usual case, the more one appreciates the pursuit itself, the less onerous it seems. The goal, attained or not, takes second place behind the fulfillments of work itself.

This is innate to Man's nature. We cannot become or remain happy by playing pointlessly. Indeed, even our recreations are goal-focused -- and it's a maxim of long-standing that "It isn't whether you win or lose; it's how you play the game." As Ursula Leguin put it in The Left Hand of Darkness, "It is good to have an end to journey toward, but it is the journey that matters, in the end."

But let's not downplay the "freely chosen" part of goal pursuit. If you're compelled to pursue someone else's choice of a goal, it's as unlikely to make you happy as enforced idleness. Indeed, removing free choice from the formula and adding coercion to it is what makes labor truly onerous. He who wishes to torment a victim most severely won't kill him -- the dead, after all, have reached the end of all temporal suffering -- but will make him a slave.

"He [Sauron] does not need you -- he has many more useful servants -- but he won't forget you again. And hobbits as miserable slaves would please him far more than hobbits happy and free. There is such a thing as malice and revenge." [J.R.R. Tolkien, The Fellowship of the Ring]

Let's spend a moment on that Tolkien citation. Sauron is an evil Maiar, an immortal and immensely powerful being comparable to a fallen angel from Christian theocosmogony. His whole motivation is to inflict suffering; he seeks to conquer and enslave. The servants to whom the passage above refers are the Orcs, which he, and Morgoth before him, fashioned from captured Elves and their offspring. They are his instruments for the extension of his evil dominion throughout Middle Earth.

But Sauron doesn't need anything. Indeed, it's unclear that he's capable of desiring anything other than the suffering of helpless victims. His slaves labor solely to make more slaves. They produce no other satisfaction of desire.

Tolkien's vision of ultimate evil was quite clear.


"Barack Obama will force you to work." -- Michelle Obama, 2008

The flip side of the promotion of idleness is the conscription of labor. The more idlers there are, the less work is done, the less is produced, and the poorer grows the nation. At some point political pressures, engendered by economic deterioration, will arise against the welfare culture. Even before that a form of conscription will exist, practiced through confiscatory taxation and redistribution. But when the next crisis point arrives, the political class will "reluctantly" agree that "something must be done," at which point labor-force conscription will begin:

    "Point One: All workers, wage earners, and employees of any kind whatsoever shall henceforth be attached to their jobs, and shall not leave, nor be dismissed, nor change employment, on penalty of a term in jail. The penalty shall be determined by the Unification Board, such Board to be appointed by the Bureau of Economic Planning and National Resources. All persons reaching the age of twenty-one shall report to the Unification Board, which shall assign them to where, in its opinion, their services shall best serve the interests of the nation.
    "Point Two: All industrial, commercial, manufacturing and business establishments of any nature whatsoever shall henceforth remain in operation, and the owners of such establishments shall not quit nor leave nor retire, nor close, sell, or transfer their business, under penalty of the nationalization of their establishment and of any and all of their property." [Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged]

Compulsory labor laws -- labor-force conscription -- were enacted in post-war Britain under Clement Attlee. There's no reason to think they couldn't happen here.


Our political masters seem hell-bent on legitimizing government-funded idleness as a way of life. (Remember "funemployment?") The more innocent among them might not realize to what ultimate end that would deliver these United States. However, I'm persuaded that some of them do realize it -- and yearn for it more ardently than any good man could possibly imagine.

Why would anyone wish such a consummation?
The answer lies in the identities and histories of those who do wish it.
The great majority of them have never worked toward anything but higher and higher office.
They have ample reason to know how valueless they are to others.
And it has filled them with malice toward the rest of us.

Is there any greater irony than that the capo di tutti capi of this malevolent gang, Barack Hussein Obama, should be the chief political beneficiary of the unearned guilt so many Americans feel about slavery?

Food for thought.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Wastrels

[In response to the quite overwhelming number of readers who remembered it and pleaded for it after reading this piece, below appears a post that first appeared at Eternity Road on November 22, 2009. -- FWP]


To those who come here for spiritual reinforcement, to those seeking uplift or tools with which to defend their faith, to those whose sense of direction is wavering, and to those who read these Ruminations for their chuckle value:

Forgive me, Gentle Readers. I'm having one of those days.

***

The C.S.O. and I went to a concert yesterday evening at the Capital One Theater, formerly called the Westbury Music Fair. It was part of the theater's "Legends" series, which features some of the iconic performers of the past half-century. Last night's headliner was one of the immortals of song, the great Tony Bennett.

Tony Bennett, baptized Antonio Dominic Benedetto, is 83 years old this year. He's been a musical professional for sixty years. Were it his preference, he'd have every right to regard his career as successful -- and concluded. Any number of other entertainers younger than he have hung up the mike and retired on their laurels, well-earned or not.

It was clear from last night's performance that Bennett still "has it." His voice retains all its old power, ever so slightly roughened by the years. He hardly needed a microphone to fill the theater with song, nor did his several soft-shoe episodes suggest that there's a walker in his near future.

It was equally clear that Bennett still loves music, particularly the soft-jazz ballads for which he's famous. He performed, with his daughter Antonia, for nearly two hours, and might have gone on longer were it not for theater policy and local zoning ordinances. He stinted nothing, reaching all the high notes with apparent ease, caressing the pianissimi and belting out the fortissimi like a young man of twenty-five.

There wasn't a soul in that theater who didn't love him unreservedly. Nor were we all nursing-home escapees.

With that love came a wholehearted trust. We paid big bucks to see and hear Bennett perform. We endured a horrible traffic pattern, a crowded, overheated theater, and thirty minutes of misery struggling to get out of the worst-designed parking lot on Long Island. No one does that without trusting in the performer's fidelity to his trade: not to slough his responsibility to perform only at his best, never to turn in a pro forma hack job just because he needs the money.

In large measure, that love and trust was inspired by Bennett himself, an entirely admirable performer whose fidelity to his art and his chosen idiom has never wavered, and who answered that trust by giving us his best from first to last. But there was another component to it.

Bennett reminds us of better days.

Days of innocence, when we trusted ourselves and one another, and expected nothing that was not ours by right.
Days of promise, each to build upon the ones before and prepare for higher ascents in days to come.
Days of open-eyed, confident engagement with life's challenges.
Days of enterprise, achievement, and glory.
Days of love.

America's days of wine and roses.

***

Often, when an old fart like me starts rambling about "the good old days," he's trading on highly polished memories that bear only a passing resemblance to the texture of the time he thinks he recalls. Lord knows, memory can be polished to a very high gloss. But there's always a chance that the veneer genuinely reflects the reality, at least in essence. The persistence of a Tony Bennett, even in an age of doubt and gloom, is evidence to that effect, albeit most circumstantial and not at all conclusive.

Despite the adage that "history is written by the victor," there are enough survivors of our better years to dispel most doubts about their veracity. Some of them are our grandparents. Some of them are our parents. And some of them, of course, are ourselves.

The past half-century has been a time of decline. The most significant aspect of that decline has been the dissipation of trust.

***

In a discussion of the big AGW scandal issuing from the Hadley CRU leak, one participant expressed bewilderment, averring that:

...a hoax on this scale would require the collusion of a whole lot of people…

Not so, in the traditional sense of "collusion." Scientists, just like the rest of humanity, respond to incentives and penalties. The warmistas in the scientific community were drawn there by a variety of incentives.

Some were undoubtedly sincere, certain that with enough evidence they could validate the greenhouse-gas thesis and willing to explain away "inconvenient data" with the usual dismissals of the true believer.
Some were loyal Hessians, willing to go wherever their idols and masters might point them.
Some were "following the money," as ever greater amounts of money poured from government coffers and the treasuries of left-leaning foundations to support the promulgation of the anthropogenic-global-warming thesis.
Some were merely publicity hounds, who would ride any wagon that appeared to have the media's attention.
Some were flogged into sullen support of AGW, fearful that refraining would cause them to be stripped of their funding and relegated to the outer darkness.

No doubt there are other reasons...in light of the fraud the Hadley CRU docments have revealed, none of them in any way connected to the core doctrines of science.

What matters is the fraud itself. Some thousands of "scientists" were moved to abandon science as it's been practiced for centuries by motives that, if they're to be summed up in one word, could only be called evil. Yes, tens of millions of persons worldwide cheered them on, but that's hardly an exculpation.

We have created -- and institutionalized -- incentives for fraud and penalties for honesty and candor. Not just for men of science; for virtually every trade and walk of life. For many men, the touchstone of ethical judgment is no longer "Is it right?" It's "Can I get away with it?"

We have destroyed the bedrock of freedom: our ability to trust.

***

It might sound implausible to younger Americans, but half a century ago the typical American would reflexively trust the word even of a passing stranger. We trusted one another because we knew ourselves, in the small and in the large, to be honorable men. It was a knowledge forged from experience and tempered by our recognition of a common moral and ethical foundation: the Judeo-Christian code of conduct.

We believed in the manly virtues. More, we believed that those around us believed in them, too.

Were there thieves, con men, and chiselers among us then? Of course. But their number was far smaller than it is today. The social-legal environment didn't yet incorporate all the inducements to dishonesty and chiseling that we suffer in the year of Our Lord 2009. Perhaps more important, we didn't yet endure the perpetual hectoring about how cruel, venal, and untrustworthy we are, from institutions that wax upon men's distrust of one another.

We trusted our merchants and business associates. We understood free enterprise to be an inherently honorable, honesty-promoting thing. We trusted our spouses, knowing that the marriage vow was taken seriously by our communities and that a departure from it would be held against the violator. We trusted lawyers to represent us honestly and capably at need, and courts to return just verdicts and sentences. We even trusted politicians, which was the beginning of unwisdom.

Whenever and wherever men decide that they cannot trust one another to behave honorably, to meet their obligations and honor their commitments, or to cleave to fundamental moral principles about violence, theft, fraud, filial duty, and false witness, the sequel is always the same: we recur to the State, the institution whose sole instrument is force. We accede to laws innumerable, expecting them to substitute for trustworthiness in our fellow men. They seldom have that effect, for every law, however well intentioned and carefully designed, creates a black market in the behavior it forbids: an inducement for evil men to sell their willingness to accept the risks of violating it.

The State, of course, is perfectly happy to take the burden, for its operators are past masters at the twinned arts of taking credit for good outcomes and sloughing the odium for bad ones onto others' shoulders. By gentle, all but imperceptible degrees, it pares away our freedom, our property, and what remains of our willingness to trust one another, gobbling down the slices with Pantagruelian voracity. The progression can have only one terminus, yet most of us remain willing to accept politicians' protestations of devotion to the commonweal in the teeth of all experience...until the day we find our own oxen being filleted for our masters' tables.

That's usually the day we discover that all the sand has fallen to the bottom of the hourglass...that the vector of our subjugation can no longer be reversed.

***

The mint-mark of political speech is the promise. We hear them by the thousands these days: give me power, give me this or that little bite from your wallet or your liberty, and I will ease whatever it is that pains you. But none of the promisers ever post a bond for non-performance. Except for the pitiful few literally caught with tainted cash in their freezers, none of them ever have to repay the electorate for their defaults.

The subtext of any political promise is, of course, "Trust me." As the late Cyril Northcote Parkinson observed long ago, only a politician would say that; since then, politicians have learned to imply it, never to be caught actually mouthing the words. But the demand is there even so, and as their failures accumulate, ordinary persons find their residual willingness to trust being whittled away.

***

After two centuries of blessedness, America has entered the hour of the power of darkness:

  • Our military is being emasculated as we speak, with funding cuts to deprive it of men and machines, and legal entanglements to ensure that no soldier in the field can ever be certain that he won't be tried for murder by civilians, or worse, by foreigners.
  • Our alliances are faltering as no one ever expected, as our chief executive kowtows to the worst men in the world and fails to uphold America's actions in its own interest.
  • Our politicians are interested solely in getting elected and staying in office, and will do anything, sacrifice anyone, and betray any principle of right, to achieve those goals.
  • Our economy is being bled to death by layer after layer of taxation, regulation, legal mandates, and outright nationalizations, nearly all intended to benefit some provincial interest some gaggle of politicians counts on for support.
  • Our currency has been so debased that the other nations of the world, fooled over the decades into accepting mountains of it for their wares, are getting ready to write it off.
  • Our schools have become cesspits of socialist indoctrination and multicultural propaganda, where a child saying grace over his lunch is subject to harassment as a bigot.
  • Our cities and communities are weakening under the assaults of illegal immigration, eminent-domain attacks on property rights, forced injection of "refugees" who hate America and all it stands for, and the use of insane lawsuits to prevent development in the name of "saving the planet."
  • Our churches -- the ones that still respect God and value freedom -- are steadily being muzzled by the moral and cultural relativists, the "inclusionists," and the Muslims.
  • Our women are largely persuaded that killing an unborn baby constitutes a "woman's right" and a "safe medical procedure."
  • Our arts have become unfathomably vile.
  • Every right we have is under sustained, determined assault.
  • Our people are losing faith in one another, in themselves, in their futures, and the futures of their children.

Soon the national motto will no longer be "E pluribus unum," but rather "Sauve qui peut."

We did it to ourselves, by squandering one another's trust.

***

They unwound and flung from them with rage, as a rag that defiled them
The imperial gains of the age which their forefathers piled them.
They ran panting in haste to lay waste and embitter for ever
The wellsprings of Wisdom and Strength which are Faith and Endeavour.
They nosed out and digged up and dragged forth and exposed to derision
All doctrine of purpose and worth and restraint and prevision:
And it ceased, and God granted them all things for which they had striven,
And the heart of a beast in the place of a man’s heart was given. . .

[Rudyard Kipling, "The City of Brass"]

No, America isn't quite as bad as that, yet, but we're headed in that direction. What Kipling foretells in the concluding stanza of his epic poem will draw ever nearer, the longer we persist in the folly of demanding that others bear our burdens for us, at no cost to ourselves -- that is, the longer we trust in the State in preference to trusting ourselves and our fellow men.

We have lived, collectively, as wastrels. We have consumed much and produced little. Especially, we've consumed the trust and good will of our fellows, with our conniving, our chiseling, and our gaming the laws and the courts in search of personal or provincial advantage. That can only go on for so long before Hobbes's "war of each against all" must resume.

It's the sort of premonition that makes me glad to be an old man. Perhaps I won't live to see this Hell-Bound Train reach the Depot Way Down Yonder.

Whatever you came to Eternity Road seeking today, Gentle Reader, I'd bet a pretty that the above wasn't it.

Forgive me.

Monday, December 2, 2013

I Think I'm In Love

This young woman is exactly what America needs. Spread her message far and wide!

Pre-Funeral Eulogies

There's a sadness descending upon the Dextrosphere. Consider this, from Oleg at The People's Cube:

I have seen the future and ran away.

At first the move to America from the former USSR made me feel as though I had made a jump in time, from the stagnant depraved past into a distant dynamic future.

There was an abundance of commonly available futuristic contraptions, machines, and appliances that made everyday existence easier and more enjoyable. Less obvious but just as exciting was the media's openness: I no longer needed to read between the lines to know what was happening.

Most importantly, there was honesty, dignity, and respect in relations among people.

Today I'm feeling like a time traveler again.

Only this time the productive, honest and self-reliant America is vanishing in the past, as we are quickly approaching the all too familiar future.

It is the future of equal poverty, one-party rule, media mooching, government looting, bureaucratic corruption, rigged elections, underground literature, half-whispered jokes, and the useful habit of looking over your shoulder.

It was nice living in America before it changed the course and followed Obama's direction "Forward," which, according to my compass, is pointing backward.

All of a sudden I find myself playing the role of a comrade from the future, helping my new compatriots to navigate the quagmire ahead of us.

Oleg isn't alone. Far from it:

Whom do you trust?...

The article below states that two-thirds of Americans cannot be trusted. This is no surprise to anyone with a moral character. Add the percentage of people who voted for Obama, all government workers and people collecting a government entitlement. Remove the intersecting population and we have at least two-thirds of the country.

The article David cites:

WASHINGTON (AP) - You can take our word for it. Americans don't trust each other anymore.

We're not talking about the loss of faith in big institutions such as the government, the church or Wall Street, which fluctuates with events. For four decades, a gut-level ingredient of democracy - trust in the other fellow - has been quietly draining away.

These days, only one-third of Americans say most people can be trusted. Half felt that way in 1972, when the General Social Survey first asked the question.

Forty years later, a record high of nearly two-thirds say "you can't be too careful" in dealing with people.

An AP-GfK poll conducted last month found that Americans are suspicious of each other in everyday encounters. Less than one-third expressed a lot of trust in clerks who swipe their credit cards, drivers on the road, or people they meet when traveling.

Let that sink in for a moment while I hunt up an old favorite quote.


There is no need in human life so great as that men should trust one another and should trust their government, should believe in promises, and should keep promises in order that future promises may be believed in and in order that confident cooperation may be possible. Good faith -- personal, national, and international -- is the first prerequisite of decent living, of the steady going on of industry, of governmental financial strength, and of international peace. -- Benjamin M. Anderson, Economics and the Public Welfare: A Financial and Economic History of the United States, 1914 -- 1946

Trust is one of the social assets we seldom stop to appreciate until it's gone.

America was once a land in which trust was near to universal. Men trusted women. Customers trusted merchants. Even strangers encountering one another on the street trusted one another, at least in modest things. And why not? This is was America, where talent and effort were everything, where your word was your bond, where you learned right and wrong at your mother's knee. Besides, word got around. You simply couldn't get very far if you short-weighted someone or misdirected him to his loss and your gain.

The conditions of life in these United States made duplicitousness a losing strategy. It wasn't that we were "all in it together;" it was that the existing structure of incentives and penalties made lying, cheating, and stealing unprofitable in the long term. As another favorite quote puts it:

A thousand truths do not mark a man as a truth-teller, but a single lie marks him as a damned liar....Lying to other people is your business, but I tell you this: once a man gets a reputation as a liar, he might as well be struck dumb, for people do not listen to the wind. [Robert A. Heinlein, Citizen Of The Galaxy]

Trust must be accumulated over a long interval of honest dealing. It can be lost with a single lapse into venality. Therefore, when the incentives reward honest dealing better than fraud and theft, people generally will gradually accumulate trust while the few "dissenters" are forced to society's margins. Society will slowly embed a default assumption of honesty among men.

Today's incentive structure does the opposite.


It's difficult to be precise about the influences that bear on a miasmic affliction such as the diminution of trust. Some of them are right out in front of us:

  • The size of the rewards for betrayal and deceit;
  • The size of the rewards that go to the beneficiaries of litigation and chance;
  • Loss of confidence in the punishment of the untrustworthy, formally or otherwise;
  • The obvious duplicity of persons in government;
  • The anti-ethic of moral relativism.

Each of these things makes the honest man question his own behavior. "I work hard; I give value for value; I stand behind my statements and my products. I stay within the lines. And where has it gotten me? Look at this clown who just hit the lottery, and that one who collected millions from a defamation suit, and that other one who managed to patent something he didn't invent. Which of us knows better what it really takes to get ahead?"

Actually, it's even worse than that:

While what little remains of America's middle class is happy and eager to put in its 9-to-5 each-and-every day, an increasing number of Americans - those record 91.5 million who are no longer part of the labor force - are perfectly happy to benefit from the ever more generous hand outs of the welfare state. Prepare yourself before listening to this... calling on her self-admitted Obamaphone, Texas welfare recipient Lucy, 32, explains why "taxpayers are the fools"...

"...To all you workers out there preaching morality about those of us who live on welfare... can you really blame us? I get to sit around all day, visit my friends, smoke weed.. and we are still gonna get paid, on time every month..."

She intends to stay on welfare her entire life, if possible, just like her parents (and expects her kids to do the same). As we vociferously concluded previously, the tragedy of America's welfare state is that work is punished.

Perhaps the quoted welfare recipient doesn't live quite as well as you or I. It's plain that she's happy with her bargain. By accepting a modestly lower level of income, she's achieved a life of idleness and dissolution: things that are apparently valuable enough to her and her husband that they're willing to forgo whatever satisfactions there are in working and earning somewhat more.

Imagine encountering such a person on the street knowingly. Would you trust her? Now, with the incentive structures at work on Americans today producing persons like her in ever increasing numbers, what becomes of your general attitude toward random encounters, where the ethics of the other person are unknown to you?


Sanity was once called the ability to swim in waters not entirely familiar: to recognize shifts in the currents and to adapt as they occur. Sanity, viewed thus, is closely related to competence: the ability to "get it done" regardless of prevailing conditions.

Does it begin to appear to you, Gentle Reader, that to be a trusting and trustworthy person, in these concluding days of the Republic, is no longer inarguably sane? Just how much ability and resilience is required of such a person? How much self-respect and ethical armor? How greatly does all of it depend upon his locale and the specific identities of his associates? And how long will he and those who depend upon him last should his habits of honesty and reliability vanish utterly from the world around him?

O my people, O my city!

Sunday, December 1, 2013

For The First Sunday Of Advent

A number of Gentle Readers have written to ask what I think of Pope Francis’s recent encyclical that appears to condemn capitalism. How, the questions run, does the pope’s authority pertain to the denial of human freedom as expressed in our productive and commercial activities? After all, he’s infallible, isn’t he? Doesn’t his proclamation on such matters bind Catholics as firmly as any statement about abortion?

The short answer: It doesn’t.

The long answer: The pope’s authority is theological, not temporal. He cannot create new obligations upon mortal men; neither can he remove a sin from the catalogue established by the Commandments. If it were otherwise, he could contravene the explicit dictates of Jesus Himself.

Even if the disputed translation of Francis’s words from Spanish to English should prove to be accurate, and he really does mean to condemn capitalism root and branch, there is no Divine authority in such a statement. Popes will occasionally orate on temporal matters, but in doing so they shed the authority conferred by the apostolic succession. Should this one have taken up cudgels against human enterprise and the free market, his words bear no greater weight than mine.

Be not afraid.


Nevertheless, with the Holy Father’s seeming approval behind them, some priests will prattle about the “injustice” of a market economy. In a way that’s nothing new; it’s what some of them do and have always done. But a priest who does so is betraying his parishioners by perverting his office: the conservation and promulgation of the teachings of Christ as they are expressed in the four Gospels. It is no more forgivable for having a papal emission behind it than if it were utterly isolated from all else.

The politicization of Catholicism in America has done great harm to both the country and the Church. Many lifelong Catholics have departed their congregations because of the displacement of faith by politics. Concerned Catholics who want to make a difference in the fortunes of the Church should take a hand in the effort to rein in such clerics. It’s a more strenuous undertaking than making out a check for the repaving of the church parking lot, but it’s far more important.


By the way, I’m fine. I just needed a day to cope with other concerns.


Today begins a fresh liturgical year for Catholics worldwide. In today’s case, it also renews the three-year liturgical cycle by which we proceed through the Gospels and the associated readings in the Old and New Testaments. But most pertinent in the near term, it opens the season of preparation and anticipation for the birth of Our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God and Redeemer of Man, which we commemorate on Christmas Day.

It’s always struck me as just a little odd that the Mass, designed to commemorate the Last Supper, should change so little for the Advent season. The Last Supper, of course, was the precursor to the Passion: the darkest period of Christ’s mission among us. That, too, is part of the liturgical year, of course. All the same, by a surface reflection it seems just a bit “out of season” for the period during which we await His Nativity.

Perhaps not. The entirety of the story of Jesus is with us at all times. Surely He knew the fate that awaited His mortal body. Though He was not born exclusively to die, that terrible event was required to prepare for the Resurrection: the capstone of Christian belief. No part of His life story could take precedence over that.

Yes, we celebrate the glory of His birth...but had He not suffered and died to open the gates of heaven to fallen Man, His claim to be the Son of God would not have been confirmed beyond all doubt. History would have treated Him as one more in the series of prophets come to tell us to mend our ways. His Passion and Resurrection must remain in our thoughts even in this joyous season.

May God bless and keep you all.